Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1011.6448 · Physical Review Letters

Does Ignorance of the Whole Imply Ignorance of the Parts? Large Violations of Noncontextuality in Quantum Theory

Thomas Vidick, Stephanie Wehner

Published Jul 13, 2011• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A central question in our understanding of the physical world is how our knowledge of the whole relates to our knowledge of the individual parts. One aspect of this question is the following: to what extent does ignorance about a whole preclude knowledge of at least one of its parts? Relying purely on classical intuition, one would certainly be inclined to conjecture that a strong ignorance of the whole cannot come without significant ignorance of at least one of its parts. Indeed, we show that this reasoning holds in any noncontextual (NC) hidden-variable model (HV). Curiously, however, such a conjecture is false in quantum theory: we provide an explicit example where a large ignorance about the whole can coexist with an almost perfect knowledge of each of its parts. More specifically, we provide a simple information-theoretic inequality satisfied in any NC HV, but which can be arbitrarily violated by quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.107.030402

Related papers

Hiding Ignorance Using High Dimensions

Michael J. Kewming, Sally Shrapnel, Andrew G. White +1 more

The absence of information-entirely or partly-is called ignorance. Naturally, one might ask if some ignorance of a whole system will imply some ignorance of its parts. Our classical intuition tells us yes, however quantum theory tells us no: it is possible to encode information in a quantum system so that despite some ignorance of the whole, it is impossible to identify the unknown part [T. Vidick and S. Wehner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 030402 (2011).PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.107.030402]. Experimentally verifying this counterintuitive fact requires controlling and measuring quantum systems of high dimension (d>9). We provide this experimental evidence using the transverse spatial modes of light, a powerful resource for testing high-dimensional quantum phenomena.

arXiv:1903.09487•Physical Review Letters•Jun 22, 2020•11 citations

Identity, wholes, and parts in quantum mechanics

Gregg S. Jaeger

The most natural realist view of the physical world is one of independently existing bodies. The question of how one might yet represent quantum systems realistically, given its indeterministic nature and the presence of locally inexplicable distant correlations associated with entanglement, has continued to be central to the investigation of the foundations of quantum theory. Underlying the question is the grounding of individuality, which relates also to the relationship between wholes and parts. These issues and some recent attempts to address them are discussed here.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Identity, Wholes, and Parts in Quantum Mechanics

Gregg S. Jaeger, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Gregg S. Jaeger +2 more

The most natural realist view of the physical world is one of independently existing bodies. The question of how one might yet represent quantum systems realistically, given its indeterministic nature and the presence of locally inexplicable distant correlations associated with entanglement, has continued to be central to the investigation of the foundations of quantum theory. Underlying the question is the grounding of individuality, which relates also to the relationship between wholes and parts. These issues and some recent attempts to address them are discussed here.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Universality of State-Independent Violation of Correlation Inequalities for Noncontextual Theories

Piotr Badziąg, Ingemar Bengtsson, Adán Cabello +1 more

We show that the state-independent violation of inequalities for noncontextual hidden variable theories introduced in [Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 210401 (2008)] is universal, i.e., occurs for any quantum mechanical system in which noncontextuality is meaningful. We describe a method to obtain state-independent violations for any system of dimension d> or =3. This universality proves that, according to quantum mechanics, there are no "classical" states.

arXiv:0809.0430•Physical Review Letters•Jul 28, 2009•113 citations

Hidden Variables: Ontology/Epistemology & Contextuality/Non-Classicality

Fred Alan Wolf; Have Brains / Will Travel

What does quantum physics tell us about the nature of reality, specifically the parts of reality we do not directly perceive called hidden variables? One may think it could tell us a lot because of our enhanced technological sensing abilities that delve into the realms that quantum physics covers so well. Surprisingly, it seems to surround us in a deeper mystery rather than reveal more of nature's secrets. It seems that we cannot escape from philosophical consideration when dealing with what is hidden in quantum physics. In Part I we will look at how Epistemology and Ontology bear upon Hidden Variables. In Part II we will consider Hidden Variables in the light of Contextuality, and Non-Classicality. Inevitably questions of subjectivity and objectivity arise in dealing with states of observation. How should we think about these states? Perhaps it is a question of the meaning associated with our knowledge of a state-that is, a question of ontology or epistemology. The issue of ontic and epistemic states is particularly important when considering hidden variables in quantum physics because, as one may argue, the interpretation of quantum states as either ontic or epistemic will naturally lead to different assumptions about how reality is constructed; if it is constructed or not. It also raises the question of what attributes we are able to observe simultaneously and that brings contextuality into the discussion. If it turns out that reality is constructed contextually what does that imply about ontological realism? If on the other hand reality is constructed non-contextually what does that imply about ontological realism? Many implications can arise when considering these questions from a quantum physical point of view. In this paper I shall discuss how quantum physics provides some answers to these questions by considering quantum physical states and their measurements.

Cosmos and history•Aug 25, 2018•0 citations

Contextual hidden variables theories and Bell's Inequalities

Abner Shimony

Noncontextual hidden variables theories, assigning simultaneous values to all quantum mechanical observables, are inconsistent by theorems of Gleason and others. These theorems do not exclude contextual hidden variables theories, in which a complete state assigns values to physical quantities only relative to contexts. However, any contextual theory obeying a certain factorisability condition implies one of Bell's Inequalities, thereby precluding complete agreement with quantum mechanical predictions. The present paper distinguishes two kinds of contextual theories, ‘algebraic’ and ‘environmental’, and investigates when factorisability is reasonable. Some statements by Fine about the philosophical significance of Bell's Inequalities are then assessed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•3 citations
A central question in our understanding of the physical world is how our knowledge of the whole relates to our knowledge of the individual parts. One aspect of this question is the following: to what extent does ignorance about a whole preclude knowledge of at least one of its parts? Relying purely on classical intuition, one would certainly be inclined to conjecture that a strong ignorance of the whole cannot come without significant ignorance of at least one of its parts. Indeed, we show that this reasoning holds in any noncontextual (NC) hidden-variable model (HV). Curiously, however, such a conjecture is false in quantum theory: we provide an explicit example where a large ignorance about the whole can coexist with an almost perfect knowledge of each of its parts. More specifically, we provide a simple information-theoretic inequality satisfied in any NC HV, but which can be arbitrarily violated by quantum mechanics.
The absence of information-entirely or partly-is called ignorance. Naturally, one might ask if some ignorance of a whole system will imply some ignorance of its parts. Our classical intuition tells us yes, however quantum theory tells us no: it is possible to encode information in a quantum system so that despite some ignorance of the whole, it is impossible to identify the unknown part [T. Vidick and S. Wehner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 030402 (2011).PRLTAO0031-900710.1103/PhysRevLett.107.030402]. Experimentally verifying this counterintuitive fact requires controlling and measuring quantum systems of high dimension (d>9). We provide this experimental evidence using the transverse spatial modes of light, a powerful resource for testing high-dimensional quantum phenomena.
The most natural realist view of the physical world is one of independently existing bodies. The question of how one might yet represent quantum systems realistically, given its indeterministic nature and the presence of locally inexplicable distant correlations associated with entanglement, has continued to be central to the investigation of the foundations of quantum theory. Underlying the question is the grounding of individuality, which relates also to the relationship between wholes and parts. These issues and some recent attempts to address them are discussed here.
The most natural realist view of the physical world is one of independently existing bodies. The question of how one might yet represent quantum systems realistically, given its indeterministic nature and the presence of locally inexplicable distant correlations associated with entanglement, has continued to be central to the investigation of the foundations of quantum theory. Underlying the question is the grounding of individuality, which relates also to the relationship between wholes and parts. These issues and some recent attempts to address them are discussed here.
What does quantum physics tell us about the nature of reality, specifically the parts of reality we do not directly perceive called hidden variables? One may think it could tell us a lot because of our enhanced technological sensing abilities that delve into the realms that quantum physics covers so well. Surprisingly, it seems to surround us in a deeper mystery rather than reveal more of nature's secrets. It seems that we cannot escape from philosophical consideration when dealing with what is hidden in quantum physics. In Part I we will look at how Epistemology and Ontology bear upon Hidden Variables. In Part II we will consider Hidden Variables in the light of Contextuality, and Non-Classicality. Inevitably questions of subjectivity and objectivity arise in dealing with states of observation. How should we think about these states? Perhaps it is a question of the meaning associated with our knowledge of a state-that is, a question of ontology or epistemology. The issue of ontic and epistemic states is particularly important when considering hidden variables in quantum physics because, as one may argue, the interpretation of quantum states as either ontic or epistemic will naturally lead to different assumptions about how reality is constructed; if it is constructed or not. It also raises the question of what attributes we are able to observe simultaneously and that brings contextuality into the discussion. If it turns out that reality is constructed contextually what does that imply about ontological realism? If on the other hand reality is constructed non-contextually what does that imply about ontological realism? Many implications can arise when considering these questions from a quantum physical point of view. In this paper I shall discuss how quantum physics provides some answers to these questions by considering quantum physical states and their measurements.
Noncontextual hidden variables theories, assigning simultaneous values to all quantum mechanical observables, are inconsistent by theorems of Gleason and others. These theorems do not exclude contextual hidden variables theories, in which a complete state assigns values to physical quantities only relative to contexts. However, any contextual theory obeying a certain factorisability condition implies one of Bell's Inequalities, thereby precluding complete agreement with quantum mechanical predictions. The present paper distinguishes two kinds of contextual theories, ‘algebraic’ and ‘environmental’, and investigates when factorisability is reasonable. Some statements by Fine about the philosophical significance of Bell's Inequalities are then assessed.