Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1108.2376 · Communications in Numerical Analysis

Heisenberg uncertainty relation and statistical measures in the square well

Ricardo López‐Ruiz, Jaime Sañudo A

Published Jan 1, 2012• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A non stationary state in the one-dimensional infinite square well formed by a combination of the ground state and the first excited one is considered. The statistical complexity and the Fisher-Shannon entropy in position and momentum are calculated with time for this system. These measures are compared with the Heisenberg uncertainty relation, ΔxΔp. It is observed that the extreme values of ΔxΔp coincide in time with extreme values of the other two statistical magnitudes.

DOI
10.5899/2012/cna-00117

Related papers

Quantum Uncertainty Principles and Classical Statistical Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle for position-momentum delta x delta p >= hbar/2 is considered as an important statement regarding quantum mechanics i.e. one cannot know both p and x exactly. Delta x and delta p stand out because in classical mechanics one has an eact p and x at each t. Mathematically, however, delta x and delta p are standard deviations which may also be calculated in classical statistical mechanics, for example with the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. In particular, if one considers the ground state of a simple harmonic oscillator, the quantum P(x) proportional to exp(-pp/a) and P(p) proportional to exp(-xxa) match the classical statistical probabilities P(x) and P(p) for a fixed value of T proportional to sqrt(k/m) where k is the spring constant. Thus for this special T, delta x delta p for a classical statistical mechanical gas is identical to delta x delta p for the ground state quantum oscillator. The probability is normalized the same way for both. The physics of the two situations, however, is completely different. Thus the Heisenberg uncertainty principle does not necessarily describe quantum mechanical behaviour alone. If one uses entropic uncertainty, i.e. Sp + Sx where S is Shannon’s entropy, once again one uses P(p)=a*(p)a(p) and P(x)=W*(x)W(x) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). In principle, one could also calculate such an entropy for a classical gas i.e. use P(x)P(p) in Shannon’s entropy. The result Sp+Sx does not imply one does not know about p if one knows x i.e. the usual quantum statement.

•Apr 28, 2022•0 citations

Uncertainty relations for a particle confined in a finite square well potential

Akira Tamura, Yohhei Tatsumi

Abstract In order to specify the uncertainty relation for a particle confined in a finite square well potential we derived the standard deviation of momentum Δ p and that of position Δ x . It is shown that Δ p has a peak as a function of the well width and both Δ x and Δ p ⋅ Δ x have a dip in contrast to the case of the particle confined in an infinite square well potential. We clarified that Δ p 0 ⋅ Δ x 0 of the particle occupying the ground state exists in the finite range as a function of the well width and the potential-barrier height, but a particle confined in an infinite square well potential has a constant Δ p 0 ⋅ Δ x 0 . In addition, we found that the values of Δ p n ⋅ Δ x n for excited states diverge in a certain range of well widths, where the energy level of the confined particle exceeds the potential barrier.

European Journal of Physics•Aug 4, 2017•4 citations

Fisher information and Shannon entropy under the cotangent hyperbolic potential model

B. B. Deji-Jinadu, C. A. Onate, O. O. Ajani

A Schrödinger equation is solved for a cotangent hyperbolic potential using the elegant parametric Nikiforov–Uvarov method. The results obtained are used to calculate the Fisher information for position space and momentum space as well as the Shannon entropy for position space and momentum space at the ground state. The energies of the cotangent potential are observed to be fully bounded for different quantum states. The Fisher information satisfied the Fisher relation known as Cramer–Rao inequality for the Fisher product. Its result also obeyed the Heisenberg principle as its alternative for uncertainty measurement. However, the Shannon entropy only satisfied the Bialynick-Birula, Mycielski inequality for higher values of the screening parameter. Its relation to the Heisenberg principle failed as both the position space and the momentum space are parallel with high entropy squeezing. This potential has not been reported for any system to the best of our understanding.

Modern Physics Letters A•Feb 28, 2025•5 citations

On moments-based Heisenberg inequalities

Steeve Zozor, M. Portesi, Pablo Sánchez-Moreno +1 more

In this paper we revisit the quantitative formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The primary version of this principle establishes the impossibility of refined simultaneous measurement of position x and momentum u for a (1-dimensional) quantum particle in terms of variances: <||x||^2> <||u||^2> ≥ 1/4. Since this inequality applies provided each variance exists, some authors proposed entropic versions of this principle as an alternative (employing Shannon's or Rényi's entropies). As another alternative, we consider moments-based formulations and show that inequalities involving moments of orders other than 2 can be found. Our procedure is based on the Rényi entropic versions of the Heisenberg relation together with the search for the maximal entropy un- der statistical moments' constraints ( <||x||^a> and <||u||^b> ). Our result improves a relation proposed very recently by Dehesa et al. [1] where the same approach was used but starting with the Shannon version of the entropic uncertainty relation. Furthermore, we show that when a = b, the best bound we can find with our approach coincides with that of Ref. [1] and, in addition, for a = b = 2 the variance-based Heisenberg relation is recovered. Finally, we illustrate our results in the cases of d-dimensional hydrogenic systems.

•Jul 4, 2010•0 citations

Entropic uncertainty relations for the infinite well

Vladimír Majerník, Lukáš Richterek

We calculate the entropic and standard uncertainty relations for the position and momentum of the infinite potential well as functions of its quantum states. We show that the entropic uncertainty relations express more adequately the uncertainty principle than the standard ones which use the dispersions as measures of the uncertainties for two non-commuting observables.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 21, 1997•55 citations

Modified Heisenberg Commutation Relations and the Infinite-Square Well Potential: Some Simple Consequences

Mauricio Contreras G., Roberto Ortiz, José Mauricio González

We explore some consequences of modifying the usual Heisenberg commutation relations of two simple systems: first, the one-dimensional quantum system given by the infinite square-well potential, and second, the case of a gas of N non-interacting particles in a box of volume V, which permit obtaining analytical solutions. We analyse two possible cases of modified Heisenberg commutation relations: one with a linear and non-linear dependence on the position and another with a linear and quadratic dependence on the momentum. We determine the eigenfunctions, probability densities, and energy eigenvalues for the one-dimensional square well for both deformation cases. For linear and non-linear x deformation dependence, the wave functions and energy levels change substantially when the weight factor associated with the modification term increases. Here, the energy levels are rescaled homogeneously. Instead, for linear and quadratic momentum p deformation dependence, the changes in the energy spectrum depend on the energy level. However, the probability densities are the same as those without any modification. For the non-interacting gas, the position deformation implies that the ideal gas state equation is modified, acquiring the form of a virial expansion in the volume, whereas the internal energy is unchanged. Instead, the ideal gas state equation remains unchanged at the lowest order in β for the momentum modification case. However, the temperature modifies the internal energy at the lowest order in β. Thus, this study indicates that gravity could generate forces on particles by modifying the Heisenberg commutation relations. Therefore, gravitation could be the cause of the other three forces of nature.

Symmetry•Sep 26, 2024•2 citations
A non stationary state in the one-dimensional infinite square well formed by a combination of the ground state and the first excited one is considered. The statistical complexity and the Fisher-Shannon entropy in position and momentum are calculated with time for this system. These measures are compared with the Heisenberg uncertainty relation, ΔxΔp. It is observed that the extreme values of ΔxΔp coincide in time with extreme values of the other two statistical magnitudes.
Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle for position-momentum delta x delta p >= hbar/2 is considered as an important statement regarding quantum mechanics i.e. one cannot know both p and x exactly. Delta x and delta p stand out because in classical mechanics one has an eact p and x at each t. Mathematically, however, delta x and delta p are standard deviations which may also be calculated in classical statistical mechanics, for example with the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. In particular, if one considers the ground state of a simple harmonic oscillator, the quantum P(x) proportional to exp(-pp/a) and P(p) proportional to exp(-xxa) match the classical statistical probabilities P(x) and P(p) for a fixed value of T proportional to sqrt(k/m) where k is the spring constant. Thus for this special T, delta x delta p for a classical statistical mechanical gas is identical to delta x delta p for the ground state quantum oscillator. The probability is normalized the same way for both. The physics of the two situations, however, is completely different. Thus the Heisenberg uncertainty principle does not necessarily describe quantum mechanical behaviour alone. If one uses entropic uncertainty, i.e. Sp + Sx where S is Shannon’s entropy, once again one uses P(p)=a*(p)a(p) and P(x)=W*(x)W(x) where W(x)=wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx). In principle, one could also calculate such an entropy for a classical gas i.e. use P(x)P(p) in Shannon’s entropy. The result Sp+Sx does not imply one does not know about p if one knows x i.e. the usual quantum statement.
Abstract In order to specify the uncertainty relation for a particle confined in a finite square well potential we derived the standard deviation of momentum Δ p and that of position Δ x . It is shown that Δ p has a peak as a function of the well width and both Δ x and Δ p ⋅ Δ x have a dip in contrast to the case of the particle confined in an infinite square well potential. We clarified that Δ p 0 ⋅ Δ x 0 of the particle occupying the ground state exists in the finite range as a function of the well width and the potential-barrier height, but a particle confined in an infinite square well potential has a constant Δ p 0 ⋅ Δ x 0 . In addition, we found that the values of Δ p n ⋅ Δ x n for excited states diverge in a certain range of well widths, where the energy level of the confined particle exceeds the potential barrier.
A Schrödinger equation is solved for a cotangent hyperbolic potential using the elegant parametric Nikiforov–Uvarov method. The results obtained are used to calculate the Fisher information for position space and momentum space as well as the Shannon entropy for position space and momentum space at the ground state. The energies of the cotangent potential are observed to be fully bounded for different quantum states. The Fisher information satisfied the Fisher relation known as Cramer–Rao inequality for the Fisher product. Its result also obeyed the Heisenberg principle as its alternative for uncertainty measurement. However, the Shannon entropy only satisfied the Bialynick-Birula, Mycielski inequality for higher values of the screening parameter. Its relation to the Heisenberg principle failed as both the position space and the momentum space are parallel with high entropy squeezing. This potential has not been reported for any system to the best of our understanding.
In this paper we revisit the quantitative formulation of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. The primary version of this principle establishes the impossibility of refined simultaneous measurement of position x and momentum u for a (1-dimensional) quantum particle in terms of variances: <||x||^2> <||u||^2> ≥ 1/4. Since this inequality applies provided each variance exists, some authors proposed entropic versions of this principle as an alternative (employing Shannon's or Rényi's entropies). As another alternative, we consider moments-based formulations and show that inequalities involving moments of orders other than 2 can be found. Our procedure is based on the Rényi entropic versions of the Heisenberg relation together with the search for the maximal entropy un- der statistical moments' constraints ( <||x||^a> and <||u||^b> ). Our result improves a relation proposed very recently by Dehesa et al. [1] where the same approach was used but starting with the Shannon version of the entropic uncertainty relation. Furthermore, we show that when a = b, the best bound we can find with our approach coincides with that of Ref. [1] and, in addition, for a = b = 2 the variance-based Heisenberg relation is recovered. Finally, we illustrate our results in the cases of d-dimensional hydrogenic systems.
We explore some consequences of modifying the usual Heisenberg commutation relations of two simple systems: first, the one-dimensional quantum system given by the infinite square-well potential, and second, the case of a gas of N non-interacting particles in a box of volume V, which permit obtaining analytical solutions. We analyse two possible cases of modified Heisenberg commutation relations: one with a linear and non-linear dependence on the position and another with a linear and quadratic dependence on the momentum. We determine the eigenfunctions, probability densities, and energy eigenvalues for the one-dimensional square well for both deformation cases. For linear and non-linear x deformation dependence, the wave functions and energy levels change substantially when the weight factor associated with the modification term increases. Here, the energy levels are rescaled homogeneously. Instead, for linear and quadratic momentum p deformation dependence, the changes in the energy spectrum depend on the energy level. However, the probability densities are the same as those without any modification. For the non-interacting gas, the position deformation implies that the ideal gas state equation is modified, acquiring the form of a virial expansion in the volume, whereas the internal energy is unchanged. Instead, the ideal gas state equation remains unchanged at the lowest order in β for the momentum modification case. However, the temperature modifies the internal energy at the lowest order in β. Thus, this study indicates that gravity could generate forces on particles by modifying the Heisenberg commutation relations. Therefore, gravitation could be the cause of the other three forces of nature.