Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1205.0073

Measurement uncertainties in the quantum formalism: quasi-realities of individual systems

Holger Friedrich Hofmann

Published May 1, 2012• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The evaluation of uncertainties in quantum measurements is problematic since the correct value of an observable between state preparation and measurement is experimentally inaccessible. In Ozawa's formulation of uncertainty relations for quantum measurements, the correct value of an observable is represented by the operator of that observable. Here, I consider the implications of this operator-based assignment of values to individual systems and discuss the relation with weak values and weak measurement statistics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1205.0073

Related papers

Uncertainty Relations for Accurate Measurements

Seiji Kosugi

Our investigation of the results of the neutron spin experiment by Ehhart et al. demonstrates that their results cannot be understood in accordance with common sense. For example, their results obtained with different measurement errors are equal to each other for a same neutron state. This is because their measurement values have a large systematic error due to adopting an incorrect measurement-value operator, which is the operator that gives the measurement values of the measured observable. They asserted that their results confirmed the validity of a universally valid uncertainty relation proposed by Ozawa. Therefore, their results demonstrate unexpectedly that Ozawa's uncertainty relation holds true for incorrect measurements. In addition, we have proved this fact theoretically. The measurement-value operator must be defined in order that the systematic error of measurement values predicted by the operator is zero. Such a measurement is called an accurate measurement. Two kind of uncertainty relations are derived for accurate measurements of a pre-measurement observable $\hat{x}_0$. In addition, we have presented an uncertainty relation for accurate measurements of a post-measurement observable $\hat{x}_t$. Heisenberg's original uncertainty relation for measurement processes should be interpreted as this relation between the resolution, that is, the measurement error of the post-measurement observable $\hat{x}_t$ and the disturbance of an object observable $\hat{y}_0$.

arXiv:1309.1966•Sep 8, 2013•0 citations

A universal formulation of uncertainty relation for errors

Jaeha Lee, Izumi Tsutsui

We present a universal formulation of uncertainty relation valid for any conceivable quantum measurement of statistical nature. Owing to its simplicity and operational tangibility, our general relation is also experimentally verifiable. Our relation violates the traditional naïve bound ħ / 2 for the position-momentum measurement while respecting Heisenberg's original philosophy of the uncertainty principle. Our relation entails, among others, the Arthurs–Kelly–Goodman and Ozawa relations as corollaries to its special cases, and also seamlessly reduces itself to the standard Kennard–Robertson (Schrödinger) relation when the measurement is non-informative.

Physics Letters A•Oct 5, 2024•3 citations

A Universal Formulation of Uncertainty Relation for Errors under Local Representability

Jaeha Lee

A universal formulation of uncertainty relations for quantum measurements is presented with additional focus on the representability of quantum observables by classical observables over a given state. Owing to the simplicity and operational tangibility of the framework, the resultant general relations admit natural operational interpretations and characterisations, and are thus also experimentally verifiable. In view of the universal formulation, Heisenberg's philosophy of the uncertainty principle is also revisited; it is reformulated and restated as a refined no-go theorem, albeit perhaps in a weaker form than was originally intended. In fact, the relations entail, in essence as corollaries to their special cases, several previously known relations, including most notably the Arthurs-Kelly-Goodman, Ozawa, and Watanabe-Sagawa-Ueda relations for quantum measurements. The Schr{ö}dinger relation (hence the standard Kennard-Robertson relation as its trivial corollary as well) is also shown to be a special case when the measurement is non-informative.

arXiv:2203.08197•Mar 15, 2022•3 citations

Uncertainty limits for quantum metrology obtained from the statistics of weak measurements

Holger Friedrich Hofmann

Quantum metrology uses small changes in the output probabilities of a quantum measurement to estimate the magnitude of a weak interaction with the system. The sensitivity of this procedure depends on the relation between the input state, the measurement results, and the generator observable describing the effect of the weak interaction on the system. This is similar to the situation in weak measurements, where the weak value of an observable exhibits a symmetric dependence on initial and final conditions. In this paper, it is shown that the phase sensitivity of a quantum measurement is in fact given by the variance of the imaginary parts of the weak values of the generator over the different measurement outcomes. It is then possible to include the limitations of a specific quantum measurement in the uncertainty bound for phase estimates by subtracting the variance of the real parts of the weak values from the initial generator uncertainty. This uncertainty relation can be interpreted as the time-symmetric formulation of the uncertainty limit of quantum metrology, where the real parts of the weak values represent the information about the generator observable in the final measurement result.

arXiv:1005.4741•Physical Review A•Feb 22, 2011•53 citations

Weak value as a fundamental concept and uncertainty relation

Akio Hosoya

In the previous meeting I demonstrated that the contextual value of an observable coincides with the weak value of Aharonov and his colleagues on the basis of consistency of quantum mechanics with Kolmogorov's measure theory of probability and that this consistency also leads to Born's rule as the unique probability measure of events to be discovered by the post-selection. I would like to point out in the meeting of this year that the error and disturbance defined by Ozawa in his work on the Heisenberg uncertainty relation can be interpreted in terms of the weak value. This observation further strengthens the viewpoint that the weak value is the "true value" of an observable before measurement.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Measuring non-Hermitian operators via weak values

Arun Kumar Pati, Uttam Singh, Urbasi Sinha

In quantum theory, a physical observable is represented by a Hermitian operator as it admits real eigenvalues. This stems from the fact that any measuring apparatus that is supposed to measure a physical observable will always yield a real number. However, the reality of an eigenvalue of some operator does not mean that it is necessarily Hermitian. There are examples of non-Hermitian operators that may admit real eigenvalues under some symmetry conditions. In general, given a non-Hermitian operator, its average value in a quantum state is a complex number and there are only very limited methods available to measure it. Following standard quantum mechanics, we provide an experimentally feasible protocol to measure the expectation value of any non-Hermitian operator via weak measurements. The average of a non-Hermitian operator in a pure state is a complex multiple of the weak value of the positive-semidefinite part of the non-Hermitian operator. We also prove an uncertainty relation for any two non-Hermitian operators and show that the fidelity of a quantum state under a quantum channel can be measured using the average of the corresponding Kraus operators. The importance of our method is shown in testing the stronger uncertainty relation, verifying the Ramanujan formula, and measuring the product of noncommuting projectors.

arXiv:1406.3007•Physical Review A•Nov 25, 2015•75 citations
The evaluation of uncertainties in quantum measurements is problematic since the correct value of an observable between state preparation and measurement is experimentally inaccessible. In Ozawa's formulation of uncertainty relations for quantum measurements, the correct value of an observable is represented by the operator of that observable. Here, I consider the implications of this operator-based assignment of values to individual systems and discuss the relation with weak values and weak measurement statistics.
Our investigation of the results of the neutron spin experiment by Ehhart et al. demonstrates that their results cannot be understood in accordance with common sense. For example, their results obtained with different measurement errors are equal to each other for a same neutron state. This is because their measurement values have a large systematic error due to adopting an incorrect measurement-value operator, which is the operator that gives the measurement values of the measured observable. They asserted that their results confirmed the validity of a universally valid uncertainty relation proposed by Ozawa. Therefore, their results demonstrate unexpectedly that Ozawa's uncertainty relation holds true for incorrect measurements. In addition, we have proved this fact theoretically. The measurement-value operator must be defined in order that the systematic error of measurement values predicted by the operator is zero. Such a measurement is called an accurate measurement. Two kind of uncertainty relations are derived for accurate measurements of a pre-measurement observable x^0\hat{x}_0x^0​. In addition, we have presented an uncertainty relation for accurate measurements of a post-measurement observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​. Heisenberg's original uncertainty relation for measurement processes should be interpreted as this relation between the resolution, that is, the measurement error of the post-measurement observable x^t\hat{x}_tx^t​ and the disturbance of an object observable y^0\hat{y}_0y^​0​.
We present a universal formulation of uncertainty relation valid for any conceivable quantum measurement of statistical nature. Owing to its simplicity and operational tangibility, our general relation is also experimentally verifiable. Our relation violates the traditional naïve bound ħ / 2 for the position-momentum measurement while respecting Heisenberg's original philosophy of the uncertainty principle. Our relation entails, among others, the Arthurs–Kelly–Goodman and Ozawa relations as corollaries to its special cases, and also seamlessly reduces itself to the standard Kennard–Robertson (Schrödinger) relation when the measurement is non-informative.
A universal formulation of uncertainty relations for quantum measurements is presented with additional focus on the representability of quantum observables by classical observables over a given state. Owing to the simplicity and operational tangibility of the framework, the resultant general relations admit natural operational interpretations and characterisations, and are thus also experimentally verifiable. In view of the universal formulation, Heisenberg's philosophy of the uncertainty principle is also revisited; it is reformulated and restated as a refined no-go theorem, albeit perhaps in a weaker form than was originally intended. In fact, the relations entail, in essence as corollaries to their special cases, several previously known relations, including most notably the Arthurs-Kelly-Goodman, Ozawa, and Watanabe-Sagawa-Ueda relations for quantum measurements. The Schr{ö}dinger relation (hence the standard Kennard-Robertson relation as its trivial corollary as well) is also shown to be a special case when the measurement is non-informative.
Quantum metrology uses small changes in the output probabilities of a quantum measurement to estimate the magnitude of a weak interaction with the system. The sensitivity of this procedure depends on the relation between the input state, the measurement results, and the generator observable describing the effect of the weak interaction on the system. This is similar to the situation in weak measurements, where the weak value of an observable exhibits a symmetric dependence on initial and final conditions. In this paper, it is shown that the phase sensitivity of a quantum measurement is in fact given by the variance of the imaginary parts of the weak values of the generator over the different measurement outcomes. It is then possible to include the limitations of a specific quantum measurement in the uncertainty bound for phase estimates by subtracting the variance of the real parts of the weak values from the initial generator uncertainty. This uncertainty relation can be interpreted as the time-symmetric formulation of the uncertainty limit of quantum metrology, where the real parts of the weak values represent the information about the generator observable in the final measurement result.
In the previous meeting I demonstrated that the contextual value of an observable coincides with the weak value of Aharonov and his colleagues on the basis of consistency of quantum mechanics with Kolmogorov's measure theory of probability and that this consistency also leads to Born's rule as the unique probability measure of events to be discovered by the post-selection. I would like to point out in the meeting of this year that the error and disturbance defined by Ozawa in his work on the Heisenberg uncertainty relation can be interpreted in terms of the weak value. This observation further strengthens the viewpoint that the weak value is the "true value" of an observable before measurement.
In quantum theory, a physical observable is represented by a Hermitian operator as it admits real eigenvalues. This stems from the fact that any measuring apparatus that is supposed to measure a physical observable will always yield a real number. However, the reality of an eigenvalue of some operator does not mean that it is necessarily Hermitian. There are examples of non-Hermitian operators that may admit real eigenvalues under some symmetry conditions. In general, given a non-Hermitian operator, its average value in a quantum state is a complex number and there are only very limited methods available to measure it. Following standard quantum mechanics, we provide an experimentally feasible protocol to measure the expectation value of any non-Hermitian operator via weak measurements. The average of a non-Hermitian operator in a pure state is a complex multiple of the weak value of the positive-semidefinite part of the non-Hermitian operator. We also prove an uncertainty relation for any two non-Hermitian operators and show that the fidelity of a quantum state under a quantum channel can be measured using the average of the corresponding Kraus operators. The importance of our method is shown in testing the stronger uncertainty relation, verifying the Ramanujan formula, and measuring the product of noncommuting projectors.