A major problem facing no-collapse interpretations of quantum mechanics in the tradition of Everett is how to understand the probabilistic axiom of quantum mechanics (the Born rule) in the context of a deterministic theory in which every outcome of a measurement occurs. Deutsch claims to derive a decision-theoretic analogue of the Born rule from the non-probabilistic part of quantum mechanics and some non-probabilistic axioms of classical decision theory, and hence concludes that no probabilistic axiom is needed. I argue that Deutsch’s derivation begs the question.
This paper derives the complete mathematical structure of quantum mechanics—complex Hilbert spaces, unitary evolution, and Born-rule probabilities—from five information-theoretic axioms, without assuming quantum mechanics at the outset. Starting from an ontology of microhistories (fully specified microscopic trajectories), we define branches as equivalence classes of operationally indistinguishable microhistories. We then show that five physically motivated constraints on how information is stored, mixed, and transformed uniquely force the effective state space to be a complex projective space with unitary dynamics.
We derive finite-dimensional quantum mechanics from a single ontological principle, that \emph{existence is constituted by distinguishability}, together with two structural commitments: finite capacity
N (parametric input) and self-referential consistency (SRC, a closure schema with two equivalent forms, operational and information-theoretic). SRC unpacks into eight derived structural conditions; structural unambiguity (S5) completes the hierarchy, uniquely selecting the Born rule as the geometric/probabilistic closure. The graded distinguishability kernel
K(x,y)∈[0,1] realises both axioms, with a state constituted by its
K-profile against all others. For each
N≥3, the unique distinguishability space is
(CPN−1,K) with
K(ψ,φ)=1−∣⟨ψ∣φ⟩∣2, from which complex coefficients, the Born rule
pk=∣ck∣2, unitary dynamics, and tensor-product composition all follow. Indeterminism is forced by capacity overflow; alternatives (e.g. Bohmian mechanics) are classified rather than refuted. Standard QM is the
N→∞ limit; finite
N is the only free parameter. The algebraic spine is machine-checked in Lean 4 modulo five imported classical theorems and the existence direction of Stone's theorem; the Appendix states the verification scope.
"This paper derives the complex Hilbert space structure and Born rule of quantum mechanics from five information-theoretic axioms governing coarse-grained microhistory branches. No quantum structure is assumed; linearity, complex numbers, unitary dynamics, and Born probabilities all emerge from constraints on how operational information can be stored, transformed, and composed. The reconstruction is independent of any specific microscopic model but naturally accommodates microhistory ontologies indexed by various ordering parameters (physical time, relational clocks, scalar fields)."