Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1201.5304

Wave-particle duality: suggestion for an experiment

Rathindra Nath Sen

Published Jan 23, 2012• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Feynman contended that the double-slit experiment contained the `only mystery' in quantum mechanics. The mystery was that electrons traverse the interferometer as waves, but are detected as particles. This note was motivated by the question whether single electrons can be detected as waves. It suggests a double-slit interferometry experiment with atoms of noble gases in which it may be possible to detect an individual atom as a probability wave, using a detector which can execute two different types of simple harmonic motion: as a simple pendulum, and as a torsion pendulum. In the experiment, a torsional oscillation will never be induced by the impact of a probability wave, but will always be induced by the impact of a particle. Detection as a wave is contingent on the atom interacting much more strongly with the macroscopic detector as a whole than with its microscopic constituents. This requirement may be more difficult to meet with electrons, protons, neutrons or photons than with atoms.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1201.5304

Related papers

Can wave-particle duality be a source of quantum nonlocality?

Rathindra Nath Sen

In matter wave interferometry, detectors detect individual particles; the wave picture (interference pattern) emerges only as a statistical aggregation, after a large number of particles have been detected. Feynman, mystified by such facts, declared that 'nobody understands quantum mechanics'. A few decades later, Ketterle summed up the situation as 'one gets used to preparing waves and detecting particles'. But why are matter waves detected only as particles? Is there a law of nature forbidding their detection as waves? This question does not seem to have been addressed. The present communication suggests that it may be possible to detect matter waves as waves if there exists a nonlocal interaction - due to wave-particle duality - that causes a nonlocal transfer of energy and momentum from microscopic objects to mesoscopic or macroscopic ones. It describes the principle of a possible wave detector and the scheme of an experiment. The experiment may be feasible in the foreseeable future with a mesoscopic detector made of carbon nanostructures, or in an earth satellite in an elliptical orbit. The detection of a single atom or molecule as a wave will have enormous consequences, both practical and conceptual.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Wave–Particle Duality

David Prutchi, Shanni R. Prutchi

This chapter contains sections titled: Gamma-Ray Spectrum Analysis What is the Nature of Light? Two-Slit Interference with Single Photons Imaging Single Photons The Answer: Complementarity Matter Waves Matter Waves and the Bohr Atom Experimental Confirmation of De Broglie's Matter Waves Two-Slit Interference with Single Electrons A Simple TEM Blurring the Line Between Quantum and Classical Particle–Wave Duality in the Macroscopic World Experiments and Questions

Wiley eBooks•Jan 20, 2012•0 citations

Cross-Double-Slit Experiments and Wave-Particle Duality

Huei Peng

We report observations of Cross-Double-Slit Experiment and Which-Path-Cross-Double-Slit experiment. Cross-Double-Slit apparatus contains two double-slit, where first double-slit is perpendicular to second double-slit. The first double-slit and the second double-slit generate not only their own interference pattern perpendicular to each other, but also generate “Cross-interference-patterns”. When we do which-way experiment with one of two double-slit, say first double-slit, then its interference pattern disappeared, i.e., photons behave as particles; but the second double-slit’s interference pattern and the cross-interference-pattern still exist; which implies an significant phenomenon that in the same experiment, photons behave as both wave and particle, which is first time caught on film. Thus we suggest to re-study wave-particle duality, which is the basic mystery of quantum mechanics. We postulate that the particle nature of photons is intrinsic; while the wave-like of photons is manifest-behavior.

•May 1, 2019•0 citations

Atom Interferometers: Beyond Complementarity Principles

Zhiyuan Li

Complementarity lies at the heart of conceptual foundation of orthodox quantum mechanics. The wave-particle duality makes it impossible to tell which slit each particle passes through and still observe an interference pattern in a Young's double-slit experiment. In this paper, this duality is appraised under the standard formulation of quantum mechanics for atom interferometers. It is found that the internal freedoms like electronic states of an atom can be used to detect the which-path information of each atom while uphold the interference pattern of atoms when the center-of-mass motion of atoms is detected.

arXiv:quant-ph/0109023•Sep 4, 2001•2 citations

Double Slit Experiment Still Has Much to Offer (4): New Double Slit Experiments Violating Wave Description

Peng, Hui

Young's double slit experiments representing the mystery of quantum mechanics have been descripted by wave theories. To study the mystery, the double slit experiments were extended to the cross-double slit experiments. A description should explain all the double slit and cross-double slit experiments consistently. To test the wave description, the two postulates are proposed, which state that before passing through the double slit and before landing on the detector, photons behave as particles, but not as waves. To test the two postulates, the comprehensive double slit/cross-double slit experiments are proposed and performed. By placing shields and/or blockers near the detector/screen, the comprehensive double slit/cross-double slit experiments show that the fringes are created independently and partially, which discloses the particle nature of photons in the double slit/crossdouble slit experiments and violates the wave descriptions. The comprehensive double slit/cross-double slit experiments provide the comprehensive phenomena for developing theoretical model to study the mystery of double slit, complementarity principle, wave-particle duality, and wave theory of light.

•Oct 8, 2021•6 citations

An experiment to improve understanding wave-particle duality

Michel Gondran, Alexandre Gondran

This article presents an experiment that can be conducted today and that could provide a deeper understanding of the interaction between the wave and particle aspects of an atom. The wave-particle duality is often presented as mutually exclusive: one considers either the wave aspect or the particle aspect. Our proposed experiment involves both aspects simultaneously and raises new questions. It is a slightly modified version of Young's double-slit interference experiment (a grid of narrow slits is added between the two wide slits) and is carried out using Rydberg atoms. Young-type interference experiments typically involve only the de Broglie wave $ψ$, which depends solely on the mass and velocity of the atoms. However, with Rydberg atoms having a large principal quantum number, the ``size'' of the atom-particle also becomes significant. The two large slits are wide enough to allow the Rydberg atoms to pass through, whereas the grid of narrow slits prevents them from passing through. We numerically simulate the possible outcomes based on different hypotheses regarding wave-particle interaction. Conducting the experiment in practice would allow us to distinguish between these hypotheses and deepen our understanding of wave-particle interaction. The conceptual framework of Louis de Broglie's double solution theory is well-suited to this experiment because it distinguishes between two types of waves: an external or statistical wave (de Broglie's wave) and an internal or physical wave (corresponding to the physical particle). We will examine the relevance of this approach.

arXiv:2509.04882•Sep 5, 2025•0 citations
Feynman contended that the double-slit experiment contained the `only mystery' in quantum mechanics. The mystery was that electrons traverse the interferometer as waves, but are detected as particles. This note was motivated by the question whether single electrons can be detected as waves. It suggests a double-slit interferometry experiment with atoms of noble gases in which it may be possible to detect an individual atom as a probability wave, using a detector which can execute two different types of simple harmonic motion: as a simple pendulum, and as a torsion pendulum. In the experiment, a torsional oscillation will never be induced by the impact of a probability wave, but will always be induced by the impact of a particle. Detection as a wave is contingent on the atom interacting much more strongly with the macroscopic detector as a whole than with its microscopic constituents. This requirement may be more difficult to meet with electrons, protons, neutrons or photons than with atoms.
In matter wave interferometry, detectors detect individual particles; the wave picture (interference pattern) emerges only as a statistical aggregation, after a large number of particles have been detected. Feynman, mystified by such facts, declared that 'nobody understands quantum mechanics'. A few decades later, Ketterle summed up the situation as 'one gets used to preparing waves and detecting particles'. But why are matter waves detected only as particles? Is there a law of nature forbidding their detection as waves? This question does not seem to have been addressed. The present communication suggests that it may be possible to detect matter waves as waves if there exists a nonlocal interaction - due to wave-particle duality - that causes a nonlocal transfer of energy and momentum from microscopic objects to mesoscopic or macroscopic ones. It describes the principle of a possible wave detector and the scheme of an experiment. The experiment may be feasible in the foreseeable future with a mesoscopic detector made of carbon nanostructures, or in an earth satellite in an elliptical orbit. The detection of a single atom or molecule as a wave will have enormous consequences, both practical and conceptual.
We report observations of Cross-Double-Slit Experiment and Which-Path-Cross-Double-Slit experiment. Cross-Double-Slit apparatus contains two double-slit, where first double-slit is perpendicular to second double-slit. The first double-slit and the second double-slit generate not only their own interference pattern perpendicular to each other, but also generate “Cross-interference-patterns”. When we do which-way experiment with one of two double-slit, say first double-slit, then its interference pattern disappeared, i.e., photons behave as particles; but the second double-slit’s interference pattern and the cross-interference-pattern still exist; which implies an significant phenomenon that in the same experiment, photons behave as both wave and particle, which is first time caught on film. Thus we suggest to re-study wave-particle duality, which is the basic mystery of quantum mechanics. We postulate that the particle nature of photons is intrinsic; while the wave-like of photons is manifest-behavior.
Complementarity lies at the heart of conceptual foundation of orthodox quantum mechanics. The wave-particle duality makes it impossible to tell which slit each particle passes through and still observe an interference pattern in a Young's double-slit experiment. In this paper, this duality is appraised under the standard formulation of quantum mechanics for atom interferometers. It is found that the internal freedoms like electronic states of an atom can be used to detect the which-path information of each atom while uphold the interference pattern of atoms when the center-of-mass motion of atoms is detected.
Young's double slit experiments representing the mystery of quantum mechanics have been descripted by wave theories. To study the mystery, the double slit experiments were extended to the cross-double slit experiments. A description should explain all the double slit and cross-double slit experiments consistently. To test the wave description, the two postulates are proposed, which state that before passing through the double slit and before landing on the detector, photons behave as particles, but not as waves. To test the two postulates, the comprehensive double slit/cross-double slit experiments are proposed and performed. By placing shields and/or blockers near the detector/screen, the comprehensive double slit/cross-double slit experiments show that the fringes are created independently and partially, which discloses the particle nature of photons in the double slit/crossdouble slit experiments and violates the wave descriptions. The comprehensive double slit/cross-double slit experiments provide the comprehensive phenomena for developing theoretical model to study the mystery of double slit, complementarity principle, wave-particle duality, and wave theory of light.
This article presents an experiment that can be conducted today and that could provide a deeper understanding of the interaction between the wave and particle aspects of an atom. The wave-particle duality is often presented as mutually exclusive: one considers either the wave aspect or the particle aspect. Our proposed experiment involves both aspects simultaneously and raises new questions. It is a slightly modified version of Young's double-slit interference experiment (a grid of narrow slits is added between the two wide slits) and is carried out using Rydberg atoms. Young-type interference experiments typically involve only the de Broglie wave ψψψ, which depends solely on the mass and velocity of the atoms. However, with Rydberg atoms having a large principal quantum number, the ``size'' of the atom-particle also becomes significant. The two large slits are wide enough to allow the Rydberg atoms to pass through, whereas the grid of narrow slits prevents them from passing through. We numerically simulate the possible outcomes based on different hypotheses regarding wave-particle interaction. Conducting the experiment in practice would allow us to distinguish between these hypotheses and deepen our understanding of wave-particle interaction. The conceptual framework of Louis de Broglie's double solution theory is well-suited to this experiment because it distinguishes between two types of waves: an external or statistical wave (de Broglie's wave) and an internal or physical wave (corresponding to the physical particle). We will examine the relevance of this approach.