Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1012.5355 · Physical Review A

General comparison theorem for eigenvalues of a certain class of Hamiltonians

Claude Semay

Published Feb 16, 2011• 21 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Using the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, a general comparison theorem is established for an eigenvalue equation of the form $(T+V)|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}=E|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}$, where $T$ is a kinetic part which depends only on momenta and $V$ is a potential which depends only on positions. We assume that ${H}^{(1)}=T+{V}^{(1)}$ and ${H}^{(2)}=T+{V}^{(2)}$ (${H}^{(1)}={T}^{(1)}+V$ and ${H}^{(2)}={T}^{(2)}+V$) support both discrete eigenvalues ${E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(1)}$ and ${E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(2)}$, where ${\ensuremath{\alpha}}$ represents a set of quantum numbers. We prove that, if ${V}^{(1)}\ensuremath{\leqslant}{V}^{(2)}$ (${T}^{(1)}\ensuremath{\leqslant}{T}^{(2)}$) for all position (momentum) variables, then the corresponding eigenvalues are ordered as ${E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(1)}\ensuremath{\leqslant}{E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(2)}$. Some analytical applications are given.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.83.024101

Related papers

The Hellmann–Feynman theorem, the comparison theorem, and the envelope theory

Claude Semay

The envelope theory is a convenient method to compute approximate solutions for bound state equations in quantum mechanics. It is shown that these approximate solutions obey a kind of Hellmann–Feynman theorem, and that the comparison theorem can be applied to these approximate solutions for two ordered Hamiltonians.

Results in Physics•Jan 1, 2015•2 citations

Hellmann–Feynman theorem in a linear superposition of energy eigenstates

S. Balasubramanian

A generalization to the Hellmann–Feynman theorem is presented when the quantum mechanical state is a linear superposition of energy eigenstates. Some simple applications are discussed.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1994•4 citations

Hellmann-Feynman theorem in non-Hermitian systems

Gaurav Hajong, Ranjan Modak, Bhabani Prasad Mandal

We revisit the celebrated Hellmann-Feynman theorem (HFT) in the parity-time $(\mathcal{PT})$ invariant non-Hermitian quantum physics framework. We derive a modified version of HFT by changing the definition of inner product and explicitly show that it holds good for both $\mathcal{PT}$ broken and unbroken phases and even at the exceptional point of the theory. The derivation is extremely general and works for even the $\mathcal{PT}$ noninvariant Hamiltonian. We consider several examples of discrete and continuum variable systems to test our results. We find that, if the eigenvalue goes through a real-to-complex transition as a function of the Hermiticity breaking parameter, both sides of the modified HFT expression diverge at that point. If that point turns out to be an EP of the $\mathcal{PT}$-invariant quantum theory, then one also sees the divergence at EP. Moreover, we have also demonstrated that using the modified HFT can give rise to a potential numerical advantage for computing the expectation value of many-body operators for interacting many-body Hamiltonian. Finally, we also derive a generalized virial theorem for non-Hermitian systems using the modified HFT, which potentially can be tested in experiments.

arXiv:2308.13914•Physical Review A•Feb 20, 2024•14 citations

General theorem on the Schrödinger equation

X. R. Wang

Two discrete energy spectra of a particle moving in two different potential wells are compared. We find a general property: If one potential well ${\mathit{V}}_{1}$(r) is less than or equal to the other potential well ${\mathit{V}}_{2}$(r) everywhere in space, i.e., ${\mathit{V}}_{1}$(r)\ensuremath{\le}${\mathit{V}}_{2}$(r) for all r, then the nth eigenvalue of the particle in the first well, ${\mathit{V}}_{1}$, is always not greater than the nth eigenvalue of the particle in the second well, ${\mathit{V}}_{2}$.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1992•17 citations

Emergent non-Hermitian contributions to the Ehrenfest and Hellmann-Feynman theorems

Georgios S. Konstantinou, Kyriakos Kyriakou, Konstantinos Moulopoulos

We point out that two of the most important theorems of Quantum Mechanics, the Ehrenfest theorem and the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, lack in their standard form important information: there are cases where non-Hermitian boundary contributions emerge. These contributions actually appear naturally, in order for the above theorems to be valid and applicable (i.e. in multiply-connected spaces), and this occurs for physical quantities that are not represented by well-defined self-adjoint operators (such as the position operator in a periodic potential, or in general Aharonov-Bohm configurations, either in real or in an arbitrary parameter-space, in the sense of Berry's adiabatic and cyclic procedures). In this short note, we report modifications of these two theorems when such non-Hermiticities appear, and we demonstrate how they resolve certain Quantum Mechanical paradoxes (most of them having been noticed in the past as violations of the so-called Hypervirial theorem in Quantum Chemistry). This resolution of paradoxes (essentially the re-establishment of applicability of the Ehrenfest theorem even in multiply-connected spaces) always proceeds through the appearance of certain generalized currents, in a theoretical picture with interesting structure (where a generalized continuity equation with a sink term shows up naturally).

arXiv:1605.06534•IJEIR•May 17, 2016•6 citations

Hellmann-Feynman theorem in a mixed ensemble

Dhurba Rai

The Hellmann-Feynman theorem in a pure ensemble is extended to a quasidegenerate mixed ensemble (canonical) as an ensemble average value. The theorem is also extended to a grand canonical ensemble wherein average particle number is conserved. Connections with the thermodynamic observables are made. An approximate relation between $\ensuremath{\partial}{[\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{H}]}_{C}∕\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and $\ensuremath{\partial}{[\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{H}]}_{G}∕\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is established at the leading order of the saddle-point approximation.

Physical Review A•Mar 21, 2007•9 citations
Using the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, a general comparison theorem is established for an eigenvalue equation of the form (T+V)∣\ensuremathψ\ensuremath⟩=E∣\ensuremathψ\ensuremath⟩(T+V)|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}=E|\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremath{\rangle}(T+V)∣\ensuremathψ\ensuremath⟩=E∣\ensuremathψ\ensuremath⟩, where TTT is a kinetic part which depends only on momenta and VVV is a potential which depends only on positions. We assume that H(1)=T+V(1){H}^{(1)}=T+{V}^{(1)}H(1)=T+V(1) and H(2)=T+V(2){H}^{(2)}=T+{V}^{(2)}H(2)=T+V(2) (H(1)=T(1)+V{H}^{(1)}={T}^{(1)}+VH(1)=T(1)+V and H(2)=T(2)+V{H}^{(2)}={T}^{(2)}+VH(2)=T(2)+V) support both discrete eigenvalues E\ensuremathα(1){E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(1)}E\ensuremathα(1)​ and E\ensuremathα(2){E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(2)}E\ensuremathα(2)​, where \ensuremathα{\ensuremath{\alpha}}\ensuremathα represents a set of quantum numbers. We prove that, if V(1)\ensuremath⩽V(2){V}^{(1)}\ensuremath{\leqslant}{V}^{(2)}V(1)\ensuremath⩽V(2) (T(1)\ensuremath⩽T(2){T}^{(1)}\ensuremath{\leqslant}{T}^{(2)}T(1)\ensuremath⩽T(2)) for all position (momentum) variables, then the corresponding eigenvalues are ordered as E\ensuremathα(1)\ensuremath⩽E\ensuremathα(2){E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(1)}\ensuremath{\leqslant}{E}_{{\ensuremath{\alpha}}}^{(2)}E\ensuremathα(1)​\ensuremath⩽E\ensuremathα(2)​. Some analytical applications are given.
We revisit the celebrated Hellmann-Feynman theorem (HFT) in the parity-time (PT)(\mathcal{PT})(PT) invariant non-Hermitian quantum physics framework. We derive a modified version of HFT by changing the definition of inner product and explicitly show that it holds good for both PT\mathcal{PT}PT broken and unbroken phases and even at the exceptional point of the theory. The derivation is extremely general and works for even the PT\mathcal{PT}PT noninvariant Hamiltonian. We consider several examples of discrete and continuum variable systems to test our results. We find that, if the eigenvalue goes through a real-to-complex transition as a function of the Hermiticity breaking parameter, both sides of the modified HFT expression diverge at that point. If that point turns out to be an EP of the PT\mathcal{PT}PT-invariant quantum theory, then one also sees the divergence at EP. Moreover, we have also demonstrated that using the modified HFT can give rise to a potential numerical advantage for computing the expectation value of many-body operators for interacting many-body Hamiltonian. Finally, we also derive a generalized virial theorem for non-Hermitian systems using the modified HFT, which potentially can be tested in experiments.
Two discrete energy spectra of a particle moving in two different potential wells are compared. We find a general property: If one potential well V1{\mathit{V}}_{1}V1​(r) is less than or equal to the other potential well V2{\mathit{V}}_{2}V2​(r) everywhere in space, i.e., V1{\mathit{V}}_{1}V1​(r)\ensuremath{\le}V2{\mathit{V}}_{2}V2​(r) for all r, then the nth eigenvalue of the particle in the first well, V1{\mathit{V}}_{1}V1​, is always not greater than the nth eigenvalue of the particle in the second well, V2{\mathit{V}}_{2}V2​.
We point out that two of the most important theorems of Quantum Mechanics, the Ehrenfest theorem and the Hellmann-Feynman theorem, lack in their standard form important information: there are cases where non-Hermitian boundary contributions emerge. These contributions actually appear naturally, in order for the above theorems to be valid and applicable (i.e. in multiply-connected spaces), and this occurs for physical quantities that are not represented by well-defined self-adjoint operators (such as the position operator in a periodic potential, or in general Aharonov-Bohm configurations, either in real or in an arbitrary parameter-space, in the sense of Berry's adiabatic and cyclic procedures). In this short note, we report modifications of these two theorems when such non-Hermiticities appear, and we demonstrate how they resolve certain Quantum Mechanical paradoxes (most of them having been noticed in the past as violations of the so-called Hypervirial theorem in Quantum Chemistry). This resolution of paradoxes (essentially the re-establishment of applicability of the Ehrenfest theorem even in multiply-connected spaces) always proceeds through the appearance of certain generalized currents, in a theoretical picture with interesting structure (where a generalized continuity equation with a sink term shows up naturally).
The Hellmann-Feynman theorem in a pure ensemble is extended to a quasidegenerate mixed ensemble (canonical) as an ensemble average value. The theorem is also extended to a grand canonical ensemble wherein average particle number is conserved. Connections with the thermodynamic observables are made. An approximate relation between $\ensuremath{\partial}{[\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{H}]}_{C}∕\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and $\ensuremath{\partial}{[\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{H}]}_{G}∕\ensuremath{\partial}\ensuremath{\lambda}$ is established at the leading order of the saddle-point approximation.