Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1202.4187

Relational Quadrilateralland. Analogues of Isospin and Hypercharge

Edward James Anderson

Published Feb 19, 2012• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

I consider the momenta and conserved quantities for CP^2 interpreted as the space of quadrilaterals. This builds on seminar I and II's kinematics via making use of MacFarlane's work considering the SU(3)-like (and thus particle physics-like) conserved quantities that occur for CP^2. I perform the additional step of further interpreting that as the configuration space of all relational quadrilaterals and thus an interesting toy model for whole-universe, relational and geometrodynamical-analogue physics. I also provide the Kuchar observables for the quadrilateral, which is a particular resolution of the Problem of Observables. I study HO-like and highly symmetric potentials. I also provide some exact solutions and qualitative behaviours for dynamics on CP^2. In each case, I reinterpret the results in terms of quadrilaterals. This paves the way for the quantum mechanical study of the relational quadrilateral and for investigations of a number of Problem of Time strategies and of a number of other foundational and qualitative investigations of Quantum Cosmology.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1202.4187

Related papers

Relational Quadrilateralland. II. The Quantum Theory

Anderson, Edward, Kneller, Sophie

This paper provides the quantum treatment of the relational quadrilateral. The underlying reduced configuration spaces are $\mathbb{CP}^2$ and the cone over this, C($\mathbb{CP}^2$). We consider exact free and isotropic HO potential cases and perturbations about these. Moreover, our purely relational kinematical quantization is distinct from the usual one for $\mathbb{CP}^2$, which turns out to carry absolutist connotations instead. Thus this paper is the first to note absolute-versus-relational motion distinctions at the kinematical rather than dynamical level, and also an example of value to the discussion of kinematical quantization along the lines of Isham 1984. This treatment of the relational quadrilateral is the first relational QM with very new mathematics for a finite QM model, and is far more typical of the general quantum relational $N$-a-gon than the previously-studied case of the relational triangle. We consider useful integrals as regards perturbation theory and the peaking interpretation of quantum cosmology. We subsequently consider problem of time applications of this: quantum Kuchař beables, the Machian version of the semiclassical approach and the timeless naive Schrodinger interpretation. These go toward extending the combined Machian semiclassical-histories-timeless approach of [1] to the case of the quadrilateral, which will be treated in subsequent papers.

arXiv:1303.5645•Mar 22, 2013•48 citations

Relational quadrilateralland II: The Quantum Theory

Edward James Anderson, Sophie Kneller

We provide the quantum treatment of the relational quadrilateral. The underlying reduced configuration spaces are ℂℙ 2 and the cone over this. We consider exact free and isotropic HO potential cases and perturbations about these. Moreover, our purely relational kinematical quantization is distinct from the usual one for ℂℙ 2 , which turns out to carry absolutist connotations instead. Thus, this paper is the first to note absolute-versus-relational motion distinctions at the kinematical rather than dynamical level. It is also an example of value to the discussion of kinematical quantization along the lines of Isham, 1984. The relational quadrilateral is the simplest RPM whose mathematics is not standard in atomic physics (the triangle and four particles on a line are both based on 𝕊 2 and ℝ 3 mathematics). It is far more typical of the general quantum relational N-a-gon than the previously studied case of the relational triangle. We consider useful integrals as regards perturbation theory and the peaking interpretation of quantum cosmology. We subsequently consider problem of time (PoT) applications of this: quantum Kuchař beables, the Machian version of the semiclassical approach and the timeless naïve Schrödinger interpretation. These go toward extending the combined Machian semiclassical-Histories-Timeless Approach of [Int. J. Mod. Phys. D23 (2014) 1450014] to the case of the quadrilateral, which will be treated in subsequent papers.

International Journal of Modern Physics D•Apr 21, 2014•11 citations

QUANTUM COSMOLOGICAL METROLAND MODEL

Edward James Anderson, Anne T. Franzen, Theoretical Physics +1 more

Relational particle mechanics is useful for modelling whole-universe issues such as quantum cosmology or the problem of time in quantum gravity, including some aspects outside the reach of comparably complex mini-superspace models. In this paper, we consider the mechanics of pure shape and not scale of four particles on a line, so that the only physically significant quantities are ratios of relative separations between the constituents' physical objects. Many of our ideas and workings extend to the N-particle case. As such models' configurations resemble depictions of metro lines in public transport maps, we term them 'N-stop metrolands'. This 4-stop model's configuration space is a 2-sphere, from which our metroland mechanics interpretation is via the 'cubic' tessellation. This model yields conserved quantities which are mathematically SO(3) objects like angular momenta but are physically relative dilational momenta (i.e. coordinates dotted with momenta). We provide and interpret various exact and approximate classical and quantum solutions for 4-stop metroland; from these results one can construct expectations and spreads of shape operators that admit interpretations as relative sizes and the 'homogeneity of the model universe's contents', and also objects of significance for the problem of time in quantum gravity (e.g. in the naïve Schrödinger and records theory timeless approaches).

•Jan 1, 2010•32 citations

Towards a Relational Quantum Theory of Gravity: A Framework from Shape Dynamics and Quantum Frames

Mojtaba Dadashkarimi

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Shape Operators and Zodiac Tessellation: Improved Interpretation of Quantum Cosmological Triangleland

Edward James Anderson

With toy modelling of conceptual aspects of quantum cosmology and the problem of time in quantum gravity in mind, I study the classical and quantum dynamics of the scalefree triangle formed by 3 particles in 2-d. The shape spaces (configuration spaces for scalefree systems) both for this and for 4 particles in 1-d are spheres. Three quantities u whose squares sum to one play the role of Cartesian coordinates for an auxiliary surrounding flat 3-space and are then good variables from the perspective of kinematical quantization. These quantities turn out to be obvious ratios of relative separations for 4 particles in 1-d and rather less trivial Dragt-type coordinates in the case of the triangle. In each case, the u furthermore admit useful interpretation as shape quantities; the triangle’s three Dragt-type coordinates are an ellipicity of the system’s moments of inertia, a measure of anisoscelesness and the triangle’s area up to proportionality. I promote these quantities at the quantum level to operators whose expectation and spread are then useful in understanding the quantum states of the system. Additionally, I tessellate the mass-weighted shape sphere by its physical interpretation as the triangle, which parallels partitioning the night sky zodiacally and austro-boreally; juxtaposing this with classical trajectories/quantum mechanical wavefunctions permits straightforward reading off of the sequence of triangles in the motion/how probable each triangle is. I explain how features desirable for quantum cosmology cause one’s models to depart in detail from somewhat similar models already studied in molecular physics. I include applications to multiverse modelling and to timeless approaches to the problem of time.

•Sep 13, 2009•0 citations

An Attempt to Understand Relational Quantum Mechanics

PEKKA J. LAHTI, Juha-Pekka Pellonpää

Abstract We search for a possible mathematical formulation of some of the key ideas of the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics and study their consequences. We also briefly overview some proposals of relational quantum mechanics for an axiomatic reconstruction of the Hilbert space formulation of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2207.01380•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Aug 3, 2023•4 citations
I consider the momenta and conserved quantities for CP^2 interpreted as the space of quadrilaterals. This builds on seminar I and II's kinematics via making use of MacFarlane's work considering the SU(3)-like (and thus particle physics-like) conserved quantities that occur for CP^2. I perform the additional step of further interpreting that as the configuration space of all relational quadrilaterals and thus an interesting toy model for whole-universe, relational and geometrodynamical-analogue physics. I also provide the Kuchar observables for the quadrilateral, which is a particular resolution of the Problem of Observables. I study HO-like and highly symmetric potentials. I also provide some exact solutions and qualitative behaviours for dynamics on CP^2. In each case, I reinterpret the results in terms of quadrilaterals. This paves the way for the quantum mechanical study of the relational quadrilateral and for investigations of a number of Problem of Time strategies and of a number of other foundational and qualitative investigations of Quantum Cosmology.
This paper provides the quantum treatment of the relational quadrilateral. The underlying reduced configuration spaces are CP2\mathbb{CP}^2CP2 and the cone over this, C(CP2\mathbb{CP}^2CP2). We consider exact free and isotropic HO potential cases and perturbations about these. Moreover, our purely relational kinematical quantization is distinct from the usual one for CP2\mathbb{CP}^2CP2, which turns out to carry absolutist connotations instead. Thus this paper is the first to note absolute-versus-relational motion distinctions at the kinematical rather than dynamical level, and also an example of value to the discussion of kinematical quantization along the lines of Isham 1984. This treatment of the relational quadrilateral is the first relational QM with very new mathematics for a finite QM model, and is far more typical of the general quantum relational NNN-a-gon than the previously-studied case of the relational triangle. We consider useful integrals as regards perturbation theory and the peaking interpretation of quantum cosmology. We subsequently consider problem of time applications of this: quantum Kuchař beables, the Machian version of the semiclassical approach and the timeless naive Schrodinger interpretation. These go toward extending the combined Machian semiclassical-histories-timeless approach of [1] to the case of the quadrilateral, which will be treated in subsequent papers.
We provide the quantum treatment of the relational quadrilateral. The underlying reduced configuration spaces are ℂℙ 2 and the cone over this. We consider exact free and isotropic HO potential cases and perturbations about these. Moreover, our purely relational kinematical quantization is distinct from the usual one for ℂℙ 2 , which turns out to carry absolutist connotations instead. Thus, this paper is the first to note absolute-versus-relational motion distinctions at the kinematical rather than dynamical level. It is also an example of value to the discussion of kinematical quantization along the lines of Isham, 1984. The relational quadrilateral is the simplest RPM whose mathematics is not standard in atomic physics (the triangle and four particles on a line are both based on 𝕊 2 and ℝ 3 mathematics). It is far more typical of the general quantum relational N-a-gon than the previously studied case of the relational triangle. We consider useful integrals as regards perturbation theory and the peaking interpretation of quantum cosmology. We subsequently consider problem of time (PoT) applications of this: quantum Kuchař beables, the Machian version of the semiclassical approach and the timeless naïve Schrödinger interpretation. These go toward extending the combined Machian semiclassical-Histories-Timeless Approach of [Int. J. Mod. Phys. D23 (2014) 1450014] to the case of the quadrilateral, which will be treated in subsequent papers.
Relational particle mechanics is useful for modelling whole-universe issues such as quantum cosmology or the problem of time in quantum gravity, including some aspects outside the reach of comparably complex mini-superspace models. In this paper, we consider the mechanics of pure shape and not scale of four particles on a line, so that the only physically significant quantities are ratios of relative separations between the constituents' physical objects. Many of our ideas and workings extend to the N-particle case. As such models' configurations resemble depictions of metro lines in public transport maps, we term them 'N-stop metrolands'. This 4-stop model's configuration space is a 2-sphere, from which our metroland mechanics interpretation is via the 'cubic' tessellation. This model yields conserved quantities which are mathematically SO(3) objects like angular momenta but are physically relative dilational momenta (i.e. coordinates dotted with momenta). We provide and interpret various exact and approximate classical and quantum solutions for 4-stop metroland; from these results one can construct expectations and spreads of shape operators that admit interpretations as relative sizes and the 'homogeneity of the model universe's contents', and also objects of significance for the problem of time in quantum gravity (e.g. in the naïve Schrödinger and records theory timeless approaches).
With toy modelling of conceptual aspects of quantum cosmology and the problem of time in quantum gravity in mind, I study the classical and quantum dynamics of the scalefree triangle formed by 3 particles in 2-d. The shape spaces (configuration spaces for scalefree systems) both for this and for 4 particles in 1-d are spheres. Three quantities u whose squares sum to one play the role of Cartesian coordinates for an auxiliary surrounding flat 3-space and are then good variables from the perspective of kinematical quantization. These quantities turn out to be obvious ratios of relative separations for 4 particles in 1-d and rather less trivial Dragt-type coordinates in the case of the triangle. In each case, the u furthermore admit useful interpretation as shape quantities; the triangle’s three Dragt-type coordinates are an ellipicity of the system’s moments of inertia, a measure of anisoscelesness and the triangle’s area up to proportionality. I promote these quantities at the quantum level to operators whose expectation and spread are then useful in understanding the quantum states of the system. Additionally, I tessellate the mass-weighted shape sphere by its physical interpretation as the triangle, which parallels partitioning the night sky zodiacally and austro-boreally; juxtaposing this with classical trajectories/quantum mechanical wavefunctions permits straightforward reading off of the sequence of triangles in the motion/how probable each triangle is. I explain how features desirable for quantum cosmology cause one’s models to depart in detail from somewhat similar models already studied in molecular physics. I include applications to multiverse modelling and to timeless approaches to the problem of time.