Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1012.3532

Group theoretic formulation of complementarity

Joan A. Vaccaro

Published Dec 16, 2010• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We generalize Bohr's complementarity principle for wave and particle properties to arbitrary quantum systems. We begin by noting that a particle-like state is represented by a spatially-localized wave function and its narrow probability density is displaced by spatial translations. In contrast a wave-like state is represented by a spatially-delocalized wave function and the corresponding broad position probability density is invariant to spatial translations. The wave-particle dichotomy can therefore be seen as a competition between displacement and invariance of the state with respect to spatial translations. We generalize this dichotomy to arbitrary quantum systems with finite dimensional Hilbert spaces as follows. We use arbitrary finite symmetry groups to represent transformations of the quantum system. The symmetry (i.e. invariance) or asymmetry (i.e. displacement) of a given state with respect to transformations of the group are identified with the generalized wave and particle nature, respectively. We adopt a measure of wave and particle properties based on the amount of information that can be encoded in the symmetric and asymmetric parts of the state.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1012.3532

Related papers

Particle-wave duality: a dichotomy between symmetry and asymmetry

Joan A. Vaccaro

Symmetry plays a central role in many areas of modern physics. Here, we show that it also underpins the dual particle and wave nature of quantum systems. We begin by noting that a classical point particle breaks translational symmetry, whereas a wave with uniform amplitude does not. This provides a basis for associating particle nature with asymmetry and wave nature with symmetry. We derive expressions for the maximum amount of classical information we can have about the symmetry and asymmetry of a quantum system with respect to an arbitrary group. We find that the sum of the information about the symmetry (wave nature) and the asymmetry (particle nature) is bounded by , where D is the dimension of the Hilbert space. The combination of multiple systems is shown to exhibit greater symmetry and thus a more wavelike character. In particular, a class of entangled systems is shown to be capable of exhibiting wave-like symmetry as a whole while exhibiting particle-like asymmetry internally. We also show that superdense coding can be viewed as being essentially an interference phenomenon involving wave-like symmetry with respect to the group of Pauli operators.

arXiv:1105.0083•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Dec 7, 2011•27 citations

Coherence and complementarity in state-channel interaction

Shunlong Luo, Yuan Sun

While Bohr's complementarity principle constitutes a bedrock of quantum mechanics with profound implications, coherence, as a defining feature of the quantum realm originating from the superposition principle, pervades almost every quantum consideration. By exploiting the algebraic and geometric structure of state-channel interaction, we show that an information-theoretic measure of coherence and a quantitative symmetry-asymmetry complementarity emerge naturally from the formalism of quantum mechanics. This is achieved by decomposing the state-channel interaction into a symmetric part and an asymmetric part, which satisfy a conservation relation. The symmetric part is represented by the symmetric Jordan product, and the asymmetric part is synthesized by the skew-symmetric Lie product. The latter further leads to a significant extension of the celebrated Wigner--Yanase skew information, and has an operational interpretation as quantum coherence of a state with respect to a channel. This not only presents a basic and alternative framework for addressing complementarity, but also puts the study of coherence in a broad context involving channels. Fundamental properties of the symmetry-asymmetry complementarity are revealed, and applications and implications are illustrated via several prototypical channels as well as the Mach--Zehnder interferometry, in which the fringe visibility is linked to symmetry and the which-path is linked to asymmetry.

Physical Review A•Jul 11, 2018•112 citations

A Note on Quantum Theory, Complementarity, and Uncertainty

Paul Busch, PEKKA J. LAHTI

Uncertainty relations and complementarity of canonically conjugate position and momentum observables in quantum theory are discussed with respect to some general coupling properties of a function and its Fourier transform. The question of joint localization of a particle on bounded position and momentum value sets and the relevance of this question to the interpretation of position-momentum uncertainty relations is surveyed. In particular, it is argued that the Heisenberg interpretation of the uncertainty relations can consistently be carried through in a natural extension of the usual Hilbert space frame of the quantum theory.

Philosophy of Science•Mar 1, 1985•24 citations

The State of a System

Uri Peskin

According to the postulates of quantum mechanics, the state of a system is associated with a wave function that contains any measurable information on the system at any time. In this chapter we become familiar with wave functions and how they represent the position of particles within the system. Within the realm of quantum mechanics, the position of particles is not deterministic. It is defined by a probability distribution. The wave function is a position-dependent complex-valued amplitude, whose absolute value squared is identified with the probability density for locating the particle in the position space. This identification of the wave function with a probability amplitude imposes some limitation. Particularly, for a closed system in which the particles are bound, the wave function must be proper (square integrable) and normalizable. These properties are discussed and demonstrated for different coordinate systems.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations

Quantum coherence with incomplete set of pointers and corresponding wave-particle duality

Ingita Banerjee, Kornikar Sen, Chirag Srivastava +1 more

Quantum coherence quantifies the amount of superposition in a quantum system, and is the reason and resource behind several phenomena and technologies. It depends on the natural basis in which the quantum state of the system is expressed, which in turn hinges on the physical set-up being analyzed and utilized. While quantum coherence has hitherto been conceptualized by employing different categories of complete bases, there do exist interesting physical situations, where the natural basis is an incomplete one, an example being an interferometric set-up with the observer controlling only a certain fraction of all the slits. We introduce a quantification of quantum coherence with respect to an arbitrary incomplete basis for general quantum states, and develop the corresponding resource theory, identifying the free states and operations. Moreover, we obtain a complementarity relation between the so-defined quantum coherence and the which-path information in an interferometric set-up with several slits, of which only a section is in control of the observer or is accessible to her. This therefore provides us with another face of the wave-particle duality in quantum systems, demonstrating that the complementarity is functional in more general set-ups than thus far considered.

arXiv:2108.05849•Aug 12, 2021•5 citations

An updated quantum complementarity principle

Diego S. Starke, Marcos L. W. Basso, Jonas Maziero

Bohr’s complementarity principle has long been a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics, positing that, within a given experimental set-up, a quantum system (or quanton) can exhibit either its wave-like character, denoted as W , or its particle-like character, denoted as P , but not both simultaneously. Modern interpretations of Bohr’s complementarity principle acknowledge the coexistence of these aspects in the same experiment while introducing the constraint W + P ≤ α . Notably, estimations of W or P frequently rely on indirect retrodiction methods, a practice that has led to the claim of the violation of Bohr’s complementarity principle. By taking a different route, recent advancements demonstrate that quantum complementarity relations can be rigorously derived from the axioms of quantum mechanics. To reconcile these observations and eliminate potential paradoxes or violations, we propose an updated formulation for the quantum complementarity principle, which is stated as follows: For a given quantum state preparation ρ t at a specific instant of time t , the wave and particle behaviours of a quanton are constrained by a complementarity relation 𝔚 ( ρ t ) + 𝔓 ( ρ t ) ≤ α ( d ) , which is derived directly from the axioms of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2312.02743•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 1, 2024•13 citations
We generalize Bohr's complementarity principle for wave and particle properties to arbitrary quantum systems. We begin by noting that a particle-like state is represented by a spatially-localized wave function and its narrow probability density is displaced by spatial translations. In contrast a wave-like state is represented by a spatially-delocalized wave function and the corresponding broad position probability density is invariant to spatial translations. The wave-particle dichotomy can therefore be seen as a competition between displacement and invariance of the state with respect to spatial translations. We generalize this dichotomy to arbitrary quantum systems with finite dimensional Hilbert spaces as follows. We use arbitrary finite symmetry groups to represent transformations of the quantum system. The symmetry (i.e. invariance) or asymmetry (i.e. displacement) of a given state with respect to transformations of the group are identified with the generalized wave and particle nature, respectively. We adopt a measure of wave and particle properties based on the amount of information that can be encoded in the symmetric and asymmetric parts of the state.
Symmetry plays a central role in many areas of modern physics. Here, we show that it also underpins the dual particle and wave nature of quantum systems. We begin by noting that a classical point particle breaks translational symmetry, whereas a wave with uniform amplitude does not. This provides a basis for associating particle nature with asymmetry and wave nature with symmetry. We derive expressions for the maximum amount of classical information we can have about the symmetry and asymmetry of a quantum system with respect to an arbitrary group. We find that the sum of the information about the symmetry (wave nature) and the asymmetry (particle nature) is bounded by , where D is the dimension of the Hilbert space. The combination of multiple systems is shown to exhibit greater symmetry and thus a more wavelike character. In particular, a class of entangled systems is shown to be capable of exhibiting wave-like symmetry as a whole while exhibiting particle-like asymmetry internally. We also show that superdense coding can be viewed as being essentially an interference phenomenon involving wave-like symmetry with respect to the group of Pauli operators.
While Bohr's complementarity principle constitutes a bedrock of quantum mechanics with profound implications, coherence, as a defining feature of the quantum realm originating from the superposition principle, pervades almost every quantum consideration. By exploiting the algebraic and geometric structure of state-channel interaction, we show that an information-theoretic measure of coherence and a quantitative symmetry-asymmetry complementarity emerge naturally from the formalism of quantum mechanics. This is achieved by decomposing the state-channel interaction into a symmetric part and an asymmetric part, which satisfy a conservation relation. The symmetric part is represented by the symmetric Jordan product, and the asymmetric part is synthesized by the skew-symmetric Lie product. The latter further leads to a significant extension of the celebrated Wigner--Yanase skew information, and has an operational interpretation as quantum coherence of a state with respect to a channel. This not only presents a basic and alternative framework for addressing complementarity, but also puts the study of coherence in a broad context involving channels. Fundamental properties of the symmetry-asymmetry complementarity are revealed, and applications and implications are illustrated via several prototypical channels as well as the Mach--Zehnder interferometry, in which the fringe visibility is linked to symmetry and the which-path is linked to asymmetry.
Uncertainty relations and complementarity of canonically conjugate position and momentum observables in quantum theory are discussed with respect to some general coupling properties of a function and its Fourier transform. The question of joint localization of a particle on bounded position and momentum value sets and the relevance of this question to the interpretation of position-momentum uncertainty relations is surveyed. In particular, it is argued that the Heisenberg interpretation of the uncertainty relations can consistently be carried through in a natural extension of the usual Hilbert space frame of the quantum theory.
According to the postulates of quantum mechanics, the state of a system is associated with a wave function that contains any measurable information on the system at any time. In this chapter we become familiar with wave functions and how they represent the position of particles within the system. Within the realm of quantum mechanics, the position of particles is not deterministic. It is defined by a probability distribution. The wave function is a position-dependent complex-valued amplitude, whose absolute value squared is identified with the probability density for locating the particle in the position space. This identification of the wave function with a probability amplitude imposes some limitation. Particularly, for a closed system in which the particles are bound, the wave function must be proper (square integrable) and normalizable. These properties are discussed and demonstrated for different coordinate systems.
Quantum coherence quantifies the amount of superposition in a quantum system, and is the reason and resource behind several phenomena and technologies. It depends on the natural basis in which the quantum state of the system is expressed, which in turn hinges on the physical set-up being analyzed and utilized. While quantum coherence has hitherto been conceptualized by employing different categories of complete bases, there do exist interesting physical situations, where the natural basis is an incomplete one, an example being an interferometric set-up with the observer controlling only a certain fraction of all the slits. We introduce a quantification of quantum coherence with respect to an arbitrary incomplete basis for general quantum states, and develop the corresponding resource theory, identifying the free states and operations. Moreover, we obtain a complementarity relation between the so-defined quantum coherence and the which-path information in an interferometric set-up with several slits, of which only a section is in control of the observer or is accessible to her. This therefore provides us with another face of the wave-particle duality in quantum systems, demonstrating that the complementarity is functional in more general set-ups than thus far considered.
Bohr’s complementarity principle has long been a fundamental concept in quantum mechanics, positing that, within a given experimental set-up, a quantum system (or quanton) can exhibit either its wave-like character, denoted as W , or its particle-like character, denoted as P , but not both simultaneously. Modern interpretations of Bohr’s complementarity principle acknowledge the coexistence of these aspects in the same experiment while introducing the constraint W + P ≤ α . Notably, estimations of W or P frequently rely on indirect retrodiction methods, a practice that has led to the claim of the violation of Bohr’s complementarity principle. By taking a different route, recent advancements demonstrate that quantum complementarity relations can be rigorously derived from the axioms of quantum mechanics. To reconcile these observations and eliminate potential paradoxes or violations, we propose an updated formulation for the quantum complementarity principle, which is stated as follows: For a given quantum state preparation ρ t at a specific instant of time t , the wave and particle behaviours of a quanton are constrained by a complementarity relation 𝔚 ( ρ t ) + 𝔓 ( ρ t ) ≤ α ( d ) , which is derived directly from the axioms of quantum mechanics.