Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1107.3736

A Comment on a Recent Derivation of the Born Rule by Zurek

Cecilia Jarlskog

Published Jul 19, 2011• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The derivation of the Born rule by Zurek uses a "splitting procedure" where a physical state is subdivided into a number of states. It is argued that in quantum field theory, which encompasses quantum mechanics, such a procedure would in general modify the physics.
DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1107.3736

Related papers

What Do We Learn by Deriving Born's Rule

James B. Hartle

Derivations of Borns Rule are of interest because they tell us what's connected to what in quantum mechanics if we ever need to change or modify it.

arXiv:2107.02297•Jul 5, 2021•3 citations

The Born Rule is a Feature of Superposition

David Ellerman

The Born Rule plays a critical role in quantum mechanics (QM) since it supplies the link between the mathematical formalism and experimental results in terms of probabilities. The Born Rule does not occur in ordinary probability theory. Where then does it come from? This has been a topic of considerable controversy in the literature. We take the approach of asking what is the simplest extension of ordinary probability theory where the Born rule appears. This is answered by showing that the Born Rule appears by adding the notion of superposition events (in addition to the ordinary discrete events) to finite probability theory. Hence the rule does not need any physics-based derivation. It is simply a feature of the mathematics of superposition when only superposition events are added to ordinary probability theory.

Qeios•Nov 28, 2023•0 citations

The Born Rule—100 Years Ago and Today

Arnold Neumaier

The details of the contents and formulations of the Born rule have changed considerably from its inception by Born in 1926 to the present day. This paper traces the early history of the Born rule 100 years ago, its generalization (essential for today's quantum optics and quantum information theory) to POVMs around 50 years ago, and a modern derivation from an intuitive definition of the notion of a quantum detector. Also discussed is the extent to which the various forms of the Born rule have, like any other statement in physics, a restricted domain of validity, which leads to problems when applied outside this domain.

arXiv:2502.08545•Entropy•Apr 11, 2025•9 citations

Unified Quantum Dynamics: The Emergence of the Born Rule

Weidner, Martin

While the Born rule is traditionally introduced as a separate postulate of quantum mechanics, we show it emerges naturally from a modified Schrödinger equation that includes "small-signal truncation". This parallels the way quantum decoherence gives rise to the branches of the multiverse in the "Many-Worlds Interpretation", eliminating the need for a separate measurement postulate. Our approach thus offers a unified framework in which both the emergence of multiple branches of the multiverse and their statistical properties follow from a single fundamental law of motion. We model "small-signal truncation" in a somewhat stylized manner, but we argue that the precise details of its underlying physical mechanism do not affect the emergence of the Born rule.

arXiv:2504.06495•Apr 8, 2025•1 citation

The Born rule as a statistics of quantum micro-events

Yurii Vladimirovich Brezhnev

We deduce the Born rule from a purely statistical take on quantum theory within minimalistic math-setup. No use is required of quantum postulates. One exploits only rudimentary quantum mathematics—a linear, not Hilbert’, vector space—and empirical notion of the Statistical Length of a state. Its statistical nature comes from the lab micro-events (detector-clicks) being formalized into the C -coefficients of quantum superpositions. We also comment that not only has the use not been made of quantum axioms (scalar-product, operators, interpretations , etc.), but that the involving thereof would be, in a sense, inconsistent when deriving the rule. In point of fact, the quadratic character of the statistical length, and even not (the ‘physics’ of) Born’s formula, represents a first step in constructing the mathematical structure we name the Hilbert space of quantum states.

arXiv:1905.03332•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 1, 2020•4 citations

Quantum probability law from ‘environment-assisted invariance’ in terms of pure-state twin unitaries

Fedor Herbut

Zurek's derivation of the Born rule from envariance (environment-assisted invariance) is retraced in an attempt to present a more detailed derivation, which is extended to encompass the trace-rule form of the quantum probability law in its full generality. The investigation begins by a review presentation of Schmidt decomposition, and a detailed and complete theory of twin unitaries, which are the other face of envariance, and which stand in close connection with twin observables. The trace rule tr( E ρ), with E being an event (projector) and ρ a quantum state (density operator), is derived in five stages. The first three achieve the same as Zurek's derivation of Born's rule, but in a different way, using the full power of twin unitaries. Stage 4 extends the Zurek-like derivation to states (ray projectors) that are not eigenstates of the density operator. Finally, stage 5 utilizes the assumption of continuity of the probability law in the density operators to extend the trace rule to isolated (not correlated) systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611220•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 14, 2007•14 citations
The Born Rule plays a critical role in quantum mechanics (QM) since it supplies the link between the mathematical formalism and experimental results in terms of probabilities. The Born Rule does not occur in ordinary probability theory. Where then does it come from? This has been a topic of considerable controversy in the literature. We take the approach of asking what is the simplest extension of ordinary probability theory where the Born rule appears. This is answered by showing that the Born Rule appears by adding the notion of superposition events (in addition to the ordinary discrete events) to finite probability theory. Hence the rule does not need any physics-based derivation. It is simply a feature of the mathematics of superposition when only superposition events are added to ordinary probability theory.
The details of the contents and formulations of the Born rule have changed considerably from its inception by Born in 1926 to the present day. This paper traces the early history of the Born rule 100 years ago, its generalization (essential for today's quantum optics and quantum information theory) to POVMs around 50 years ago, and a modern derivation from an intuitive definition of the notion of a quantum detector. Also discussed is the extent to which the various forms of the Born rule have, like any other statement in physics, a restricted domain of validity, which leads to problems when applied outside this domain.
While the Born rule is traditionally introduced as a separate postulate of quantum mechanics, we show it emerges naturally from a modified Schrödinger equation that includes "small-signal truncation". This parallels the way quantum decoherence gives rise to the branches of the multiverse in the "Many-Worlds Interpretation", eliminating the need for a separate measurement postulate. Our approach thus offers a unified framework in which both the emergence of multiple branches of the multiverse and their statistical properties follow from a single fundamental law of motion. We model "small-signal truncation" in a somewhat stylized manner, but we argue that the precise details of its underlying physical mechanism do not affect the emergence of the Born rule.
We deduce the Born rule from a purely statistical take on quantum theory within minimalistic math-setup. No use is required of quantum postulates. One exploits only rudimentary quantum mathematics—a linear, not Hilbert’, vector space—and empirical notion of the Statistical Length of a state. Its statistical nature comes from the lab micro-events (detector-clicks) being formalized into the C -coefficients of quantum superpositions. We also comment that not only has the use not been made of quantum axioms (scalar-product, operators, interpretations , etc.), but that the involving thereof would be, in a sense, inconsistent when deriving the rule. In point of fact, the quadratic character of the statistical length, and even not (the ‘physics’ of) Born’s formula, represents a first step in constructing the mathematical structure we name the Hilbert space of quantum states.
Zurek's derivation of the Born rule from envariance (environment-assisted invariance) is retraced in an attempt to present a more detailed derivation, which is extended to encompass the trace-rule form of the quantum probability law in its full generality. The investigation begins by a review presentation of Schmidt decomposition, and a detailed and complete theory of twin unitaries, which are the other face of envariance, and which stand in close connection with twin observables. The trace rule tr( E ρ), with E being an event (projector) and ρ a quantum state (density operator), is derived in five stages. The first three achieve the same as Zurek's derivation of Born's rule, but in a different way, using the full power of twin unitaries. Stage 4 extends the Zurek-like derivation to states (ray projectors) that are not eigenstates of the density operator. Finally, stage 5 utilizes the assumption of continuity of the probability law in the density operators to extend the trace rule to isolated (not correlated) systems.