Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1009.5953 · Classical and Quantum Gravity

An effective approach to the problem of time

Martin Bojowald A, Philipp A. Höhn, Artur Tsobanjan

Published Jan 11, 2011• 132 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A practical way to deal with the problem of time in quantum cosmology and quantum gravity is proposed. The main tool is effective equations, which mainly restrict explicit considerations to semiclassical regimes but have the crucial advantage of allowing the consistent use of local internal times in non-deparameterizable systems. Different local internal times are related merely by gauge transformations, thereby enabling relational evolution through turning points of non-global internal times. The main consequence of the local nature of internal time is the necessity of its complex-valuedness, reminiscent of but more general than non-unitarity of evolution defined for finite ranges of time. By several general arguments, the consistency of this setting is demonstrated. Finally, we attempt an outlook on the nature of time in highly quantum regimes. The focus of this note is on conceptual issues.

DOI
10.1088/0264-9381/28/3/035006

Related papers

Effective approach to the problem of time: General features and examples

Martin Bojowald A, Philipp A. Höhn, Artur Tsobanjan

The effective approach to quantum dynamics allows a reformulation of the Dirac quantization procedure for constrained systems in terms of an infinite-dimensional constrained system of classical type. For semiclassical approximations, the quantum constrained system can be truncated to finite size and solved by the reduced phase space or gauge-fixing methods. In particular, the classical feasibility of local internal times is directly generalized to quantum systems, overcoming the main difficulties associated with the general problem of time in the semiclassical realm. The key features of local internal times and the procedure of patching global solutions using overlapping intervals of local internal times are described and illustrated by two quantum mechanical examples. Relational evolution in a given choice of internal time is most conveniently described and interpreted in a corresponding choice of gauge at the effective level and changing the internal clock is, therefore, essentially achieved by a gauge transformation. This article complements the conceptual discussion in [M. Bojowald, P. A. H\"ohn, and A. Tsobanjan, Classical Quantum Gravity 28, 035006 (2011).].

arXiv:1011.3040•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 21, 2011•125 citations

Relational Emergent Time for Quantum System: A Multi-Observer, Gravitational, and Cosmological Framework

Amir Hossein Ghasemi

We present a relational framework in which temporal structure is not fundamental but emerges from correlations within a globally stationary quantum state. Each subsystem includes an internal clock, and conditional states evolve effectively with respect to these internal readings. The construction naturally extends to relativistic motion, gravitational redshift, and cosmological expansion, leading to a unified emergent-time functional valid across diverse physical regimes. The theory reproduces classical time dilation, predicts correlation-dependent deviations from standard evolution, and suggests that non-interacting or massless particles exhibit negligible internal time. These consequences open directions for conceptual and experimental investigations in the foundations of temporal physics, from multi-clock quantum systems to precision metrology and cosmological settings. In particular, the framework suggests measurable deviation from standard quantum evolution for highly entangled systems and predicts negligible internal time for massless particles.

quant-pharXiv:2512.15789•Dec 17, 2025•3 citations

External Time or Emergent Time UCL

Iker Ibarrola Echeverría

This paper develops a consistent and self-contained formulation of external (physical) time as an emergent quantity, arising from the internal temporal evolution of correlational sites within the Universal Correlational Lattice (UCL) framework. Rather than assuming time as a fundamental background parameter, the theory distinguishes between: Internal times, defined locally at each correlational site through intrinsic dynamical evolution, and External time, which emerges relationally from the synchronization, ordering, and stability of correlations among multiple sites. The work formalizes how a coherent, observer-independent notion of temporal flow can arise without postulating a pre-existing global clock. External time is shown to correspond to a coarse-grained, effective parameter that captures persistent, ordered correlations across the correlational network, while remaining compatible with regimes where no global time is well-defined. Key results include: A precise definition of temporal evolution along internal time without reference to external time units. The emergence of a one-parameter effective temporal ordering from correlational dynamics. A clear separation between pre-geometric (timeless or multi-temporal) regimes and geometric regimes where an effective spacetime description becomes valid. Conceptual and mathematical consistency with relativistic causality, decoherence, and macroscopic temporal stability. This framework provides a natural resolution to longstanding tensions between quantum theory and general relativity regarding the status of time, without invoking collapse postulates or external observers. Time is not fundamental, but real and physical as an emergent, relational structure. The paper is intended for researchers interested in foundational questions of time, quantum gravity, emergent spacetime, and relational approaches to physics.

•Dec 19, 2025•0 citations

Time and causality in quantum gravity

Charis Anastopoulos

The problem of time in quantum gravity is often presented as a consequence of applying quantum theory to general relativity. These notes adopt a broader perspective. We first examine how time enters classical mechanics, relativity, quantum theory, and quantum field theory, distinguishing three principal aspects: causal order, temporal duration, and the present. This analysis shows that the conceptual difficulties associated with time do not arise only when gravity is quantised. Tensions between causal structure, clocks, observables, and measurement are already present in the theories from which quantum gravity is constructed. We then survey responses to the problem of time across the principal approaches to quantum gravity. These include canonical and Wheeler-DeWitt quantisation, path-integral and histories formulations, perturbative and background-dependent approaches, causal sets, and twistor theory. The programmes are compared according to whether they retain an external time, render time problematic through quantisation, or incorporate causal or temporal structure into their foundations. Particular emphasis is placed on questions arising from quantum foundations and relativistic quantum information. We conclude by examining linearised gravity and weak-gravity quantum systems. This regime shows that the problem of time is not confined to Planck-scale physics, but arises already in attempts to provide a predictive and operationally meaningful quantum description of spacetime near flat geometry.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2609.22890•Sep 22, 2026

Phenomenology, decoherence, and the arrow of time

Claus Kiefer

This final chapter starts with a brief review of quantum-gravity phenomenology. It then focuses on an important conceptual issue – the relevance of quantum gravity for the general interpretation of quantum theory. A central part is devoted to the discussion of the quantum-to-classical transition, with decoherence as its crucial mechanism. It is shown that the quantum states used in cosmology can be interpreted in a sensible way. The chapter also contains a discussion of the arrow of time in the light of quantum cosmology and ends with a brief outlook and reflections.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Apr 19, 2012•0 citations

Time and Quantum Clocks: A Review of Recent Developments

M. B. Altaie, Daniel Hodgson, Almut Beige

In this review we present the problem of time in quantum physics, including a short history of the problem and the known objections about considering time as a quantum observable. The need to deal with time as an observable is elaborated through some unresolved problems. The lack of a consistent theory of time is currently hindering the formulation of a full-fledged theory of quantum gravity. It is argued that the proposal set forth by several authors of considering an intrinsic measurement of quantum time, besides having the conventional external time, is compelling. Recently several suggestions have been put forward to revive the proposal of Page and Wootters (1983), elaborating and resolving some of the main ambiguities of the original proposal and opening new scope for understanding its content. The approach followed in these new contributions exposes the need to go beyond the limitations enforced by the conventional approach of quantum physics. The attitude of covariant loop quantum gravity, in which it is called to completely ignore time, is also discussed. This review could be a step forward in an endeavour to reform our outlook of the unification of the theory of relativity and quantum physics by furnishing the conceptual ground needed for this goal. Intentionally, some technical details are avoided since we aim to present the approaches to resolve the problem in a simple way with the clearest possible outlook. These can be looked up in the original references provided.

arXiv:2203.12564•Frontiers in Physics•Jun 3, 2022•40 citations
A practical way to deal with the problem of time in quantum cosmology and quantum gravity is proposed. The main tool is effective equations, which mainly restrict explicit considerations to semiclassical regimes but have the crucial advantage of allowing the consistent use of local internal times in non-deparameterizable systems. Different local internal times are related merely by gauge transformations, thereby enabling relational evolution through turning points of non-global internal times. The main consequence of the local nature of internal time is the necessity of its complex-valuedness, reminiscent of but more general than non-unitarity of evolution defined for finite ranges of time. By several general arguments, the consistency of this setting is demonstrated. Finally, we attempt an outlook on the nature of time in highly quantum regimes. The focus of this note is on conceptual issues.
The effective approach to quantum dynamics allows a reformulation of the Dirac quantization procedure for constrained systems in terms of an infinite-dimensional constrained system of classical type. For semiclassical approximations, the quantum constrained system can be truncated to finite size and solved by the reduced phase space or gauge-fixing methods. In particular, the classical feasibility of local internal times is directly generalized to quantum systems, overcoming the main difficulties associated with the general problem of time in the semiclassical realm. The key features of local internal times and the procedure of patching global solutions using overlapping intervals of local internal times are described and illustrated by two quantum mechanical examples. Relational evolution in a given choice of internal time is most conveniently described and interpreted in a corresponding choice of gauge at the effective level and changing the internal clock is, therefore, essentially achieved by a gauge transformation. This article complements the conceptual discussion in [M. Bojowald, P. A. H\"ohn, and A. Tsobanjan, Classical Quantum Gravity 28, 035006 (2011).].
We present a relational framework in which temporal structure is not fundamental but emerges from correlations within a globally stationary quantum state. Each subsystem includes an internal clock, and conditional states evolve effectively with respect to these internal readings. The construction naturally extends to relativistic motion, gravitational redshift, and cosmological expansion, leading to a unified emergent-time functional valid across diverse physical regimes. The theory reproduces classical time dilation, predicts correlation-dependent deviations from standard evolution, and suggests that non-interacting or massless particles exhibit negligible internal time. These consequences open directions for conceptual and experimental investigations in the foundations of temporal physics, from multi-clock quantum systems to precision metrology and cosmological settings. In particular, the framework suggests measurable deviation from standard quantum evolution for highly entangled systems and predicts negligible internal time for massless particles.
This paper develops a consistent and self-contained formulation of external (physical) time as an emergent quantity, arising from the internal temporal evolution of correlational sites within the Universal Correlational Lattice (UCL) framework. Rather than assuming time as a fundamental background parameter, the theory distinguishes between: Internal times, defined locally at each correlational site through intrinsic dynamical evolution, and External time, which emerges relationally from the synchronization, ordering, and stability of correlations among multiple sites. The work formalizes how a coherent, observer-independent notion of temporal flow can arise without postulating a pre-existing global clock. External time is shown to correspond to a coarse-grained, effective parameter that captures persistent, ordered correlations across the correlational network, while remaining compatible with regimes where no global time is well-defined. Key results include: A precise definition of temporal evolution along internal time without reference to external time units. The emergence of a one-parameter effective temporal ordering from correlational dynamics. A clear separation between pre-geometric (timeless or multi-temporal) regimes and geometric regimes where an effective spacetime description becomes valid. Conceptual and mathematical consistency with relativistic causality, decoherence, and macroscopic temporal stability. This framework provides a natural resolution to longstanding tensions between quantum theory and general relativity regarding the status of time, without invoking collapse postulates or external observers. Time is not fundamental, but real and physical as an emergent, relational structure. The paper is intended for researchers interested in foundational questions of time, quantum gravity, emergent spacetime, and relational approaches to physics.
The problem of time in quantum gravity is often presented as a consequence of applying quantum theory to general relativity. These notes adopt a broader perspective. We first examine how time enters classical mechanics, relativity, quantum theory, and quantum field theory, distinguishing three principal aspects: causal order, temporal duration, and the present. This analysis shows that the conceptual difficulties associated with time do not arise only when gravity is quantised. Tensions between causal structure, clocks, observables, and measurement are already present in the theories from which quantum gravity is constructed. We then survey responses to the problem of time across the principal approaches to quantum gravity. These include canonical and Wheeler-DeWitt quantisation, path-integral and histories formulations, perturbative and background-dependent approaches, causal sets, and twistor theory. The programmes are compared according to whether they retain an external time, render time problematic through quantisation, or incorporate causal or temporal structure into their foundations. Particular emphasis is placed on questions arising from quantum foundations and relativistic quantum information. We conclude by examining linearised gravity and weak-gravity quantum systems. This regime shows that the problem of time is not confined to Planck-scale physics, but arises already in attempts to provide a predictive and operationally meaningful quantum description of spacetime near flat geometry.
This final chapter starts with a brief review of quantum-gravity phenomenology. It then focuses on an important conceptual issue – the relevance of quantum gravity for the general interpretation of quantum theory. A central part is devoted to the discussion of the quantum-to-classical transition, with decoherence as its crucial mechanism. It is shown that the quantum states used in cosmology can be interpreted in a sensible way. The chapter also contains a discussion of the arrow of time in the light of quantum cosmology and ends with a brief outlook and reflections.
In this review we present the problem of time in quantum physics, including a short history of the problem and the known objections about considering time as a quantum observable. The need to deal with time as an observable is elaborated through some unresolved problems. The lack of a consistent theory of time is currently hindering the formulation of a full-fledged theory of quantum gravity. It is argued that the proposal set forth by several authors of considering an intrinsic measurement of quantum time, besides having the conventional external time, is compelling. Recently several suggestions have been put forward to revive the proposal of Page and Wootters (1983), elaborating and resolving some of the main ambiguities of the original proposal and opening new scope for understanding its content. The approach followed in these new contributions exposes the need to go beyond the limitations enforced by the conventional approach of quantum physics. The attitude of covariant loop quantum gravity, in which it is called to completely ignore time, is also discussed. This review could be a step forward in an endeavour to reform our outlook of the unification of the theory of relativity and quantum physics by furnishing the conceptual ground needed for this goal. Intentionally, some technical details are avoided since we aim to present the approaches to resolve the problem in a simple way with the clearest possible outlook. These can be looked up in the original references provided.