Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1206.5472 · Cold atoms

Reconciling the Classical-Field Method with the Beliaev Broken-Symmetry Approach

Tod M. Wright, Matthew J. Davis, Nick P. Proukakis

Published Mar 18, 2013• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present our views on the issues raised in the previous chapter by Griffin and Zaremba. We review some of the strengths and limitations of the Bose symmetry-breaking assumption, and explain how such an approach precludes the description of many important phenomena in degenerate Bose gases. We discuss the theoretical justification for the classical-field (c-field) methods, their relation to other non-perturbative methods for similar systems, and their utility in the description of beyond-mean-field physics. Although it is true that present implementations of c-field methods cannot accurately describe certain collective oscillations of the partially condensed Bose gas, there is no fundamental reason why these methods cannot be extended to treat such scenarios. By contrast, many regimes of non-equilibrium dynamics that can be described with c-field methods are beyond the reach of generalised mean-field kinetic approaches based on symmetry breaking, such as the ZNG formalism.

DOI
10.1142/9781848168121_0019

Related papers

The Beliaev Broken-Symmetry Description of Superfluidity vs the Classical-Field Approach

Allan Griffin, E. Zaremba

The standard theoretical basis for understanding superfluidity in Bose systems was formulated by Beliaev in 1957, based on splitting the quantum field operator into a macroscopically occupied condensate component and a non-condensate component. This leads to a description of the condensate in terms of a 'single-particle state', the so-called macroscopic wavefunction. Since the discovery of Bose-condensed gases, an alternative theoretical picture has been developed which is based on a 'coherent band' of classically occupied states. This is often called the classical or c-field approach. The goal of this chapter is to review the differences between the Beliaev broken symmetry and c-field approach, and to argue that the c-field concept of a coherent condensate band of states has problems as a description of Bose superfluidity. However, the c-field idea of treating the lowest energy excitations classically can be used to advantage to simplify calculations within the Beliaev broken-symmetry formalism.

arXiv:1206.5471•Cold atoms•Mar 18, 2013•3 citations

Many-body physics in the classical-field description of a degenerate Bose gas

Tod M. Wright, Nick P. Proukakis, Matthew J. Davis

The classical-field formalism has been widely applied in the calculation of normal correlation functions, and the characterization of condensation, in finite-temperature Bose gases. Here we discuss the extension of this method to the calculation of more general correlations, including the so-called anomalous correlations of the field, without recourse to symmetry-breaking assumptions. Our method is based on the introduction of $\mathrm{U}(1)$-symmetric classical-field variables analogous to the modified quantum ladder operators of number-conserving approaches to the degenerate Bose gas, and allows us to rigorously quantify the anomalous and non-Gaussian character of the field fluctuations. We compare our results for anomalous correlation functions with the predictions of mean-field theories, and demonstrate that the nonlinear classical-field dynamics incorporate a full description of many-body processes which modify the effective mean-field potentials experienced by condensate and noncondensate atoms. We discuss the role of these processes in shaping the condensate mode, and thereby demonstrate the consistency of the Penrose-Onsager definition of the condensate orbital in the classical-field equilibrium. We consider the contribution of various noncondensate-field correlations to the overall suppression of density fluctuations and interactions in the field, and demonstrate the distinct roles of phase and density fluctuations in the transition of the field to the normal phase.

arXiv:1011.6289•Physical Review A•Aug 5, 2011•31 citations

Physical aspects of symmetry breaking in Bose gases at thermal equilibrium

Alexej Schelle

The theory of non-interacting Bose gases is supplemented by a numerical quantum field description with a two-dimensional non-local order parameter that allows the modeling of wave-like atomic correlations and interference effects in the limit of low atomic densities. From the present model, it is possible to explain symmetry aspects of non-interacting and very weakly interacting Bose gases in the limit of fluctuating particle numbers, like the forward propagation of time and the relation to the breaking and preservation of phase gauge symmetry in solids. In the present formalism, the propagation of one-directional time arises from the pre-defined and equivalent convergence of independent quantum fields towards the Boltzmann equilibrium, and it is shown that Glauber coherent states are related to the definition of the quantized field. Coherently coupling condensate and non-condensate parts as a direct consequence of the increasing quantum coherence time between the different quantum field components in the Bose gas from cooling to below the critical temperature, the present model describes symmetry breaking, which is originally known from the definition of a specific gauge field from Elitzur's theorem for local gauge fields, as a global physical rather than a purely formal mathematical process.

arXiv:2410.10893•Oct 12, 2024•0 citations

C-Field Methods for Non-Equilibrium Bose Gases

Matthew J. Davis, Tod M. Wright, P. B. Blakie +3 more

We review c-field methods for simulating the non-equilibrium dynamics of degenerate Bose gases beyond the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii approximation. We describe three separate approaches that utilise similar numerical methods, but have distinct regimes of validity. Systems at finite temperature can be treated with either the closed-system projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation (PGPE), or the open-system stochastic projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation (SPGPE). These are both applicable in quantum degenerate regimes in which thermal fluctuations are significant. At low or zero temperature, the truncated Wigner projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation (TWPGPE) allows for the simulation of systems in which spontaneous collision processes seeded by quantum fluctuations are important. We describe the regimes of validity of each of these methods, and discuss their relationships to one another, and to other simulation techniques for the dynamics of Bose gases. The utility of the SPGPE formalism in modelling non-equilibrium Bose gases is illustrated by its application to the dynamics of spontaneous vortex formation in the growth of a Bose-Einstein condensate.

arXiv:1206.5470•Cold atoms•Mar 18, 2013•6 citations

Methods of quantum field theory for trapped Bose–Einstein condensates

J. Rogel-Salazar, Seok Jin Choi, G.H.C. New +1 more

In this tutorial we present an introduction to some theoretical methods of quantum field theory applied to the description of a trapped Bose–Einstein condensate. First of all, we give a brief account of the main characteristics of the phenomenon of condensation and present the many-body Hamiltonian of the system. We outline some of the most important approaches used in the characterization of a condensed Bose gas, including the mean-field theory and the Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov method. Finally we illustrate the use of these techniques addressing some important issues in quantum atom optics. We characterize the quantum state of a Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) at zero temperature. We also describe a process of Beliaev coupling between quasiparticles using a method that includes terms beyond the usual Bogoliubov approach.

Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Jun 18, 2004•10 citations

Effective action approach to Bose-Einstein condensation of ideal gases

Klaus Kirsten, David J. Toms

We present a short review of how the effective action formalism, well known in relativistic quantum field theory, can be used to discuss Bose-Einstein condensation of non-relativistic gases.This method lends itself very naturally to an interpretation of Bose-Einstein condensation in terms of symmetry breaking.It also allows for the definition of a very elegant regularization technique involving generalized ␨ -functions.We show how this method can be used to recover the well known results for the free boson gas, as well as the charged boson gas in a constant magnetic field.A general criterion for interpreting Bose-Einstein condensation in terms of a phase transition with symmetry breaking is given.Finally we present an analysis of Bose-Einstein condensation in a harmonic oscillator confining potential trap, and show how the results of this simple model are in excellent agreement with experiment.

Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology•Jul 1, 1996•10 citations
We present our views on the issues raised in the previous chapter by Griffin and Zaremba. We review some of the strengths and limitations of the Bose symmetry-breaking assumption, and explain how such an approach precludes the description of many important phenomena in degenerate Bose gases. We discuss the theoretical justification for the classical-field (c-field) methods, their relation to other non-perturbative methods for similar systems, and their utility in the description of beyond-mean-field physics. Although it is true that present implementations of c-field methods cannot accurately describe certain collective oscillations of the partially condensed Bose gas, there is no fundamental reason why these methods cannot be extended to treat such scenarios. By contrast, many regimes of non-equilibrium dynamics that can be described with c-field methods are beyond the reach of generalised mean-field kinetic approaches based on symmetry breaking, such as the ZNG formalism.
The standard theoretical basis for understanding superfluidity in Bose systems was formulated by Beliaev in 1957, based on splitting the quantum field operator into a macroscopically occupied condensate component and a non-condensate component. This leads to a description of the condensate in terms of a 'single-particle state', the so-called macroscopic wavefunction. Since the discovery of Bose-condensed gases, an alternative theoretical picture has been developed which is based on a 'coherent band' of classically occupied states. This is often called the classical or c-field approach. The goal of this chapter is to review the differences between the Beliaev broken symmetry and c-field approach, and to argue that the c-field concept of a coherent condensate band of states has problems as a description of Bose superfluidity. However, the c-field idea of treating the lowest energy excitations classically can be used to advantage to simplify calculations within the Beliaev broken-symmetry formalism.
The classical-field formalism has been widely applied in the calculation of normal correlation functions, and the characterization of condensation, in finite-temperature Bose gases. Here we discuss the extension of this method to the calculation of more general correlations, including the so-called anomalous correlations of the field, without recourse to symmetry-breaking assumptions. Our method is based on the introduction of U(1)\mathrm{U}(1)U(1)-symmetric classical-field variables analogous to the modified quantum ladder operators of number-conserving approaches to the degenerate Bose gas, and allows us to rigorously quantify the anomalous and non-Gaussian character of the field fluctuations. We compare our results for anomalous correlation functions with the predictions of mean-field theories, and demonstrate that the nonlinear classical-field dynamics incorporate a full description of many-body processes which modify the effective mean-field potentials experienced by condensate and noncondensate atoms. We discuss the role of these processes in shaping the condensate mode, and thereby demonstrate the consistency of the Penrose-Onsager definition of the condensate orbital in the classical-field equilibrium. We consider the contribution of various noncondensate-field correlations to the overall suppression of density fluctuations and interactions in the field, and demonstrate the distinct roles of phase and density fluctuations in the transition of the field to the normal phase.
The theory of non-interacting Bose gases is supplemented by a numerical quantum field description with a two-dimensional non-local order parameter that allows the modeling of wave-like atomic correlations and interference effects in the limit of low atomic densities. From the present model, it is possible to explain symmetry aspects of non-interacting and very weakly interacting Bose gases in the limit of fluctuating particle numbers, like the forward propagation of time and the relation to the breaking and preservation of phase gauge symmetry in solids. In the present formalism, the propagation of one-directional time arises from the pre-defined and equivalent convergence of independent quantum fields towards the Boltzmann equilibrium, and it is shown that Glauber coherent states are related to the definition of the quantized field. Coherently coupling condensate and non-condensate parts as a direct consequence of the increasing quantum coherence time between the different quantum field components in the Bose gas from cooling to below the critical temperature, the present model describes symmetry breaking, which is originally known from the definition of a specific gauge field from Elitzur's theorem for local gauge fields, as a global physical rather than a purely formal mathematical process.
We review c-field methods for simulating the non-equilibrium dynamics of degenerate Bose gases beyond the mean-field Gross-Pitaevskii approximation. We describe three separate approaches that utilise similar numerical methods, but have distinct regimes of validity. Systems at finite temperature can be treated with either the closed-system projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation (PGPE), or the open-system stochastic projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation (SPGPE). These are both applicable in quantum degenerate regimes in which thermal fluctuations are significant. At low or zero temperature, the truncated Wigner projected Gross-Pitaevskii equation (TWPGPE) allows for the simulation of systems in which spontaneous collision processes seeded by quantum fluctuations are important. We describe the regimes of validity of each of these methods, and discuss their relationships to one another, and to other simulation techniques for the dynamics of Bose gases. The utility of the SPGPE formalism in modelling non-equilibrium Bose gases is illustrated by its application to the dynamics of spontaneous vortex formation in the growth of a Bose-Einstein condensate.
In this tutorial we present an introduction to some theoretical methods of quantum field theory applied to the description of a trapped Bose–Einstein condensate. First of all, we give a brief account of the main characteristics of the phenomenon of condensation and present the many-body Hamiltonian of the system. We outline some of the most important approaches used in the characterization of a condensed Bose gas, including the mean-field theory and the Hartree–Fock–Bogoliubov method. Finally we illustrate the use of these techniques addressing some important issues in quantum atom optics. We characterize the quantum state of a Bose–Einstein condensate (BEC) at zero temperature. We also describe a process of Beliaev coupling between quasiparticles using a method that includes terms beyond the usual Bogoliubov approach.
We present a short review of how the effective action formalism, well known in relativistic quantum field theory, can be used to discuss Bose-Einstein condensation of non-relativistic gases.This method lends itself very naturally to an interpretation of Bose-Einstein condensation in terms of symmetry breaking.It also allows for the definition of a very elegant regularization technique involving generalized ␨ -functions.We show how this method can be used to recover the well known results for the free boson gas, as well as the charged boson gas in a constant magnetic field.A general criterion for interpreting Bose-Einstein condensation in terms of a phase transition with symmetry breaking is given.Finally we present an analysis of Bose-Einstein condensation in a harmonic oscillator confining potential trap, and show how the results of this simple model are in excellent agreement with experiment.