Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1203.0927

Response to `Comment on "Experimental demonstration of a universally valid error-disturbance uncertainty relation in spin measurements" '

Jacqueline Erhart, Stephan Sponar, Georg Sulyok, G. Badurek, Masanao Ozawa, Yuji Hasegawa

Published Mar 5, 2012• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Here, we reply to the comment by Y. Kurihara. We show that the argument by the author is on an improper basis and thus disagree with his opinion.
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1203.0927

Related papers

Comment on "Experimental demonstration of a universally valid error-disturbance uncertainty relation in spin measurements"

Y. Kurihara

In this comment we show that the experimental results for a universally valid uncertainty relation in ref.[J. Erhart et al. Nat. Phys.(2012)10.1038/nphys2194]cannot be justified. The experiments cannot be recognized to establish a violation of the Heisenberg-type uncertainty relation suggested by Ozawa[Phys. Lett. A318(2003)21, Phys. Rev. A67(2003)042105].

arXiv:1201.5151•Jan 24, 2012•3 citations

Experimental demonstration of a universally valid error–disturbance uncertainty relation in spin measurements

Jacqueline Erhart, Stephan Sponar, Georg Sulyok +3 more

arXiv:1201.1833•Nature Physics•Jan 13, 2012•256 citations

Experimental Test of Error, Disturbance, and Uncertainty Relations in Quantum Measurement(Research)

圭一 枝松, 文寛 金田, So-Young Baek +1 more

日本物理學會誌•Mar 1, 2015•0 citations

Violation of Heisenberg's error-disturbance uncertainty relation in neutron-spin measurements

Georg Sulyok, Stephan Sponar, Jacqueline Erhart +3 more

In its original formulation, Heisenberg's uncertainty principle dealt with the relationship between the error of a quantum measurement and the thereby induced disturbance on the measured object. Meanwhile, Heisenberg's heuristic arguments have turned out to be correct only for special cases. An alternative universally valid relation was derived by Ozawa in 2003. Here, we demonstrate that Ozawa's predictions hold for projective neutron-spin measurements. The experimental inaccessibility of error and disturbance claimed elsewhere has been overcome using a tomographic method. By a systematic variation of experimental parameters in the entire configuration space, the physical behavior of error and disturbance for projective spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ measurements is illustrated comprehensively. The violation of Heisenberg's original relation, as well as the validity of Ozawa's relation become manifest. In addition, our results conclude that the widespread assumption of a reciprocal relation between error and disturbance is not valid in general.

arXiv:1305.7251•Physical Review A•Aug 14, 2013•106 citations

Reply to ’’Comment on ’Spin and uncertainty in the interpretation of quantum mechanics’ ’’

David Hestenes

See also commentary Comment on ’’Spin and uncertainty in the interpretation of quantum mechanics’’

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1981•0 citations

Experimental Investigations of Uncertainty Relations Inherent in Successive $$1/2-$$Spin Measurements

Yuji Hasegawa

Springer proceedings in mathematics & statistics•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations
In its original formulation, Heisenberg's uncertainty principle dealt with the relationship between the error of a quantum measurement and the thereby induced disturbance on the measured object. Meanwhile, Heisenberg's heuristic arguments have turned out to be correct only for special cases. An alternative universally valid relation was derived by Ozawa in 2003. Here, we demonstrate that Ozawa's predictions hold for projective neutron-spin measurements. The experimental inaccessibility of error and disturbance claimed elsewhere has been overcome using a tomographic method. By a systematic variation of experimental parameters in the entire configuration space, the physical behavior of error and disturbance for projective spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ measurements is illustrated comprehensively. The violation of Heisenberg's original relation, as well as the validity of Ozawa's relation become manifest. In addition, our results conclude that the widespread assumption of a reciprocal relation between error and disturbance is not valid in general.
Experimental Investigations of Uncertainty Relations Inherent in Successive 1/2−1/2-1/2−Spin Measurements