Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1102.1963 · IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)

On quantum limit of optical communications: Concatenated codes and joint-detection receivers

Saikat Guha, Zachary Dutton, Jeffrey H. Shapiro

Published Jul 1, 2011• 24 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

When classical information is sent over a channel with quantum-state modulation alphabet, such as the free-space optical (FSO) channel, attaining the ultimate (Holevo) limit to channel capacity requires the receiver to make joint measurements over long codeword blocks. In recent work, we showed a receiver for a pure-state channel that can attain the ultimate capacity by applying a single-shot optical (unitary) transformation on the received codeword state followed by simultaneous (but separable) projective measurements on the single-modulation-symbol state spaces. In this paper, we study the ultimate tradeoff between photon efficiency and spectral efficiency for the FSO channel. Based on our general results for the pure-state quantum channel, we show some of the first concrete examples of codes and laboratory-realizable joint-detection optical receivers that can achieve fundamentally higher (superadditive) channel capacity than receivers that physically detect each modulation symbol one at a time, as is done by all conventional (coherent or direct-detection) optical receivers.

DOI
10.1109/isit.2011.6034073

Related papers

Structured Optical Receivers to Attain Superadditive Capacity and the Holevo Limit

Saikat Guha

Attaining the ultimate (Holevo) limit to the classical capacity of a quantum channel requires the receiver to make joint measurements over long code-word blocks. For a pure-state channel, we show that the Holevo limit can be attained by a receiver that uses a multisymbol unitary transformation on the quantum code word followed by separable projective measurements. We show a concatenated coding and joint-detection architecture to approach the Holevo limit. We then construct some of the first concrete examples of codes and structured joint-detection receivers for the lossy bosonic channel, which can achieve fundamentally higher (superadditive) capacity than conventional receivers that detect each modulation symbol individually. We thereby pave the way for research into codes and structured receivers for reliable communication data rates approaching the Holevo limit.

arXiv:1101.1550•Physical Review Letters•Jun 14, 2011•152 citations

Polar coding to achieve the Holevo capacity of a pure-loss optical channel

Saikat Guha, Mark M. Wilde

In the low-energy high-energy-efficiency regime of classical optical communications - relevant to deep-space optical channels - there is a big gap between reliable communication rates achievable via conventional optical receivers and the ultimate (Holevo) capacity. Achieving the Holevo capacity requires not only optimal codes but also receivers that make collective measurements on long (modulated) codeword waveforms, and it is impossible to implement these collective measurements via symbol-by-symbol detection along with classical postprocessing [1], [2]. Here, we apply our recent results on the classical-quantum polar code [3] - the first near-explicit, linear, symmetric-Holevo-rate achieving code - to the lossy optical channel, and we show that it almost closes the entire gap to the Holevo capacity in the low photon number regime. In contrast, Arikan's original polar codes, applied to the DMC induced by the physical optical channel paired with any conceivable structured optical receiver (including optical homodyne, heterodyne, or direct-detection) fails to achieve the ultimate Holevo limit to channel capacity. However, our polar code construction (which uses the quantum fidelity as a channel parameter rather than the classical Bhattacharyya quantity to choose the “good channels” in the polar-code construction), paired with a quantum successive-cancellation receiver - which involves a sequence of collective non-destructive binary projective measurements on the joint quantum state of the received codeword waveform - can attain the Holevo limit, and can hence in principle achieve higher rates than Arikan's polar code and decoder directly applied to the optical channel. However, even a theoretical recipe for construction of an optical realization of the quantum successive-cancellation receiver remains an open question.

arXiv:1202.0533•IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jul 1, 2012•60 citations

Extracting classical information from quantum states : fundamental limits, adaptive and finite-length measurements

Hye Won Chung

Motivated by the increasing demand for more powerful and efficient optical communication systems, quantum mechanics of information processing has become the key element in determining the fundamental limits of physical channels, and in designing quantum communication systems that approach those fundamental limits. To achieve higher data rates over quantum optical channels, we need to efficiently extract classical information from quantum states. However, peculiar properties of quantum states, such as the no-cloning theorem and the non-reversible measurement process, provide new challenges in the measurement of quantum states; in quantum information science, there is no concept analogous to sufficient statistics in classical information science. Therefore, to extract as much information as possible from quantum states, it is important to choose the right measurement process. In this thesis, we investigate the fundamental question of how to design the measurement process to efficiently extract information from quantum states. First, we consider adaptive measurement, with which we measure each received quantum state one at a time, and then update the next measurement process based on the previous observations. We show that for binary hypothesis testing between two ideal laser light pulses, if we update the adaptive measurement to maximize the communication efficiency at each instant, based on recursively updated knowledge of the receiver, then we can achieve the theoretical lower bound of the detection error probability. Using this viewpoint, we give a natural generalization of the adaptive measurement to general Mary hypothesis testing problems. We also analyze the information capacity with adaptive measurement, and compare the result with that for direct detection receivers and the ultimate capacity of quantum channels (the Holevo limit). We also investigate finite-blocklength joint receivers. The ultimate capacity of quantum channels is calculated under the assumption that an infinite number of quantum states can be collectively measured in one shot. However, this assumption becomes the primary barrier that prevents practical implementations of capacity-achieving joint detection receivers. The maximum number of classical information bits extracted per use of the quantum channel strictly increases with the number of channel outputs jointly measured at the receiver. This phenomenon is called strict superadditivity, and it has been thought of as a unique property that can be observed only in quantum channels, but not in classical discrete memoryless channels (DMCs). In this thesis, we introduce a new aspect of understanding strict superadditivity by comparing the performance of concatenated coding over quantum channels and classical DMCs, for a fixed inner code length. We show that the strict superadditivity in information rate occurs due to a loss of information from hard-decisions at the finite blocklength. We also find a lower bound on the maximum achievable information rate as a function of the length of the quantum measurement. The analysis and new insights into the measurement process of quantum states that we develop in this thesis can be used to improve not only current quantum optical communication systems, but also classical information processing, where the data is too big to be handled with sufficient statistics. Our work would help develop new concepts of efficient statistics that provide systematic ways to choose useful information among big data while discarding the rest.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Capacity of optical communication in loss and noise with general quantum Gaussian receivers

Masahiro Takeoka, Saikat Guha

Laser-light (coherent-state) modulation is sufficient to achieve the ultimate (Holevo) capacity of classical communication over a lossy and noisy optical channel, but requires a receiver that jointly detects long modulated code words with highly nonlinear quantum operations, which are near-impossible to realize using current technology. We analyze the capacity of the lossy-noisy optical channel when the transmitter uses coherent-state modulation but the receiver is restricted to a general quantum-limited Gaussian receiver, i.e., one that may involve arbitrary combinations of Gaussian operations [passive linear optics: beam splitters and phase shifters; second-order nonlinear optics (or active linear optics): squeezers, along with homodyne or heterodyne detection measurements] and any amount of classical feedforward within the receiver. Under these assumptions, we show that the Gaussian receiver that attains the maximum mutual information is either homodyne detection, heterodyne detection, or time sharing between the two, depending upon the received power level. In other words, our result shows that to exceed the theoretical limit of conventional coherent optical communication, one has to incorporate non-Gaussian, i.e., third- or higher-order nonlinear operations in the receiver. Finally we compare our Gaussian receiver limit with experimentally feasible non-Gaussian receivers and show that in the regime of low received photon flux, it is possible to overcome the Gaussian receiver limit by relatively simple non-Gaussian receivers based on photon counting.

arXiv:1401.5132•Physical Review A•Apr 10, 2014•46 citations

Capacity of optical communication in loss and noise with general quantum Gaussian receivers

Masahiro Takeoka, Saikat Guha

Laser-light (coherent-state) modulation is sufficient to achieve the ultimate (Holevo) capacity of classical communication over a lossy and noisy optical channel, but requires a receiver that jointly detects long modulated codewords with highly nonlinear quantum operations, which are near-impossible to realize using current technology. We analyze the capacity of the lossy-noisy optical channel when the transmitter uses coherent state modulation but the receiver is restricted to a general quantum-limited Gaussian receiver, i.e., one that may involve arbitrary combinations of Gaussian operations (passive linear optics: beamsplitters and phase-shifters, second order nonlinear process (squeezers), along with homodyne or heterodyne detection measurements) and any amount of classical feedforward within the receiver. Under these assumptions, we show that the Gaussian receiver that attains the maximum mutual information is either homodyne detection, heterodyne detection, or time sharing between the two, depending upon the received power level. In other words, our result shows that to exceed the theoretical limit of conventional coherent optical communications, one has to incorporate non-Gaussian (i.e. higher order nonlinear) operations in the receiver.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2014•12 citations

The ultimate limits of optical communication efficiency with photon-counting receivers

Sam Dolinar, Baris I. Erkmen, Bruce E. Moision +2 more

Coherent states achieve the Holevo capacity of a pure-loss channel when paired with an optimal measurement, but a physical realization of this measurement is unknown, and likely to be of high complexity. In this paper, we focus on the photon-counting measurement and study the photon and dimensional efficiencies attainable with modulations over classical- and nonclassical-state alphabets. We first review state-of-the-art coherent on-off-keying (OOK) and pulse-position modulation (PPM) with a photon-counting measurement, illustrating its asymptotic inefficiency relative to the Holevo limit. Then we analyze two architectures that improve upon the dimensional versus photon efficiency tradeoff achievable with conventional OOK or PPM. We show that at high photon efficiency these architectures achieve an efficiency tradeoff that differs from the best possible tradeoff by only a constant factor. The first architecture is a coherent-state transmitter that relies on feedback from the receiver to control the transmitted energy. The second architecture uses a single-photon number-state source.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jul 1, 2012•10 citations
When classical information is sent over a channel with quantum-state modulation alphabet, such as the free-space optical (FSO) channel, attaining the ultimate (Holevo) limit to channel capacity requires the receiver to make joint measurements over long codeword blocks. In recent work, we showed a receiver for a pure-state channel that can attain the ultimate capacity by applying a single-shot optical (unitary) transformation on the received codeword state followed by simultaneous (but separable) projective measurements on the single-modulation-symbol state spaces. In this paper, we study the ultimate tradeoff between photon efficiency and spectral efficiency for the FSO channel. Based on our general results for the pure-state quantum channel, we show some of the first concrete examples of codes and laboratory-realizable joint-detection optical receivers that can achieve fundamentally higher (superadditive) channel capacity than receivers that physically detect each modulation symbol one at a time, as is done by all conventional (coherent or direct-detection) optical receivers.
Attaining the ultimate (Holevo) limit to the classical capacity of a quantum channel requires the receiver to make joint measurements over long code-word blocks. For a pure-state channel, we show that the Holevo limit can be attained by a receiver that uses a multisymbol unitary transformation on the quantum code word followed by separable projective measurements. We show a concatenated coding and joint-detection architecture to approach the Holevo limit. We then construct some of the first concrete examples of codes and structured joint-detection receivers for the lossy bosonic channel, which can achieve fundamentally higher (superadditive) capacity than conventional receivers that detect each modulation symbol individually. We thereby pave the way for research into codes and structured receivers for reliable communication data rates approaching the Holevo limit.
In the low-energy high-energy-efficiency regime of classical optical communications - relevant to deep-space optical channels - there is a big gap between reliable communication rates achievable via conventional optical receivers and the ultimate (Holevo) capacity. Achieving the Holevo capacity requires not only optimal codes but also receivers that make collective measurements on long (modulated) codeword waveforms, and it is impossible to implement these collective measurements via symbol-by-symbol detection along with classical postprocessing [1], [2]. Here, we apply our recent results on the classical-quantum polar code [3] - the first near-explicit, linear, symmetric-Holevo-rate achieving code - to the lossy optical channel, and we show that it almost closes the entire gap to the Holevo capacity in the low photon number regime. In contrast, Arikan's original polar codes, applied to the DMC induced by the physical optical channel paired with any conceivable structured optical receiver (including optical homodyne, heterodyne, or direct-detection) fails to achieve the ultimate Holevo limit to channel capacity. However, our polar code construction (which uses the quantum fidelity as a channel parameter rather than the classical Bhattacharyya quantity to choose the “good channels” in the polar-code construction), paired with a quantum successive-cancellation receiver - which involves a sequence of collective non-destructive binary projective measurements on the joint quantum state of the received codeword waveform - can attain the Holevo limit, and can hence in principle achieve higher rates than Arikan's polar code and decoder directly applied to the optical channel. However, even a theoretical recipe for construction of an optical realization of the quantum successive-cancellation receiver remains an open question.
Motivated by the increasing demand for more powerful and efficient optical communication systems, quantum mechanics of information processing has become the key element in determining the fundamental limits of physical channels, and in designing quantum communication systems that approach those fundamental limits. To achieve higher data rates over quantum optical channels, we need to efficiently extract classical information from quantum states. However, peculiar properties of quantum states, such as the no-cloning theorem and the non-reversible measurement process, provide new challenges in the measurement of quantum states; in quantum information science, there is no concept analogous to sufficient statistics in classical information science. Therefore, to extract as much information as possible from quantum states, it is important to choose the right measurement process. In this thesis, we investigate the fundamental question of how to design the measurement process to efficiently extract information from quantum states. First, we consider adaptive measurement, with which we measure each received quantum state one at a time, and then update the next measurement process based on the previous observations. We show that for binary hypothesis testing between two ideal laser light pulses, if we update the adaptive measurement to maximize the communication efficiency at each instant, based on recursively updated knowledge of the receiver, then we can achieve the theoretical lower bound of the detection error probability. Using this viewpoint, we give a natural generalization of the adaptive measurement to general Mary hypothesis testing problems. We also analyze the information capacity with adaptive measurement, and compare the result with that for direct detection receivers and the ultimate capacity of quantum channels (the Holevo limit). We also investigate finite-blocklength joint receivers. The ultimate capacity of quantum channels is calculated under the assumption that an infinite number of quantum states can be collectively measured in one shot. However, this assumption becomes the primary barrier that prevents practical implementations of capacity-achieving joint detection receivers. The maximum number of classical information bits extracted per use of the quantum channel strictly increases with the number of channel outputs jointly measured at the receiver. This phenomenon is called strict superadditivity, and it has been thought of as a unique property that can be observed only in quantum channels, but not in classical discrete memoryless channels (DMCs). In this thesis, we introduce a new aspect of understanding strict superadditivity by comparing the performance of concatenated coding over quantum channels and classical DMCs, for a fixed inner code length. We show that the strict superadditivity in information rate occurs due to a loss of information from hard-decisions at the finite blocklength. We also find a lower bound on the maximum achievable information rate as a function of the length of the quantum measurement. The analysis and new insights into the measurement process of quantum states that we develop in this thesis can be used to improve not only current quantum optical communication systems, but also classical information processing, where the data is too big to be handled with sufficient statistics. Our work would help develop new concepts of efficient statistics that provide systematic ways to choose useful information among big data while discarding the rest.
Laser-light (coherent-state) modulation is sufficient to achieve the ultimate (Holevo) capacity of classical communication over a lossy and noisy optical channel, but requires a receiver that jointly detects long modulated code words with highly nonlinear quantum operations, which are near-impossible to realize using current technology. We analyze the capacity of the lossy-noisy optical channel when the transmitter uses coherent-state modulation but the receiver is restricted to a general quantum-limited Gaussian receiver, i.e., one that may involve arbitrary combinations of Gaussian operations [passive linear optics: beam splitters and phase shifters; second-order nonlinear optics (or active linear optics): squeezers, along with homodyne or heterodyne detection measurements] and any amount of classical feedforward within the receiver. Under these assumptions, we show that the Gaussian receiver that attains the maximum mutual information is either homodyne detection, heterodyne detection, or time sharing between the two, depending upon the received power level. In other words, our result shows that to exceed the theoretical limit of conventional coherent optical communication, one has to incorporate non-Gaussian, i.e., third- or higher-order nonlinear operations in the receiver. Finally we compare our Gaussian receiver limit with experimentally feasible non-Gaussian receivers and show that in the regime of low received photon flux, it is possible to overcome the Gaussian receiver limit by relatively simple non-Gaussian receivers based on photon counting.
Laser-light (coherent-state) modulation is sufficient to achieve the ultimate (Holevo) capacity of classical communication over a lossy and noisy optical channel, but requires a receiver that jointly detects long modulated codewords with highly nonlinear quantum operations, which are near-impossible to realize using current technology. We analyze the capacity of the lossy-noisy optical channel when the transmitter uses coherent state modulation but the receiver is restricted to a general quantum-limited Gaussian receiver, i.e., one that may involve arbitrary combinations of Gaussian operations (passive linear optics: beamsplitters and phase-shifters, second order nonlinear process (squeezers), along with homodyne or heterodyne detection measurements) and any amount of classical feedforward within the receiver. Under these assumptions, we show that the Gaussian receiver that attains the maximum mutual information is either homodyne detection, heterodyne detection, or time sharing between the two, depending upon the received power level. In other words, our result shows that to exceed the theoretical limit of conventional coherent optical communications, one has to incorporate non-Gaussian (i.e. higher order nonlinear) operations in the receiver.
Coherent states achieve the Holevo capacity of a pure-loss channel when paired with an optimal measurement, but a physical realization of this measurement is unknown, and likely to be of high complexity. In this paper, we focus on the photon-counting measurement and study the photon and dimensional efficiencies attainable with modulations over classical- and nonclassical-state alphabets. We first review state-of-the-art coherent on-off-keying (OOK) and pulse-position modulation (PPM) with a photon-counting measurement, illustrating its asymptotic inefficiency relative to the Holevo limit. Then we analyze two architectures that improve upon the dimensional versus photon efficiency tradeoff achievable with conventional OOK or PPM. We show that at high photon efficiency these architectures achieve an efficiency tradeoff that differs from the best possible tradeoff by only a constant factor. The first architecture is a coherent-state transmitter that relies on feedback from the receiver to control the transmitted energy. The second architecture uses a single-photon number-state source.