Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1105.4561 · Physical Review A

Quantum state tomography with fully symmetric measurements and product measurements

Huangjun Zhu, Berthold‐Georg Englert

Published Aug 22, 2011• 78 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce random-matrix theory to study the tomographic efficiency of a wide class of measurements constructed out of weighted 2-designs, including symmetric informationally complete (SIC) probability operator measurements (POMs). In particular, we derive analytic formulas for the mean Hilbert-Schmidt distance and the mean trace distance between the estimator and the true state, which clearly show the difference between the scaling behaviors of the two error measures with the dimension of the Hilbert space. We then prove that the product SIC POMs, the multipartite analog of the SIC POMs, are optimal among all product measurements in the same sense as the SIC POMs are optimal among all joint measurements. We further show that, for bipartite systems, there is only a marginal efficiency advantage of the joint SIC POMs over the product SIC POMs. In marked contrast, for multipartite systems, the efficiency advantage of the joint SIC POMs increases exponentially with the number of parties.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.84.022327

Related papers

Experimental proposal for symmetric minimal two-qubit state tomography

Amir Kalev, Jiangwei Shang, Berthold‐Georg Englert

We propose an experiment that realizes a symmetric informationally complete (SIC) probability-operator measurement (POM) in the four-dimensional Hilbert space of a qubit pair. The qubit pair is carried by a single photon as a polarization qubit and a path qubit. The implementation of the SIC POM is accomplished with the means of linear optics. The experimental scheme exploits an approach to SIC POMs that uses a two-step process: a measurement with full-rank outcomes, followed by a projective measurement on a basis that is chosen in accordance with the result of the first measurement. The basis of the first measurement and the four bases of the second measurements are pairwise unbiased---a hint at a possibly profound link between SIC POMs and mutually unbiased bases.

arXiv:1203.1675•Physical Review A•May 17, 2012•12 citations

Symmetric minimal quantum tomography by successive measurements

Amir Kalev, Jiangwei Shang, Berthold‐Georg Englert

We consider the implementation of a symmetric informationally complete probability-operator measurement (SIC POM) in the Hilbert space of a $d$-level system by a two-step measurement process: a diagonal-operator measurement with high-rank outcomes, followed by a rank-1 measurement in a basis chosen in accordance with the result of the first measurement. We find that any Heisenberg-Weyl group-covariant SIC POM can be realized by such a sequence where the second measurement is simply a measurement in the Fourier basis, independent of the result of the first measurement. Furthermore, at least for the particular cases studied, of dimensions 2, 3, 4, and 8, this scheme reveals an unexpected operational relation between mutually unbiased bases and SIC POMs; the former are used to construct the latter. As a laboratory application of the two-step measurement process, we propose feasible optical experiments that would realize SIC POMs in various dimensions.

arXiv:1203.1677•Physical Review A•May 17, 2012•14 citations

Bipartite quantum measurements with optimal single-sided distinguishability

Jakub Czartowski, Karol Życzkowski

We analyse orthogonal bases in a composite N×N Hilbert space describing a bipartite quantum system and look for a basis with optimal single-sided mutual state distinguishability. This condition implies that in each subsystem the N2 reduced states form a regular simplex of a maximal edge length, defined with respect to the trace distance. In the case N=2 of a two-qubit system our solution coincides with the elegant joint measurement introduced by Gisin. We derive explicit expressions of an analogous constellation for N=3 and provide a general construction of N2 states forming such an optimal basis in HN⊗HN . Our construction is valid for all dimensions for which a symmetric informationally complete (SIC) generalized measurement is known. Furthermore, we show that the one-party measurement that distinguishes the states of an optimal basis of the composite system leads to a local quantum state tomography with a linear reconstruction formula. Finally, we test the introduced tomographical scheme on a complete set of three mutually unbiased bases for a single qubit using two different IBM machines.

arXiv:2010.14868•Quantum•Apr 26, 2021•13 citations

The varieties of minimal tomographically complete measurements

John B. DeBrota, Christopher A. Fuchs, Blake C. Stacey

Minimal Informationally Complete quantum measurements, or MICs, illuminate the structure of quantum theory and how it departs from the classical. Central to this capacity is their role as tomographically complete measurements with the fewest possible number of outcomes for a given finite dimension. Despite their advantages, little is known about them. We establish general properties of MICs, explore constructions of several classes of them, and make some developments to the theory of MIC Gram matrices. These Gram matrices turn out to be a rich subject of inquiry, relating linear algebra, number theory and probability. Among our results are some equivalent conditions for unbiased MICs, a characterization of rank-1 MICs through the Hadamard product, several ways in which immediate properties of MICs capture the abandonment of classical phase space intuitions, and a numerical study of MIC Gram matrix spectra. We also present, to our knowledge, the first example of an unbiased rank-1 MIC which is not group covariant. This work provides further context to the discovery that the symmetric informationally complete quantum measurements (SICs) are in many ways optimal among MICs. In a deep sense, the ideal measurements of quantum physics are not orthogonal bases.

arXiv:1812.08762•International Journal of Quantum Information•Oct 27, 2020•34 citations

Tomographic and Lie algebraic significance of generalized symmetric informationally complete measurements

Huangjun Zhu

Generalized symmetric informationally complete (SIC) measurements are SIC measurements that are not necessarily rank 1. They are interesting originally because of their connection with rank-1 SICs. Here we reveal several merits of generalized SICs in connection with quantum state tomography and Lie algebra that are interesting in their own right. These properties uniquely characterize generalized SICs among minimal informationally complete (IC) measurements although, on the face of it, they bear little resemblance to the original definition. In particular, we show that in quantum state tomography generalized SICs are optimal among minimal IC measurements with given average purity of measurement outcomes. Besides its significance to the current study, this result may help us to understand tomographic efficiencies of minimal IC measurements under the influence of noise. When minimal IC measurements are taken as bases for the Lie algebra of the unitary group, generalized SICs are uniquely characterized by the antisymmetry of the associated structure constants.

arXiv:1408.0560•Physical Review A•Sep 8, 2014•14 citations

Optimal quantum state tomography with local informationally complete measurements

Casey Jameson, Zhen Qin, Alireza Goldar +3 more

Quantum state tomography (QST) remains the gold standard for benchmarking and verification of near-term quantum devices. While QST for a generic quantum many-body state requires an exponentially large amount of resources, most physical quantum states are structured and can often be represented by a much smaller number of parameters, making efficient QST potentially possible. A prominent example is a matrix product state (MPS) or a matrix product density operator (MPDO), which is believed to represent most physical states generated by one-dimensional (1D) quantum devices. We study whether a general MPS/MPDO state can be recovered with bounded errors using only a number of state copies polynomial in the number of qubits, which is necessary for efficient QST. To make this question practically interesting, we assume only local measurements of qubits directly on the target state. By using a local symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measurement (SIC-POVM), we provide a positive answer to the above question for a variety of common many-body quantum states, including typical short-range entangled states, random MPS/MPDO states, and thermal states of one-dimensional Hamiltonians. In addition, we also provide an affirmative no answer for certain long-range entangled states such as a family of generalized GHZ states, but with the exception of target states that are known to have real-valued wavefunctions. Our answers are supported by a near-perfect agreement between an efficient calculation of the Cramer-Rao bound that rigorously bounds the sample complexity and numerical optimization results using a machine learning assisted maximal likelihood estimation (MLE) algorithm. This agreement also leads to an optimal QST protocol using local SIC-POVM that can be practically implemented on current quantum hardware and is highly efficient for most 1D physical states.

arXiv:2408.07115•Aug 13, 2024•14 citations
We introduce random-matrix theory to study the tomographic efficiency of a wide class of measurements constructed out of weighted 2-designs, including symmetric informationally complete (SIC) probability operator measurements (POMs). In particular, we derive analytic formulas for the mean Hilbert-Schmidt distance and the mean trace distance between the estimator and the true state, which clearly show the difference between the scaling behaviors of the two error measures with the dimension of the Hilbert space. We then prove that the product SIC POMs, the multipartite analog of the SIC POMs, are optimal among all product measurements in the same sense as the SIC POMs are optimal among all joint measurements. We further show that, for bipartite systems, there is only a marginal efficiency advantage of the joint SIC POMs over the product SIC POMs. In marked contrast, for multipartite systems, the efficiency advantage of the joint SIC POMs increases exponentially with the number of parties.
We propose an experiment that realizes a symmetric informationally complete (SIC) probability-operator measurement (POM) in the four-dimensional Hilbert space of a qubit pair. The qubit pair is carried by a single photon as a polarization qubit and a path qubit. The implementation of the SIC POM is accomplished with the means of linear optics. The experimental scheme exploits an approach to SIC POMs that uses a two-step process: a measurement with full-rank outcomes, followed by a projective measurement on a basis that is chosen in accordance with the result of the first measurement. The basis of the first measurement and the four bases of the second measurements are pairwise unbiased---a hint at a possibly profound link between SIC POMs and mutually unbiased bases.
We consider the implementation of a symmetric informationally complete probability-operator measurement (SIC POM) in the Hilbert space of a ddd-level system by a two-step measurement process: a diagonal-operator measurement with high-rank outcomes, followed by a rank-1 measurement in a basis chosen in accordance with the result of the first measurement. We find that any Heisenberg-Weyl group-covariant SIC POM can be realized by such a sequence where the second measurement is simply a measurement in the Fourier basis, independent of the result of the first measurement. Furthermore, at least for the particular cases studied, of dimensions 2, 3, 4, and 8, this scheme reveals an unexpected operational relation between mutually unbiased bases and SIC POMs; the former are used to construct the latter. As a laboratory application of the two-step measurement process, we propose feasible optical experiments that would realize SIC POMs in various dimensions.
We analyse orthogonal bases in a composite N×N Hilbert space describing a bipartite quantum system and look for a basis with optimal single-sided mutual state distinguishability. This condition implies that in each subsystem the N2 reduced states form a regular simplex of a maximal edge length, defined with respect to the trace distance. In the case N=2 of a two-qubit system our solution coincides with the elegant joint measurement introduced by Gisin. We derive explicit expressions of an analogous constellation for N=3 and provide a general construction of N2 states forming such an optimal basis in HN⊗HN . Our construction is valid for all dimensions for which a symmetric informationally complete (SIC) generalized measurement is known. Furthermore, we show that the one-party measurement that distinguishes the states of an optimal basis of the composite system leads to a local quantum state tomography with a linear reconstruction formula. Finally, we test the introduced tomographical scheme on a complete set of three mutually unbiased bases for a single qubit using two different IBM machines.
Minimal Informationally Complete quantum measurements, or MICs, illuminate the structure of quantum theory and how it departs from the classical. Central to this capacity is their role as tomographically complete measurements with the fewest possible number of outcomes for a given finite dimension. Despite their advantages, little is known about them. We establish general properties of MICs, explore constructions of several classes of them, and make some developments to the theory of MIC Gram matrices. These Gram matrices turn out to be a rich subject of inquiry, relating linear algebra, number theory and probability. Among our results are some equivalent conditions for unbiased MICs, a characterization of rank-1 MICs through the Hadamard product, several ways in which immediate properties of MICs capture the abandonment of classical phase space intuitions, and a numerical study of MIC Gram matrix spectra. We also present, to our knowledge, the first example of an unbiased rank-1 MIC which is not group covariant. This work provides further context to the discovery that the symmetric informationally complete quantum measurements (SICs) are in many ways optimal among MICs. In a deep sense, the ideal measurements of quantum physics are not orthogonal bases.
Generalized symmetric informationally complete (SIC) measurements are SIC measurements that are not necessarily rank 1. They are interesting originally because of their connection with rank-1 SICs. Here we reveal several merits of generalized SICs in connection with quantum state tomography and Lie algebra that are interesting in their own right. These properties uniquely characterize generalized SICs among minimal informationally complete (IC) measurements although, on the face of it, they bear little resemblance to the original definition. In particular, we show that in quantum state tomography generalized SICs are optimal among minimal IC measurements with given average purity of measurement outcomes. Besides its significance to the current study, this result may help us to understand tomographic efficiencies of minimal IC measurements under the influence of noise. When minimal IC measurements are taken as bases for the Lie algebra of the unitary group, generalized SICs are uniquely characterized by the antisymmetry of the associated structure constants.
Quantum state tomography (QST) remains the gold standard for benchmarking and verification of near-term quantum devices. While QST for a generic quantum many-body state requires an exponentially large amount of resources, most physical quantum states are structured and can often be represented by a much smaller number of parameters, making efficient QST potentially possible. A prominent example is a matrix product state (MPS) or a matrix product density operator (MPDO), which is believed to represent most physical states generated by one-dimensional (1D) quantum devices. We study whether a general MPS/MPDO state can be recovered with bounded errors using only a number of state copies polynomial in the number of qubits, which is necessary for efficient QST. To make this question practically interesting, we assume only local measurements of qubits directly on the target state. By using a local symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measurement (SIC-POVM), we provide a positive answer to the above question for a variety of common many-body quantum states, including typical short-range entangled states, random MPS/MPDO states, and thermal states of one-dimensional Hamiltonians. In addition, we also provide an affirmative no answer for certain long-range entangled states such as a family of generalized GHZ states, but with the exception of target states that are known to have real-valued wavefunctions. Our answers are supported by a near-perfect agreement between an efficient calculation of the Cramer-Rao bound that rigorously bounds the sample complexity and numerical optimization results using a machine learning assisted maximal likelihood estimation (MLE) algorithm. This agreement also leads to an optimal QST protocol using local SIC-POVM that can be practically implemented on current quantum hardware and is highly efficient for most 1D physical states.