Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1106.4938 · Physical Review B

Evaluation of high-order terms for the Hubbard model in the strong-coupling limit

Eva Kalinowski, Władysław Gluza

Published Jan 6, 2012• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The ground-state energy of the Hubbard model on a Bethe lattice with infinite connectivity at half filling is calculated for the insulating phase. Using Kohn's transformation to derive an effective Hamiltonian for the strong-coupling limit, the resulting class of diagrams is determined. We develop an algorithm for an algebraic evaluation of the contributions of high-order terms and check it by applying it to the Falicov-Kimball model that is exactly solvable. For the Hubbard model, the ground-state energy is exactly calculated up to order ${t}^{12}/{U}^{11}$. The results of the strong-coupling expansion deviate from numerical calculations as quantum Monte Carlo (or density-matrix renormalization group) by less than $0.13%$ ($0.32%$ respectively) for $U>4.76$.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.85.045105

Related papers

Comparison of computer-algebra strong-coupling perturbation theory and dynamical mean-field theory for the Mott-Hubbard insulator in high dimensions

Martin Paech, W. Apel, Eva Kalinowski +1 more

We present a large-scale combinatorial-diagrammatic computation of high-order contributions to the strong-coupling Kato-Takahashi perturbation series for the Hubbard model in high dimensions. The ground-state energy of the Mott-insulating phase is determined exactly up to the 15th order in $1/U$. The perturbation expansion is extrapolated to infinite order and the critical behavior is determined using the Domb-Sykes method. We compare the perturbative results with two dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) calculations using a quantum Monte Carlo method and a density-matrix renormalization group method as impurity solvers. The comparison demonstrates the excellent agreement and accuracy of both extrapolated strong-coupling perturbation theory and quantum Monte Carlo based DMFT, even close to the critical coupling where the Mott insulator becomes unstable.

arXiv:1410.6630•Physical Review B•Dec 29, 2014•0 citations

Extended Hubbard model at strong coupling

P. G. J. van Dongen

The half-filled extended Hubbard model (containing nearest-neighbor interaction) is considered at strong coupling in fourth-order perturbation theory. The ground-state energies in the spin- and charge-density-wave phases and the resulting phase diagram are calculated in various dimensions: here d=1, d=\ensuremath{\infty}, high dimensions (d\ensuremath{\gg}1), and d=2,3 are discussed separately. In d=1 it is shown that, for U\ensuremath{\gtrsim}6, fourth-order perturbation theory leads to excellent agreement with existing Monte Carlo data. Second-order perturbation theory alone is valid only at unrealistically large values of U and V. In d=\ensuremath{\infty}, one needs fourth-order perturbation theory to obtain any nontrivial contribution to the phase diagram at all. As a consequence the fourth-order corrections to the ground-state energy and to the phase diagram are large also in d=2,3. The formalism used to obtain the perturbative expansion is discussed in an appendix.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Mar 15, 1994•104 citations

Ground-state phase diagram of the one-dimensional extended Hubbard model: A density-matrix renormalization-group approach

G. P. Zhang

We use the density-matrix renormalization group to calculate the phase diagram of the one-dimensional extended Hubbard chain at half filling. We find that for one specific $U,$ the critical value of ${V}_{c}$ for the charge-density-wave versus spin-density-wave phase transition is smaller than that predicted from the Monte Carlo simulation. Our results are consistent with the strong- and weak-coupling limit results, whereas the previous results from the Monte Carlo simulations deviate from the weak-coupling limit result. As $U$ increases, we find that the first-order phase transition develops gradually. The tricritical point is estimated to occur at ${U}_{c}=4--6,$ not ${U}_{c}=3$ as previously predicted from the Monte Carlo simulation. Due to the topological difference, we observe that with the periodic boundary condition, the phase transition is more abrupt for finite chains of length $N=4M$ than for chains of $N=4M+2,$ where $M$ is an integer, for the same $U$ and $V.$ The difference will diminish in the thermodynamic limit.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 15, 1997•46 citations

Strong-coupling expansion for the momentum distribution of the Bose-Hubbard model with benchmarking against exact numerical results

James K. Freericks, H. R. Krishnamurthy, Yasuyuki Kato +2 more

A strong-coupling expansion for the Green's functions, self-energies, and correlation functions of the Bose-Hubbard model is developed. We illustrate the general formalism, which includes all possible (normal-phase) inhomogeneous effects in the formalism, such as disorder or a trap potential, as well as effects of thermal excitations. The expansion is then employed to calculate the momentum distribution of the bosons in the Mott phase for an infinite homogeneous periodic system at zero temperature through third order in the hopping. By using scaling theory for the critical behavior at zero momentum and at the critical value of the hopping for the Mott insulator--to--superfluid transition along with a generalization of the random-phase-approximation-like form for the momentum distribution, we are able to extrapolate the series to infinite order and produce very accurate quantitative results for the momentum distribution in a simple functional form for one, two, and three dimensions. The accuracy is better in higher dimensions and is on the order of a few percent relative error everywhere except close to the critical value of the hopping divided by the on-site repulsion. In addition, we find simple phenomenological expressions for the Mott-phase lobes in two and three dimensions which are much more accurate than the truncated strong-coupling expansions and any other analytic approximation we are aware of. The strong-coupling expansions and scaling-theory results are benchmarked against numerically exact quantum Monte Carlo simulations in two and three dimensions and against density-matrix renormalization-group calculations in one dimension. These analytic expressions will be useful for quick comparison of experimental results to theory and in many cases can bypass the need for expensive numerical simulations.

arXiv:0902.3435•Physical Review A•May 20, 2009•85 citations

High-order strong-coupling expansion for the Bose-Hubbard model

Tao Wang, Xuefeng Zhang, Chunfeng Hou +2 more

Based on the process-chain method, we work out in detail a high-order strong-coupling expansion (HSCE) algorithm for determining the quantum phase boundary between the Mott insulator and the superfluid phase of the Bose-Hubbard model in different dimensions. A comparison with quantum Monte-Carlo results reveals the high efficiency and accuracy of the HSCE. With a symbolized evaluation of the algorithm we obtain an analytic expression for the strong-coupling boundary for different fillings up to eighth order. A subsequent Pad\'e approximation then yields a scaling function, which rescales lobes with different fillings to one lobe. As a further crosscheck, we perform a hopping expansion of the phase boundaries obtained from the effective potential Landau theory (EPLT) and find that the respective expansion coefficients coincide with those of HSCE.

•Jan 5, 2018•2 citations

Strong-coupling approach to the Mott-Hubbard insulator on a Bethe lattice in dynamical mean-field theory

Daniel Ruhl, Florian Gebhard

We calculate the Hubbard bands for the half-filled Hubbard model on a Bethe lattice with an infinite coordination number up to and including third order in the inverse Hubbard interaction. We employ the Kato-Takahashi perturbation theory to solve the self-consistency equation of the dynamical mean-field theory analytically for the single-impurity Anderson model in multichain geometry. The weight of the secondary Hubbard sub-bands is of fourth order so that the two-chain geometry is sufficient for our study. Our results for the Mott-Hubbard gap and the density of states of the lower Hubbard band agree very well with those from numerical dynamical density-matrix renormalization group calculations, apart from a resonance contribution at the upper band edge, which cannot be reproduced in low-order perturbation theory.

arXiv:1009.4100•Physical Review B•Jan 19, 2011•3 citations
The ground-state energy of the Hubbard model on a Bethe lattice with infinite connectivity at half filling is calculated for the insulating phase. Using Kohn's transformation to derive an effective Hamiltonian for the strong-coupling limit, the resulting class of diagrams is determined. We develop an algorithm for an algebraic evaluation of the contributions of high-order terms and check it by applying it to the Falicov-Kimball model that is exactly solvable. For the Hubbard model, the ground-state energy is exactly calculated up to order t12/U11{t}^{12}/{U}^{11}t12/U11. The results of the strong-coupling expansion deviate from numerical calculations as quantum Monte Carlo (or density-matrix renormalization group) by less than 0.130.13%0.13 (0.320.32%0.32 respectively) for U>4.76U>4.76U>4.76.
We present a large-scale combinatorial-diagrammatic computation of high-order contributions to the strong-coupling Kato-Takahashi perturbation series for the Hubbard model in high dimensions. The ground-state energy of the Mott-insulating phase is determined exactly up to the 15th order in 1/U1/U1/U. The perturbation expansion is extrapolated to infinite order and the critical behavior is determined using the Domb-Sykes method. We compare the perturbative results with two dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) calculations using a quantum Monte Carlo method and a density-matrix renormalization group method as impurity solvers. The comparison demonstrates the excellent agreement and accuracy of both extrapolated strong-coupling perturbation theory and quantum Monte Carlo based DMFT, even close to the critical coupling where the Mott insulator becomes unstable.
The half-filled extended Hubbard model (containing nearest-neighbor interaction) is considered at strong coupling in fourth-order perturbation theory. The ground-state energies in the spin- and charge-density-wave phases and the resulting phase diagram are calculated in various dimensions: here d=1, d=\ensuremath{\infty}, high dimensions (d\ensuremath{\gg}1), and d=2,3 are discussed separately. In d=1 it is shown that, for U\ensuremath{\gtrsim}6, fourth-order perturbation theory leads to excellent agreement with existing Monte Carlo data. Second-order perturbation theory alone is valid only at unrealistically large values of U and V. In d=\ensuremath{\infty}, one needs fourth-order perturbation theory to obtain any nontrivial contribution to the phase diagram at all. As a consequence the fourth-order corrections to the ground-state energy and to the phase diagram are large also in d=2,3. The formalism used to obtain the perturbative expansion is discussed in an appendix.
We use the density-matrix renormalization group to calculate the phase diagram of the one-dimensional extended Hubbard chain at half filling. We find that for one specific U,U,U, the critical value of Vc{V}_{c}Vc​ for the charge-density-wave versus spin-density-wave phase transition is smaller than that predicted from the Monte Carlo simulation. Our results are consistent with the strong- and weak-coupling limit results, whereas the previous results from the Monte Carlo simulations deviate from the weak-coupling limit result. As UUU increases, we find that the first-order phase transition develops gradually. The tricritical point is estimated to occur at Uc=4−−6,{U}_{c}=4--6,Uc​=4−−6, not Uc=3{U}_{c}=3Uc​=3 as previously predicted from the Monte Carlo simulation. Due to the topological difference, we observe that with the periodic boundary condition, the phase transition is more abrupt for finite chains of length N=4MN=4MN=4M than for chains of N=4M+2,N=4M+2,N=4M+2, where MMM is an integer, for the same UUU and V.V.V. The difference will diminish in the thermodynamic limit.
A strong-coupling expansion for the Green's functions, self-energies, and correlation functions of the Bose-Hubbard model is developed. We illustrate the general formalism, which includes all possible (normal-phase) inhomogeneous effects in the formalism, such as disorder or a trap potential, as well as effects of thermal excitations. The expansion is then employed to calculate the momentum distribution of the bosons in the Mott phase for an infinite homogeneous periodic system at zero temperature through third order in the hopping. By using scaling theory for the critical behavior at zero momentum and at the critical value of the hopping for the Mott insulator--to--superfluid transition along with a generalization of the random-phase-approximation-like form for the momentum distribution, we are able to extrapolate the series to infinite order and produce very accurate quantitative results for the momentum distribution in a simple functional form for one, two, and three dimensions. The accuracy is better in higher dimensions and is on the order of a few percent relative error everywhere except close to the critical value of the hopping divided by the on-site repulsion. In addition, we find simple phenomenological expressions for the Mott-phase lobes in two and three dimensions which are much more accurate than the truncated strong-coupling expansions and any other analytic approximation we are aware of. The strong-coupling expansions and scaling-theory results are benchmarked against numerically exact quantum Monte Carlo simulations in two and three dimensions and against density-matrix renormalization-group calculations in one dimension. These analytic expressions will be useful for quick comparison of experimental results to theory and in many cases can bypass the need for expensive numerical simulations.
Based on the process-chain method, we work out in detail a high-order strong-coupling expansion (HSCE) algorithm for determining the quantum phase boundary between the Mott insulator and the superfluid phase of the Bose-Hubbard model in different dimensions. A comparison with quantum Monte-Carlo results reveals the high efficiency and accuracy of the HSCE. With a symbolized evaluation of the algorithm we obtain an analytic expression for the strong-coupling boundary for different fillings up to eighth order. A subsequent Pad\'e approximation then yields a scaling function, which rescales lobes with different fillings to one lobe. As a further crosscheck, we perform a hopping expansion of the phase boundaries obtained from the effective potential Landau theory (EPLT) and find that the respective expansion coefficients coincide with those of HSCE.
We calculate the Hubbard bands for the half-filled Hubbard model on a Bethe lattice with an infinite coordination number up to and including third order in the inverse Hubbard interaction. We employ the Kato-Takahashi perturbation theory to solve the self-consistency equation of the dynamical mean-field theory analytically for the single-impurity Anderson model in multichain geometry. The weight of the secondary Hubbard sub-bands is of fourth order so that the two-chain geometry is sufficient for our study. Our results for the Mott-Hubbard gap and the density of states of the lower Hubbard band agree very well with those from numerical dynamical density-matrix renormalization group calculations, apart from a resonance contribution at the upper band edge, which cannot be reproduced in low-order perturbation theory.