Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1204.5304 · Physical Review A

Revisiting Bohr's principle of complementarity with a quantum device

Jian‐Shun Tang, Yu-Long Li, Chuan‐Feng Li, Guang‐Can Guo

Published Jul 22, 2013• 41 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Bohr's principle of complementarity (BPC) is the cornerstone of quantum mechanics. According to this principle, the total wavelike and particlelike information of a particle is limited by the Englert-Greenberger (EG) duality relation. Here, by introducing a quantum detecting device into the experiment, we find that the limit of the EG duality relation is exceeded because of the interference between the wave and particle properties of the photon. A generalized EG duality relation is further developed. Our work provides a generalization of BPC and gives new insights into quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.88.014103

Related papers

Experimental test of Bohr's complementarity principle with single neutral atoms

Zhihui Wang, Yali Tian, Yang Chen +3 more

An experimental test of the quantum complementarity principle based on single neutral atoms trapped in a blue detuned bottle trap was here performed. A Ramsey interferometer was used to assess the wavelike behavior or particlelike behavior with second $\ensuremath{\pi}/2$ rotation on or off. The wavelike behavior or particlelike behavior is characterized by the visibility $V$ of the interference or the predictability $P$ of which-path information, respectively. The measured results fulfill the complementarity relation ${P}^{2}+{V}^{2}\ensuremath{\le}1$. Imbalance losses were deliberately introduced to the system and we find the complementarity relation is then formally ``violated.'' All the experimental results can be completely explained theoretically by quantum mechanics without considering the interference between wave and particle behaviors. This observation complements existing information concerning Bohr's complementarity principle based on wave-particle duality of a massive quantum system.

arXiv:1608.01450•Physical Review A•Dec 29, 2016•12 citations

Quantum complementarity from a measurement-based perspective

Shan Huang, Wen‐Bo Liu, Yundu Zhao +3 more

One of the most remarkable features of quantum physics is that attributes of quantum objects, such as the wavelike and particlelike behaviors of single photons, can be complementary in the sense that they are equally real but cannot be observed simultaneously. Quantum measurements, serving as windows providing views into the abstract edifice of quantum theory, are basic tools for manifesting the intrinsic behaviors of quantum objects. However, a quantitative formulation of complementarity that highlights its manifestations in general measurement scenarios remains elusive. Here we develop a general framework for demonstrating quantum complementarity in the form of information exclusion relations (IERs), which incorporates the wave-particle duality relations as particular examples. Moreover, we explore the applications of our theory in entanglement detection and elucidate that our IERs lead to an extended form of entropic uncertainty relations, providing insights into the connection between quantum complementarity and the preparation uncertainty.

arXiv:2210.00958•Physical Review A•Feb 26, 2024•3 citations

The Duality Illusion: Complementarity as a Precision Bound, Not a Prohibition

Saurav Thakur

We propose a theoretical framework demonstrating that the traditional interpretation of Bohr’s complementarity principle, asserting mutual exclusivity of wave and particle signatures, arises not from a fundamental physical prohibition but from the historical restriction to projective (von Neumann) measurements. Using positive operator valued measures (POVMs), the Lindblad master equation, and quantum Fisher information, we establish that simultaneous access to interference visibility V and path distinguishability D is mathematically permitted within the Englert–Greenberger bound D² + V² ≤ 1. Five experimental architectures are proposed: a photovoltaic detection screen (baseline), an asymmetric photovoltaic slit apparatus, an optomechanical mirror configuration, a quantum memory delayed emission scheme, and a room temperature telecom fiber duality disc mapper. Three closed form metrological identities are derived: flat Fubini–Study geometry of the Englert circle (F_Q(θ) = 1), reciprocity bounds √N σ(V̂) ≥ D and √N σ(D̂) ≥ V with the estimation cost sum rule, and autonomous duality flow equations with Gudermannian (tanh/sech) solutions. We term the resulting reframing the “duality illusion”: complementarity is a constraint on joint measurement precision, not a prohibition against joint measurement. This is a purely theoretical proposal. No experiments have been performed; all numerical values are predictions. Keywords: wave particle duality, complementarity, quantum measurement, POVM, Lindblad equation, quantum Fisher information, Englert–Greenberger inequality, optomechanics, quantum dots

•Aug 26, 2025•0 citations

Experimental analysis of the quantum complementarity principle

R. Auccaise, Roberto M. Serra, Jefferson Gonçalves Filgueiras +3 more

One of the milestones of quantum mechanics is Bohr's complementarity principle. It states that a single quantum can exhibit a particlelike $or$ a wavelike behavior, but never both at the same time. These are mutually exclusive and complementary aspects of the quantum system. This means that we need distinct experimental arrangements in order to measure the particle or the wave nature of a physical system. One of the most known representations of this principle is the single-photon Mach-Zehnder interferometer. When the interferometer is closed an interference pattern is observed (wave aspect of the quantum) while if it is open, the quantum behaves like a particle. Here, using a molecular quantum information processor and employing nuclear magnetic resonant (NMR) techniques, we analyze the quantum version of this principle by means of an interferometer that is in a quantum superposition of being closed and open, and confirm that we can indeed measure both aspects of the system with the same experimental apparatus. More specifically, we observe with a single apparatus the interference between the particle and the wave aspects of a quantum system.

arXiv:1201.5951•Physical Review A•Mar 21, 2012•75 citations

Simultaneous Measurement of Wave and Particle Properties Using Modified Young's Double-Slit Experiment

Kazufumi Sakai

The principle of complementarity is the foundation of quantum mechanics; its correctness has been verified by several studies. At present, the Englert-Greenberger duality relation is used for quantitative evaluations. We fabricated a new double slit experimental apparatus capable of simultaneously measuring the visibility and path-distinguishability, and measured the wave and particle properties. We thus obtained results in disagreement with the principle of complementarity.

•Apr 1, 2018•4 citations

Quantum twist to complementarity: A duality relation

Tabish Qureshi

Some recent works have introduced a quantum twist to the concept of complementarity, exemplified by a setup in which the which-way detector is in a superposition of being present and absent. It has been argued that such experiments allow measurement of particle-like and wave-like behavior at the same time. Here, we derive an inequality which puts a bound on the visibility of interference and the amount of which-way information that one can obtain, in the context of such modified experiments. As the wave aspect can only be revealed by an ensemble of detections, we argue that, in such experiments, a single detection can contribute only to one subensemble, corresponding to either wave aspect or particle aspect. This way, each detected particle behaves either as particle or as wave, never both, and Bohr's complementarity is fully respected.

arXiv:1205.2207•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Apr 1, 2013•13 citations
Bohr's principle of complementarity (BPC) is the cornerstone of quantum mechanics. According to this principle, the total wavelike and particlelike information of a particle is limited by the Englert-Greenberger (EG) duality relation. Here, by introducing a quantum detecting device into the experiment, we find that the limit of the EG duality relation is exceeded because of the interference between the wave and particle properties of the photon. A generalized EG duality relation is further developed. Our work provides a generalization of BPC and gives new insights into quantum mechanics.
An experimental test of the quantum complementarity principle based on single neutral atoms trapped in a blue detuned bottle trap was here performed. A Ramsey interferometer was used to assess the wavelike behavior or particlelike behavior with second $\ensuremath{\pi}/2$ rotation on or off. The wavelike behavior or particlelike behavior is characterized by the visibility VVV of the interference or the predictability PPP of which-path information, respectively. The measured results fulfill the complementarity relation ${P}^{2}+{V}^{2}\ensuremath{\le}1$. Imbalance losses were deliberately introduced to the system and we find the complementarity relation is then formally ``violated.'' All the experimental results can be completely explained theoretically by quantum mechanics without considering the interference between wave and particle behaviors. This observation complements existing information concerning Bohr's complementarity principle based on wave-particle duality of a massive quantum system.
One of the most remarkable features of quantum physics is that attributes of quantum objects, such as the wavelike and particlelike behaviors of single photons, can be complementary in the sense that they are equally real but cannot be observed simultaneously. Quantum measurements, serving as windows providing views into the abstract edifice of quantum theory, are basic tools for manifesting the intrinsic behaviors of quantum objects. However, a quantitative formulation of complementarity that highlights its manifestations in general measurement scenarios remains elusive. Here we develop a general framework for demonstrating quantum complementarity in the form of information exclusion relations (IERs), which incorporates the wave-particle duality relations as particular examples. Moreover, we explore the applications of our theory in entanglement detection and elucidate that our IERs lead to an extended form of entropic uncertainty relations, providing insights into the connection between quantum complementarity and the preparation uncertainty.
We propose a theoretical framework demonstrating that the traditional interpretation of Bohr’s complementarity principle, asserting mutual exclusivity of wave and particle signatures, arises not from a fundamental physical prohibition but from the historical restriction to projective (von Neumann) measurements. Using positive operator valued measures (POVMs), the Lindblad master equation, and quantum Fisher information, we establish that simultaneous access to interference visibility V and path distinguishability D is mathematically permitted within the Englert–Greenberger bound D² + V² ≤ 1. Five experimental architectures are proposed: a photovoltaic detection screen (baseline), an asymmetric photovoltaic slit apparatus, an optomechanical mirror configuration, a quantum memory delayed emission scheme, and a room temperature telecom fiber duality disc mapper. Three closed form metrological identities are derived: flat Fubini–Study geometry of the Englert circle (F_Q(θ) = 1), reciprocity bounds √N σ(V̂) ≥ D and √N σ(D̂) ≥ V with the estimation cost sum rule, and autonomous duality flow equations with Gudermannian (tanh/sech) solutions. We term the resulting reframing the “duality illusion”: complementarity is a constraint on joint measurement precision, not a prohibition against joint measurement. This is a purely theoretical proposal. No experiments have been performed; all numerical values are predictions. Keywords: wave particle duality, complementarity, quantum measurement, POVM, Lindblad equation, quantum Fisher information, Englert–Greenberger inequality, optomechanics, quantum dots
One of the milestones of quantum mechanics is Bohr's complementarity principle. It states that a single quantum can exhibit a particlelike ororor a wavelike behavior, but never both at the same time. These are mutually exclusive and complementary aspects of the quantum system. This means that we need distinct experimental arrangements in order to measure the particle or the wave nature of a physical system. One of the most known representations of this principle is the single-photon Mach-Zehnder interferometer. When the interferometer is closed an interference pattern is observed (wave aspect of the quantum) while if it is open, the quantum behaves like a particle. Here, using a molecular quantum information processor and employing nuclear magnetic resonant (NMR) techniques, we analyze the quantum version of this principle by means of an interferometer that is in a quantum superposition of being closed and open, and confirm that we can indeed measure both aspects of the system with the same experimental apparatus. More specifically, we observe with a single apparatus the interference between the particle and the wave aspects of a quantum system.
Some recent works have introduced a quantum twist to the concept of complementarity, exemplified by a setup in which the which-way detector is in a superposition of being present and absent. It has been argued that such experiments allow measurement of particle-like and wave-like behavior at the same time. Here, we derive an inequality which puts a bound on the visibility of interference and the amount of which-way information that one can obtain, in the context of such modified experiments. As the wave aspect can only be revealed by an ensemble of detections, we argue that, in such experiments, a single detection can contribute only to one subensemble, corresponding to either wave aspect or particle aspect. This way, each detected particle behaves either as particle or as wave, never both, and Bohr's complementarity is fully respected.