Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1205.3048 · New Journal of Physics

Measures of macroscopicity for quantum spin systems

Florian Fröwis, Wolfgang Dür

Published Sep 21, 2012• 129 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the notion of 'macroscopicity' in the case of quantum spin systems and provide two main results. Firstly, we motivate the quantum Fisher information as a measure of the macroscopicity of quantum states. Secondly, we make a comparison with the existing literature on this topic. We report on a hierarchy among the measures and we conclude that one should carefully distinguish between 'macroscopic quantum states' and 'macroscopic superpositions', which is a strict subclass of the former.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/14/9/093039

Related papers

Quantum macroscopicity versus distillation of macroscopic superpositions

Benjamin Yadin, Vlatko Vedral

We suggest a way to quantify a type of macroscopic entanglement via distillation of Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states by local operations and classical communication. We analyze how this relates to an existing measure of quantum macroscopicity based on the quantum Fisher information in several examples. Both cluster states and Kitaev surface code states are found to not be macroscopically quantum but can be distilled into macroscopic superpositions. We look at these distillation protocols in more detail and ask whether they are robust to perturbations. One key result is that one-dimensional cluster states are not distilled robustly but higher-dimensional cluster states are.

arXiv:1407.2442•Physical Review A•Aug 28, 2015•19 citations

Measurement-based measure of the size of macroscopic quantum superpositions

Jan Ivar Korsbakken, K. Birgitta Whaley, Jonathan L. DuBois +1 more

Recent experiments claiming the formation of quantum superposition states in near-macroscopic systems raise the question of how the sizes of general quantum superposition states in an interacting system are to be quantified. We propose here a measure of size for such superposition states that is based on what measurements can be performed to probe and distinguish the different branches of the state. The measure allows the comparison of the effective size for superposition states in very different physical systems. It can be applied to a very general class of superposition states and reproduces known results for near-ideal cases. Comparison with a prior measure based on analysis of coherence between branches indicates that significantly smaller effective superposition sizes result from our measurement-based measure. Application to a system of interacting bosons in a double-well trapping potential shows that the effective superposition size is strongly dependent on the relative magnitude of the barrier height and interparticle interaction.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611121•Physical Review A•Apr 13, 2007•96 citations

Are Cloned Quantum States Macroscopic?

Florian Fröwis, Wolfgang Dür

We study quantum states produced by optimal phase covariant quantum cloners. We argue that cloned quantum superpositions are not macroscopic superpositions in the spirit of Schrödinger's cat, despite their large particle number. This is indicated by calculating several measures for macroscopic superpositions from the literature, as well as by investigating the distinguishability of the two superposed cloned states. The latter rapidly diminishes when considering imperfect detectors or noisy states and does not increase with the system size. In contrast, we find that cloned quantum states themselves are macroscopic, in the sense of both proposed measures and their usefulness in quantum metrology with an optimal scaling in system size. We investigate the applicability of cloned states for parameter estimation in the presence of different kinds of noise.

arXiv:1203.0319•Physical Review Letters•Oct 24, 2012•15 citations

A quantum phase transition implementation of quantum measurement

Peter B. Weichman

A model of quantum measurement, illustrated using the spin--boson model, is formulated in terms of a cascading pair of quantum phase transitions. The first produces the desired superposition of macroscopic responses to the microscopic state under investigation, while the second provides a mechanism for subsequent "wavefunction collapse," suppressing superpositions of distinct macroscopic states, producing instead a density matrix that implements the expected classical observation outcome via the Born probability rule. Motivated by numerous carefully designed measurements that may occur during the course of a quantum computation, effects of entanglement are investigated when the measurement is performed on only a subset of the microscopic degrees of freedom.

arXiv:1912.08764•Dec 18, 2019•1 citation

Macroscopic entanglement of many-magnon states

Tomoyuki Morimae, Ayumu Sugita, Akira Shimizu

We study macroscopic entanglement of various pure states of a one-dimensional $N$-spin system with $N⪢1$. Here, a quantum state is said to be macroscopically entangled if it is a superposition of macroscopically distinct states. To judge whether such superposition is hidden in a general state, we use an essentially unique index $p$: A pure state is macroscopically entangled if $p=2$, whereas it may be entangled but not macroscopically if $p<2$. This index is directly related to fundamental stabilities of many-body states. We calculate the index $p$ for various states in which magnons are excited with various densities and wave numbers. We find macroscopically entangled states $(p=2)$ as well as states with $p=1$. The former states are unstable in the sense that they are unstable against some local measurements. On the other hand, the latter states are stable in the senses that they are stable against any local measurements and that their decoherence rates never exceed $O(N)$ in any weak classical noises. For comparison, we also calculate the von Neumann entropy ${S}_{N∕2}(N)$ of a subsystem composed of $N∕2$ spins as a measure of bipartite entanglement. We find that ${S}_{N∕2}(N)$ of some states with $p=1$ is of the same order of magnitude as the maximum value $N∕2$. On the other hand, ${S}_{N∕2}(N)$ of the macroscopically entangled states with $p=2$ is as small as $O(\mathrm{log}\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}N)⪡N∕2$. Therefore larger ${S}_{N∕2}(N)$ does not mean more instability. We also point out that these results are partly analogous to those for interacting many bosons. Furthermore, the origin of the huge entanglement, as measured either by $p$ or ${S}_{N∕2}(N)$, is discussed to be due to spatial propagation of magnons.

arXiv:quant-ph/0405173•Physical Review A•Mar 17, 2005•43 citations

Signatures for Generalized Macroscopic Superpositions

Eric G. Cavalcanti, M. D. Reid

We develop criteria sufficient to enable detection of macroscopic coherence where there are not just two macroscopically distinct outcomes for a pointer measurement, but rather a spread of outcomes over a macroscopic range. The criteria provide a means to distinguish a macroscopic quantum description from a microscopic one based on mixtures of microscopic superpositions of pointer-measurement eigenstates. The criteria are applied to Gaussian-squeezed and spin-entangled states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0701204•Physical Review Letters•Oct 26, 2006•55 citations
We investigate the notion of 'macroscopicity' in the case of quantum spin systems and provide two main results. Firstly, we motivate the quantum Fisher information as a measure of the macroscopicity of quantum states. Secondly, we make a comparison with the existing literature on this topic. We report on a hierarchy among the measures and we conclude that one should carefully distinguish between 'macroscopic quantum states' and 'macroscopic superpositions', which is a strict subclass of the former.
We suggest a way to quantify a type of macroscopic entanglement via distillation of Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states by local operations and classical communication. We analyze how this relates to an existing measure of quantum macroscopicity based on the quantum Fisher information in several examples. Both cluster states and Kitaev surface code states are found to not be macroscopically quantum but can be distilled into macroscopic superpositions. We look at these distillation protocols in more detail and ask whether they are robust to perturbations. One key result is that one-dimensional cluster states are not distilled robustly but higher-dimensional cluster states are.
Recent experiments claiming the formation of quantum superposition states in near-macroscopic systems raise the question of how the sizes of general quantum superposition states in an interacting system are to be quantified. We propose here a measure of size for such superposition states that is based on what measurements can be performed to probe and distinguish the different branches of the state. The measure allows the comparison of the effective size for superposition states in very different physical systems. It can be applied to a very general class of superposition states and reproduces known results for near-ideal cases. Comparison with a prior measure based on analysis of coherence between branches indicates that significantly smaller effective superposition sizes result from our measurement-based measure. Application to a system of interacting bosons in a double-well trapping potential shows that the effective superposition size is strongly dependent on the relative magnitude of the barrier height and interparticle interaction.
We study quantum states produced by optimal phase covariant quantum cloners. We argue that cloned quantum superpositions are not macroscopic superpositions in the spirit of Schrödinger's cat, despite their large particle number. This is indicated by calculating several measures for macroscopic superpositions from the literature, as well as by investigating the distinguishability of the two superposed cloned states. The latter rapidly diminishes when considering imperfect detectors or noisy states and does not increase with the system size. In contrast, we find that cloned quantum states themselves are macroscopic, in the sense of both proposed measures and their usefulness in quantum metrology with an optimal scaling in system size. We investigate the applicability of cloned states for parameter estimation in the presence of different kinds of noise.
A model of quantum measurement, illustrated using the spin--boson model, is formulated in terms of a cascading pair of quantum phase transitions. The first produces the desired superposition of macroscopic responses to the microscopic state under investigation, while the second provides a mechanism for subsequent "wavefunction collapse," suppressing superpositions of distinct macroscopic states, producing instead a density matrix that implements the expected classical observation outcome via the Born probability rule. Motivated by numerous carefully designed measurements that may occur during the course of a quantum computation, effects of entanglement are investigated when the measurement is performed on only a subset of the microscopic degrees of freedom.
We study macroscopic entanglement of various pure states of a one-dimensional NNN-spin system with N⪢1N⪢1N⪢1. Here, a quantum state is said to be macroscopically entangled if it is a superposition of macroscopically distinct states. To judge whether such superposition is hidden in a general state, we use an essentially unique index ppp: A pure state is macroscopically entangled if p=2p=2p=2, whereas it may be entangled but not macroscopically if p<2p<2p<2. This index is directly related to fundamental stabilities of many-body states. We calculate the index ppp for various states in which magnons are excited with various densities and wave numbers. We find macroscopically entangled states (p=2)(p=2)(p=2) as well as states with p=1p=1p=1. The former states are unstable in the sense that they are unstable against some local measurements. On the other hand, the latter states are stable in the senses that they are stable against any local measurements and that their decoherence rates never exceed O(N)O(N)O(N) in any weak classical noises. For comparison, we also calculate the von Neumann entropy SN∕2(N){S}_{N∕2}(N)SN∕2​(N) of a subsystem composed of N∕2N∕2N∕2 spins as a measure of bipartite entanglement. We find that SN∕2(N){S}_{N∕2}(N)SN∕2​(N) of some states with p=1p=1p=1 is of the same order of magnitude as the maximum value N∕2N∕2N∕2. On the other hand, SN∕2(N){S}_{N∕2}(N)SN∕2​(N) of the macroscopically entangled states with p=2p=2p=2 is as small as O(logN)⪡N∕2O(\mathrm{log}\phantom{\rule{0.2em}{0ex}}N)⪡N∕2O(logN)⪡N∕2. Therefore larger SN∕2(N){S}_{N∕2}(N)SN∕2​(N) does not mean more instability. We also point out that these results are partly analogous to those for interacting many bosons. Furthermore, the origin of the huge entanglement, as measured either by ppp or SN∕2(N){S}_{N∕2}(N)SN∕2​(N), is discussed to be due to spatial propagation of magnons.