Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1107.4646 · Scientific Reports

No-go theorem for passive single-rail linear optical quantum computing

Lian-Ao Wu, Philip John Walther, Daniel A. Lidar

Published Mar 6, 2013• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Photonic quantum systems are among the most promising architectures for quantum computers. It is well known that for dual-rail photons effective non-linearities and near-deterministic non-trivial two-qubit gates can be achieved via the measurement process and by introducing ancillary photons. While in principle this opens a legitimate path to scalable linear optical quantum computing, the technical requirements are still very challenging and thus other optical encodings are being actively investigated. One of the alternatives is to use single-rail encoded photons, where entangled states can be deterministically generated. Here we prove that even for such systems universal optical quantum computing using only passive optical elements such as beam splitters and phase shifters is not possible. This no-go theorem proves that photon bunching cannot be passively suppressed even when extra ancilla modes and arbitrary number of photons are used. Our result provides useful guidance for the design of optical quantum computers.

DOI
10.1038/srep01394

Related papers

Adaptive phase measurements in linear optical quantum computation

Timothy C. Ralph, Austin P. Lund, Howard M. Wiseman

Photon counting induces an effective non-linear optical phase shift in certain states derived by linear optics from single photons. Although this non-linearity is non-deterministic, it is sufficient in principle to allow scalable linear optics quantum computation (LOQC). The most obvious way to encode a qubit optically is as a superposition of the vacuum and a single photon in one mode—so-called ‘single-rail’ logic. Until now this approach was thought to be prohibitively expensive (in resources) compared to ‘dual-rail’ logic where a qubit is stored by a photon across two modes. Here we attack this problem with real-time feedback control, which can realize a quantum-limited phase measurement on a single mode, as has been recently demonstrated experimentally. We show that with this added measurement resource, the resource requirements for single-rail LOQC are not substantially different from those of dual-rail LOQC. In particular, with adaptive phase measurements an arbitrary qubit state can be prepared deterministically .

arXiv:quant-ph/0507192•Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Sep 14, 2005•29 citations

Generating entanglement with linear optics

Stasja Stanisic, Noah Linden, Ashley Montanaro +1 more

Entanglement is the basic building block of linear optical quantum computation, and as such understanding how to generate it in detail is of great importance for optical architectures. We prove that Bell states cannot be generated using only three photons in the dual-rail encoding, and give strong numerical evidence for the optimality of the existing four photon schemes. In a setup with a single photon in each input mode, we find a fundamental limit on the possible entanglement between a single mode Alice and arbitrary Bob. We investigate and compare other setups aimed at characterizing entanglement in settings more general than dual-rail encoding. The results draw attention to the trade-off between the entanglement a state has and the probability of postselecting that state, which can give surprising constant bounds on entanglement even with increasing numbers of photons.

arXiv:1702.05209•Physical Review A•Oct 26, 2017•27 citations

Creation of Entangled Photonic States Using Linear Optics

Sara Bartolucci, Patrick M. Birchall, Mercedes Gimeno-Segovia +7 more

Using only linear optical elements, the creation of dual-rail photonic entangled states is inherently probabilistic. Known entanglement generation schemes have low success probabilities, requiring large-scale multiplexing to achieve near-deterministic operation of quantum information processing protocols. In this paper, we introduce multiple techniques and methods to generate photonic entangled states with high probability, which have the potential to reduce the footprint of Linear Optical Quantum Computing (LOQC) architectures drastically. Most notably, we are showing how to improve Bell state preparation from four single photons to up to p=2/3, boost Type-I fusion to 75% with a dual-rail Bell state ancilla and improve Type-II fusion beyond the limits of Bell state discrimination.

arXiv:2106.13825•Jun 25, 2021•81 citations

Deterministic entangling gates with nonlinear quantum photonic interferometers

Francesco Scala, Davide Nigro, Dario Gerace

Abstract The single-photon quantum computing paradigm currently relies on the multi-port interference in linear optical devices, which is intrinsically based on probabilistic measurements outcome, and thus non-deterministic. Devising a fully deterministic, universal, and practically achievable quantum computing platform based on single-photon encoding and integrated photonic circuits is still an open challenge. Here we propose to exploit the interplay of distributed self-Kerr nonlinearity and localized hopping in quantum photonic interferometers to implement deterministic entangling quantum gates with dual rail photonic qubits. It is shown that a universal set of single- and two-qubit gates can be designed by a suitable concatenation of few optical interferometric elements, reaching optimal fidelities arbitrarily close to 100% that are theoretically demonstrated through a bound constrained optimization algorithm. The actual realization would require the concatenation of a few tens of elementary operations, as well as on-chip optical nonlinearities that are compatible with some of the existing quantum photonic platforms, as it is finally discussed.

arXiv:2306.05072•Communications Physics•Apr 5, 2024•14 citations

Intrasystem Entanglement Generator and Unambiguos Bell States Discriminator on Chip

Fabio Antonio Bovino

Bell measurements, jointly projecting two qubits onto the so-called Bell basis, constitute a crucial step in many quantum computation and communication protocols, including dense coding, quantum repeaters, and teleportation-based quantum computation. A problem is the impossibility of deterministic unambiguous Bell measurements using passive linear optics, even when arbitrarily many auxiliary photons, photon-number-resolving detectors, and dynamical (conditionally changing) networks are available. Current proposals for going over the 50% upper bound without using experimentally challenging nonlinearities rely on using entangled photon ancilla states and a sufficiently large interferometer to combine the signal and ancilla modes. We demonstrate that the novel Multiple Rail architecture, based on the propagation of a single photon in a complex multipath optical circuit (or multiwaveguide optical circuit), provides the possibility to perform deterministic Bell measurements so to unambiguously discrimate all four Bell States.

IEEE International Conference on Acoustics Speech and Signal Processing•Apr 17, 2019•2 citations

Beating the One-Half Limit of Ancilla-Free Linear Optics Bell Measurements

Hussain Zaidi, Peter van Loock

We show that optically encoded two-qubit Bell states can be unambiguously discriminated with a success probability of more than 50% in both single-rail and dual-rail encodings by using active linear-optical resources that include Gaussian squeezing operations. These results are in contrast to the well-known upper bound of 50% for unambiguous discrimination of dual-rail Bell states using passive, static linear optics and arbitrarily many vacuum modes. We present experimentally feasible schemes that improve the success probability to 64.3% in dual-rail and to 62.5% in single-rail for a uniform random distribution of Bell states. Conceptually, this demonstrates that neither interactions that induce nonlinear mode transformations (such as Kerr interactions) nor auxiliary entangled photons are required to go beyond the one-half limit. We discuss the optimality of our single-rail scheme and talk about an application of our dual-rail scheme in quantum communication.

arXiv:1301.2749•Physical Review Letters•Jun 24, 2013•65 citations
Photonic quantum systems are among the most promising architectures for quantum computers. It is well known that for dual-rail photons effective non-linearities and near-deterministic non-trivial two-qubit gates can be achieved via the measurement process and by introducing ancillary photons. While in principle this opens a legitimate path to scalable linear optical quantum computing, the technical requirements are still very challenging and thus other optical encodings are being actively investigated. One of the alternatives is to use single-rail encoded photons, where entangled states can be deterministically generated. Here we prove that even for such systems universal optical quantum computing using only passive optical elements such as beam splitters and phase shifters is not possible. This no-go theorem proves that photon bunching cannot be passively suppressed even when extra ancilla modes and arbitrary number of photons are used. Our result provides useful guidance for the design of optical quantum computers.
Photon counting induces an effective non-linear optical phase shift in certain states derived by linear optics from single photons. Although this non-linearity is non-deterministic, it is sufficient in principle to allow scalable linear optics quantum computation (LOQC). The most obvious way to encode a qubit optically is as a superposition of the vacuum and a single photon in one mode—so-called ‘single-rail’ logic. Until now this approach was thought to be prohibitively expensive (in resources) compared to ‘dual-rail’ logic where a qubit is stored by a photon across two modes. Here we attack this problem with real-time feedback control, which can realize a quantum-limited phase measurement on a single mode, as has been recently demonstrated experimentally. We show that with this added measurement resource, the resource requirements for single-rail LOQC are not substantially different from those of dual-rail LOQC. In particular, with adaptive phase measurements an arbitrary qubit state can be prepared deterministically .
Entanglement is the basic building block of linear optical quantum computation, and as such understanding how to generate it in detail is of great importance for optical architectures. We prove that Bell states cannot be generated using only three photons in the dual-rail encoding, and give strong numerical evidence for the optimality of the existing four photon schemes. In a setup with a single photon in each input mode, we find a fundamental limit on the possible entanglement between a single mode Alice and arbitrary Bob. We investigate and compare other setups aimed at characterizing entanglement in settings more general than dual-rail encoding. The results draw attention to the trade-off between the entanglement a state has and the probability of postselecting that state, which can give surprising constant bounds on entanglement even with increasing numbers of photons.
Using only linear optical elements, the creation of dual-rail photonic entangled states is inherently probabilistic. Known entanglement generation schemes have low success probabilities, requiring large-scale multiplexing to achieve near-deterministic operation of quantum information processing protocols. In this paper, we introduce multiple techniques and methods to generate photonic entangled states with high probability, which have the potential to reduce the footprint of Linear Optical Quantum Computing (LOQC) architectures drastically. Most notably, we are showing how to improve Bell state preparation from four single photons to up to p=2/3, boost Type-I fusion to 75% with a dual-rail Bell state ancilla and improve Type-II fusion beyond the limits of Bell state discrimination.
Abstract The single-photon quantum computing paradigm currently relies on the multi-port interference in linear optical devices, which is intrinsically based on probabilistic measurements outcome, and thus non-deterministic. Devising a fully deterministic, universal, and practically achievable quantum computing platform based on single-photon encoding and integrated photonic circuits is still an open challenge. Here we propose to exploit the interplay of distributed self-Kerr nonlinearity and localized hopping in quantum photonic interferometers to implement deterministic entangling quantum gates with dual rail photonic qubits. It is shown that a universal set of single- and two-qubit gates can be designed by a suitable concatenation of few optical interferometric elements, reaching optimal fidelities arbitrarily close to 100% that are theoretically demonstrated through a bound constrained optimization algorithm. The actual realization would require the concatenation of a few tens of elementary operations, as well as on-chip optical nonlinearities that are compatible with some of the existing quantum photonic platforms, as it is finally discussed.
Bell measurements, jointly projecting two qubits onto the so-called Bell basis, constitute a crucial step in many quantum computation and communication protocols, including dense coding, quantum repeaters, and teleportation-based quantum computation. A problem is the impossibility of deterministic unambiguous Bell measurements using passive linear optics, even when arbitrarily many auxiliary photons, photon-number-resolving detectors, and dynamical (conditionally changing) networks are available. Current proposals for going over the 50% upper bound without using experimentally challenging nonlinearities rely on using entangled photon ancilla states and a sufficiently large interferometer to combine the signal and ancilla modes. We demonstrate that the novel Multiple Rail architecture, based on the propagation of a single photon in a complex multipath optical circuit (or multiwaveguide optical circuit), provides the possibility to perform deterministic Bell measurements so to unambiguously discrimate all four Bell States.
We show that optically encoded two-qubit Bell states can be unambiguously discriminated with a success probability of more than 50% in both single-rail and dual-rail encodings by using active linear-optical resources that include Gaussian squeezing operations. These results are in contrast to the well-known upper bound of 50% for unambiguous discrimination of dual-rail Bell states using passive, static linear optics and arbitrarily many vacuum modes. We present experimentally feasible schemes that improve the success probability to 64.3% in dual-rail and to 62.5% in single-rail for a uniform random distribution of Bell states. Conceptually, this demonstrates that neither interactions that induce nonlinear mode transformations (such as Kerr interactions) nor auxiliary entangled photons are required to go beyond the one-half limit. We discuss the optimality of our single-rail scheme and talk about an application of our dual-rail scheme in quantum communication.