Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1206.0630 · New Journal of Physics

Three-dimensionality of space and the quantum bit: an information-theoretic approach

Markus P Müller, Lluís Masanes

Published May 28, 2013• 56 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is sometimes pointed out as a curiosity that the state space of quantum two-level systems, i.e. the qubit, and actual physical space are both three-dimensional and Euclidean. In this paper, we suggest an information-theoretic analysis of this relationship, by proving a particular mathematical result: suppose that physics takes place in d spatial dimensions, and that some events happen probabilistically (not assuming quantum theory in any way). Furthermore, suppose there are systems that carry 'minimal amounts of direction information', interacting via some continuous reversible time evolution. We prove that this uniquely determines spatial dimension d = 3 and quantum theory on two qubits (including entanglement and unitary time evolution), and that it allows observers to infer local spatial geometry from probability measurements.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/15/5/053040

Related papers

Entanglement and the three-dimensionality of the Bloch ball

Lluís Masanes, Markus P. Müller, David Pérez-García +1 more

We consider a very natural generalization of quantum theory by letting the dimension of the Bloch ball be not necessarily three. We analyze bipartite state spaces where each of the components has a d-dimensional Euclidean ball as state space. In addition to this, we impose two very natural assumptions: the continuity and reversibility of dynamics and the possibility of characterizing bipartite states by local measurements. We classify all these bipartite state spaces and prove that, except for the quantum two-qubit state space, none of them contains entangled states. Equivalently, in any of these non-quantum theories, interacting dynamics is impossible. This result reveals that “existence of entanglement” is the requirement with minimal logical content which singles out quantum theory from our family of theories.

arXiv:1111.4060•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2014•37 citations

On Qubits and Quantum Information Technologies

Guang-Liang Li

The basic assumption underlying various quantum information technologies, such as quantum computation and quantum communication, is that qubits are physical objects. However, this assumption is false. A qubit is a quantum superposition, which is a purely mathematical entity in a Hilbert space for description of a two-level quantum system. There is no theoretical or experimental evidence for quantum superpositions in general, and for qubits in particular, having physical counterparts in the real world, although quantum systems themselves are all physical objects. Nevertheless, quantum superpositions failing to be physical objects does not necessarily imply quantum mechanics failing to be correct. Hilbert spaces differ essentially from the three-dimensional Euclidean space; the latter is the model of space in which we live and measure physical quantities. Associated with time or space coordinates, measurements of all quantum systems must be performed in the real world. However, precise time and space coordinates are not attainable by measurement. Based on a comparison between the Euclidean space and Hilbert spaces, this paper shows that no quantum systems in the real world can realize qubits, and hence, quantum information technologies are not physically realizable; their so-called advantages over classical information technologies make little sense.

Qeios•Nov 16, 2023•2 citations

Non-Euclidean Geometry for Quantum Information Theory

Jincheng Zhang

This paper explores the potential of non-Euclidean geometry to provide a novel framework for understanding and modeling quantum information. Traditional approaches often treat quantum information as a purely mathematical construct, limiting its applicability to purely computational contexts. We propose a radical shift, formalizing quantum information as a geometric object within a non-Euclidean space, leveraging the properties of geometry to reveal deeper connections to the physical world. The core mechanism centers around extending the concept of quantum information beyond classical representations, allowing for the visualization and manipulation of entanglement and other quantum phenomena through a geometric lens. This paper will detail the conceptual groundwork, mathematical framework, and potential implications of this approach, emphasizing its capacity to bridge the gap between abstract mathematics and the complexities of quantum mechanics. Chapter 1: Foundations – Geometry and Information The fundamental concept underpinning this research lies in the recognition that geometry, particularly non-Euclidean geometry, possesses inherent properties that resonate with the nature of quantum information. Classical geometry, with its inherent Euclidean assumptions, struggles to adequately capture the counterintuitive aspects of quantum mechanics. The inherent non-Euclidean nature of space, where distances are not absolute but relative, mirrors the fundamental fuzziness and probabilistic nature of quantum states. Furthermore, the distribution of information, a cornerstone of quantum mechanics, can be visualized as a complex geometric pattern, and non-Euclidean geometry offers a powerful tool to analyze and manipulate this pattern. The challenge, therefore, is to move beyond a purely mathematical abstraction to a geometric understanding of information itself. Early attempts to model quantum information often relied on representations like Hilbert spaces, which, while powerful, represent information as a vector space. However, this representation lacks the inherent geometric richness that is crucial for understanding entanglement and other quantum phenomena. We propose a shift towards representing quantum information as points within a non-Euclidean space, where the distance and orientation of these points encode the quantum state. This shift is predicated on the observation that geometric properties, such as curvature and connectivity, are intimately linked to quantum entanglement and the preservation of information. The core idea is to formulate a geometric model where entanglement is represented not as a correlation between particles but as a distortion of the geometric space itself, influenced by the quantum state. This distortion, driven by the inherent properties of the non-Euclidean space, provides a richer and potentially more intuitive understanding of quantum phenomena. The choice of non-Euclidean geometry is not arbitrary; it is intended to be a 'natural' choice, reflecting the underlying structure of quantum information. Chapter 2: Non-Euclidean Geometry – A Conceptual Framework We introduce a specific type of non-Euclidean geometry, termed "Hyperbolic Geometry for Quantum Information," that incorporates several key features. Unlike Euclidean geometry, Hyperbolic Geometry allows for the representation of multiple, potentially conflicting, states simultaneously. This is achieved through the concept of "Hyperbolic Density," which quantifies the probability of finding a quantum state within a given region of the space. The density of a Hyperbolic Density is influenced by the quantum state, creating a dynamic and evolving geometric representation. The mathematical framework of Hyperbolic Geometry is built around the concept of "Geometric Curvature." This curvature is not simply a measure of distance but rather a representation of the quantum state's inherent orientation. Specifically, we define a curvature function that is sensitive to the quantum state. This curvature is not constant; it adapts to the quantum state, creating a continuously evolving geometric representation. This adaptation is crucial for capturing the inherent randomness and non-determinism of quantum mechanics. Furthermore, we introduce the concept of "Geometric Connectivity," which describes the relationships between points within the Hyperbolic Geometry. These connections are not simply spatial relationships but are defined by the quantum state's inherent properties. The strength and type of connectivity represent the degree to which the quantum state is entangled with the geometric structure. This connectivity is dynamically modified by the curvature function, creating a complex and interconnected geometric pattern. The core mathematical tool for manipulating these geometries is the "Geometric Transformation." This transformation allows us to 'morph' geometric forms into new forms, representing the evolution of quantum information. The transformation is based on a specific set of rules which are intrinsically linked to the nature of entanglement. These rules are carefully designed to preserve the fundamental properties of quantum information.

•Sep 6, 2026•0 citations

Towards Quantum Information Theory in Space and Time

Igor Vasil'evich Volovich

Modern quantum information theory deals with an idealized situation when the spacetime dependence of quantum phenomena is neglected. However the transmission and processing of (quantum) information is a physical process in spacetime. Therefore such basic notions in quantum information theory as qubit, channel, composite systems and entangled states should be formulated in space and time. In particlular we suggest that instead of a two level system (qubit) the basic notion in a relativistic quantum information theory should be a notion of an elementary quantum system, i.e. an infinite dimensional Hilbert space $H$ invariant under an irreducible representation of the Poincare group labeled by $[m,s]$ where $m\geq 0$ is mass and $s=0,1/2,1,...$ is spin. We emphasize an importance of consideration of quantum information theory from the point of view of quantum field theory. We point out and discuss a fundamental fact that in quantum field theory there is a statistical dependence between two regions in spacetime even if they are spacelike separated. A classical probabilistic representation for a family of correlation functions in quantum field theory is obtained. Entangled states in space and time are considered. It is shown that any reasonable state in relativistic quantum field theory becomes disentangled (factorizable) at large spacelike distances if one makes local observations. As a result a violation of Bell`s inequalities can be observed without inconsistency with principles of relativistic quantum theory only if the distance between detectors is rather small. We suggest a further experimental study of entangled states in spacetime by studying the dependence of the correlation functions on the distance between detectors.

arXiv:quant-ph/0203030•Mar 6, 2002•27 citations

Quantum Theory and Beyond: Is Entanglement Special?

Borivoje Dakić, Časlav Brukner

Quantum theory makes the most accurate empirical predictions and yet it lacks simple, comprehensible physical principles from which the theory can be uniquely derived. A broad class of probabilistic theories exist which all share some features with quantum theory, such as probabilistic predictions for individual outcomes (indeterminism), the impossibility of information transfer faster than speed of light (no-signaling) or the impossibility of copying of unknown states (no-cloning). A vast majority of attempts to find physical principles behind quantum theory either fall short of deriving the theory uniquely from the principles or are based on abstract mathematical assumptions that require themselves a more conclusive physical motivation. Here, we show that classical probability theory and quantum theory can be reconstructed from three reasonable axioms: (1) (Information capacity) All systems with information carrying capacity of one bit are equivalent. (2) (Locality) The state of a composite system is completely determined by measurements on its subsystems. (3) (Reversibility) Between any two pure states there exists a reversible transformation. If one requires the transformation from the last axiom to be continuous, one separates quantum theory from the classical probabilistic one. A remarkable result following from our reconstruction is that no probability theory other than quantum theory can exhibit entanglement without contradicting one or more axioms.

arXiv:0911.0695•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 18, 2011•281 citations

The Missing Premises of Quantum Measurement - Definite records and the Born rule from identity under transformation

Marc Maibom

La Profilée is the structural architecture of determinate nature: Constitution identifies the whole, Transformation evaluates its existence and identity through change, and Coexistence evaluates relations among realized wholes. This paper applies the full architecture to quantum measurement without changing the quantum equations. Its physical subject remains definite outcomes, their relation to unitary evolution, the Born law, and the identity of the records that carry them. A physically completed coupling resolves an exhaustive exclusive record variable; LP determinability then gives one actual record value without an observer selecting it. Exclusive actuality does not entail projection of the globally retained quantum state. Rank-one calibration and repeatability fix the affirmative branch map. Statistical non-contextuality additionally requires identity of the complete input–event experiment and descent of its law to that identity class. Stable Boolean event frequencies then give the Gleason representation, and preparation faithfulness identifies its operator with the prepared state. Each inference is proved in the text. The argument determines the carrier and instrument before using these results. It proves that a unique instrument constitution does not select a run outcome, and that decoherence alone does not identify the physical record partition. Worked reversible-laboratory and relational cases distinguish an actual event from persistence of its record. Quantum recovery makes the distinction quantitative: a two-qubit copying channel preserves classical labels exactly, loses local full-qubit recoverability with optimal normalized diamond error one half, and preserves the full code jointly. Continuation-family and complementary-channel results connect those measurement records to information preservation, including evaporation. The resulting measurement theorem states its structural and physical requirements explicitly; it does not predict the individual outcome or infer multi-time consistency from a formal state–label pair alone.

•Jul 21, 2026•0 citations
It is sometimes pointed out as a curiosity that the state space of quantum two-level systems, i.e. the qubit, and actual physical space are both three-dimensional and Euclidean. In this paper, we suggest an information-theoretic analysis of this relationship, by proving a particular mathematical result: suppose that physics takes place in d spatial dimensions, and that some events happen probabilistically (not assuming quantum theory in any way). Furthermore, suppose there are systems that carry 'minimal amounts of direction information', interacting via some continuous reversible time evolution. We prove that this uniquely determines spatial dimension d = 3 and quantum theory on two qubits (including entanglement and unitary time evolution), and that it allows observers to infer local spatial geometry from probability measurements.
We consider a very natural generalization of quantum theory by letting the dimension of the Bloch ball be not necessarily three. We analyze bipartite state spaces where each of the components has a d-dimensional Euclidean ball as state space. In addition to this, we impose two very natural assumptions: the continuity and reversibility of dynamics and the possibility of characterizing bipartite states by local measurements. We classify all these bipartite state spaces and prove that, except for the quantum two-qubit state space, none of them contains entangled states. Equivalently, in any of these non-quantum theories, interacting dynamics is impossible. This result reveals that “existence of entanglement” is the requirement with minimal logical content which singles out quantum theory from our family of theories.
The basic assumption underlying various quantum information technologies, such as quantum computation and quantum communication, is that qubits are physical objects. However, this assumption is false. A qubit is a quantum superposition, which is a purely mathematical entity in a Hilbert space for description of a two-level quantum system. There is no theoretical or experimental evidence for quantum superpositions in general, and for qubits in particular, having physical counterparts in the real world, although quantum systems themselves are all physical objects. Nevertheless, quantum superpositions failing to be physical objects does not necessarily imply quantum mechanics failing to be correct. Hilbert spaces differ essentially from the three-dimensional Euclidean space; the latter is the model of space in which we live and measure physical quantities. Associated with time or space coordinates, measurements of all quantum systems must be performed in the real world. However, precise time and space coordinates are not attainable by measurement. Based on a comparison between the Euclidean space and Hilbert spaces, this paper shows that no quantum systems in the real world can realize qubits, and hence, quantum information technologies are not physically realizable; their so-called advantages over classical information technologies make little sense.
This paper explores the potential of non-Euclidean geometry to provide a novel framework for understanding and modeling quantum information. Traditional approaches often treat quantum information as a purely mathematical construct, limiting its applicability to purely computational contexts. We propose a radical shift, formalizing quantum information as a geometric object within a non-Euclidean space, leveraging the properties of geometry to reveal deeper connections to the physical world. The core mechanism centers around extending the concept of quantum information beyond classical representations, allowing for the visualization and manipulation of entanglement and other quantum phenomena through a geometric lens. This paper will detail the conceptual groundwork, mathematical framework, and potential implications of this approach, emphasizing its capacity to bridge the gap between abstract mathematics and the complexities of quantum mechanics. Chapter 1: Foundations – Geometry and Information The fundamental concept underpinning this research lies in the recognition that geometry, particularly non-Euclidean geometry, possesses inherent properties that resonate with the nature of quantum information. Classical geometry, with its inherent Euclidean assumptions, struggles to adequately capture the counterintuitive aspects of quantum mechanics. The inherent non-Euclidean nature of space, where distances are not absolute but relative, mirrors the fundamental fuzziness and probabilistic nature of quantum states. Furthermore, the distribution of information, a cornerstone of quantum mechanics, can be visualized as a complex geometric pattern, and non-Euclidean geometry offers a powerful tool to analyze and manipulate this pattern. The challenge, therefore, is to move beyond a purely mathematical abstraction to a geometric understanding of information itself. Early attempts to model quantum information often relied on representations like Hilbert spaces, which, while powerful, represent information as a vector space. However, this representation lacks the inherent geometric richness that is crucial for understanding entanglement and other quantum phenomena. We propose a shift towards representing quantum information as points within a non-Euclidean space, where the distance and orientation of these points encode the quantum state. This shift is predicated on the observation that geometric properties, such as curvature and connectivity, are intimately linked to quantum entanglement and the preservation of information. The core idea is to formulate a geometric model where entanglement is represented not as a correlation between particles but as a distortion of the geometric space itself, influenced by the quantum state. This distortion, driven by the inherent properties of the non-Euclidean space, provides a richer and potentially more intuitive understanding of quantum phenomena. The choice of non-Euclidean geometry is not arbitrary; it is intended to be a 'natural' choice, reflecting the underlying structure of quantum information. Chapter 2: Non-Euclidean Geometry – A Conceptual Framework We introduce a specific type of non-Euclidean geometry, termed "Hyperbolic Geometry for Quantum Information," that incorporates several key features. Unlike Euclidean geometry, Hyperbolic Geometry allows for the representation of multiple, potentially conflicting, states simultaneously. This is achieved through the concept of "Hyperbolic Density," which quantifies the probability of finding a quantum state within a given region of the space. The density of a Hyperbolic Density is influenced by the quantum state, creating a dynamic and evolving geometric representation. The mathematical framework of Hyperbolic Geometry is built around the concept of "Geometric Curvature." This curvature is not simply a measure of distance but rather a representation of the quantum state's inherent orientation. Specifically, we define a curvature function that is sensitive to the quantum state. This curvature is not constant; it adapts to the quantum state, creating a continuously evolving geometric representation. This adaptation is crucial for capturing the inherent randomness and non-determinism of quantum mechanics. Furthermore, we introduce the concept of "Geometric Connectivity," which describes the relationships between points within the Hyperbolic Geometry. These connections are not simply spatial relationships but are defined by the quantum state's inherent properties. The strength and type of connectivity represent the degree to which the quantum state is entangled with the geometric structure. This connectivity is dynamically modified by the curvature function, creating a complex and interconnected geometric pattern. The core mathematical tool for manipulating these geometries is the "Geometric Transformation." This transformation allows us to 'morph' geometric forms into new forms, representing the evolution of quantum information. The transformation is based on a specific set of rules which are intrinsically linked to the nature of entanglement. These rules are carefully designed to preserve the fundamental properties of quantum information.
Modern quantum information theory deals with an idealized situation when the spacetime dependence of quantum phenomena is neglected. However the transmission and processing of (quantum) information is a physical process in spacetime. Therefore such basic notions in quantum information theory as qubit, channel, composite systems and entangled states should be formulated in space and time. In particlular we suggest that instead of a two level system (qubit) the basic notion in a relativistic quantum information theory should be a notion of an elementary quantum system, i.e. an infinite dimensional Hilbert space HHH invariant under an irreducible representation of the Poincare group labeled by [m,s][m,s][m,s] where m≥0m\geq 0m≥0 is mass and s=0,1/2,1,...s=0,1/2,1,...s=0,1/2,1,... is spin. We emphasize an importance of consideration of quantum information theory from the point of view of quantum field theory. We point out and discuss a fundamental fact that in quantum field theory there is a statistical dependence between two regions in spacetime even if they are spacelike separated. A classical probabilistic representation for a family of correlation functions in quantum field theory is obtained. Entangled states in space and time are considered. It is shown that any reasonable state in relativistic quantum field theory becomes disentangled (factorizable) at large spacelike distances if one makes local observations. As a result a violation of Bell`s inequalities can be observed without inconsistency with principles of relativistic quantum theory only if the distance between detectors is rather small. We suggest a further experimental study of entangled states in spacetime by studying the dependence of the correlation functions on the distance between detectors.
Quantum theory makes the most accurate empirical predictions and yet it lacks simple, comprehensible physical principles from which the theory can be uniquely derived. A broad class of probabilistic theories exist which all share some features with quantum theory, such as probabilistic predictions for individual outcomes (indeterminism), the impossibility of information transfer faster than speed of light (no-signaling) or the impossibility of copying of unknown states (no-cloning). A vast majority of attempts to find physical principles behind quantum theory either fall short of deriving the theory uniquely from the principles or are based on abstract mathematical assumptions that require themselves a more conclusive physical motivation. Here, we show that classical probability theory and quantum theory can be reconstructed from three reasonable axioms: (1) (Information capacity) All systems with information carrying capacity of one bit are equivalent. (2) (Locality) The state of a composite system is completely determined by measurements on its subsystems. (3) (Reversibility) Between any two pure states there exists a reversible transformation. If one requires the transformation from the last axiom to be continuous, one separates quantum theory from the classical probabilistic one. A remarkable result following from our reconstruction is that no probability theory other than quantum theory can exhibit entanglement without contradicting one or more axioms.
La Profilée is the structural architecture of determinate nature: Constitution identifies the whole, Transformation evaluates its existence and identity through change, and Coexistence evaluates relations among realized wholes. This paper applies the full architecture to quantum measurement without changing the quantum equations. Its physical subject remains definite outcomes, their relation to unitary evolution, the Born law, and the identity of the records that carry them. A physically completed coupling resolves an exhaustive exclusive record variable; LP determinability then gives one actual record value without an observer selecting it. Exclusive actuality does not entail projection of the globally retained quantum state. Rank-one calibration and repeatability fix the affirmative branch map. Statistical non-contextuality additionally requires identity of the complete input–event experiment and descent of its law to that identity class. Stable Boolean event frequencies then give the Gleason representation, and preparation faithfulness identifies its operator with the prepared state. Each inference is proved in the text. The argument determines the carrier and instrument before using these results. It proves that a unique instrument constitution does not select a run outcome, and that decoherence alone does not identify the physical record partition. Worked reversible-laboratory and relational cases distinguish an actual event from persistence of its record. Quantum recovery makes the distinction quantitative: a two-qubit copying channel preserves classical labels exactly, loses local full-qubit recoverability with optimal normalized diamond error one half, and preserves the full code jointly. Continuation-family and complementary-channel results connect those measurement records to information preservation, including evaporation. The resulting measurement theorem states its structural and physical requirements explicitly; it does not predict the individual outcome or infer multi-time consistency from a formal state–label pair alone.