Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1112.5456 · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences

Unforgeable noise-tolerant quantum tokens

Fernando Pastawski, Norman Y. Yao, Liang Jiang, Mikhail D. Lukin, J. I. Cirac

Published Sep 17, 2012• 79 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The realization of devices that harness the laws of quantum mechanics represents an exciting challenge at the interface of modern technology and fundamental science. An exemplary paragon of the power of such quantum primitives is the concept of “quantum money” [Wiesner S (1983) ACM SIGACT News 15:78–88]. A dishonest holder of a quantum bank note will invariably fail in any counterfeiting attempts; indeed, under assumptions of ideal measurements and decoherence-free memories such security is guaranteed by the no-cloning theorem. In any practical situation, however, noise, decoherence, and operational imperfections abound. Thus, the development of secure “quantum money”-type primitives capable of tolerating realistic infidelities is of both practical and fundamental importance. Here, we propose a novel class of such protocols and demonstrate their tolerance to noise; moreover, we prove their rigorous security by determining tight fidelity thresholds. Our proposed protocols require only the ability to prepare, store, and measure single quantum bit memories, making their experimental realization accessible with current technologies.

DOI
10.1073/pnas.1203552109

Related papers

Practical quantum tokens without quantum memories and experimental tests

Adrian Kent, David Lowndes, Damián Pitalúa-García +1 more

Abstract Unforgeable quantum money tokens were the first invention of quantum information science, but remain technologically challenging as they require quantum memories and/or long-distance quantum communication. More recently, virtual “S-money” tokens were introduced. These are generated by quantum cryptography, do not require quantum memories or long-distance quantum communication, and yet in principle guarantee many of the security advantages of quantum money. Here, we describe implementations of S-money schemes with off-the-shelf quantum key distribution technology, and analyse security in the presence of noise, losses, and experimental imperfection. Our schemes satisfy near-instant validation without cross-checking. We show that, given standard assumptions in mistrustful quantum cryptographic implementations, unforgeability and user privacy could be guaranteed with attainable refinements of our off-the-shelf setup. We discuss the possibilities for unconditionally secure (assumption-free) implementations.

arXiv:2104.11717•npj Quantum Information•Mar 11, 2022•13 citations

Noise-tolerant public-key quantum money from a classical oracle

Peter Yuen

Quantum money is the task of verifying the validity of banknotes while ensuring that they cannot be counterfeited. Public-key quantum money allows anyone to perform verification, while the private-key setting restricts the ability to verify to banks, as in Wiesner's original scheme. The current state of technological progress means that errors are impossible to entirely suppress, hence the requirement for noise-tolerant schemes. We show for the first time how to achieve noise-tolerance in the public-key setting. Our techniques follow Aaronson and Christiano's oracle model, where we use the ideas of quantum error correction to extend their scheme: a valid banknote is now a subspace state possibly affected by noise, and verification is performed by using classical oracles to check for membership in "larger spaces." Additionally, a banknote in our scheme is minted by preparing conjugate coding states and applying a unitary that permutes the standard basis vectors.

arXiv:2407.06463•Quantum•Apr 7, 2025•4 citations

Experimental demonstration of practical unforgeable quantum money

Mathieu Bozzio, Adeline Orieux, Luis Trigo Vidarte +3 more

Wiesner's unforgeable quantum money scheme is widely celebrated as the first quantum information application. Based on the no-cloning property of quantum mechanics, this scheme allows for the creation of credit cards used in authenticated transactions offering security guarantees impossible to achieve by classical means. However, despite its central role in quantum cryptography, its experimental implementation has remained elusive because of the lack of realistic protocols adapted to practical quantum storage devices and verification techniques. Here, we experimentally demonstrate a quantum money protocol that rigorously satisfies the security condition for unforgeability, using a practical system exploiting single-photon polarization encoding of highly attenuated coherent states of light for on-the-fly credit card state generation and readout. Our implementation includes classical verification and is designed to be compatible with state-of-the-art quantum memories, which have been taken into account in the security analysis, together with all system imperfections. Our results constitute a major step towards a real-world realization of this milestone protocol.

•Sep 18, 2017•1 citation

Approaches to Practical Quantum Cryptography

Peter Yuen

There are various practical obstacles in quantum cryptography. These include the problems that arise in implementing quantum cryptographic protocols with current and near-term technology, and those that come with the development and security analysis of new protocols. In this work, we examine a few of these obstacles and, for each one, we highlight an approach that aims to mitigate it. We start by examining the setting of device-independence, with oblivious transfer in the bounded-quantum-storage-model as the primitive of interest. The typical approach to enabling device-independence is the use of a Bell-inequality violation, which requires a strict non-communication assumption that is practically difficult to enforce. We develop and analyze the security of a device-independent oblivious transfer protocol that replaces the Bell-inequality violation approach with a computational assumption, thereby relaxing the non-communication assumption. Our second topic examines the problem of noise in a quantum money scheme. We show how to achieve noise-tolerance in the public-key setting. Our scheme can be seen as a generalization of the [AC12] scheme: a valid banknote is now a subspace state possibly affected by noise, and verification is performed by using classical oracles to check for membership in "larger spaces." Additionally, a banknote in our scheme is minted by preparing conjugate coding states and applying a unitary. For our last topic, we consider the general task of proving security against a specious adversary, which is the quantum analogue of the classical semi-honest adversary. A useful feature of specious adversaries is that security against them can guarantee security against stronger adversaries [DNS12]. This motivates the search for a canonical specious adversary, where proving security against such an adversary guarantees security against the entire class of specious adversaries. Within a restricted setting, we define a particular specious adversary and show that it satisfies our definition of canonical.

•Jul 7, 2025•0 citations

Experimental investigation of practical unforgeable quantum money

Mathieu Bozzio, Adeline Orieux, Luis Trigo Vidarte +3 more

Abstract Wiesner’s unforgeable quantum money scheme is widely celebrated as the first quantum information application. Based on the no-cloning property of quantum mechanics, this scheme allows for the creation of credit cards used in authenticated transactions offering security guarantees impossible to achieve by classical means. However, despite its central role in quantum cryptography, its experimental implementation has remained elusive because of the lack of quantum memories and of practical verification techniques. Here, we experimentally implement a quantum money protocol relying on classical verification that rigorously satisfies the security condition for unforgeability. Our system exploits polarization encoding of weak coherent states of light and operates under conditions that ensure compatibility with state-of-the-art quantum memories. We derive working regimes for our system using a security analysis taking into account all practical imperfections. Our results constitute a major step towards a real-world realization of this milestone protocol.

arXiv:1705.01428•npj Quantum Information•Jan 19, 2018•63 citations

A Note on Publicly Verifiable Quantum Money with Low Quantum Computational Resources

Fabrizio Genovese, Lev Stambler

In this work we present a publicly verifiable quantum money protocol which assumes close to no quantum computational capabilities. We rely on one-time memories which in turn can be built from quantum conjugate coding and hardware-based assumptions. Specifically, our scheme allows for a limited number of verifications and also allows for quantum tokens for digital signatures. Double spending is prevented by the no-cloning principle of conjugate coding states. An implementation of the concepts presented in this work can be found at https://github.com/neverlocal/otm_billz.

quant-pharXiv:2512.21304•Dec 25, 2025•0 citations
The realization of devices that harness the laws of quantum mechanics represents an exciting challenge at the interface of modern technology and fundamental science. An exemplary paragon of the power of such quantum primitives is the concept of “quantum money” [Wiesner S (1983) ACM SIGACT News 15:78–88]. A dishonest holder of a quantum bank note will invariably fail in any counterfeiting attempts; indeed, under assumptions of ideal measurements and decoherence-free memories such security is guaranteed by the no-cloning theorem. In any practical situation, however, noise, decoherence, and operational imperfections abound. Thus, the development of secure “quantum money”-type primitives capable of tolerating realistic infidelities is of both practical and fundamental importance. Here, we propose a novel class of such protocols and demonstrate their tolerance to noise; moreover, we prove their rigorous security by determining tight fidelity thresholds. Our proposed protocols require only the ability to prepare, store, and measure single quantum bit memories, making their experimental realization accessible with current technologies.
Abstract Unforgeable quantum money tokens were the first invention of quantum information science, but remain technologically challenging as they require quantum memories and/or long-distance quantum communication. More recently, virtual “S-money” tokens were introduced. These are generated by quantum cryptography, do not require quantum memories or long-distance quantum communication, and yet in principle guarantee many of the security advantages of quantum money. Here, we describe implementations of S-money schemes with off-the-shelf quantum key distribution technology, and analyse security in the presence of noise, losses, and experimental imperfection. Our schemes satisfy near-instant validation without cross-checking. We show that, given standard assumptions in mistrustful quantum cryptographic implementations, unforgeability and user privacy could be guaranteed with attainable refinements of our off-the-shelf setup. We discuss the possibilities for unconditionally secure (assumption-free) implementations.
Quantum money is the task of verifying the validity of banknotes while ensuring that they cannot be counterfeited. Public-key quantum money allows anyone to perform verification, while the private-key setting restricts the ability to verify to banks, as in Wiesner's original scheme. The current state of technological progress means that errors are impossible to entirely suppress, hence the requirement for noise-tolerant schemes. We show for the first time how to achieve noise-tolerance in the public-key setting. Our techniques follow Aaronson and Christiano's oracle model, where we use the ideas of quantum error correction to extend their scheme: a valid banknote is now a subspace state possibly affected by noise, and verification is performed by using classical oracles to check for membership in "larger spaces." Additionally, a banknote in our scheme is minted by preparing conjugate coding states and applying a unitary that permutes the standard basis vectors.
Wiesner's unforgeable quantum money scheme is widely celebrated as the first quantum information application. Based on the no-cloning property of quantum mechanics, this scheme allows for the creation of credit cards used in authenticated transactions offering security guarantees impossible to achieve by classical means. However, despite its central role in quantum cryptography, its experimental implementation has remained elusive because of the lack of realistic protocols adapted to practical quantum storage devices and verification techniques. Here, we experimentally demonstrate a quantum money protocol that rigorously satisfies the security condition for unforgeability, using a practical system exploiting single-photon polarization encoding of highly attenuated coherent states of light for on-the-fly credit card state generation and readout. Our implementation includes classical verification and is designed to be compatible with state-of-the-art quantum memories, which have been taken into account in the security analysis, together with all system imperfections. Our results constitute a major step towards a real-world realization of this milestone protocol.
There are various practical obstacles in quantum cryptography. These include the problems that arise in implementing quantum cryptographic protocols with current and near-term technology, and those that come with the development and security analysis of new protocols. In this work, we examine a few of these obstacles and, for each one, we highlight an approach that aims to mitigate it. We start by examining the setting of device-independence, with oblivious transfer in the bounded-quantum-storage-model as the primitive of interest. The typical approach to enabling device-independence is the use of a Bell-inequality violation, which requires a strict non-communication assumption that is practically difficult to enforce. We develop and analyze the security of a device-independent oblivious transfer protocol that replaces the Bell-inequality violation approach with a computational assumption, thereby relaxing the non-communication assumption. Our second topic examines the problem of noise in a quantum money scheme. We show how to achieve noise-tolerance in the public-key setting. Our scheme can be seen as a generalization of the [AC12] scheme: a valid banknote is now a subspace state possibly affected by noise, and verification is performed by using classical oracles to check for membership in "larger spaces." Additionally, a banknote in our scheme is minted by preparing conjugate coding states and applying a unitary. For our last topic, we consider the general task of proving security against a specious adversary, which is the quantum analogue of the classical semi-honest adversary. A useful feature of specious adversaries is that security against them can guarantee security against stronger adversaries [DNS12]. This motivates the search for a canonical specious adversary, where proving security against such an adversary guarantees security against the entire class of specious adversaries. Within a restricted setting, we define a particular specious adversary and show that it satisfies our definition of canonical.
Abstract Wiesner’s unforgeable quantum money scheme is widely celebrated as the first quantum information application. Based on the no-cloning property of quantum mechanics, this scheme allows for the creation of credit cards used in authenticated transactions offering security guarantees impossible to achieve by classical means. However, despite its central role in quantum cryptography, its experimental implementation has remained elusive because of the lack of quantum memories and of practical verification techniques. Here, we experimentally implement a quantum money protocol relying on classical verification that rigorously satisfies the security condition for unforgeability. Our system exploits polarization encoding of weak coherent states of light and operates under conditions that ensure compatibility with state-of-the-art quantum memories. We derive working regimes for our system using a security analysis taking into account all practical imperfections. Our results constitute a major step towards a real-world realization of this milestone protocol.
In this work we present a publicly verifiable quantum money protocol which assumes close to no quantum computational capabilities. We rely on one-time memories which in turn can be built from quantum conjugate coding and hardware-based assumptions. Specifically, our scheme allows for a limited number of verifications and also allows for quantum tokens for digital signatures. Double spending is prevented by the no-cloning principle of conjugate coding states. An implementation of the concepts presented in this work can be found at https://github.com/neverlocal/otm_billz.