Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1108.1197 · Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics

What Can Gauge-Gravity Duality Teach Us About Condensed Matter Physics?

Subir Sachdev A

Published Mar 1, 2011• 267 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

I discuss the impact of gauge-gravity duality on our understanding of two classes of systems: conformal quantum matter and compressible quantum matter. The first conformal class includes systems, such as the boson Hubbard model in two spatial dimensions, which display quantum critical points described by conformal field theories. Questions associated with nonzero temperature dynamics and transport are difficult to answer using conventional field-theoretic methods. I argue that many of these can be addressed systematically using gauge-gravity duality and discuss the prospects for reliable computation of low-frequency correlations. Compressible quantum matter is characterized by the smooth dependence of the charge density, associated with a global U(1) symmetry, upon a chemical potential. Familiar examples are solids, superfluids, and Fermi liquids, but there are more exotic possibilities involving deconfined phases of gauge fields in the presence of Fermi surfaces. I survey the compressible systems studied using gauge-gravity duality and discuss their relationship to the condensed matter classification of such states. The gravity methods offer hope of a deeper understanding of exotic and strongly coupled compressible quantum states.

DOI
10.1146/annurev-conmatphys-020911-125141

Related papers

Fermi surfaces and gauge-gravity duality

Liza Huijse, Subir Sachdev A

We give a unified overview of the zero temperature phases of compressible quantum matter: i.e., phases in which the expectation value of a globally conserved U(1) density, $\mathcal{Q}$, varies smoothly as a function of parameters. Provided the global U(1) and translational symmetries are unbroken, such phases are expected to have Fermi surfaces, and the Luttinger theorem relates the volumes enclosed by these Fermi surfaces to $⟨\mathcal{Q}⟩$. We survey models of interacting bosons and/or fermions and/or gauge fields which realize such phases. Some phases have Fermi surfaces with the singularities of Landau's Fermi liquid theory, while other Fermi surfaces have non-Fermi liquid singularities. Compressible phases found in models applicable to condensed-matter systems are argued to also be present in models obtained by applying chemical potentials (and other deformations allowed by the residual symmetry at nonzero chemical potential) to the paradigmatic supersymmetric gauge theories underlying gauge-gravity duality: the Aharony-Bergman-Jafferis-Maldacena model in spatial dimension $d=2$, and the $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills theory in $d=3$.

arXiv:1104.5022•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 5, 2011•100 citations

Quantum Condensed Matter

Bertrand I. Halperin, Subir Sachdev A, Nathan Goldman +1 more

I present a selective survey of the phases of quantum matter with varieties of many particle quantum entanglement. I classify the phases as gapped, conformal, or compressible quantum matter. Gapped quantum matter is illustrated by a simple discussion of the ℤ 2 spin liquid, and connections are made to topological field theories. I discuss how conformal matter is realized at quantum critical points of realistic lattice models, and make connections to a number of experimental systems. Recent progress in our understanding of compressible quantum phases which are not Fermi liquids is summarized. Finally, I discuss how the strongly-coupled phases of quantum matter may be described by gauge-gravity duality. The structure of the N c →∞ limit of SU (N c ) gauge theory, coupled to adjoint fermion matter at non-zero density, suggests aspects of gravitational duals of compressible quantum matter.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Mar 26, 2013•1 citation

Compressible quantum phases from conformal field theories in 2+1 dimensions

Subir Sachdev A

Conformal field theories (CFTs) with a globally conserved U(1) charge $\mathcal{Q}$ can be deformed into compressible phases by modifying their Hamiltonian, $\mathcal{H}$, by a chemical potential $\mathcal{H}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathcal{H}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\mu}\mathcal{Q}$. We study $2+1$ dimensional CFTs upon which an explicit $S$ duality mapping can be performed. We find that this construction leads naturally to compressible phases which are superfluids, solids, or non-Fermi liquids which are more appropriately called ``Bose metals'' in the present context. The Bose metal preserves all symmetries and has Fermi surfaces of gauge-charged fermions, even in cases where the parent CFT can be expressed solely by bosonic degrees of freedom. Monopole operators are identified as order parameters of the solids, and the product of their magnetic charge and $\mathcal{Q}$ determines the area of the unit cell. We present implications for holographic theories on asymptotically ${\mathrm{AdS}}_{4}$ spacetimes: $S$ duality and monopole/dyon fields play important roles in this connection.

arXiv:1209.1637•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Dec 19, 2012•42 citations

Holography and strongly correlated systems

Nabil Iqbal

In this thesis we apply techniques arising from string theory - gauge-gravity/duality, or holography - to problems associated with strongly coupled quantum field theories under extreme conditions such as finite temperature or density. We first study a strongly coupled field theory at finite temperature. We demonstrate that its low frequency limit is determined by the horizon geometry of its gravity dual, i.e. by the "membrane paradigm" fluid of classical black hole mechanics. Thus generic boundary theory transport coefficients can be expressed in terms of geometric quantities evaluated at the horizon, providing a simple understanding of results such as the universality of the shear viscosity in theories with gravity duals. Away from the low frequency limit we find a nontrivial radial flow from the black hole horizon to the boundary of the spacetime; we derive equations governing this flow and demonstrate their use in the simple examples of charge and momentum diffusion. Next, we turn to the study of strongly coupled theories with a finite density of a U(1) charge. The near-horizon geometry of the gravity dual of such a state has an AdS 2 factor, indicating the existence of a nontrivial emergent conformal symmetry in the infrared with nontrivial scaling only in the time direction. We review earlier work indicating that fermionic perturbations of such a state reveal non-Fermi-liquid behavior, i.e. gapless fermionic excitations that are not those of Fermi liquid theory. We perform a one-loop calculation in the bulk to compute the contribution from these Fermi surfaces to the conductivity of the full system. Interestingly, within this class of non-Fermi liquids we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior both resemble those of strange metals, i.e. the anomalous metallic state existing in the real-life high Tc cuprates above their superconducting transition temperature. In particular, for these examples the contribution to the conductivity is inversely proportional to temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point. We then turn to models of symmetry breaking in holographic models at finite density. We observe that the presence of the AdS₂ factor can result in the condensation of a neutral scalar operator. This can be used to model an "antiferromagnetic" phase in which a global SU(2) symmetry is broken down to U(1). We study the collective modes of the ordered phase and recover the expected spin waves from a gravitational treatment. We then note that the phase transition can be driven to zero temperature by tuning various bulk couplings, resulting in a quantum phase transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. We study this transition in detail, revealing novel critical behavior, including locally quantum critical dynamics and the existence of an infinite tower of excited states related by a discrete subgroup of the original emergent conformal symmetry. Throughout this thesis we focus on how the novel viewpoint provided by holography can help us gain new insights into the physics of strongly correlated systems.

•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Duality and strongly correlated systems in two dimensions

Hart Goldman

Many of the most vexing phenomena observed in condensed matter physics involve strongly correlated systems near quantum critical points in two spatial dimensions. Examples range from the sharing of critical exponents (superuniversality) among quantum Hall plateau transitions to the emergence of a charge-vortex symmetry near the field-tuned superconductor-insulator transition in thin films to the appearance of “anomalous” metallic states which evade localization. These problems elude theoretical understanding because they lack small parameters; standard perturbative approaches constitute poor, often uncontrolled approximations. This thesis concerns itself with the development of techniques reaching beyond the perturbative paradigm, focusing especially on duality, the idea that two seemingly different theories are actually one and the same. While a duality is most useful when it relates a strongly interacting theory to a weakly interacting one, even dualities between strongly coupled theories can reveal emergent symmetries and exotic gapped phases that may be obscure in one theory but not its dual. Recently, starting from a relativistic analogue of flux attachment, an entire web of quantum field theory dualities was proposed connecting a wide variety of quantum critical states in two spatial dimensions. This web of dualities has led to a surge of progress on a wide variety of condensed matter problems, several examples of which are presented in this thesis. One of the major challenges that comes with the proposal of new dualities is to “derive” them. In Chapter 2, we construct simple, explicit derivations of many members of the web of dualities in (particle-hole symmetric) models of relativistic current loops. In relativistic theories, flux attachment necessarily involves transmutation of both statistics and spin, an operation which can be made precise in the context of loop models. We further show that while non-relativistic theories are invariant under attachment of even numbers of flux quanta due to the periodicity of statistics, this symmetry is completely lost in relativistic theories due to the presence of spin, clarifying the interpretation of earlier loop models in which this symmetry appeared to be present. Motivated in part by this lack of statistical periodicity in relativistic flux attachment, in Chapter 3 we turn our attention to the metallic, “composite Fermi liquid” states occuring in quantum Hall systems at filling fraction ν = 1/2n. Famously, the state at ν = 1/2 is known to display particle-hole symmetry, which has recently led to the proposal of a manifestly particle-hole symmetric theory of relativistic, or Dirac, composite fermions that features prominently in the web of dualities. Surprisingly, however, an analogous “reflection symmetry” has also been observed in transport experiments about ν = 1/4. To explain this symmetry, we propose a series of relativistic composite fermion theories for the compressible states at ν = 1/2n, in which the reflection symmetry is incorporated as a mean field time-reversal symmetry of the composite fermions. These theories consist of electrically neutral Dirac fermions attached to 2n flux quanta via an emergent Chern-Simons gauge field. While not possessing an explicit particle-hole symmetry, these theories reproduce the known Jain sequence states proximate to ν = 1/2n, and we show that such states can be related by the observed reflection symmetry, at least at mean field level. In Chapter 4, we describe how duality can be used to access exotic gapped phases, in particular non- Abelian quantum Hall states. Using proposed non-Abelian bosonization dualities in two spatial dimensions, which morally relate U(N)k and SU(k)−N Chern-Simons-matter theories, we present pairing scenarios for which non-Abelian quantum Hall states can be obtained starting from theories of Abelian composite particles. The advantage of these dualities is that regions of the phase diagram which may be obscure on one side of the duality can be accessed by condensing local operators on the other side. Starting from parent Abelian states, we use this approach to construct Landau-Ginzburg theories of non-Abelian states through a pairing mechanism. In particular, we obtain the bosonic Read-Rezayi sequence at fillings ν = k/(kM +2) by starting from k layers of bosons at ν = 1/2 with M Abelian fluxes attached and then condensing k-clusters of the dual non-Abelian bosons. We further extend this constructions to obtain generalizations of the Read-Rezayi states with emergent global symmetries. In Chapter 5, we describe a context in which non-perturbative ideas from duality and perturbative results in the language of the renormalization group (RG) can inform one another: the interplay of quenched disorder and strong interaction effects near quantum critical points. In particular, we focus on the problem of quenched disorder at the superfluid-insulator transition of the O(N) model in the large-N limit. While a random mass is strongly relevant at the free fixed point, its effect is screened by the strong interactions of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point in this model, enabling a perturbative RG study of the interplay of disorder and interactions about this fixed point. In contrast to the spiralling flows obtained in earlier double-ε expansions, we show that the theory flows directly to a quantum critical point characterized by finite disorder and interactions, with critical exponents in remarkable agreement with numerical studies of the superfluid-Mott glass transition. With these results in hand, we apply duality to discuss the possible implications of this result for the dual Abelian Higgs and Chern-Simons-Dirac fermion theories when N = 1.

•Nov 18, 2020•0 citations

Universal properties of the U(1) current at deconfined quantum critical points: Comparison with predictions from gauge-gravity duality

Flavio S. Nogueira

The deconfined quantum critical point of a two-dimensional $SU(N)$ antiferromagnet is governed by an Abelian Higgs model in $d=2+1$ spacetime dimensions featuring $N$ complex scalar fields. In this context, we derive for $2\ensuremath{\le}d\ensuremath{\le}4$ an exact formula for the central charge of the $U(1)$ current in terms of the gauge coupling at quantum criticality and compare it with the corresponding result obtained using gauge-gravity duality. There is a remarkable similarity precisely for $d=2+1$. In this case the amplitude of the current correlation function has the same form as predicted by the gauge-gravity duality. We also compare finite temperature results for the charge susceptibility in the large $N$ limit with the result predicted by the gauge-gravity duality. Our results suggest that condensed matter systems at quantum criticality may provide interesting quantitative tests of the gauge-gravity duality even in the absence of supersymmetry.

arXiv:0902.0364•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 8, 2009•1 citation
I discuss the impact of gauge-gravity duality on our understanding of two classes of systems: conformal quantum matter and compressible quantum matter. The first conformal class includes systems, such as the boson Hubbard model in two spatial dimensions, which display quantum critical points described by conformal field theories. Questions associated with nonzero temperature dynamics and transport are difficult to answer using conventional field-theoretic methods. I argue that many of these can be addressed systematically using gauge-gravity duality and discuss the prospects for reliable computation of low-frequency correlations. Compressible quantum matter is characterized by the smooth dependence of the charge density, associated with a global U(1) symmetry, upon a chemical potential. Familiar examples are solids, superfluids, and Fermi liquids, but there are more exotic possibilities involving deconfined phases of gauge fields in the presence of Fermi surfaces. I survey the compressible systems studied using gauge-gravity duality and discuss their relationship to the condensed matter classification of such states. The gravity methods offer hope of a deeper understanding of exotic and strongly coupled compressible quantum states.
We give a unified overview of the zero temperature phases of compressible quantum matter: i.e., phases in which the expectation value of a globally conserved U(1) density, Q\mathcal{Q}Q, varies smoothly as a function of parameters. Provided the global U(1) and translational symmetries are unbroken, such phases are expected to have Fermi surfaces, and the Luttinger theorem relates the volumes enclosed by these Fermi surfaces to ⟨Q⟩⟨\mathcal{Q}⟩⟨Q⟩. We survey models of interacting bosons and/or fermions and/or gauge fields which realize such phases. Some phases have Fermi surfaces with the singularities of Landau's Fermi liquid theory, while other Fermi surfaces have non-Fermi liquid singularities. Compressible phases found in models applicable to condensed-matter systems are argued to also be present in models obtained by applying chemical potentials (and other deformations allowed by the residual symmetry at nonzero chemical potential) to the paradigmatic supersymmetric gauge theories underlying gauge-gravity duality: the Aharony-Bergman-Jafferis-Maldacena model in spatial dimension d=2d=2d=2, and the N=4\mathcal{N}=4N=4 super Yang-Mills theory in d=3d=3d=3.
I present a selective survey of the phases of quantum matter with varieties of many particle quantum entanglement. I classify the phases as gapped, conformal, or compressible quantum matter. Gapped quantum matter is illustrated by a simple discussion of the ℤ 2 spin liquid, and connections are made to topological field theories. I discuss how conformal matter is realized at quantum critical points of realistic lattice models, and make connections to a number of experimental systems. Recent progress in our understanding of compressible quantum phases which are not Fermi liquids is summarized. Finally, I discuss how the strongly-coupled phases of quantum matter may be described by gauge-gravity duality. The structure of the N c →∞ limit of SU (N c ) gauge theory, coupled to adjoint fermion matter at non-zero density, suggests aspects of gravitational duals of compressible quantum matter.
Conformal field theories (CFTs) with a globally conserved U(1) charge Q\mathcal{Q}Q can be deformed into compressible phases by modifying their Hamiltonian, H\mathcal{H}H, by a chemical potential $\mathcal{H}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\mathcal{H}\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\mu}\mathcal{Q}$. We study 2+12+12+1 dimensional CFTs upon which an explicit SSS duality mapping can be performed. We find that this construction leads naturally to compressible phases which are superfluids, solids, or non-Fermi liquids which are more appropriately called ``Bose metals'' in the present context. The Bose metal preserves all symmetries and has Fermi surfaces of gauge-charged fermions, even in cases where the parent CFT can be expressed solely by bosonic degrees of freedom. Monopole operators are identified as order parameters of the solids, and the product of their magnetic charge and Q\mathcal{Q}Q determines the area of the unit cell. We present implications for holographic theories on asymptotically AdS4{\mathrm{AdS}}_{4}AdS4​ spacetimes: SSS duality and monopole/dyon fields play important roles in this connection.
In this thesis we apply techniques arising from string theory - gauge-gravity/duality, or holography - to problems associated with strongly coupled quantum field theories under extreme conditions such as finite temperature or density. We first study a strongly coupled field theory at finite temperature. We demonstrate that its low frequency limit is determined by the horizon geometry of its gravity dual, i.e. by the "membrane paradigm" fluid of classical black hole mechanics. Thus generic boundary theory transport coefficients can be expressed in terms of geometric quantities evaluated at the horizon, providing a simple understanding of results such as the universality of the shear viscosity in theories with gravity duals. Away from the low frequency limit we find a nontrivial radial flow from the black hole horizon to the boundary of the spacetime; we derive equations governing this flow and demonstrate their use in the simple examples of charge and momentum diffusion. Next, we turn to the study of strongly coupled theories with a finite density of a U(1) charge. The near-horizon geometry of the gravity dual of such a state has an AdS 2 factor, indicating the existence of a nontrivial emergent conformal symmetry in the infrared with nontrivial scaling only in the time direction. We review earlier work indicating that fermionic perturbations of such a state reveal non-Fermi-liquid behavior, i.e. gapless fermionic excitations that are not those of Fermi liquid theory. We perform a one-loop calculation in the bulk to compute the contribution from these Fermi surfaces to the conductivity of the full system. Interestingly, within this class of non-Fermi liquids we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior both resemble those of strange metals, i.e. the anomalous metallic state existing in the real-life high Tc cuprates above their superconducting transition temperature. In particular, for these examples the contribution to the conductivity is inversely proportional to temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point. We then turn to models of symmetry breaking in holographic models at finite density. We observe that the presence of the AdS₂ factor can result in the condensation of a neutral scalar operator. This can be used to model an "antiferromagnetic" phase in which a global SU(2) symmetry is broken down to U(1). We study the collective modes of the ordered phase and recover the expected spin waves from a gravitational treatment. We then note that the phase transition can be driven to zero temperature by tuning various bulk couplings, resulting in a quantum phase transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. We study this transition in detail, revealing novel critical behavior, including locally quantum critical dynamics and the existence of an infinite tower of excited states related by a discrete subgroup of the original emergent conformal symmetry. Throughout this thesis we focus on how the novel viewpoint provided by holography can help us gain new insights into the physics of strongly correlated systems.
Many of the most vexing phenomena observed in condensed matter physics involve strongly correlated systems near quantum critical points in two spatial dimensions. Examples range from the sharing of critical exponents (superuniversality) among quantum Hall plateau transitions to the emergence of a charge-vortex symmetry near the field-tuned superconductor-insulator transition in thin films to the appearance of “anomalous” metallic states which evade localization. These problems elude theoretical understanding because they lack small parameters; standard perturbative approaches constitute poor, often uncontrolled approximations. This thesis concerns itself with the development of techniques reaching beyond the perturbative paradigm, focusing especially on duality, the idea that two seemingly different theories are actually one and the same. While a duality is most useful when it relates a strongly interacting theory to a weakly interacting one, even dualities between strongly coupled theories can reveal emergent symmetries and exotic gapped phases that may be obscure in one theory but not its dual. Recently, starting from a relativistic analogue of flux attachment, an entire web of quantum field theory dualities was proposed connecting a wide variety of quantum critical states in two spatial dimensions. This web of dualities has led to a surge of progress on a wide variety of condensed matter problems, several examples of which are presented in this thesis. One of the major challenges that comes with the proposal of new dualities is to “derive” them. In Chapter 2, we construct simple, explicit derivations of many members of the web of dualities in (particle-hole symmetric) models of relativistic current loops. In relativistic theories, flux attachment necessarily involves transmutation of both statistics and spin, an operation which can be made precise in the context of loop models. We further show that while non-relativistic theories are invariant under attachment of even numbers of flux quanta due to the periodicity of statistics, this symmetry is completely lost in relativistic theories due to the presence of spin, clarifying the interpretation of earlier loop models in which this symmetry appeared to be present. Motivated in part by this lack of statistical periodicity in relativistic flux attachment, in Chapter 3 we turn our attention to the metallic, “composite Fermi liquid” states occuring in quantum Hall systems at filling fraction ν = 1/2n. Famously, the state at ν = 1/2 is known to display particle-hole symmetry, which has recently led to the proposal of a manifestly particle-hole symmetric theory of relativistic, or Dirac, composite fermions that features prominently in the web of dualities. Surprisingly, however, an analogous “reflection symmetry” has also been observed in transport experiments about ν = 1/4. To explain this symmetry, we propose a series of relativistic composite fermion theories for the compressible states at ν = 1/2n, in which the reflection symmetry is incorporated as a mean field time-reversal symmetry of the composite fermions. These theories consist of electrically neutral Dirac fermions attached to 2n flux quanta via an emergent Chern-Simons gauge field. While not possessing an explicit particle-hole symmetry, these theories reproduce the known Jain sequence states proximate to ν = 1/2n, and we show that such states can be related by the observed reflection symmetry, at least at mean field level. In Chapter 4, we describe how duality can be used to access exotic gapped phases, in particular non- Abelian quantum Hall states. Using proposed non-Abelian bosonization dualities in two spatial dimensions, which morally relate U(N)k and SU(k)−N Chern-Simons-matter theories, we present pairing scenarios for which non-Abelian quantum Hall states can be obtained starting from theories of Abelian composite particles. The advantage of these dualities is that regions of the phase diagram which may be obscure on one side of the duality can be accessed by condensing local operators on the other side. Starting from parent Abelian states, we use this approach to construct Landau-Ginzburg theories of non-Abelian states through a pairing mechanism. In particular, we obtain the bosonic Read-Rezayi sequence at fillings ν = k/(kM +2) by starting from k layers of bosons at ν = 1/2 with M Abelian fluxes attached and then condensing k-clusters of the dual non-Abelian bosons. We further extend this constructions to obtain generalizations of the Read-Rezayi states with emergent global symmetries. In Chapter 5, we describe a context in which non-perturbative ideas from duality and perturbative results in the language of the renormalization group (RG) can inform one another: the interplay of quenched disorder and strong interaction effects near quantum critical points. In particular, we focus on the problem of quenched disorder at the superfluid-insulator transition of the O(N) model in the large-N limit. While a random mass is strongly relevant at the free fixed point, its effect is screened by the strong interactions of the Wilson-Fisher fixed point in this model, enabling a perturbative RG study of the interplay of disorder and interactions about this fixed point. In contrast to the spiralling flows obtained in earlier double-ε expansions, we show that the theory flows directly to a quantum critical point characterized by finite disorder and interactions, with critical exponents in remarkable agreement with numerical studies of the superfluid-Mott glass transition. With these results in hand, we apply duality to discuss the possible implications of this result for the dual Abelian Higgs and Chern-Simons-Dirac fermion theories when N = 1.
The deconfined quantum critical point of a two-dimensional SU(N)SU(N)SU(N) antiferromagnet is governed by an Abelian Higgs model in d=2+1d=2+1d=2+1 spacetime dimensions featuring NNN complex scalar fields. In this context, we derive for $2\ensuremath{\le}d\ensuremath{\le}4$ an exact formula for the central charge of the U(1)U(1)U(1) current in terms of the gauge coupling at quantum criticality and compare it with the corresponding result obtained using gauge-gravity duality. There is a remarkable similarity precisely for d=2+1d=2+1d=2+1. In this case the amplitude of the current correlation function has the same form as predicted by the gauge-gravity duality. We also compare finite temperature results for the charge susceptibility in the large NNN limit with the result predicted by the gauge-gravity duality. Our results suggest that condensed matter systems at quantum criticality may provide interesting quantitative tests of the gauge-gravity duality even in the absence of supersymmetry.