Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1205.1416 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

On a proposal of superluminal communication

GianCarlo Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Published May 23, 2012• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently, various new proposals of superluminal transmission of information have been suggested in the literature. Since the proposals make systematic use of recent formal and practical improvements in quantum mechanics, the old theorems proving the impossibility of such a performance must be adapted to the new scenario. In this communication, we consider some of the most challenging proposals of this kind and we show why they cannot work.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/45/23/232001

Related papers

On a Proposal of Superluminal Communication (Russian Version)

G. C. Ghirardi, Raffaele Romano

Recently, various new proposals of superluminal transmission of information have appeared in the literature. Since they make systematic resort to recent formal and practical improvements in quantum mechanics, the old theorems proving the impossibility of such a performance must be adapted to the new scenario. In this paper we consider some of the most challenging proposals of this kind and we show why they cannot work.

•Jun 1, 2018•0 citations

On superluminal information transmission using quantum systems

Giovanni Andrea Fantasia

Abstract. In the present work we investigate the possibility of superluminal information transmission using quantum systems. We give a general argument to prove that local actions on general entangled system are not useful at the purpose. A protocol for superluminal information transmission that makes use of a kind of observables we have discovered is proposed.

•Jan 20, 2003•0 citations

Superluminality in Quantum Theory

Giovanni Andrea Fantasia

In the present work we investigate the possibility of superluminal information transmission in quantum theory. We give simple and general arguments to prove that the general structure (Hilbert's space plus instantaneous state reduction) of the theory allows the existence of superluminal communication. We discuss how this relates with existing no-signalling theorems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0301100•Jan 20, 2003•0 citations

Comments on a recent proposal of superluminal communication

G. C. Ghirardi

We analyze critically a recent proposal of faster than light communication.

arXiv:1411.0893•Nov 4, 2014•4 citations

On Kalamidas' proposal of faster than light quantum communication

G. C. Ghirardi, Romano, Raffaele

In a recent paper, Kalamidas has advanced a new proposal of faster than light communication which has not yet been proved invalid. In this paper, by strictly sticking to the standard quantum formalism we prove that, as all previous proposals, it does not work.

arXiv:1306.1133•Jun 5, 2013•1 citation

A Unified Classification of FTL No Go Results

John Eonas

The Causal Bottleneck argues that two physics literatures which never cite each other quantum information no-signaling theorems (Gisin, Polchinski) and general-relativistic chronology protection (Everett, Krasnikov, Barceló et al.) are actually answering the same question with the same answer. It sorts every faster-than-light transport scheme into one dichotomy: is it triggerable (can an agent actually control the outcome, not just correlate with it) and is it covariant (does it work the same way for any boosted observer, with no hidden preferred frame)? A short theorem shows that anything satisfying both, plus genuine superluminal signaling, composes into a signal arriving before it's sent. The paper then runs fourteen distinct FTL proposals five from quantum mechanics, nine from wormholes/warp drives through that test and shows each one fails by violating exactly one of the two conditions (with three "Class B" cases that fail because they're not really distinct new mechanisms at all, just relabelings of existing physics). It also includes an original negative result specific to your QEL formalism (the phase-antisymmetry/$S_{AB}$ construction). The core claim isn't a new impossibility theorem the underlying argument is old but the convergence itself: two unconnected fields, tested against one common standard, land on the identical obstruction every time.

•Aug 30, 2026•0 citations
Recently, various new proposals of superluminal transmission of information have been suggested in the literature. Since the proposals make systematic use of recent formal and practical improvements in quantum mechanics, the old theorems proving the impossibility of such a performance must be adapted to the new scenario. In this communication, we consider some of the most challenging proposals of this kind and we show why they cannot work.
The Causal Bottleneck argues that two physics literatures which never cite each other quantum information no-signaling theorems (Gisin, Polchinski) and general-relativistic chronology protection (Everett, Krasnikov, Barceló et al.) are actually answering the same question with the same answer. It sorts every faster-than-light transport scheme into one dichotomy: is it triggerable (can an agent actually control the outcome, not just correlate with it) and is it covariant (does it work the same way for any boosted observer, with no hidden preferred frame)? A short theorem shows that anything satisfying both, plus genuine superluminal signaling, composes into a signal arriving before it's sent. The paper then runs fourteen distinct FTL proposals five from quantum mechanics, nine from wormholes/warp drives through that test and shows each one fails by violating exactly one of the two conditions (with three "Class B" cases that fail because they're not really distinct new mechanisms at all, just relabelings of existing physics). It also includes an original negative result specific to your QEL formalism (the phase-antisymmetry/SABS_{AB}SAB​ construction). The core claim isn't a new impossibility theorem the underlying argument is old but the convergence itself: two unconnected fields, tested against one common standard, land on the identical obstruction every time.