Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1103.5585 · New Journal of Physics

The Fermi problem in discrete systems

Erez Zohar, Benni Reznik

Published Jul 29, 2011• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Fermi two-atom problem illustrates an apparent causality violation in quantum field theory that has to do with the nature of the built-in correlations in the vacuum. It has been a constant subject of theoretical debate and discussion in the last few decades. Nevertheless, although the issues at hand could in principle be tested experimentally, the smallness of such apparent violations of causality in quantum electrodynamics have prevented the observation of the predicted effect. In this paper, we show that the problem can be simulated within the framework of discrete systems that can be manifested, for instance, by trapped atoms in optical lattices or trapped ions. Unlike the original continuum case, the causal structure is no longer sharp. Nevertheless, as we show, it is possible to distinguish between ‘trivial’ effects due to ‘direct’ causality violations and the effects associated with Fermi's problem, even in such discrete settings. The ability to control externally the strength of the atom–field interactions enables us also to study both the original Fermi problem with ‘bare atoms’ and correction in the scenario that involves ‘dressed’ atoms. Finally, we show that, in principle, the Fermi effect can be detected using trapped ions.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/13/7/075016

Related papers

Dynamics in a Fermi lattice gas

Wenchao Xu

We use 40K atoms trapped in a cubic optical lattice to simulate the Fermi-Hubbard model. The work in this thesis focuses on investigating dynamics in the Fermi-Hubbard model and developing techniques for engineering Hamiltonians beyond the minimal Hubbard model. We discussed three experiments. In the first, we investigated the transport properties of a Fermi lattice gas by directly measuring the transport lifetime at various interaction strengths and temperatures. The resistivity is inferred from the measured transport lifetime. We observe anomalous transport behavior, which is analogous to bad-metal behavior in strongly correlated electronic materials. The second experiment presents the first realization of correlated, density-dependent tunneling in a Fermi-Hubbard optical lattice model by applied Raman laser fields. This correlated tunneling involves spin-flips and the generation of doublons, which have been observed experimentally. We also confirmed that the amplitude of correlated tunneling is suppressed when neighboring lattice sites are unoccupied. The last experiment explores the possibility to introduce long-range interactions for fermions trapped in optical lattices via Rydberg-dressed states. We developed a novel velocity-selective spectroscopy method to measure the transition between the 5P_1/2 and Rydberg states via electromagnetically induced transparency. This measurement is a first step toward inducing Rydberg-dressed interactions in optical lattices.

•Mar 26, 2018•0 citations

Experimentally separating vacuum fluctuations from source radiation

Alexa Herter, Frieder Lindel, Laura Gabriel +2 more

The distinction between vacuum-field and source-radiation effects in phenomena such as the Lamb shift, Casimir forces, and spontaneous emission relies on additional assumptions at the theoretical level, and an experimental approach was never considered feasible. Fermi’s two-atom problem, a Gedankenexperiment on how atoms interact with the electromagnetic field via vacuum and source radiation, provides key theoretical insight. Advances in ultrafast optics now enable experimental analogues using two laser pulses in a nonlinear crystal. Here we demonstrate the detection of vacuum- and source-radiation-induced correlations between two pulses, separated by their causal properties. Specifically, vacuum fluctuations and source radiation are shown to correlate distinct quadratures of near-infrared pulses, enabling individual probing via phase-sensitive detection. Our results experimentally verify the time-domain fluctuation-dissipation theorem at the quantum level and open avenues for studying quantum radiation effects in time-dependent media, including entanglement harvesting from the vacuum and quantum field detection in curved-space analogues. Two nearby atoms build up correlations due to two fundamentally different effects: individual interactions with the same vacuum fluctuations, and photon exchange. It is normally assumed that only the total effect is experimentally observable, and not the two individual contributions. Here, the authors challenge this in an experiment using an electro-optic analogue of Fermi’s two atoms setup.

Nature Communications•Feb 17, 2026•2 citations

Fermi Problem with Artificial Atoms in Circuit QED

Carlos Sabín, Marco del Rey, Juan José García‐Ripoll +1 more

We propose a feasible experimental test of a 1D version of the Fermi problem using superconducting qubits. We give an explicit nonperturbative proof of strict causality in this model, showing that the probability of excitation of a two-level artificial atom with a dipolar coupling to a quantum field is completely independent of the other qubit until signals from it may arrive. We explain why this is in perfect agreement with the existence of nonlocal correlations and previous results which were used to claim apparent causality problems for Fermi's two-atom system.

arXiv:1103.4129•Physical Review Letters•Oct 6, 2011•35 citations

NONLOCALITY AND CAUSALITY IN QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS

G. Compagno, G. Massimo Palma, Roberto Passante +1 more

The problem of relativistic causality in atom-radiation interacting systems is investigated. The excitation transfer in the Fermi problem is considered and it is shown that, independently from the initial state of the two atoms, it is causal, as well as the propagation of the electromagnetic field emitted by an excited atom. Nonlocal interatomic correlations and nonlocal spatial field correlations however appear in the evolution of the systems considered. These nonlocal correlations are shown to be compatible with relativistic causality. Our results are discussed with reference to questions recently raised in the literature about possible violations of relativistic causality.

Solvay Conference on Physics•Aug 1, 2003•1 citation

Detectors interacting through quantum fields: Non-Markovian effects, nonperturbative generation of correlations, and apparent noncausality

Theodora Kolioni, Charis Anastopoulos

We study a system of two localized detectors (oscillators) interacting through a massless quantum field in a vacuum state via an Unruh-DeWitt coupling. This system admits an exact solution and provides a good model for addressing fundamental issues in particle-field interactions, causality, and locality in quantum field measurements that are relevant to proposed quantum experiments in space. Our analysis of the exact solution leads to the following results. (i) Common approximations used in the study of analogous open quantum systems fail when the distance between the detectors becomes of the order of the relaxation time. In particular, the creation of correlations between remote detectors is not well described by ordinary perturbation theory and the Markov approximation. (ii) There is a unique asymptotic state that is correlated; it is not entangled unless the detector separation is of the order of magnitude of the wavelength of the exchanged quanta. (iii) The evolution of seemingly localized observables is noncausal. The latter is a manifestation of Fermi's two-atom problem, albeit in an exactly solvable system. We argue that the problem of causality requires a reexamination of the notion of entanglement in relativistic systems, in particular, the physical relevance of its extraction from the quantum vacuum.

arXiv:1909.10379•Physical Review A•Dec 10, 2020•5 citations

Phenomenology of small violations of Fermi and Bose statistics

Oscar Wallace Greenberg, Rabindra Nath Mohapatra

In a recent paper, we proposed a ``paronic'' field-theory framework for possible small deviations from the Pauli exclusion principle. This theory cannot be represented in a positive-metric (Hilbert) space. Nonetheless, the issue of possible small violations of the exclusion principle can be addressed in the framework of quantum mechanics, without being connected with a local quantum field theory. In this paper, we discuss the phenomenology of small violations of both Fermi and Bose statistics. We consider the implications of such violations in atomic, nuclear, particle, and condensed-matter physics and in astrophysics and cosmology. We also discuss experiments that can detect small violations of Fermi and Bose statistics or place stringent bounds on their validity.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Apr 1, 1989•109 citations
The Fermi two-atom problem illustrates an apparent causality violation in quantum field theory that has to do with the nature of the built-in correlations in the vacuum. It has been a constant subject of theoretical debate and discussion in the last few decades. Nevertheless, although the issues at hand could in principle be tested experimentally, the smallness of such apparent violations of causality in quantum electrodynamics have prevented the observation of the predicted effect. In this paper, we show that the problem can be simulated within the framework of discrete systems that can be manifested, for instance, by trapped atoms in optical lattices or trapped ions. Unlike the original continuum case, the causal structure is no longer sharp. Nevertheless, as we show, it is possible to distinguish between ‘trivial’ effects due to ‘direct’ causality violations and the effects associated with Fermi's problem, even in such discrete settings. The ability to control externally the strength of the atom–field interactions enables us also to study both the original Fermi problem with ‘bare atoms’ and correction in the scenario that involves ‘dressed’ atoms. Finally, we show that, in principle, the Fermi effect can be detected using trapped ions.
We use 40K atoms trapped in a cubic optical lattice to simulate the Fermi-Hubbard model. The work in this thesis focuses on investigating dynamics in the Fermi-Hubbard model and developing techniques for engineering Hamiltonians beyond the minimal Hubbard model. We discussed three experiments. In the first, we investigated the transport properties of a Fermi lattice gas by directly measuring the transport lifetime at various interaction strengths and temperatures. The resistivity is inferred from the measured transport lifetime. We observe anomalous transport behavior, which is analogous to bad-metal behavior in strongly correlated electronic materials. The second experiment presents the first realization of correlated, density-dependent tunneling in a Fermi-Hubbard optical lattice model by applied Raman laser fields. This correlated tunneling involves spin-flips and the generation of doublons, which have been observed experimentally. We also confirmed that the amplitude of correlated tunneling is suppressed when neighboring lattice sites are unoccupied. The last experiment explores the possibility to introduce long-range interactions for fermions trapped in optical lattices via Rydberg-dressed states. We developed a novel velocity-selective spectroscopy method to measure the transition between the 5P_1/2 and Rydberg states via electromagnetically induced transparency. This measurement is a first step toward inducing Rydberg-dressed interactions in optical lattices.
The distinction between vacuum-field and source-radiation effects in phenomena such as the Lamb shift, Casimir forces, and spontaneous emission relies on additional assumptions at the theoretical level, and an experimental approach was never considered feasible. Fermi’s two-atom problem, a Gedankenexperiment on how atoms interact with the electromagnetic field via vacuum and source radiation, provides key theoretical insight. Advances in ultrafast optics now enable experimental analogues using two laser pulses in a nonlinear crystal. Here we demonstrate the detection of vacuum- and source-radiation-induced correlations between two pulses, separated by their causal properties. Specifically, vacuum fluctuations and source radiation are shown to correlate distinct quadratures of near-infrared pulses, enabling individual probing via phase-sensitive detection. Our results experimentally verify the time-domain fluctuation-dissipation theorem at the quantum level and open avenues for studying quantum radiation effects in time-dependent media, including entanglement harvesting from the vacuum and quantum field detection in curved-space analogues. Two nearby atoms build up correlations due to two fundamentally different effects: individual interactions with the same vacuum fluctuations, and photon exchange. It is normally assumed that only the total effect is experimentally observable, and not the two individual contributions. Here, the authors challenge this in an experiment using an electro-optic analogue of Fermi’s two atoms setup.
We propose a feasible experimental test of a 1D version of the Fermi problem using superconducting qubits. We give an explicit nonperturbative proof of strict causality in this model, showing that the probability of excitation of a two-level artificial atom with a dipolar coupling to a quantum field is completely independent of the other qubit until signals from it may arrive. We explain why this is in perfect agreement with the existence of nonlocal correlations and previous results which were used to claim apparent causality problems for Fermi's two-atom system.
The problem of relativistic causality in atom-radiation interacting systems is investigated. The excitation transfer in the Fermi problem is considered and it is shown that, independently from the initial state of the two atoms, it is causal, as well as the propagation of the electromagnetic field emitted by an excited atom. Nonlocal interatomic correlations and nonlocal spatial field correlations however appear in the evolution of the systems considered. These nonlocal correlations are shown to be compatible with relativistic causality. Our results are discussed with reference to questions recently raised in the literature about possible violations of relativistic causality.
We study a system of two localized detectors (oscillators) interacting through a massless quantum field in a vacuum state via an Unruh-DeWitt coupling. This system admits an exact solution and provides a good model for addressing fundamental issues in particle-field interactions, causality, and locality in quantum field measurements that are relevant to proposed quantum experiments in space. Our analysis of the exact solution leads to the following results. (i) Common approximations used in the study of analogous open quantum systems fail when the distance between the detectors becomes of the order of the relaxation time. In particular, the creation of correlations between remote detectors is not well described by ordinary perturbation theory and the Markov approximation. (ii) There is a unique asymptotic state that is correlated; it is not entangled unless the detector separation is of the order of magnitude of the wavelength of the exchanged quanta. (iii) The evolution of seemingly localized observables is noncausal. The latter is a manifestation of Fermi's two-atom problem, albeit in an exactly solvable system. We argue that the problem of causality requires a reexamination of the notion of entanglement in relativistic systems, in particular, the physical relevance of its extraction from the quantum vacuum.
In a recent paper, we proposed a ``paronic'' field-theory framework for possible small deviations from the Pauli exclusion principle. This theory cannot be represented in a positive-metric (Hilbert) space. Nonetheless, the issue of possible small violations of the exclusion principle can be addressed in the framework of quantum mechanics, without being connected with a local quantum field theory. In this paper, we discuss the phenomenology of small violations of both Fermi and Bose statistics. We consider the implications of such violations in atomic, nuclear, particle, and condensed-matter physics and in astrophysics and cosmology. We also discuss experiments that can detect small violations of Fermi and Bose statistics or place stringent bounds on their validity.