Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1203.2976 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Robust self-testing of the singlet

Matthew McKague, T. H. Yang, Valerio Scarani

Published Oct 19, 2012• 251 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we introduce a general framework to study the concept of robust self-testing which can be used to self-test maximally entangled pairs of qubits (EPR pairs) and local measurement operators. The result is based only on probabilities obtained from the experiment, with tolerance to experimental errors. In particular, we show that if the results of an experiment approach the Cirel'son bound, or approximate the Mayers–Yao-type correlations, then the experiment must contain an approximate EPR pair. More specifically, there exist local bases in which the physical state is close to an EPR pair, possibly encoded in a larger environment or ancilla. Moreover, in these bases the measurements are close to the qubit operators used to achieve the Cirel'son bound or the Mayers–Yao results.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/45/45/455304

Related papers

All the self-testings of the singlet for two binary measurements

Yukun Wang, Xingyao Wu, Valerio Scarani

Self-testing refers to the possibility of characterizing uniquely (up to local isometries) the state and measurements contained in quantum devices, based only on the observed input-output statistics. Already in the basic case of the two-qubit singlet, self-testing is not unique: the two known criteria (the maximal violation of the CHSH inequality and the Mayers–Yao correlations) are not equivalent. It is unknown how many criteria there are. In this paper, we find the whole set of criteria for the ideal self-testing of a singlet with two measurements and two outcomes on each side; it coincides with all the extremal points of the quantum set that can be obtained by measuring the singlet.

arXiv:1511.04886•New Journal of Physics•Feb 23, 2016•89 citations

Experimentally Robust Self-testing for Bipartite and Tripartite Entangled States

Wen-Hao Zhang, Geng Chen, Xing-Xiang Peng +9 more

Self-testing is a method with which a classical user can certify the state and measurements of quantum systems in a device-independent way. In particular, self-testing of entangled states is of great importance in quantum information processing. An understandable example is that the maximal violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality necessarily implies that the bipartite system shares a singlet. One essential question in self-testing is that, when one observes a nonmaximum violation, how far is the tested state from the target state (which maximally violates a certain Bell inequality)? The answer to this question describes the robustness of the used self-testing criterion, which is highly important in a practical sense. Recently, J. Kaniewski derived two analytic self-testing bounds for bipartite and tripartite systems. In this Letter, we experimentally investigate these two bounds with high-quality two-qubit and three-qubit entanglement sources. The results show that these bounds are valid for various entangled states that we prepared. Thereby, a proof-of-concept demonstration of robust self-testing is achieved, which improves on the previous results significantly.

arXiv:1804.01375•Physical Review Letters•Dec 13, 2018•32 citations

Analytic robustness bound for self-testing of the singlet with two binary measurements

Xinhui Li, Yukun Wang, Yun-Guang Han +3 more

Self-testing refers to a way of uniquely identifying an uncharacterized quantum device based solely on certain extremal quantum correlations. It is known that in the ideal case of a two-qubit singlet all the extremal points that can be obtained by measuring the singlet form the whole criteria for self-testing the singlet and the associated measurements. To make these self-testing criteria more suitable for practical applications, relevant robustness bounds are necessary to discuss. However, the previous robustness analyses for these criteria were obtained by the swap method, which may not be guaranteed to be tight. In this paper, we construct a general extraction map applying to all self-testing criteria of the singlet state with two binary measurements for each party and derive analytic robustness bounds for a self-testing singlet in different regions of the boundary of the extremal quantum correlation set. The comparison shows that our robustness bounds are better than the known results and close to optimal for these self-testing criteria of a singlet state with two binary measurements.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Jan 28, 2019•7 citations

An Operational Environment for Quantum Self-Testing

Matthias Christandl, Nicholas Gauguin Houghton-Larsen, Laura Mančinska

Observed quantum correlations are known to determine in certain cases the underlying quantum state and measurements. This phenomenon is known as (quantum) self-testing .Self-testing constitutes a significant research area with practical and theoretical ramifications for quantum information theory. But since its conception two decades ago by Mayers and Yao, the common way to rigorously formulate self-testing has been in terms of operator-algebraic identities, and this formulation lacks an operational interpretation. In particular, it is unclear how to formulate self-testing in other physical theories, in formulations of quantum theory not referring to operator-algebra, or in scenarios causally different from the standard one.In this paper, we explain how to understand quantum self-testing operationally, in terms of causally structured dilations of the input-output channel encoding the correlations. These dilations model side-information which leaks to an environment according to a specific schedule, and we show how self-testing concerns the relative strength between such scheduled leaks of information. As such, the title of our paper has double meaning: we recast conventional quantum self-testing in terms of information-leaks to an environment – and this realises quantum self-testing as a special case within the surroundings of a general operational framework.Our new approach to quantum self-testing not only supplies an operational understanding apt for various generalisations, but also resolves some unexplained aspects of the existing definition, naturally suggests a distance measure suitable for robust self-testing, and points towards self-testing as a modular concept in a larger, cryptographic perspective.

arXiv:2108.06254•Quantum•Apr 27, 2022•6 citations

Experimental Realization of Robust Self-Testing of Bell State Measurements

Wen-Hao Zhang, Geng Chen, Xing-Xiang Peng +6 more

Bell state measurements, of which the eigenvectors are in an entangled form, are crucial resources in the construction of quantum networks. Therefore, device-independent certification of a Bell state measurement has significance in the quantum information process because it satisfies the exact demand on security. In this study, we implement a proof-of-concept experiment to certify a Bell state measurement device independently in an entanglement swapping process, namely, self-testing. Instead of preparing a tensor product of two singlets with four photons, multiplex encoding in polarization and spatial modes is utilized to produce two pairs of entangled qubits. As a result, we implement a full Bell state measurement and achieve a high degree of Bell violation on the remaining two qubits, which are required for nontrivial self-testing of a Bell state measurement. Furthermore, our results combine the correlations before and after the swapping; thus, the quality of the performed Bell state measurement can be precisely inferred.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 8, 2019•27 citations

Robust self-test of the maximally entangled state of two-qubits without assuming unitary observables

Alexandre C. Orthey, Magdalena Stobińska-Moretto

Standard device-independent self-testing uses Naimark dilation to assume projective measurements, masking the operational limitations of realistic non-unitary observables. We establish a robust pure self-test for the singlet and Pauli observables that entirely circumvents dilation of the measurement apparatus. Assuming a pure state to model an untrusted source, we regularize the physical non-projective operators and derive an analytic $\mathcal{O}(\sqrtε)$ robustness bound. Our results suggest that device-independent certification of real implementations is significantly more demanding than standard projective models imply.

quant-pharXiv:2607.04035•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations
In this paper, we introduce a general framework to study the concept of robust self-testing which can be used to self-test maximally entangled pairs of qubits (EPR pairs) and local measurement operators. The result is based only on probabilities obtained from the experiment, with tolerance to experimental errors. In particular, we show that if the results of an experiment approach the Cirel'son bound, or approximate the Mayers–Yao-type correlations, then the experiment must contain an approximate EPR pair. More specifically, there exist local bases in which the physical state is close to an EPR pair, possibly encoded in a larger environment or ancilla. Moreover, in these bases the measurements are close to the qubit operators used to achieve the Cirel'son bound or the Mayers–Yao results.
Self-testing refers to the possibility of characterizing uniquely (up to local isometries) the state and measurements contained in quantum devices, based only on the observed input-output statistics. Already in the basic case of the two-qubit singlet, self-testing is not unique: the two known criteria (the maximal violation of the CHSH inequality and the Mayers–Yao correlations) are not equivalent. It is unknown how many criteria there are. In this paper, we find the whole set of criteria for the ideal self-testing of a singlet with two measurements and two outcomes on each side; it coincides with all the extremal points of the quantum set that can be obtained by measuring the singlet.
Self-testing is a method with which a classical user can certify the state and measurements of quantum systems in a device-independent way. In particular, self-testing of entangled states is of great importance in quantum information processing. An understandable example is that the maximal violation of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality necessarily implies that the bipartite system shares a singlet. One essential question in self-testing is that, when one observes a nonmaximum violation, how far is the tested state from the target state (which maximally violates a certain Bell inequality)? The answer to this question describes the robustness of the used self-testing criterion, which is highly important in a practical sense. Recently, J. Kaniewski derived two analytic self-testing bounds for bipartite and tripartite systems. In this Letter, we experimentally investigate these two bounds with high-quality two-qubit and three-qubit entanglement sources. The results show that these bounds are valid for various entangled states that we prepared. Thereby, a proof-of-concept demonstration of robust self-testing is achieved, which improves on the previous results significantly.
Self-testing refers to a way of uniquely identifying an uncharacterized quantum device based solely on certain extremal quantum correlations. It is known that in the ideal case of a two-qubit singlet all the extremal points that can be obtained by measuring the singlet form the whole criteria for self-testing the singlet and the associated measurements. To make these self-testing criteria more suitable for practical applications, relevant robustness bounds are necessary to discuss. However, the previous robustness analyses for these criteria were obtained by the swap method, which may not be guaranteed to be tight. In this paper, we construct a general extraction map applying to all self-testing criteria of the singlet state with two binary measurements for each party and derive analytic robustness bounds for a self-testing singlet in different regions of the boundary of the extremal quantum correlation set. The comparison shows that our robustness bounds are better than the known results and close to optimal for these self-testing criteria of a singlet state with two binary measurements.
Observed quantum correlations are known to determine in certain cases the underlying quantum state and measurements. This phenomenon is known as (quantum) self-testing .Self-testing constitutes a significant research area with practical and theoretical ramifications for quantum information theory. But since its conception two decades ago by Mayers and Yao, the common way to rigorously formulate self-testing has been in terms of operator-algebraic identities, and this formulation lacks an operational interpretation. In particular, it is unclear how to formulate self-testing in other physical theories, in formulations of quantum theory not referring to operator-algebra, or in scenarios causally different from the standard one.In this paper, we explain how to understand quantum self-testing operationally, in terms of causally structured dilations of the input-output channel encoding the correlations. These dilations model side-information which leaks to an environment according to a specific schedule, and we show how self-testing concerns the relative strength between such scheduled leaks of information. As such, the title of our paper has double meaning: we recast conventional quantum self-testing in terms of information-leaks to an environment – and this realises quantum self-testing as a special case within the surroundings of a general operational framework.Our new approach to quantum self-testing not only supplies an operational understanding apt for various generalisations, but also resolves some unexplained aspects of the existing definition, naturally suggests a distance measure suitable for robust self-testing, and points towards self-testing as a modular concept in a larger, cryptographic perspective.
Bell state measurements, of which the eigenvectors are in an entangled form, are crucial resources in the construction of quantum networks. Therefore, device-independent certification of a Bell state measurement has significance in the quantum information process because it satisfies the exact demand on security. In this study, we implement a proof-of-concept experiment to certify a Bell state measurement device independently in an entanglement swapping process, namely, self-testing. Instead of preparing a tensor product of two singlets with four photons, multiplex encoding in polarization and spatial modes is utilized to produce two pairs of entangled qubits. As a result, we implement a full Bell state measurement and achieve a high degree of Bell violation on the remaining two qubits, which are required for nontrivial self-testing of a Bell state measurement. Furthermore, our results combine the correlations before and after the swapping; thus, the quality of the performed Bell state measurement can be precisely inferred.
Standard device-independent self-testing uses Naimark dilation to assume projective measurements, masking the operational limitations of realistic non-unitary observables. We establish a robust pure self-test for the singlet and Pauli observables that entirely circumvents dilation of the measurement apparatus. Assuming a pure state to model an untrusted source, we regularize the physical non-projective operators and derive an analytic O(ε)\mathcal{O}(\sqrtε)O(ε​) robustness bound. Our results suggest that device-independent certification of real implementations is significantly more demanding than standard projective models imply.