Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1112.5701

Superselection Rules from Measurement Theory

Shogo Tanimura

Published Dec 24, 2011• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum theory, physically measurable quantities of a microscopic system are represented by self-adjoint operators. However, not all of the self-adjoint operators correspond to measurable quantities. The superselection rule is a criterion to distinguish measurable quantities. Any measurable quantity must obey the superselection rules. By contraposition, any quantity which does not obey the superselection rules cannot be measured. Although some of superselection rules were proved, the raizon d'être of the superselection rules has been still obscure. In this paper we deduce the superselection rules from an assumption on symmetry property of measurement process. We introduce the notion of covariant indicator, which is a macroscopic observable whose value indicates the value of a microscopic object observable. We prove that if an object system has a quantity that is conserved during the measurement process, other quantities that do not commute with the conserved quantity are non-measurable by the covariant indicator. Our derivation of superselection rules is compared with the uncertainty relation under the restriction by a conservation law. An implication of the color superselection rule for the color confinement is discussed. It is also argued that spontaneous symmetry breaking enables a measurement that the superselection rule prohibits.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1112.5701

Related papers

Quantum Measurements in thePresence of Symmetry

Leon Loveridge

This thesis concerns how symmetries impinge on quantum mechanical measurements, \nand preclude certain self adjoint operators from representing observable \nquantities. After developing the requisite mathematical machinery and aspects \nof quantum measurement theory necessary for our analysis, we proceed to critically \nreview the literature surrounding the remarkable theorem of Wigner, \nAraki and Yanase (WAY) that prohibits accurate and repeatable measurements \nof any observable not commuting with an additive conserved quantity, as well \nas discussing the conditions under which approximate measurements with approximate \ndegrees of repeatability can be achieved. We strengthen the original \nstatement of the WAY theorem and generalise it to the case of position measurements \nobeying momentum conservation, leading to a solution of a long-standing \nproblem of Stein and Shimony. A superselection rule appearing as the existence \nof an observable which commutes with all others gives rise to a stronger \nrestriction than the WAY theorem, yielding self adjoint operators which do not \nrepresent observable quantities. We analyse various perspectives on superselection \nrules, aiming to clarify different viewpoints appearing in the literature \nsince the inception of the topic in 1952. We exploit an explicit description \nof relative phase observables which have been lacking in other contributions, \ndelineating conditions under which relative and (prohibited) absolute phases \nbecome statistically close. By providing simple models we are able to mimic a \nnumber of attempts to overcome superselection rules, in order to highlight the \ngeneric features of such attempts. We show that the statistical proximity of absolute \nand relative quantities arises only when there is a highly localised phase \nreference, and that the superselection rule compatible relative phase factors \nbetween certain superpositions takes on the appearence of a forbidden relative \nphase factor in this limit. However, we argue that these relative phase factors \ncan be determined fully within the confines of a superselection rule. \n

•Jul 1, 2012•4 citations

Physical Observables and Superselection

M. P. Vaughan

It is well-known that a physical state may be represented by a unit vector in a Hilbert space, whilst a physical observable may be represented by a self-adjoint operator on that same space. However, the introduction of a superselection rule on a Hilbert space imposes constraints such that not all self-adjoint operators can represent observables, which has further consequences for the states themselves as well as the physical processes that transform them. In this article, we review the concept of superselection from the view of how such rules would affect what we consider to be physical. Arguments for the existence of a superselection rule due to charge or possibly energy conservation are given and the emergence of effective superselection rules due to decoherence or the lack of a shared reference frame are also discussed.

arXiv:2611.17051•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

The Trouble with Superselection Accounts of Measurement

Mariam Thalos

A superselection rule advanced in the course of a quantum-mechanical treatment of some phenomenon is an assertion to the effect that the superposition principle of quantum mechanics is to be restricted in the application at hand. Superselection accounts of measurement all have in common a decision to represent the indicator states of detectors by eigenspaces of superselection operators named in a superselection rule, on the grounds that the states in question are states of a so-called classical quantity and therefore not subject to quantum interference effects. By this strategy superselectionists of measurement expect to dispense with use of projection postulates in treatments of measurement. I shall argue that superselection accounts of measurement are self-contradictory, and that treatments of infinite systems, if they can avoid the contradiction, are not true superselection accounts.

Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 1998•2 citations

On superselection rules for macroscopic objects

Прохоров Лев Васильевич

It is shown that for "ideal" macroscopic objects there are superselection rules forbidding superpositions of macroscopically distinguishable states of the objects. For real macroscopic bodies the notion of "weak" superselection rules is introduced. Some other aspects of the measurement problem are discussed.

arXiv:quant-ph/0406220•Jun 29, 2004•0 citations

From Micro to Macro Quantum Systems: A Unified Formalism with Superselection Rules and Its Applications

K. Kong Wan

Traditional quantum theory has a very rigid structure, making it difficult to accommodate new properties emerging from novel systems. This book presents a flexible and unified theory for physical systems, from micro and macro quantum to classical. This is achieved by incorporating superselection rules and maximal symmetric operators into the theory. The resulting theory is applicable to classical, microscopic quantum and non-orthodox mixed quantum systems of which macroscopic quantum systems are examples. A unified formalism also greatly facilitates the discussion of interactions between these systems. A scheme of quantization by parts is introduced, based on the mathematics of selfadjoint and maximal symmetric extensions of symmetric operators, to describe point interactions. The results are applied to treat superconducting quantum circuits in various configurations.This book also discusses various topics of interest such as the asymptotic treatment of quantum state preparation and quantum measurement, local observables and local values, Schrodinger's cat states in superconducting systems, and a path space formulation of quantum mechanics.This self-contained book is complete with a review of relevant geometric and operator theories, for example, vector fields and operators, symmetric operators and their maximal symmetric extensions, direct integrals of Hilbert spaces and operators.

IMPERIAL COLLEGE PRESS eBooks•Mar 1, 2006•17 citations

Superselection Rule for Charge

G. C. Wick, Arthur S. Wightman, Eugene Paul Wigner

The customary notion of superselection rule stipulates the vanishing of those matrix elements of the density matrix that connect states separated by the superselection rule, i.e., the relative phases of which are, according to the superselection rule, meaningless. It is shown that, if any two states for which an additive conserved quantity has different values are separated for all physical systems by a superselection rule at one time, the separation will persist for all times. It is concluded that the states with different electric (or baryonic) charges are so separated. The reason for the difference between electric charge and other additive conserved quantities, such as momentum, is brought out.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 15, 1970•90 citations
In quantum theory, physically measurable quantities of a microscopic system are represented by self-adjoint operators. However, not all of the self-adjoint operators correspond to measurable quantities. The superselection rule is a criterion to distinguish measurable quantities. Any measurable quantity must obey the superselection rules. By contraposition, any quantity which does not obey the superselection rules cannot be measured. Although some of superselection rules were proved, the raizon d'être of the superselection rules has been still obscure. In this paper we deduce the superselection rules from an assumption on symmetry property of measurement process. We introduce the notion of covariant indicator, which is a macroscopic observable whose value indicates the value of a microscopic object observable. We prove that if an object system has a quantity that is conserved during the measurement process, other quantities that do not commute with the conserved quantity are non-measurable by the covariant indicator. Our derivation of superselection rules is compared with the uncertainty relation under the restriction by a conservation law. An implication of the color superselection rule for the color confinement is discussed. It is also argued that spontaneous symmetry breaking enables a measurement that the superselection rule prohibits.
This thesis concerns how symmetries impinge on quantum mechanical measurements, \nand preclude certain self adjoint operators from representing observable \nquantities. After developing the requisite mathematical machinery and aspects \nof quantum measurement theory necessary for our analysis, we proceed to critically \nreview the literature surrounding the remarkable theorem of Wigner, \nAraki and Yanase (WAY) that prohibits accurate and repeatable measurements \nof any observable not commuting with an additive conserved quantity, as well \nas discussing the conditions under which approximate measurements with approximate \ndegrees of repeatability can be achieved. We strengthen the original \nstatement of the WAY theorem and generalise it to the case of position measurements \nobeying momentum conservation, leading to a solution of a long-standing \nproblem of Stein and Shimony. A superselection rule appearing as the existence \nof an observable which commutes with all others gives rise to a stronger \nrestriction than the WAY theorem, yielding self adjoint operators which do not \nrepresent observable quantities. We analyse various perspectives on superselection \nrules, aiming to clarify different viewpoints appearing in the literature \nsince the inception of the topic in 1952. We exploit an explicit description \nof relative phase observables which have been lacking in other contributions, \ndelineating conditions under which relative and (prohibited) absolute phases \nbecome statistically close. By providing simple models we are able to mimic a \nnumber of attempts to overcome superselection rules, in order to highlight the \ngeneric features of such attempts. We show that the statistical proximity of absolute \nand relative quantities arises only when there is a highly localised phase \nreference, and that the superselection rule compatible relative phase factors \nbetween certain superpositions takes on the appearence of a forbidden relative \nphase factor in this limit. However, we argue that these relative phase factors \ncan be determined fully within the confines of a superselection rule. \n
It is well-known that a physical state may be represented by a unit vector in a Hilbert space, whilst a physical observable may be represented by a self-adjoint operator on that same space. However, the introduction of a superselection rule on a Hilbert space imposes constraints such that not all self-adjoint operators can represent observables, which has further consequences for the states themselves as well as the physical processes that transform them. In this article, we review the concept of superselection from the view of how such rules would affect what we consider to be physical. Arguments for the existence of a superselection rule due to charge or possibly energy conservation are given and the emergence of effective superselection rules due to decoherence or the lack of a shared reference frame are also discussed.
A superselection rule advanced in the course of a quantum-mechanical treatment of some phenomenon is an assertion to the effect that the superposition principle of quantum mechanics is to be restricted in the application at hand. Superselection accounts of measurement all have in common a decision to represent the indicator states of detectors by eigenspaces of superselection operators named in a superselection rule, on the grounds that the states in question are states of a so-called classical quantity and therefore not subject to quantum interference effects. By this strategy superselectionists of measurement expect to dispense with use of projection postulates in treatments of measurement. I shall argue that superselection accounts of measurement are self-contradictory, and that treatments of infinite systems, if they can avoid the contradiction, are not true superselection accounts.
Traditional quantum theory has a very rigid structure, making it difficult to accommodate new properties emerging from novel systems. This book presents a flexible and unified theory for physical systems, from micro and macro quantum to classical. This is achieved by incorporating superselection rules and maximal symmetric operators into the theory. The resulting theory is applicable to classical, microscopic quantum and non-orthodox mixed quantum systems of which macroscopic quantum systems are examples. A unified formalism also greatly facilitates the discussion of interactions between these systems. A scheme of quantization by parts is introduced, based on the mathematics of selfadjoint and maximal symmetric extensions of symmetric operators, to describe point interactions. The results are applied to treat superconducting quantum circuits in various configurations.This book also discusses various topics of interest such as the asymptotic treatment of quantum state preparation and quantum measurement, local observables and local values, Schrodinger's cat states in superconducting systems, and a path space formulation of quantum mechanics.This self-contained book is complete with a review of relevant geometric and operator theories, for example, vector fields and operators, symmetric operators and their maximal symmetric extensions, direct integrals of Hilbert spaces and operators.
The customary notion of superselection rule stipulates the vanishing of those matrix elements of the density matrix that connect states separated by the superselection rule, i.e., the relative phases of which are, according to the superselection rule, meaningless. It is shown that, if any two states for which an additive conserved quantity has different values are separated for all physical systems by a superselection rule at one time, the separation will persist for all times. It is concluded that the states with different electric (or baryonic) charges are so separated. The reason for the difference between electric charge and other additive conserved quantities, such as momentum, is brought out.