Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1109.5549 · International Journal of Quantum Information

QUANTUM DISCORD AND QUANTUM COMPUTING — AN APPRAISAL

ANIMESH DATTA, Anil Shaji

Published Oct 1, 2011• 47 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We discuss models of computing that are beyond classical. The primary motivation is to unearth the cause of non-classical advantages in computation. Completeness results from computational complexity theory lead to the identification of very disparate problems, and offer a kaleidoscopic view into the realm of quantum enhancements in computation. Emphasis is placed on the "power of one qubit" model, and the boundary between quantum and classical correlations as delineated by quantum discord. A recent result by Eastin on the role of this boundary in the efficient classical simulation of quantum computation is discussed. Perceived drawbacks in the interpretation of quantum discord as a relevant certificate of quantum enhancements are addressed.

DOI
10.1142/s0219749911008416

Related papers

A Brief Review on Quantum Correlations

Wang Fe

entanglement generated by the far beyond intuitive pure quantum phenomena such as EPRparadox,Schr?dinger's Equation has been considered not only as one of the significant notions in quantum theorybut also a key of realizing the Super Dense Coding and the Quantum Teleportation in quantum communication.However,recent researches show that quantum entanglement is less likely to account for all the properties of quan-tum correlations.Except for the quantum entanglement,researchers find other non-classical correlations like quan-tum discord,which plays a pivotal role in quantum information and quantum computation and that's why the purequbit-decisive quantum computer possesses computational efficiency.With this clarification,quantum discord com-pletely can be a new resource of quantum computation.In this paper,basic notions and measurement methods ofnon- classical correlations(including quantum entanglement) were discussed and the quantum correlationproperties of the quantum discord in various models were analyzed and compared with the quantum entanglement.Conducting researches on the non-classical correlations in various quantum systems are not merely meritorious tothe quantum theory,in the mean time,may provide some efficient thoughts and motivations for researchers to em-ploy theoretical concepts about quantum correlations for avoiding decoherence and theoretical scenario for the exper-iments.

Journal of Xinjiang Normal University•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Operational significance of discord consumption

Thomas Symul, Helen M. Chrzanowski, Syed M. Assad +5 more

For many years, the notion of quantum correlations was equated with the notion of quantum entanglement. The wide range of quantum protocols whose extra-powers over classical protocol were shown to originate from quantum entanglement mostly motivated this. For example, it was shown that for certain class of problems, a quantum computer could provide exponential speed-up over its classical counterpart, given that it relied on quantum entangled resources. Recently, however, the requirement of possessing entanglement to perform efficient quantum computation has been questioned both theoretically [1] and experimentally [2]. It appears that a non-classical quantity called quantum discord [3] is all that is required.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•May 1, 2013•1 citation

The role of quantum correlations beyond entanglement in quantum information theory

Alexander Streltsov

Quantum entanglement is the most popular kind of quantum correlations. Its role in several tasks in quantum information theory like quantum cryptography, quantum dense coding and quantum teleportation is indisputable. The role of entanglement in quantum algorithms has also attracted enormous amount of attention in the literature. The research in this direction is motivated by the finding that a quantum computer can efficiently factorize arbitrary integer numbers. Since no classical algorithm is known today that can solve this problem efficiently, this example clearly demonstrates the superiority of a quantum computer compared to its classical counterpart. In this context, entanglement also plays a crucial role: if the quantum computer operates on a pure state without entanglement, then the computational process can be simulated efficiently on a classical computer. In this case entanglement is the key ingredient that makes the difference between a quantum and a classical computer. However, the situation is more involved if the computational process is not perfect. In this case the quantum computer operates on a mixed state, and the role of entanglement is less obvious. A seminal result in this direction is a quantum algorithm known under the acronym DQC1. This algorithm operates on an almost maximally mixed state with vanishingly little entanglement. However, DQC1 can still perform tasks efficiently for which no efficient classical algorithm is known today. Thus, it is reasonable to assume that entanglement in general is not related to the efficiency of a quantum algorithm. Triggered by this observation other kinds of quantum correlations have been studied. In this context a particular measure of quantum correlations known as quantum discord is referred to frequently in the literature. Quantum discord is a measure of quantum correlations beyond entanglement, i.e., a quantum state can have no entanglement, but nonvanishing quantum discord. Quantum discord is also regarded as the key resource in the DQC1 algorithm. Although this statement is still controversial, it was shown under very general assumptions that quantum discord is required if a quantum computer is to show an exponential speedup over any classical algorithm. In this thesis we give a short introduction into the theory of entanglement and general quantum correlations, and further discuss our results. In particular, we show that two different kinds of entanglement measures can coincide. This result is used to build an algorithm for computing entanglement. We also consider the role of quantum correlations for the distribution of entanglement and for the quantum measurement process. We further discuss the behavior of quantum correlations under local noise, and their monogamy properties.

•Jan 1, 2013•1 citation

Studies on the Role of Entanglement in Mixed-state Quantum Computation

Animesh Datta

In this thesis, I look at the role of quantum entanglement in mixed-state quantum computation. The model we consider is the DQC1 or `power of one qubit' model. I show that there is minimal bipartite entanglement in a typical instance of the DQC1 circuit and even put an upper bound on the possible amount of entanglement. This limited amount of entanglement, however, does not imply that the system is classically simulatable. A matrix product state (MPS) algorithm for a typical instance of the DQC1 system requires exponential classical resources. This exposes a gap between the amount of entanglement and the amount of purely nonclassical correlations in a quantum system. This gap, I suggest, can be filled by quantum discord. I calculate it in a typical instance of the DQC1 circuit and find that the amount of discord is a constant fraction of the maximum possible discord for a system of that size. This allows an interpretation of quantum discord as the resource that drives mixed-state quantum computation. I also study quantum discord as a quantity of independent interest. Its role in the phenomenon of entanglement distribution is studied through an easily comprehensible example. This thesis also contains discussions on the relation between the complexity classes P, BQP and DQC1. Additional material is presented on the connections between the DQC1 model, Jones polynomials and statistical mechanics. The thesis concludes with a discussion of a few open problems related to the DQC1 model, the quantum discord and their scope in quantum information science.

arXiv:0807.4490•Jul 28, 2008•83 citations

Quantum Discord and the Power of One Qubit

Animesh Datta, Anil Shaji, Carlton M. Caves

We use quantum discord to characterize the correlations present in the model called deterministic quantum computation with one quantum bit (DQC1), introduced by Knill and Laflamme [Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5672 (1998)10.1103/PhysRevLett.81.5672]. The model involves a collection of qubits in the completely mixed state coupled to a single control qubit that has nonzero purity. The initial state, operations, and measurements in the model all point to a natural bipartite split between the control qubit and the mixed ones. Although there is no entanglement between these two parts, we show that the quantum discord across this split is nonzero for typical instances of the DQC1 ciruit. Nonzero values of discord indicate the presence of nonclassical correlations. We propose quantum discord as figure of merit for characterizing the resources present in this computational model.

arXiv:0709.0548•Physical Review Letters•Feb 5, 2008•1,244 citations

Computing quantum discord is NP-complete

Yichen Huang

We study the computational complexity of quantum discord (a measure of quantum correlation beyond entanglement), and prove that computing quantum discord is NP-complete. Therefore, quantum discord is computationally intractable: the running time of any algorithm for computing quantum discord is believed to grow exponentially with the dimension of the Hilbert space so that computing quantum discord in a quantum system of moderate size is not possible in practice. As by-products, some entanglement measures (namely entanglement cost, entanglement of formation, relative entropy of entanglement, squashed entanglement, classical squashed entanglement, conditional entanglement of mutual information, and broadcast regularization of mutual information) and constrained Holevo capacity are NP-hard/NP-complete to compute. These complexity-theoretic results are directly applicable in common randomness distillation, quantum state merging, entanglement distillation, superdense coding, and quantum teleportation; they may offer significant insights into quantum information processing. Moreover, we prove the NP-completeness of two typical problems: linear optimization over classical states and detecting classical states in a convex set, providing evidence that working with classical states is generically computationally intractable.

arXiv:1305.5941•New Journal of Physics•Mar 21, 2014•303 citations
We discuss models of computing that are beyond classical. The primary motivation is to unearth the cause of non-classical advantages in computation. Completeness results from computational complexity theory lead to the identification of very disparate problems, and offer a kaleidoscopic view into the realm of quantum enhancements in computation. Emphasis is placed on the "power of one qubit" model, and the boundary between quantum and classical correlations as delineated by quantum discord. A recent result by Eastin on the role of this boundary in the efficient classical simulation of quantum computation is discussed. Perceived drawbacks in the interpretation of quantum discord as a relevant certificate of quantum enhancements are addressed.
entanglement generated by the far beyond intuitive pure quantum phenomena such as EPRparadox,Schr?dinger's Equation has been considered not only as one of the significant notions in quantum theorybut also a key of realizing the Super Dense Coding and the Quantum Teleportation in quantum communication.However,recent researches show that quantum entanglement is less likely to account for all the properties of quan-tum correlations.Except for the quantum entanglement,researchers find other non-classical correlations like quan-tum discord,which plays a pivotal role in quantum information and quantum computation and that's why the purequbit-decisive quantum computer possesses computational efficiency.With this clarification,quantum discord com-pletely can be a new resource of quantum computation.In this paper,basic notions and measurement methods ofnon- classical correlations(including quantum entanglement) were discussed and the quantum correlationproperties of the quantum discord in various models were analyzed and compared with the quantum entanglement.Conducting researches on the non-classical correlations in various quantum systems are not merely meritorious tothe quantum theory,in the mean time,may provide some efficient thoughts and motivations for researchers to em-ploy theoretical concepts about quantum correlations for avoiding decoherence and theoretical scenario for the exper-iments.
For many years, the notion of quantum correlations was equated with the notion of quantum entanglement. The wide range of quantum protocols whose extra-powers over classical protocol were shown to originate from quantum entanglement mostly motivated this. For example, it was shown that for certain class of problems, a quantum computer could provide exponential speed-up over its classical counterpart, given that it relied on quantum entangled resources. Recently, however, the requirement of possessing entanglement to perform efficient quantum computation has been questioned both theoretically [1] and experimentally [2]. It appears that a non-classical quantity called quantum discord [3] is all that is required.
Quantum entanglement is the most popular kind of quantum correlations. Its role in several tasks in quantum information theory like quantum cryptography, quantum dense coding and quantum teleportation is indisputable. The role of entanglement in quantum algorithms has also attracted enormous amount of attention in the literature. The research in this direction is motivated by the finding that a quantum computer can efficiently factorize arbitrary integer numbers. Since no classical algorithm is known today that can solve this problem efficiently, this example clearly demonstrates the superiority of a quantum computer compared to its classical counterpart. In this context, entanglement also plays a crucial role: if the quantum computer operates on a pure state without entanglement, then the computational process can be simulated efficiently on a classical computer. In this case entanglement is the key ingredient that makes the difference between a quantum and a classical computer. However, the situation is more involved if the computational process is not perfect. In this case the quantum computer operates on a mixed state, and the role of entanglement is less obvious. A seminal result in this direction is a quantum algorithm known under the acronym DQC1. This algorithm operates on an almost maximally mixed state with vanishingly little entanglement. However, DQC1 can still perform tasks efficiently for which no efficient classical algorithm is known today. Thus, it is reasonable to assume that entanglement in general is not related to the efficiency of a quantum algorithm. Triggered by this observation other kinds of quantum correlations have been studied. In this context a particular measure of quantum correlations known as quantum discord is referred to frequently in the literature. Quantum discord is a measure of quantum correlations beyond entanglement, i.e., a quantum state can have no entanglement, but nonvanishing quantum discord. Quantum discord is also regarded as the key resource in the DQC1 algorithm. Although this statement is still controversial, it was shown under very general assumptions that quantum discord is required if a quantum computer is to show an exponential speedup over any classical algorithm. In this thesis we give a short introduction into the theory of entanglement and general quantum correlations, and further discuss our results. In particular, we show that two different kinds of entanglement measures can coincide. This result is used to build an algorithm for computing entanglement. We also consider the role of quantum correlations for the distribution of entanglement and for the quantum measurement process. We further discuss the behavior of quantum correlations under local noise, and their monogamy properties.
In this thesis, I look at the role of quantum entanglement in mixed-state quantum computation. The model we consider is the DQC1 or `power of one qubit' model. I show that there is minimal bipartite entanglement in a typical instance of the DQC1 circuit and even put an upper bound on the possible amount of entanglement. This limited amount of entanglement, however, does not imply that the system is classically simulatable. A matrix product state (MPS) algorithm for a typical instance of the DQC1 system requires exponential classical resources. This exposes a gap between the amount of entanglement and the amount of purely nonclassical correlations in a quantum system. This gap, I suggest, can be filled by quantum discord. I calculate it in a typical instance of the DQC1 circuit and find that the amount of discord is a constant fraction of the maximum possible discord for a system of that size. This allows an interpretation of quantum discord as the resource that drives mixed-state quantum computation. I also study quantum discord as a quantity of independent interest. Its role in the phenomenon of entanglement distribution is studied through an easily comprehensible example. This thesis also contains discussions on the relation between the complexity classes P, BQP and DQC1. Additional material is presented on the connections between the DQC1 model, Jones polynomials and statistical mechanics. The thesis concludes with a discussion of a few open problems related to the DQC1 model, the quantum discord and their scope in quantum information science.
We use quantum discord to characterize the correlations present in the model called deterministic quantum computation with one quantum bit (DQC1), introduced by Knill and Laflamme [Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5672 (1998)10.1103/PhysRevLett.81.5672]. The model involves a collection of qubits in the completely mixed state coupled to a single control qubit that has nonzero purity. The initial state, operations, and measurements in the model all point to a natural bipartite split between the control qubit and the mixed ones. Although there is no entanglement between these two parts, we show that the quantum discord across this split is nonzero for typical instances of the DQC1 ciruit. Nonzero values of discord indicate the presence of nonclassical correlations. We propose quantum discord as figure of merit for characterizing the resources present in this computational model.
We study the computational complexity of quantum discord (a measure of quantum correlation beyond entanglement), and prove that computing quantum discord is NP-complete. Therefore, quantum discord is computationally intractable: the running time of any algorithm for computing quantum discord is believed to grow exponentially with the dimension of the Hilbert space so that computing quantum discord in a quantum system of moderate size is not possible in practice. As by-products, some entanglement measures (namely entanglement cost, entanglement of formation, relative entropy of entanglement, squashed entanglement, classical squashed entanglement, conditional entanglement of mutual information, and broadcast regularization of mutual information) and constrained Holevo capacity are NP-hard/NP-complete to compute. These complexity-theoretic results are directly applicable in common randomness distillation, quantum state merging, entanglement distillation, superdense coding, and quantum teleportation; they may offer significant insights into quantum information processing. Moreover, we prove the NP-completeness of two typical problems: linear optimization over classical states and detecting classical states in a convex set, providing evidence that working with classical states is generically computationally intractable.