Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1104.3381 · Progress of Theoretical Physics

Formulation of Complex Action Theory

K. Nagao, H. B. Nielsen

Published Dec 1, 2011• 24 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We formulate a complex action theory which includes operators of coordinate and momentum $\hat{q}$ and $\hat{p}$ being replaced with non-hermitian operators $\hat{q}_{new}$ and $\hat{p}_{new}$, and their eigenstates ${}_m

DOI
10.1143/ptp.126.1021

Related papers

Theory including future not excluded: Formulation of complex action theory II

Keiichi Nagao, HOLGER BECH NIELSEN

In Ref. [1] we have found errata. They are composed of two parts: one part is for the body, which is also explained in our recently published book [2], while the other part is for the appendix, which is mainly a result of the corrections to Ref. [3]. They do not influence the result of the manuscript. Rather, the latter part provides us a new additional result: the Schrödinger equation described with the Hamiltonian |$\hat{H}_B$| has been derived for the future state |$| B(t) \rangle$| via the Feynman path integral in the complex action theory. In the fifth line below Eq. (5.8), where |$f(D D^\dagger)^{-1}$| should have been replaced with |$( f(D) f(D)^\dagger )^{-1}$|⁠, we have chosen |$f(D)$| such that |$(P^\dagger)^{-1} ( f(D) f(D)^\dagger )^{-1} P^\dagger = F(\hat{H}^\dagger)$|⁠, which is rewritten as |$( f(D) f(D)^\dagger )^{-1} = F(D^\dagger)$|⁠. However, this relation does not stand, because the left-hand side is Hermitian, while the right-hand side is not Hermitian. Accordingly, the expression |$Q'=F(\hat{H}^\dagger) Q$| below Eq. (5.8), which was introduced based on the above relation, has to be corrected. In addition, the next statement, “|$F(\hat{H}^\dagger) Q \simeq F(\hat{H}_\text{eff}^\dagger) Q$| for the restricted subspace,” is not right. This is because, for any reasonable function |$h$| and any state |$|A(t) \rangle = \sum_i a_i(t) | \lambda_i \rangle$| that obeys the Schrödinger equation |$i\hbar \frac{d}{dt} | A (t) \rangle = \hat{H} | A (t) \rangle$|⁠, the following relation holds for large |$t-T_A$|⁠: |$h(\hat{H}) | A (t) \rangle\simeq h(\hat{H}_\text{eff} + i B \Lambda_A ) | \tilde{A} (t) \rangle\equiv \tilde{h}(\hat{H}_\text{eff} ) | \tilde{A} (t) \rangle$|⁠, where we have used the automatic Hermiticity mechanism and introduced |$| \tilde A(t) \rangle \equiv \sum_{i \in A} a_i(t) | \lambda_i \rangle$|⁠, |$\Lambda_A\equiv\sum_{i \in A} | \lambda_i \rangle \langle \lambda_i |_Q$|⁠, and another function |$\tilde{h}$| such that |$\tilde{h}(\text{Re}\,\lambda_i ) = h(\text{Re}\,\lambda_i + iB )$|⁠. Similarly, the statement “|$Q_2 = F(\hat{H}_{\text{eff}}^\dagger) Q$| for the restricted subspace” given in Eq. (5.6) has to be corrected. A |$dt$|-dependent normalization factor, say |$\frac{1}{\alpha(dt)}$|⁠, should be inserted on the right-hand sides of Eq. (A.2) and of the first line of Eq. (A.4). The following sentence should be inserted after the sentence “|$C$| is an arbitrary |$\ldots$| complex plane” below Eq. (A.2): “In addition, |$\alpha(dt)$| is a |$dt$|-dependent normalization factor, which is properly fixed later.” The factor |$\sqrt{\frac{2\pi i \hbar dt}{m}}$| in the second line of Eq. (A.4) should be deleted. The following sentences should be inserted after the phrase “where |$\ldots$| Eq. (3.7)” below Eq. (A.4): “Here we have taken |$\alpha(dt)= \sqrt{\frac{2\pi i \hbar dt}{m}}$| so that both sides of Eq. (A.4) correspond to each other in the vanishing limit of |$dt$|⁠. Then Eq. (A.4) is reduced to |$|\psi(t+dt) \rangle = e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar} \hat{H} dt}|\psi(t) \rangle$|⁠.” The next sentence, “Thus we have found that |$\ldots$| Eq. (A.2),” below Eq. (A.4) should be replaced with “Thus we have derived the Schrödinger equation and found that |$\ldots$| Eq.(A.2).” The following sentence should be added after the above replaced sentence: “Such a derivation of the Schrödinger equation is well known in the real action theory [4].” Factors |$\frac{1}{\alpha(dt)^*}$|⁠, |$\frac{1}{\alpha(-dt')^*}$|⁠, and |$\frac{1}{\alpha(-dt)}$| should be inserted on the right-hand side of the equation in the second sentence of the last paragraph of the appendix, on the right-hand sides of Eqs (A.5) and (A.6), respectively. The second sentence below Eq. (A.6), “Indeed, |$\hat{H}_B$| is given |$\ldots$||$\hat{H}^\dagger$|⁠,” should be replaced with “Indeed, we obtain the Schrödinger equation |$|B (t-dt) \rangle = e^{\frac{i}{\hbar} \hat{H}_B dt}|B (t) \rangle$|⁠, where |$\hat{H}_B$| is given |$\ldots$||$\hat{H}^\dagger$|⁠.”

Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Feb 9, 2018•1 citation

Formulation of Complex Action Theory

Keiichi Nagao, Holger Bech Nielsen

We formulate a complex action theory which includes operators of coordinate and momentum q and p being replaced with non-hermitian operators qnew and pnew, and their eigenstates m new q| and m new p| with complex eigenvalues q and p. Introducing a philosophy of keeping the analyticity in path integration variables, we define a modified set of complex conjugate, real and imaginary parts, hermitian conjugates and bras, and explicitly construct qnew, pnew, m new q| and m new p| by formally squeezing coherent states.We also pose a theorem on the relation between functions on the phase space and the corresponding operators.Only in our formalism can we describe a complex action theory or a real action theory with complex saddle points in the tunneling effect etc. in terms of bras and kets in the functional integral.Furthermore, in a system with a non-hermitian diagonalizable bounded Hamiltonian, we show that the mechanism to obtain a hermitian Hamiltonian after a long time development proposed in our letter 11) works also in the complex coordinate formalism.If the hermitian Hamiltonian is given in a local form, a conserved probability current density can be constructed with two kinds of wave functions.

•Dec 1, 2011•15 citations

A new Quantum Mechanics on phase space

Antonio Cassa

A complex function is associated to each bounded linear operator

arXiv:2105.03327•May 7, 2021•0 citations

Chapter 4. Complex Numbers, Wave Equations, and the Momentum Operator

Dennis Morris

De Gruyter eBooks•May 27, 2016•0 citations

Reality and hermiticity from maximizing overlap in the future-included complex action theory

K. Nagao, H. Bech Nielsen

In the complex action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future, we study a normalized matrix element of an operator |$\hat {\mathcal O}$| defined in terms of the future state at the latest time |$T_B$| and the past state at the earliest time |$T_A$| with a proper inner product that makes normal a given Hamiltonian that is non-normal at first. We present a theorem that states that, provided that the operator |$\hat {\mathcal O}$| is |$Q$|-Hermitian, i.e., Hermitian with regard to the proper inner product, the normalized matrix element becomes real and time-develops under a |$Q$|-Hermitian Hamiltonian for the past and future states selected such that the absolute value of the transition amplitude from the past state to the future state is maximized. Furthermore, we give a possible procedure to formulate the |$Q$|-Hermitian Hamiltonian in terms of |$Q$|-Hermitian coordinate and momentum operators, and construct a conserved probability current density.

arXiv:1502.00385•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•May 11, 2015•6 citations

MOMENTUM OPERATORS IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

A. M. Arthurs

Representation for real functions of quantum mechanical momentum operator obtained by functional integration in phase space

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Aug 1, 1968•9 citations
We formulate a complex action theory which includes operators of coordinate and momentum q^\hat{q}q^​ and p^\hat{p}p^​ being replaced with non-hermitian operators q^new\hat{q}_{new}q^​new​ and p^new\hat{p}_{new}p^​new​, and their eigenstates ${}_m
In Ref. [1] we have found errata. They are composed of two parts: one part is for the body, which is also explained in our recently published book [2], while the other part is for the appendix, which is mainly a result of the corrections to Ref. [3]. They do not influence the result of the manuscript. Rather, the latter part provides us a new additional result: the Schrödinger equation described with the Hamiltonian |H^B\hat{H}_BH^B​| has been derived for the future state |∣B(t)⟩| B(t) \rangle∣B(t)⟩| via the Feynman path integral in the complex action theory. In the fifth line below Eq. (5.8), where |f(DD†)−1f(D D^\dagger)^{-1}f(DD†)−1| should have been replaced with |(f(D)f(D)†)−1( f(D) f(D)^\dagger )^{-1}(f(D)f(D)†)−1|⁠, we have chosen |f(D)f(D)f(D)| such that |(P†)−1(f(D)f(D)†)−1P†=F(H^†)(P^\dagger)^{-1} ( f(D) f(D)^\dagger )^{-1} P^\dagger = F(\hat{H}^\dagger)(P†)−1(f(D)f(D)†)−1P†=F(H^†)|⁠, which is rewritten as |(f(D)f(D)†)−1=F(D†)( f(D) f(D)^\dagger )^{-1} = F(D^\dagger)(f(D)f(D)†)−1=F(D†)|⁠. However, this relation does not stand, because the left-hand side is Hermitian, while the right-hand side is not Hermitian. Accordingly, the expression |Q′=F(H^†)QQ'=F(\hat{H}^\dagger) QQ′=F(H^†)Q| below Eq. (5.8), which was introduced based on the above relation, has to be corrected. In addition, the next statement, “|F(H^†)Q≃F(H^eff†)QF(\hat{H}^\dagger) Q \simeq F(\hat{H}_\text{eff}^\dagger) QF(H^†)Q≃F(H^eff†​)Q| for the restricted subspace,” is not right. This is because, for any reasonable function |hhh| and any state |∣A(t)⟩=∑iai(t)∣λi⟩|A(t) \rangle = \sum_i a_i(t) | \lambda_i \rangle∣A(t)⟩=∑i​ai​(t)∣λi​⟩| that obeys the Schrödinger equation |iℏddt∣A(t)⟩=H^∣A(t)⟩i\hbar \frac{d}{dt} | A (t) \rangle = \hat{H} | A (t) \rangleiℏdtd​∣A(t)⟩=H^∣A(t)⟩|⁠, the following relation holds for large |t−TAt-T_At−TA​|⁠: |h(H^)∣A(t)⟩≃h(H^eff+iBΛA)∣A~(t)⟩≡h~(H^eff)∣A~(t)⟩h(\hat{H}) | A (t) \rangle\simeq h(\hat{H}_\text{eff} + i B \Lambda_A ) | \tilde{A} (t) \rangle\equiv \tilde{h}(\hat{H}_\text{eff} ) | \tilde{A} (t) \rangleh(H^)∣A(t)⟩≃h(H^eff​+iBΛA​)∣A~(t)⟩≡h~(H^eff​)∣A~(t)⟩|⁠, where we have used the automatic Hermiticity mechanism and introduced |∣A~(t)⟩≡∑i∈Aai(t)∣λi⟩| \tilde A(t) \rangle \equiv \sum_{i \in A} a_i(t) | \lambda_i \rangle∣A~(t)⟩≡∑i∈A​ai​(t)∣λi​⟩|⁠, |ΛA≡∑i∈A∣λi⟩⟨λi∣Q\Lambda_A\equiv\sum_{i \in A} | \lambda_i \rangle \langle \lambda_i |_QΛA​≡∑i∈A​∣λi​⟩⟨λi​∣Q​|⁠, and another function |h~\tilde{h}h~| such that |h~(Re λi)=h(Re λi+iB)\tilde{h}(\text{Re}\,\lambda_i ) = h(\text{Re}\,\lambda_i + iB )h~(Reλi​)=h(Reλi​+iB)|⁠. Similarly, the statement “|Q2=F(H^eff†)QQ_2 = F(\hat{H}_{\text{eff}}^\dagger) QQ2​=F(H^eff†​)Q| for the restricted subspace” given in Eq. (5.6) has to be corrected. A |dtdtdt|-dependent normalization factor, say |1α(dt)\frac{1}{\alpha(dt)}α(dt)1​|⁠, should be inserted on the right-hand sides of Eq. (A.2) and of the first line of Eq. (A.4). The following sentence should be inserted after the sentence “|CCC| is an arbitrary |…\ldots…| complex plane” below Eq. (A.2): “In addition, |α(dt)\alpha(dt)α(dt)| is a |dtdtdt|-dependent normalization factor, which is properly fixed later.” The factor |2πiℏdtm\sqrt{\frac{2\pi i \hbar dt}{m}}m2πiℏdt​​| in the second line of Eq. (A.4) should be deleted. The following sentences should be inserted after the phrase “where |…\ldots…| Eq. (3.7)” below Eq. (A.4): “Here we have taken |α(dt)=2πiℏdtm\alpha(dt)= \sqrt{\frac{2\pi i \hbar dt}{m}}α(dt)=m2πiℏdt​​| so that both sides of Eq. (A.4) correspond to each other in the vanishing limit of |dtdtdt|⁠. Then Eq. (A.4) is reduced to |∣ψ(t+dt)⟩=e−iℏH^dt∣ψ(t)⟩|\psi(t+dt) \rangle = e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar} \hat{H} dt}|\psi(t) \rangle∣ψ(t+dt)⟩=e−ℏi​H^dt∣ψ(t)⟩|⁠.” The next sentence, “Thus we have found that |…\ldots…| Eq. (A.2),” below Eq. (A.4) should be replaced with “Thus we have derived the Schrödinger equation and found that |…\ldots…| Eq.(A.2).” The following sentence should be added after the above replaced sentence: “Such a derivation of the Schrödinger equation is well known in the real action theory [4].” Factors |1α(dt)∗\frac{1}{\alpha(dt)^*}α(dt)∗1​|⁠, |1α(−dt′)∗\frac{1}{\alpha(-dt')^*}α(−dt′)∗1​|⁠, and |1α(−dt)\frac{1}{\alpha(-dt)}α(−dt)1​| should be inserted on the right-hand side of the equation in the second sentence of the last paragraph of the appendix, on the right-hand sides of Eqs (A.5) and (A.6), respectively. The second sentence below Eq. (A.6), “Indeed, |H^B\hat{H}_BH^B​| is given |…\ldots…||H^†\hat{H}^\daggerH^†|⁠,” should be replaced with “Indeed, we obtain the Schrödinger equation |∣B(t−dt)⟩=eiℏH^Bdt∣B(t)⟩|B (t-dt) \rangle = e^{\frac{i}{\hbar} \hat{H}_B dt}|B (t) \rangle∣B(t−dt)⟩=eℏi​H^B​dt∣B(t)⟩|⁠, where |H^B\hat{H}_BH^B​| is given |…\ldots…||H^†\hat{H}^\daggerH^†|⁠.”
We formulate a complex action theory which includes operators of coordinate and momentum q and p being replaced with non-hermitian operators qnew and pnew, and their eigenstates m new q| and m new p| with complex eigenvalues q and p. Introducing a philosophy of keeping the analyticity in path integration variables, we define a modified set of complex conjugate, real and imaginary parts, hermitian conjugates and bras, and explicitly construct qnew, pnew, m new q| and m new p| by formally squeezing coherent states.We also pose a theorem on the relation between functions on the phase space and the corresponding operators.Only in our formalism can we describe a complex action theory or a real action theory with complex saddle points in the tunneling effect etc. in terms of bras and kets in the functional integral.Furthermore, in a system with a non-hermitian diagonalizable bounded Hamiltonian, we show that the mechanism to obtain a hermitian Hamiltonian after a long time development proposed in our letter 11) works also in the complex coordinate formalism.If the hermitian Hamiltonian is given in a local form, a conserved probability current density can be constructed with two kinds of wave functions.
In the complex action theory whose path runs over not only past but also future, we study a normalized matrix element of an operator |O^\hat {\mathcal O}O^| defined in terms of the future state at the latest time |TBT_BTB​| and the past state at the earliest time |TAT_ATA​| with a proper inner product that makes normal a given Hamiltonian that is non-normal at first. We present a theorem that states that, provided that the operator |O^\hat {\mathcal O}O^| is |QQQ|-Hermitian, i.e., Hermitian with regard to the proper inner product, the normalized matrix element becomes real and time-develops under a |QQQ|-Hermitian Hamiltonian for the past and future states selected such that the absolute value of the transition amplitude from the past state to the future state is maximized. Furthermore, we give a possible procedure to formulate the |QQQ|-Hermitian Hamiltonian in terms of |QQQ|-Hermitian coordinate and momentum operators, and construct a conserved probability current density.