Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1108.6183 · Quantum Information and Computation

Security analysis of the time-coding quantum key distribution protocols

Thierry Debuisschert, Simon Fossier

Published Nov 1, 2011• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We report the security analysis of time-coding quantum key distribution protocols. The protocols make use of coherent single-photon pulses. The key is encoded in the photon time-detection. The use of coherent superposition of states allows to detect eavesdropping of the key. We give a mathematical model of a first protocol from which we derive a second, simpler, protocol. We derive the security analysis of both protocols and find that the secure rates can be similar to those obtained with the BB84 protocol. We then calculate the secure distance for those protocols over standard fibre links. When using low-noise superconducting single photon detectors, secure distances over 200 km can be foreseen. Finally, we analyse the consequences of photon-number splitting attacks when faint pulses are used instead of single photon pulses. A decoy states technique can be used to prevent such attacks.

DOI
10.26421/qic11.11-12-7

Related papers

Time coding protocols for quantum key distribution

Thierry Debuisschert, William Boucher

We propose quantum key distribution protocols based on coherent single-photon optical pulses with duration $T$ and with minimum time-frequency uncertainty. The pulses are sent with possible delays (e.g., 0, $T∕2$) that are used to code the information (e.g., bit 0, bit 1) and that are shorter than the pulse width. Therefore, the time detection of the photons may result in a ambiguity of the delay evaluation for a potential eavesdropper. The duration of the received pulses is controlled thanks to a contrast measurement using an interferometer. A quantum formalism is given, allowing us to model the transmission of the key and the consequences of a possible eavesdropping. Two protocols are proposed and discussed. The first one involves two states and is limited to channels with losses lower than 50%. The second one involves four states, which prevents the eavesdropper from exploiting the losses of the line. The security of each protocol is evaluated as a function of channel losses, quantum bit error rate, and contrast loss in the case of intercept-resend attacks. It is applied to situations where photocounters dark counts are the main limitation of the system. The resulting maximum propagation distance allowing secure communication is evaluated.

Physical Review A•Oct 8, 2004•23 citations

Security of decoy-state protocols for general photon-number-splitting attacks

Rolando D. Somma, Richard Hughes

Decoy-state protocols provide a way to defeat photon-number-splitting attacks in quantum cryptography implemented with weak coherent pulses. We point out that previous security analyses of such protocols relied on assumptions about eavesdropping attacks that considered treating each pulse equally and independently. We give an example to demonstrate that, without such assumptions, the security parameters of previous decoy-state implementations could be worse than the ones claimed. Next we consider more general photon-number-splitting attacks, which correlate different pulses, and give an estimation procedure for the number of single-photon signals with rigorous security statements. The impact of our result is that previous analyses of the number of times a decoy-state quantum cryptographic system can be reused before it makes a weak key must be revised.

arXiv:1304.5161•Physical Review A•Jun 24, 2013•10 citations

Security of the decoy state method for quantum key distribution

A S Trushechkin, E O Kiktenko, D A Kronberg +1 more

Abstract Quantum cryptography or, more precisely, quantum key distribution (QKD), is one of the advanced areas in the field of quantum technologies. The confidentiality of keys distributed with the use of QKD protocols is guaranteed by the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics. This paper is devoted to the decoy state method, a countermeasure against vulnerabilities caused by the use of coherent states of light for QKD protocols whose security is proved under the assumption of single-photon states. We give a formal security proof of the decoy state method against all possible attacks. We compare two widely known attacks on multiphoton pulses: photon-number splitting and beam splitting. Finally, we discuss the equivalence of polarization and phase coding.

arXiv:2101.10128•Physics-Uspekhi•Nov 1, 2020•43 citations

Effect of finite detector efficiencies on the security evaluation of quantum key distribution

Marcos Curty, Norbert Lütkenhaus

Quantum key distribution with the Bennett-Brassard 1984 protocol has been shown to be unconditionally secure even using weak coherent pulses instead of single-photon signals. The distances that can be covered by these methods are limited due to the loss in the quantum channel (e.g., loss in the optical fiber) and in the single-photon counters of the receivers. One can argue that the loss in the detectors cannot be changed by an eavesdropper in order to increase the covered distance. Here we show that the security analysis of this scenario is not as easy as is commonly assumed, since already two-photon processes allow eavesdropping strategies that outperform the known photon-number splitting attack. For this reason there is, so far, no satisfactory security analysis available in the framework of individual attacks.

arXiv:quant-ph/0311066•Physical Review A•Apr 28, 2004•30 citations

Long-distance quantum key distribution secure against coherent attacks

Bernd Fröhlich, Marco Lucamarini, J. F. Dynes +6 more

Quantum key distribution (QKD) permits information-theoretically secure transmission of digital encryption keys, assuming that the behaviour of the devices employed for the key exchange can be reliably modelled and predicted. Remarkably, no assumptions have to be made on the capabilities of an eavesdropper other than that she is bounded by the laws of Nature, thus making the security of QKD "unconditional". However, unconditional security is hard to achieve in practice. For example, any experimental realisation can only collect finite data samples, leading to vulnerabilities against coherent attacks, the most general class of attacks, and for some protocols the theoretical proof of robustness against these attacks is still missing. For these reasons, in the past many QKD experiments have fallen short of implementing an unconditionally secure protocol and have instead considered limited attacking capabilities by the eavesdropper. Here, we explore the security of QKD against coherent attacks in the most challenging environment: the long-distance transmission of keys. We demonstrate that the BB84 protocol can provide positive key rates for distances up to 240 km without multiplexing of conventional signals, and up to 200 km with multiplexing. Useful key rates can be achieved even for the longest distances, using practical thermo-electrically cooled single-photon detectors.

arXiv:1701.07252•Optica•Jan 18, 2017•195 citations

Experimental implementation of time-coding quantum key distribution

William Boucher, Thierry Debuisschert

We have implemented an experimental setup in order to demonstrate the feasibility of time-coding protocols for quantum key distribution. Alice produces coherent 20-ns faint pulses of light at 853 nm. They are sent to Bob with delay 0 ns (encoding bit 0) or 10 ns (encoding bit 1). Bob directs at random the received pulses to two different arms. In the first one, a 300 ps resolution Si photon counter allows Bob to precisely measure the detection times of each photon in order to establish the key. Comparing them with the emission times of the pulses sent by Alice allows one to evaluate the quantum bit error rate (QBER). The minimum obtained QBER is 1.62%. The possible loss of coherence in the setup can be exploited by Eve to eavesdrop the line. Therefore, the second arm of Bob setup is a Mach-Zehnder interferometer with a 10 ns propagation delay between the two paths. Contrast measurement of the output beams allows one to measure the autocorrelation function of the received pulses that characterizes their average coherence. In the case of an ideal setup, the value expected with the pulses sent by Alice is 0.576. The experimental value of the pulses autocorrelation function is found to be 0.541. Knowing the resulting loss of coherence and the measured QBER, one can evaluate the mutual information between Alice and Eve and the mutual information between Alice and Bob, in the case of intercept-resend attacks and in the case of attacks with intrication. With our values, Bob has an advantage on Eve of 0.43 bit per pulse. The maximum possible QBER corresponding to equal informations for Bob and Eve is 5.8%. With the usual attenuation of fibres at 850 nm, it shows that secure key distribution is possible up to a distance of 2.75 km, which is sufficient for local links.

arXiv:quant-ph/0601068•Physical Review A•Dec 19, 2005•23 citations
We report the security analysis of time-coding quantum key distribution protocols. The protocols make use of coherent single-photon pulses. The key is encoded in the photon time-detection. The use of coherent superposition of states allows to detect eavesdropping of the key. We give a mathematical model of a first protocol from which we derive a second, simpler, protocol. We derive the security analysis of both protocols and find that the secure rates can be similar to those obtained with the BB84 protocol. We then calculate the secure distance for those protocols over standard fibre links. When using low-noise superconducting single photon detectors, secure distances over 200 km can be foreseen. Finally, we analyse the consequences of photon-number splitting attacks when faint pulses are used instead of single photon pulses. A decoy states technique can be used to prevent such attacks.
We propose quantum key distribution protocols based on coherent single-photon optical pulses with duration TTT and with minimum time-frequency uncertainty. The pulses are sent with possible delays (e.g., 0, T∕2T∕2T∕2) that are used to code the information (e.g., bit 0, bit 1) and that are shorter than the pulse width. Therefore, the time detection of the photons may result in a ambiguity of the delay evaluation for a potential eavesdropper. The duration of the received pulses is controlled thanks to a contrast measurement using an interferometer. A quantum formalism is given, allowing us to model the transmission of the key and the consequences of a possible eavesdropping. Two protocols are proposed and discussed. The first one involves two states and is limited to channels with losses lower than 50%. The second one involves four states, which prevents the eavesdropper from exploiting the losses of the line. The security of each protocol is evaluated as a function of channel losses, quantum bit error rate, and contrast loss in the case of intercept-resend attacks. It is applied to situations where photocounters dark counts are the main limitation of the system. The resulting maximum propagation distance allowing secure communication is evaluated.
Decoy-state protocols provide a way to defeat photon-number-splitting attacks in quantum cryptography implemented with weak coherent pulses. We point out that previous security analyses of such protocols relied on assumptions about eavesdropping attacks that considered treating each pulse equally and independently. We give an example to demonstrate that, without such assumptions, the security parameters of previous decoy-state implementations could be worse than the ones claimed. Next we consider more general photon-number-splitting attacks, which correlate different pulses, and give an estimation procedure for the number of single-photon signals with rigorous security statements. The impact of our result is that previous analyses of the number of times a decoy-state quantum cryptographic system can be reused before it makes a weak key must be revised.
Abstract Quantum cryptography or, more precisely, quantum key distribution (QKD), is one of the advanced areas in the field of quantum technologies. The confidentiality of keys distributed with the use of QKD protocols is guaranteed by the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics. This paper is devoted to the decoy state method, a countermeasure against vulnerabilities caused by the use of coherent states of light for QKD protocols whose security is proved under the assumption of single-photon states. We give a formal security proof of the decoy state method against all possible attacks. We compare two widely known attacks on multiphoton pulses: photon-number splitting and beam splitting. Finally, we discuss the equivalence of polarization and phase coding.
Quantum key distribution with the Bennett-Brassard 1984 protocol has been shown to be unconditionally secure even using weak coherent pulses instead of single-photon signals. The distances that can be covered by these methods are limited due to the loss in the quantum channel (e.g., loss in the optical fiber) and in the single-photon counters of the receivers. One can argue that the loss in the detectors cannot be changed by an eavesdropper in order to increase the covered distance. Here we show that the security analysis of this scenario is not as easy as is commonly assumed, since already two-photon processes allow eavesdropping strategies that outperform the known photon-number splitting attack. For this reason there is, so far, no satisfactory security analysis available in the framework of individual attacks.
Quantum key distribution (QKD) permits information-theoretically secure transmission of digital encryption keys, assuming that the behaviour of the devices employed for the key exchange can be reliably modelled and predicted. Remarkably, no assumptions have to be made on the capabilities of an eavesdropper other than that she is bounded by the laws of Nature, thus making the security of QKD "unconditional". However, unconditional security is hard to achieve in practice. For example, any experimental realisation can only collect finite data samples, leading to vulnerabilities against coherent attacks, the most general class of attacks, and for some protocols the theoretical proof of robustness against these attacks is still missing. For these reasons, in the past many QKD experiments have fallen short of implementing an unconditionally secure protocol and have instead considered limited attacking capabilities by the eavesdropper. Here, we explore the security of QKD against coherent attacks in the most challenging environment: the long-distance transmission of keys. We demonstrate that the BB84 protocol can provide positive key rates for distances up to 240 km without multiplexing of conventional signals, and up to 200 km with multiplexing. Useful key rates can be achieved even for the longest distances, using practical thermo-electrically cooled single-photon detectors.
We have implemented an experimental setup in order to demonstrate the feasibility of time-coding protocols for quantum key distribution. Alice produces coherent 20-ns faint pulses of light at 853 nm. They are sent to Bob with delay 0 ns (encoding bit 0) or 10 ns (encoding bit 1). Bob directs at random the received pulses to two different arms. In the first one, a 300 ps resolution Si photon counter allows Bob to precisely measure the detection times of each photon in order to establish the key. Comparing them with the emission times of the pulses sent by Alice allows one to evaluate the quantum bit error rate (QBER). The minimum obtained QBER is 1.62%. The possible loss of coherence in the setup can be exploited by Eve to eavesdrop the line. Therefore, the second arm of Bob setup is a Mach-Zehnder interferometer with a 10 ns propagation delay between the two paths. Contrast measurement of the output beams allows one to measure the autocorrelation function of the received pulses that characterizes their average coherence. In the case of an ideal setup, the value expected with the pulses sent by Alice is 0.576. The experimental value of the pulses autocorrelation function is found to be 0.541. Knowing the resulting loss of coherence and the measured QBER, one can evaluate the mutual information between Alice and Eve and the mutual information between Alice and Bob, in the case of intercept-resend attacks and in the case of attacks with intrication. With our values, Bob has an advantage on Eve of 0.43 bit per pulse. The maximum possible QBER corresponding to equal informations for Bob and Eve is 5.8%. With the usual attenuation of fibres at 850 nm, it shows that secure key distribution is possible up to a distance of 2.75 km, which is sufficient for local links.