Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1103.4150 · Physical Review A

Finite-time quantum-to-classical transition for a Schrödinger-cat state

Janika Paavola, Michael J. W. Hall, Matteo G. A. Paris, Sabrina Maniscalco

Published Jul 27, 2011• 23 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The transition from quantum to classical, in the case of a quantum harmonic oscillator, is typically identified with the transition from a quantum superposition of macroscopically distinguishable states, such as the Schr\"odinger-cat state, into the corresponding statistical mixture. This transition is commonly characterized by the asymptotic loss of the interference term in the Wigner representation of the cat state. In this paper we show that the quantum-to-classical transition has different dynamical features depending on the measure for nonclassicality used. Measures based on an operatorial definition have well-defined physical meaning and allow a deeper understanding of the quantum-to-classical transition. Our analysis shows that, for most nonclassicality measures, the Schr\"odinger-cat state becomes classical after a finite time. Moreover, our results challenge the prevailing idea that more macroscopic states are more susceptible to decoherence in the sense that the transition from quantum to classical occurs faster. Since nonclassicality is a prerequisite for entanglement generation our results also bridge the gap between decoherence, which is lost only asymptotically, and entanglement, which may show a ``sudden death.'' In fact, whereas the loss of coherences still remains asymptotic, we emphasize that the transition from quantum to classical can indeed occur at a finite time.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.84.012121

Related papers

Quantum to classical transition induced by gravitational time dilation

Boris Sokolov, Iiro Vilja, Sabrina Maniscalco

We study the loss of quantumness caused by time dilation [I. Pikovski, M. Zych, F. Costa, and \ifmmode \check{C}\else \v{C}\fi{}. Brukner, Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] for a Schr\"odinger cat state. We give a holistic view of the quantum to classical transition by comparing the dynamics of several nonclassicality indicators, such as the Wigner function interference fringe, the negativity of the Wigner function, the nonclassical depth, the Vogel criterion, and the Klyshko criterion. Our results show that only two of these indicators depend critically on the size of the cat, namely, on how macroscopic the superposition is. Finally we compare the gravitation-induced decoherence times to the typical decoherence times due to classical noise originating from the unavoidable statistical fluctuations in the characteristic parameters of the system [J. Trapani, M. Bina, S. Maniscalco, and M. G. A. Paris, Phys. Rev. A 91, 022113 (2015)]. We show that the experimental observation of decoherence due to time dilation imposes severe limitations on the allowed levels of classical noise in the experiments.

arXiv:1702.02433•Physical Review A•Jul 26, 2017•9 citations

Non-Markovian Dynamics and the Quantum-To-Classical Transition for Quantum Brownian Motion

Janika Paavola

In this Thesis I discuss the dynamics of the quantum Brownian motion model in harmonic potential. This paradigmatic model has an exact solution, making it possible to consider also analytically the non-Markovian dynamics. The issues covered in this Thesis are themed around decoherence. First, I consider decoherence as the mediator of quantum-to-classical transition. I examine five different definitions for nonclassicality of quantum states, and show how each definition gives qualitatively different times for the onset of classicality. In particular I have found that all characterizations of nonclassicality, apart from one based on the interference term in the Wigner function, result in a finite, rather than asymptotic, time for the emergence of classicality. Second, I examine the diverse effects which coupling to a non-Markovian, structured reservoir, has on our system. By comparing different types of Ohmic reservoirs, I derive some general conclusions on the role of the reservoir spectrum in both the short-time and the thermalization dynamics. Finally, I apply these results to two schemes for decoherence control. Both of the methods are based on the non-Markovian properties of the dynamics.

•May 19, 2012•0 citations

Schrödinger-cat states at finite temperature: Influence of a finite-temperature heat bath on quantum interferences

M. S. Kim, Vladimír Bužek

Recently several methods have been proposed for generation of superposition (Schr\"odinger-cat) states in microwave cavities. At microwave frequencies, thermal photons can significantly affect statistical properties of superposition states. In the present paper we study the influence of a thermal heat bath on nonclassical properties of quantum superposition states. We show that at nonzero temperature the loss of coherences is much faster than at zero temperature. Using the formalism of quasiprobability distributions and solving the corresponding Fokker-Planck equations, we describe the time evolution of the super-position states in phase space and derive the rate of the decay of quantum coherence. This decay rate depends on the separation between the component states and on the temperature of the heat bath. Moreover, we discuss in detail how the interaction with a nonzero-temperature heat bath leads to a transformation of a nonclassical state to a classical state. We show that the sensitivity of the quantum coherence to the presence of thermal photons can lead to some difficulties in the preparation of Schr\"odinger-cat states in microwave cavities unless the temperature of the microwave cavity is sufficiently low.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1992•120 citations

Theory of collapse of Manera in English

Giuseppe Manera

Abstract The quantum-to-classical transition remains one of the most debated open problems in modern physics. While decoherence theory successfully explains the suppression of interference in many experimental regimes, a clear operational distinction between reversible decoherence and irreversible collapse is still lacking, especially in mesoscopic and macroscopic interferometric systems. In this work, we propose a phenomenological modification of the Schrödinger dynamics that introduces an entropy-dependent non-linear term driving an irreversible transition from quantum superpositions to classical states beyond a well-defined threshold. The model predicts finite collapse times that depend on experimentally accessible parameters and naturally suppresses any revival of coherence once the transition has occurred. The theory is explicitly falsifiable: if coherence is observed to revive beyond the predicted threshold (≈10⁶ effective degrees of freedom), the model is ruled out. We compare the predicted collapse times with the observed loss of coherence in a wide range of interferometric and mesoscopic experiments, including cavity QED, optomechanical systems, superconducting circuits, and molecular interferometry. In all analyzed regimes, the model reproduces the observed orders of magnitude of the characteristic decoherence or collapse times. Finally, we discuss experimental scenarios—particularly involving large molecules such as porphyrins—where the model can be directly tested and potentially distinguished from standard decoherence-only descriptions.

•Feb 6, 2026•0 citations

Towards Schrödinger Cat States in the Second Harmonic Generation

Ranjit Singh, Leonid A. Barinov, Grigori G. Amosov +1 more

We investigate the quantum evolution of the pump field in second-harmonic generation under strong pump depletion. Starting from a coherent state, the pump develops a nonclassical phase-space structure resembling a Schrödinger cat state. This behavior originates from phase instability induced by vacuum fluctuations of the harmonic mode. A rigorous quantum analysis has been performed for mean photon numbers up to $\langle \hat n \rangle = 100$ in pump mode. For larger photon numbers, up to $\langle \hat n \rangle = 10^{7}$, the dynamics have been analyzed using a classical trajectory method with sampled initial conditions that reproduces the main features of the quantum evolution. The results indicate that nonlinear frequency conversion can generate macroscopic superposition-like states of the pump field. Although the resulting state is not pure due to correlations with the second-harmonic wave, it remains non-classical with negative zones of Wigner function. These results indicate that strongly nonlinear frequency conversion can provide a scalable route toward macroscopic nonclassical states of light.

quant-pharXiv:2603.24067•Mar 26, 2026•1 citation

Collapse and revival of quantum coherence for a harmonic oscillator interacting with a classical fluctuating environment

Jacopo Trapani, Matteo Bina, Sabrina Maniscalco +1 more

We address the dynamics of nonclassicality for a quantum system interacting with a noisy fluctuating environment described by a classical stochastic field. As a paradigmatic example, we consider a harmonic oscillator initially prepared in a maximally nonclassical state, e.g., a Fock number state or a Schr\"odinger-cat-like state, and then coupled to either a resonant or a nonresonant external field. Stochastic modeling allows us to describe the decoherence dynamics without resorting to approximated quantum master equations and to introduce non-Markovian effects in a controlled way. A detailed comparison among different nonclassicality criteria and a thorough analysis of the decoherence time reveal a rich phenomenology whose main features may be summarized as follows: (i) Classical memory effects increase the survival time of quantum coherence and (ii) a detuning between the natural frequency of the system and the central frequency of the classical field induces revivals of quantum coherence.

arXiv:1411.0946•Physical Review A•Feb 17, 2015•34 citations
The transition from quantum to classical, in the case of a quantum harmonic oscillator, is typically identified with the transition from a quantum superposition of macroscopically distinguishable states, such as the Schr"odinger-cat state, into the corresponding statistical mixture. This transition is commonly characterized by the asymptotic loss of the interference term in the Wigner representation of the cat state. In this paper we show that the quantum-to-classical transition has different dynamical features depending on the measure for nonclassicality used. Measures based on an operatorial definition have well-defined physical meaning and allow a deeper understanding of the quantum-to-classical transition. Our analysis shows that, for most nonclassicality measures, the Schr"odinger-cat state becomes classical after a finite time. Moreover, our results challenge the prevailing idea that more macroscopic states are more susceptible to decoherence in the sense that the transition from quantum to classical occurs faster. Since nonclassicality is a prerequisite for entanglement generation our results also bridge the gap between decoherence, which is lost only asymptotically, and entanglement, which may show a ``sudden death.'' In fact, whereas the loss of coherences still remains asymptotic, we emphasize that the transition from quantum to classical can indeed occur at a finite time.
We study the loss of quantumness caused by time dilation [I. Pikovski, M. Zych, F. Costa, and \ifmmode \check{C}\else \v{C}\fi{}. Brukner, Nat. Phys. 11, 668 (2015)] for a Schr\"odinger cat state. We give a holistic view of the quantum to classical transition by comparing the dynamics of several nonclassicality indicators, such as the Wigner function interference fringe, the negativity of the Wigner function, the nonclassical depth, the Vogel criterion, and the Klyshko criterion. Our results show that only two of these indicators depend critically on the size of the cat, namely, on how macroscopic the superposition is. Finally we compare the gravitation-induced decoherence times to the typical decoherence times due to classical noise originating from the unavoidable statistical fluctuations in the characteristic parameters of the system [J. Trapani, M. Bina, S. Maniscalco, and M. G. A. Paris, Phys. Rev. A 91, 022113 (2015)]. We show that the experimental observation of decoherence due to time dilation imposes severe limitations on the allowed levels of classical noise in the experiments.
In this Thesis I discuss the dynamics of the quantum Brownian motion model in harmonic potential. This paradigmatic model has an exact solution, making it possible to consider also analytically the non-Markovian dynamics. The issues covered in this Thesis are themed around decoherence. First, I consider decoherence as the mediator of quantum-to-classical transition. I examine five different definitions for nonclassicality of quantum states, and show how each definition gives qualitatively different times for the onset of classicality. In particular I have found that all characterizations of nonclassicality, apart from one based on the interference term in the Wigner function, result in a finite, rather than asymptotic, time for the emergence of classicality. Second, I examine the diverse effects which coupling to a non-Markovian, structured reservoir, has on our system. By comparing different types of Ohmic reservoirs, I derive some general conclusions on the role of the reservoir spectrum in both the short-time and the thermalization dynamics. Finally, I apply these results to two schemes for decoherence control. Both of the methods are based on the non-Markovian properties of the dynamics.
Recently several methods have been proposed for generation of superposition (Schr\"odinger-cat) states in microwave cavities. At microwave frequencies, thermal photons can significantly affect statistical properties of superposition states. In the present paper we study the influence of a thermal heat bath on nonclassical properties of quantum superposition states. We show that at nonzero temperature the loss of coherences is much faster than at zero temperature. Using the formalism of quasiprobability distributions and solving the corresponding Fokker-Planck equations, we describe the time evolution of the super-position states in phase space and derive the rate of the decay of quantum coherence. This decay rate depends on the separation between the component states and on the temperature of the heat bath. Moreover, we discuss in detail how the interaction with a nonzero-temperature heat bath leads to a transformation of a nonclassical state to a classical state. We show that the sensitivity of the quantum coherence to the presence of thermal photons can lead to some difficulties in the preparation of Schr\"odinger-cat states in microwave cavities unless the temperature of the microwave cavity is sufficiently low.
Abstract The quantum-to-classical transition remains one of the most debated open problems in modern physics. While decoherence theory successfully explains the suppression of interference in many experimental regimes, a clear operational distinction between reversible decoherence and irreversible collapse is still lacking, especially in mesoscopic and macroscopic interferometric systems. In this work, we propose a phenomenological modification of the Schrödinger dynamics that introduces an entropy-dependent non-linear term driving an irreversible transition from quantum superpositions to classical states beyond a well-defined threshold. The model predicts finite collapse times that depend on experimentally accessible parameters and naturally suppresses any revival of coherence once the transition has occurred. The theory is explicitly falsifiable: if coherence is observed to revive beyond the predicted threshold (≈10⁶ effective degrees of freedom), the model is ruled out. We compare the predicted collapse times with the observed loss of coherence in a wide range of interferometric and mesoscopic experiments, including cavity QED, optomechanical systems, superconducting circuits, and molecular interferometry. In all analyzed regimes, the model reproduces the observed orders of magnitude of the characteristic decoherence or collapse times. Finally, we discuss experimental scenarios—particularly involving large molecules such as porphyrins—where the model can be directly tested and potentially distinguished from standard decoherence-only descriptions.
We investigate the quantum evolution of the pump field in second-harmonic generation under strong pump depletion. Starting from a coherent state, the pump develops a nonclassical phase-space structure resembling a Schrödinger cat state. This behavior originates from phase instability induced by vacuum fluctuations of the harmonic mode. A rigorous quantum analysis has been performed for mean photon numbers up to ⟨n^⟩=100\langle \hat n \rangle = 100⟨n^⟩=100 in pump mode. For larger photon numbers, up to ⟨n^⟩=107\langle \hat n \rangle = 10^{7}⟨n^⟩=107, the dynamics have been analyzed using a classical trajectory method with sampled initial conditions that reproduces the main features of the quantum evolution. The results indicate that nonlinear frequency conversion can generate macroscopic superposition-like states of the pump field. Although the resulting state is not pure due to correlations with the second-harmonic wave, it remains non-classical with negative zones of Wigner function. These results indicate that strongly nonlinear frequency conversion can provide a scalable route toward macroscopic nonclassical states of light.
We address the dynamics of nonclassicality for a quantum system interacting with a noisy fluctuating environment described by a classical stochastic field. As a paradigmatic example, we consider a harmonic oscillator initially prepared in a maximally nonclassical state, e.g., a Fock number state or a Schr\"odinger-cat-like state, and then coupled to either a resonant or a nonresonant external field. Stochastic modeling allows us to describe the decoherence dynamics without resorting to approximated quantum master equations and to introduce non-Markovian effects in a controlled way. A detailed comparison among different nonclassicality criteria and a thorough analysis of the decoherence time reveal a rich phenomenology whose main features may be summarized as follows: (i) Classical memory effects increase the survival time of quantum coherence and (ii) a detuning between the natural frequency of the system and the central frequency of the classical field induces revivals of quantum coherence.