Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1202.5590 · Physical Review Letters

Comment on “Density and Spin Response of a Strongly Interacting Fermi Gas in the Attractive and Quasirepulsive Regime”

Chih-Chun Chien, Hao Guo, Kathryn Levin

Published Sep 12, 2012• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This is a comment on Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 080401 (2012) by Palestini et al. We pointed out that the diagrammatic method in that article violates gauge invariance. As a consequence, there will a Meissner effect in the normal phase and the contribution from collective modes are not mentioned in the symmetry-broken phase.
DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.109.118901

Related papers

Density and Spin Response of a Strongly Interacting Fermi Gas in the Attractive and Quasirepulsive Regime

F. Palestini, P. Pieri, Giancarlo Calvanese Strinati

Recent experimental advances in ultracold Fermi gases allow for exploring response functions under different dynamical conditions. In particular, the issue of obtaining a "quasirepulsive" regime starting from a Fermi gas with an attractive interparticle interaction while avoiding the formation of the two-body bound state is currently debated. Here, we provide a calculation of the density and spin response for a wide range of temperature and coupling both in the attractive and quasirepulsive regime, whereby the system is assumed to evolve nonadiabatically toward the "upper branch" of the Fermi gas. A comparison is made with the available experimental data for these two quantities.

arXiv:1201.4035•Physical Review Letters•Feb 23, 2012•49 citations

Comment on “Normal Phase of an Imbalanced Fermi Gas”

Zhenhua Yu, Sascha Zöllner, C. J. Pethick

Recently Mora and Chevy [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 230402 (2010), arXiv:1003.0213v2], in studying the energy of an atomic Fermi gas consisting of a majority species, 1, and a minority species, 2, showed that, due to interatomic interactions, the energy density E of the gas has a contribution of the form E^(2)= f n_2^2 /2, where n_i is the density of species i. They attribute this term to a `modification of the single polaron properties due to Pauli blocking'. In this Comment, we demonstrate that E^(2) may equivalently be understood in terms of the familiar interaction between minority atoms induced by the majority component.

arXiv:1006.4723•Physical Review Letters•Oct 27, 2010•21 citations

Comment on “Novel Superfluidity in a Trapped Gas of Fermi Atoms with Repulsive Interaction Loaded on an Optical Lattice”

Marcos Rigol, Salvatore R. Manmana, A. Muramatsu +3 more

In a recent letter Machida et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 200402 (2004)] concluded that in a trapped gas of fermions with repulsive interactions a superfluid phase appears around the Mott-insulator at the center of the trap. They base their conclusion on a negative binding energy, and a large weight for a singlet formed by particles located at opposite sides of the Mott-insulator. We show here that the observed effects are not related to superfluidity.

arXiv:cond-mat/0502599•Physical Review Letters•Nov 14, 2005•19 citations

Comment on “Fermi-Bose Mixtures near Broad Interspecies Feshbach Resonances”

J. Dukelsky, Carlos Esebbag, Peter Schuck +1 more

In a recent Letter (Phys. Rev. lett. 105, 195301 (2010)), Song et al. introduced a new variational approach to treat strong attractive boson-fermion (BF) correlations in BF atomic mixtures. The proposed theory predicts a first order phase transition to a condensate of composite BF pairs with center of mass momentum Q=0 as opposed to a composite fermionic molecular Fermi gas. We show in this comment that their approach is incorrect and moreover, by resorting to an exactly solvable model we demonstrate that there cannot be more than one correlated Q=0 BF pair in complete contradiction with their conclusions.

arXiv:1104.1324•Physical Review Letters•Mar 21, 2011•6 citations

Establishing a consistent theory of transport in strongly correlated Fermi superfluids

Rufus Boyack

A diagrammatic method of obtaining exact gauge-invariant response functions in strongly correlated Fermi superfluids is implemented for several example condensed matter systems of current interest. These include: topological superfluids, high temperature superconductors, and superfluids with finite center-of-mass momentum pairing known as Fulde-Ferrell superfluids. Much of the literature on these systems has focused on single-particle properties or alternatively has invoked simple approximations to treat response functions. The goal is to show that, for this wide class of topical problems, one can compute exact response functions. This enables assessment of the validity of different physical scenarios and allows a very broad class of experiments to be addressed.,The method developed is based on deriving the full electromagnetic vertex, which satisfies the Ward-Takahashi identity, and determining the collective modes in a manner compatible with the self-consistent gap equation. In the condensed phase of a superfluid and a superconductor, where gauge invariance is spontaneously broken, it is crucial to determine the collective modes from the gap equation in a manner which restores gauge invariance. Our diagrammatic framework provides a very general and powerful method for obtaining these collective modes in a variety of strongly correlated Fermi superfluids. We show that a full electromagnetic vertex satisfying the Ward-Takahashi identity ensures the $f$-sum rule is satisfied and thus charge is conserved. ,This diagrammatic method is implemented for both normal and superfluid phases. While there are no collective modes in the normal phase, the Ward-Takahashi identity plays a similarly important role. In particular, for the normal phase we study Rashba spin-orbit coupled Fermi gases with intrinsic pairing in the absence and presence of a magnetic field. Exact density and spin response functions are obtained, even in the absence of a spin conservation law, providing signatures of topological order. Another set of examples studied in the normal phase include a broad collection of models of the cuprate pseudogap. For these cases too, the exact response functions are obtained and signatures of each model are identified. A detailed discussion of the superfluid phase is provided by the study of Fulde-Ferrell superfluids. The generally omitted collective modes are computed and the exact gauge-invariant response is obtained. The first complete calculation of the superfluid density, incorporating the collective mode contribution and without any assumptions on the size of the gap, is provided. It is found that the amplitude mode causes the superfluid to become unstable at temperatures much lower than the mean-field transition temperature.,As an alternative to the diagrammatic approach, the functional path integral technique for Fermi superfluids is presented. While this approach is widely studied in the literature, it is of restricted utility, in comparison to the diagrammatic approach presented here, due to the inability to perform the functional integral except in very limited cases. A short coming in the current literature is identified, in that the standard method of deriving gauge-invariant electrodynamics leads to a violation of the compressibility sum rule. It is found that to satisfy this sum rule the amplitude mode of the order parameter must be incorporated. A reformulation of the path integral method for Fermi superfluids is derived, which has both gauge-invariant electrodynamics and thermodynamics compatible with the compressibility sum rule, to all orders of approximation.

•Aug 1, 2017•1 citation

Comment on ‘‘Pseudospin symmetry and new collective modes of the Hubbard model’’

I. A. Fomin, Peter Schmitteckert, P. Wölfle

A Comment on the Letter by Shoucheng Zhang Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 120 (1990).Received 7 November 1991DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.69.214©1992 American Physical Society

Physical Review Letters•Jul 6, 1992•7 citations
Recent experimental advances in ultracold Fermi gases allow for exploring response functions under different dynamical conditions. In particular, the issue of obtaining a "quasirepulsive" regime starting from a Fermi gas with an attractive interparticle interaction while avoiding the formation of the two-body bound state is currently debated. Here, we provide a calculation of the density and spin response for a wide range of temperature and coupling both in the attractive and quasirepulsive regime, whereby the system is assumed to evolve nonadiabatically toward the "upper branch" of the Fermi gas. A comparison is made with the available experimental data for these two quantities.
Recently Mora and Chevy [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 230402 (2010), arXiv:1003.0213v2], in studying the energy of an atomic Fermi gas consisting of a majority species, 1, and a minority species, 2, showed that, due to interatomic interactions, the energy density E of the gas has a contribution of the form E^(2)= f n_2^2 /2, where n_i is the density of species i. They attribute this term to a `modification of the single polaron properties due to Pauli blocking'. In this Comment, we demonstrate that E^(2) may equivalently be understood in terms of the familiar interaction between minority atoms induced by the majority component.
In a recent Letter (Phys. Rev. lett. 105, 195301 (2010)), Song et al. introduced a new variational approach to treat strong attractive boson-fermion (BF) correlations in BF atomic mixtures. The proposed theory predicts a first order phase transition to a condensate of composite BF pairs with center of mass momentum Q=0 as opposed to a composite fermionic molecular Fermi gas. We show in this comment that their approach is incorrect and moreover, by resorting to an exactly solvable model we demonstrate that there cannot be more than one correlated Q=0 BF pair in complete contradiction with their conclusions.
A diagrammatic method of obtaining exact gauge-invariant response functions in strongly correlated Fermi superfluids is implemented for several example condensed matter systems of current interest. These include: topological superfluids, high temperature superconductors, and superfluids with finite center-of-mass momentum pairing known as Fulde-Ferrell superfluids. Much of the literature on these systems has focused on single-particle properties or alternatively has invoked simple approximations to treat response functions. The goal is to show that, for this wide class of topical problems, one can compute exact response functions. This enables assessment of the validity of different physical scenarios and allows a very broad class of experiments to be addressed.,The method developed is based on deriving the full electromagnetic vertex, which satisfies the Ward-Takahashi identity, and determining the collective modes in a manner compatible with the self-consistent gap equation. In the condensed phase of a superfluid and a superconductor, where gauge invariance is spontaneously broken, it is crucial to determine the collective modes from the gap equation in a manner which restores gauge invariance. Our diagrammatic framework provides a very general and powerful method for obtaining these collective modes in a variety of strongly correlated Fermi superfluids. We show that a full electromagnetic vertex satisfying the Ward-Takahashi identity ensures the fff-sum rule is satisfied and thus charge is conserved. ,This diagrammatic method is implemented for both normal and superfluid phases. While there are no collective modes in the normal phase, the Ward-Takahashi identity plays a similarly important role. In particular, for the normal phase we study Rashba spin-orbit coupled Fermi gases with intrinsic pairing in the absence and presence of a magnetic field. Exact density and spin response functions are obtained, even in the absence of a spin conservation law, providing signatures of topological order. Another set of examples studied in the normal phase include a broad collection of models of the cuprate pseudogap. For these cases too, the exact response functions are obtained and signatures of each model are identified. A detailed discussion of the superfluid phase is provided by the study of Fulde-Ferrell superfluids. The generally omitted collective modes are computed and the exact gauge-invariant response is obtained. The first complete calculation of the superfluid density, incorporating the collective mode contribution and without any assumptions on the size of the gap, is provided. It is found that the amplitude mode causes the superfluid to become unstable at temperatures much lower than the mean-field transition temperature.,As an alternative to the diagrammatic approach, the functional path integral technique for Fermi superfluids is presented. While this approach is widely studied in the literature, it is of restricted utility, in comparison to the diagrammatic approach presented here, due to the inability to perform the functional integral except in very limited cases. A short coming in the current literature is identified, in that the standard method of deriving gauge-invariant electrodynamics leads to a violation of the compressibility sum rule. It is found that to satisfy this sum rule the amplitude mode of the order parameter must be incorporated. A reformulation of the path integral method for Fermi superfluids is derived, which has both gauge-invariant electrodynamics and thermodynamics compatible with the compressibility sum rule, to all orders of approximation.