Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1006.3197 · Journal of Computational and Theoretical Nanoscience

Double-Slit and Electromagnetic Models to Complete Quantum Mechanics

Jayme De Luca

Published Mar 23, 2011• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We analyze a realistic microscopic model for electronic scattering with the neutral differential delay equations of motion of point charges of the Wheeler-Feynman electrodynamics. We propose a microscopic model according to the electrodynamics of point charges, complex enough to describe the essential physics. Our microscopic model reaches a simple qualitative agreement with the experimental results as regards interference in double-slit scattering and in electronic scattering by crystals. We discuss our model in the light of existing experimental results, including a qualitative disagreement found for the double-slit experiment. We discuss an approximation for the complex neutral differential delay equations of our model using piecewise-defined (discontinuous) velocities for all charges and piecewise-constant-velocities for the scattered charge. Our approximation predicts the De Broglie wavelength as an inverse function of the incoming velocity and in the correct order of magnitude. We explain the scattering by crystals in the light of the same simplified modeling with Einstein-local interactions. We include a discussion of the qualitative properties of the neutral-delay-equations of electrodynamics to stimulate future experimental tests on the possibility to complete quantum mechanics with electromagnetic models.

DOI
10.1166/jctn.2011.1782

Related papers

A Unified Physical Mechanism of Electron Single-Slit and Double-Slit Diffraction Based on Electromagnetic Interaction and Particle Exchange at Slit Walls

Jiaqing Yan

The mainstream quantum mechanics uses “probability wave superposition and single-electron self-interference” to explain electron single-slit and double-slit diffraction. This theory deviates from the essential nature of real particle interactions and has fundamental logical flaws. The electron is a negatively charged real particle with a definite physical size and high-frequency transverse oscillation; a single real particle has no physical basis for self-interference. Abandoning the abstract probability wave hypothesis, this paper establishes a complete real-interaction model including electrostatic repulsion deflection, surface electron exchange, collision scattering, microscopic refraction, and barrier diffraction, based on the three-dimensional random transverse oscillation and charge repulsion of electrons. The model uniformly explains the real formation mechanism of electron single-slit diffraction and double-slit interference fringes. This paper proves that in single-electron sequential emission, each electron passes through only one slit; all bright and dark fringes are the statistical result of multiple microscopic interactions between electrons and slit walls or the central barrier. The disappearance of fringes under observation is caused by external disturbance to the inherent oscillation and wall-interaction equilibrium, not by wave function collapse. This paper further clarifies that whether an electron can pass through a slit is determined by its transverse oscillation amplitude, not by wavelength. Amplitude directly corresponds to slit width and is the core controlling variable of diffraction. Meanwhile, if no slit is placed, electrons flying directly to the screen produce no diffraction or interference fringes, proving that electrons themselves have no self-interference ability. Fringes are generated by slit structures, not by intrinsic wave interference of electrons. This study corrects the century-long misunderstanding of electron diffraction and establishes a new microscopic diffraction mechanism consistent with classical real-particle physics.

•May 30, 2026•0 citations

On the two-slit interference experiment with electrons : a theoretical prediction of Bohm-de Broglie quantum mechanics different from the prediction of usual Copenhagen quantum mechanics

Eduardo Sergio Santini, Germán M. Chiappe

The Bohm-de Broglie quantum mechanics has made possible to calculate the trajectories of electrons in a typical double-slit experiment[C. Philippidis et al., Il Nuovo Cimento, 52 B, 15-28 (1979)]. The trajectories do not correspond to an uniform movement but to an accelerated one. The acceleration is caused by the quantum potential. From the quantum theoretical point of view, the accelerated electrons should, with a certain probabil-ity, emit photons during its movement from the slits to the screen. According to the Copenhagen interpretation we found that this quantity is strictly zero because the electron moves as a free particle along its path after it leaves the slit and before reach the screen. Then, there is no emission of photons. On the other hand, by using the Bohm-de Broglie (BdB) approach we calculate the emission power, giving a general formula and which results, for a concrete real experiment, in a very tiny but not a vanishing value. We give an idea of the type of spectrum that could be measured. Therefore we have shown that the theoretical predictions of the usual quan-tum mechanics and that of Bohm-de Broglie’s interpretation are different. An experiment could determine the correct prediction.

Notas de Física•Apr 10, 2018•0 citations

Quantum Interference without Quantum Mechanics

Arend Niehaus

A recently proposed model of the Dirac electron, which has been shown to describe several observed properties of the particle correctly, is in the present paper shown to be also able to explain quantum interference by classical probabilities. According to this model, the electron is not point-like, but rather an “entity with structure”, formed by a fast periodic motion of a “light-like object”, whose momentum (p) causes the angular momentum responsible for the spin, and whose energy (E = pc) is equal to the energy of the electron, mc2. A qualitative description of the model is given, together with the quantitative formulae that allow to discuss interference. Applied to the experimental situation of the “two-slit” experiment, the formulae yield the same time dependence of the detection probability as the quantum mechanical treatment, and hence the same interference pattern. In contrast to quantum mechanics, the pattern is due to “particle interference” rather than to “wave interference”. No wave-particle paradox arises. The merits of the model are summarized, and its physical content discussed.

arXiv:1804.00496•Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2019•3 citations

Electron Diffraction: An Essay Solely based on Classical Electromagnetic Theory

Antônio Roberto Panicali

This paper discusses up to what point the fundamental two slits electron diffraction experiment can be modelled as a purely classical electromagnetic scattering problem [1]. The trajectories of single point charges (electrons with no spin) are computed as they pass, one by one, between two ungrounded perfectly conducting spheres, all computations being exclusively based on classical electromagnetic theory [2]. The computed particles trajectories clearly exhibit “interference like” behavior like those predicted by quantum theory, namely• Particles trajectories deviations depending on the accelerating voltage, spheres radii, separation (gap) and initial particle coordinates• Trajectories exhibiting velocity/energy discontinuities similar to quantum trajectories• Depending on the overall system dimensions, the energy jumps associated to observed trajectory discontinuity have been found to bear a clear association to the energy jumps in quantum systems as expressed in terms of Pank ́s constant h.

Journal of Physics & Optics Sciences•Feb 4, 2025•0 citations

Abandoning the de Broglie Matter‑Wave: Electrodynamic Origin of Quantum Wave‑Like Phenomena

Wuyuan Zhuang

The de Broglie matter‑wave hypothesis treats wave‑like behaviour as an intrinsic property of all microscopic particles. Based on the Charge‑Cluster Topology Hypothesis (CCTH), this paper points out that such postulate conflicts with multiple basic experimental facts: particle beams propagate in straight lines without spontaneous dispersion in disturbance‑free perfect vacuum; low‑velocity coherent particle beams do not produce spontaneous interference when intersecting in vacuum; electrically‑neutral particles and macroscopic neutral grains likewise exhibit no spontaneous wave‑like behaviour, in sharp contrast to light waves which can produce interference without gratings.This work argues that so‑called quantum wave‑like behaviour is not an intrinsic property of particles, but a statistical manifestation arising from deterministic electromagnetic interactions between charge‑packets and target nuclear charge‑clusters. Diffraction and interference patterns are superpositions of deflection landing positions of numerous independent events. Huygens secondary wave‑sources are equivalent mathematical descriptions of scattering centres rather than real expanding physical waves. The inverse proportional relation between equivalent wavelength and momentum originates from inertial impedance of electromagnetic coupling for high‑speed particles.This paper also challenges the ontological assumption that the uncertainty relation is a fundamental axiom of nature. Position‑momentum uncertainty is interpreted not as intrinsic fuzziness of individual particles, but as a statistical consequence of sensitive‑to‑initial‑conditions many‑body charge‑cluster dynamics plus electromagnetic perturbations introduced during detection. The mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics provides excellent phenomenological fitting for microscopic observations, yet does not directly represent underlying physical reality.Unified physical interpretations for relativistic mass‑increase, deep inelastic scattering and high‑energy particle showers are provided, together with several testable predictions. This manuscript presents a candidate‑hypothesis‑level argument. Quantum entanglement is outside the present framework; precise internal topology of nucleonic charge‑packets and quantitative treatment of gravitation remain unfinished. This preprint is derived from the CCTH theoretical series. It provides an alternative ontological interpretation for quantum wave‑like phenomena instead of negating the computational validity of quantum‑mechanical mathematics. Testable predictions are proposed. Quantum entanglement is explicitly marked as an unresolved boundary issue; precise nucleon internal topology and quantitative gravitation treatment remain unfinished.

•Nov 4, 2026•0 citations

Double-Slit Interferometry: The De Broglie Particle-Wave Duality

Jacques Rault

The de Broglie wavelength λ= h/mv of simple particles (photon, electron, neutron) atoms (helium, neon) and molecules (fullerene, fluorous porphyrin) deduced from the de Broglie (dB) relation and those measured by double slits interferometry are compared.The de Broglie relation is verified in very large domains of velocity v and mass m of the particles, respectively 8 and 13 orders of magnitude.In this paper one analyses the interference spectra of photons and electrons and give the Intensity Relations IR(II-DI) between the interference intensity (II) by two slits and the diffracted intensity (DI) by one slit.The double slits interference in the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation is an interference of particle and pilot waves, internal and external waves each passing by a different slit.The velocities of these waves are discussed.From the universal de Broglie relation and the relation vp = vw between the particle and pilot waves one shows that only in the domain of the maximum of the light spectrum (λm~ 550 µm) the dB relation leads to the Plank-Einstein (PE) relation hν=mc 2 .A measure of the mass of the photon m* = 4 10 -36 Kg is deduced.The de Broglie relation for different wave lengths shows that the PE relation must be modified, the velocity of light is not constant as shown by various experiments: Global Positioning Systems GPS, red shift in astronomy etc.This has been discussed by Marmet in years 2000.The same conclusion was given by Sato in 2010 for electromagnetic waves.The trajectories of electrons observed by Jönsson by double slits interferometry and then calculated by Gondran according to the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation are then analyzed in detail.The correlations observed between the properties of these trajectories at short and long distances from the slits permit to give the general equation of the trajectories.The origin of these properties is discussed in the framework model of De Broglie and Bohm, assuming that at any point the intensity of the two waves (particle and pilot wave) passing by the 2 slits are deceasing functions of the distance to the slits.The changes of direction of the trajectories are explained.

Juniper Online Journal Material Science•Aug 21, 2023•0 citations
We analyze a realistic microscopic model for electronic scattering with the neutral differential delay equations of motion of point charges of the Wheeler-Feynman electrodynamics. We propose a microscopic model according to the electrodynamics of point charges, complex enough to describe the essential physics. Our microscopic model reaches a simple qualitative agreement with the experimental results as regards interference in double-slit scattering and in electronic scattering by crystals. We discuss our model in the light of existing experimental results, including a qualitative disagreement found for the double-slit experiment. We discuss an approximation for the complex neutral differential delay equations of our model using piecewise-defined (discontinuous) velocities for all charges and piecewise-constant-velocities for the scattered charge. Our approximation predicts the De Broglie wavelength as an inverse function of the incoming velocity and in the correct order of magnitude. We explain the scattering by crystals in the light of the same simplified modeling with Einstein-local interactions. We include a discussion of the qualitative properties of the neutral-delay-equations of electrodynamics to stimulate future experimental tests on the possibility to complete quantum mechanics with electromagnetic models.
The mainstream quantum mechanics uses “probability wave superposition and single-electron self-interference” to explain electron single-slit and double-slit diffraction. This theory deviates from the essential nature of real particle interactions and has fundamental logical flaws. The electron is a negatively charged real particle with a definite physical size and high-frequency transverse oscillation; a single real particle has no physical basis for self-interference. Abandoning the abstract probability wave hypothesis, this paper establishes a complete real-interaction model including electrostatic repulsion deflection, surface electron exchange, collision scattering, microscopic refraction, and barrier diffraction, based on the three-dimensional random transverse oscillation and charge repulsion of electrons. The model uniformly explains the real formation mechanism of electron single-slit diffraction and double-slit interference fringes. This paper proves that in single-electron sequential emission, each electron passes through only one slit; all bright and dark fringes are the statistical result of multiple microscopic interactions between electrons and slit walls or the central barrier. The disappearance of fringes under observation is caused by external disturbance to the inherent oscillation and wall-interaction equilibrium, not by wave function collapse. This paper further clarifies that whether an electron can pass through a slit is determined by its transverse oscillation amplitude, not by wavelength. Amplitude directly corresponds to slit width and is the core controlling variable of diffraction. Meanwhile, if no slit is placed, electrons flying directly to the screen produce no diffraction or interference fringes, proving that electrons themselves have no self-interference ability. Fringes are generated by slit structures, not by intrinsic wave interference of electrons. This study corrects the century-long misunderstanding of electron diffraction and establishes a new microscopic diffraction mechanism consistent with classical real-particle physics.
The Bohm-de Broglie quantum mechanics has made possible to calculate the trajectories of electrons in a typical double-slit experiment[C. Philippidis et al., Il Nuovo Cimento, 52 B, 15-28 (1979)]. The trajectories do not correspond to an uniform movement but to an accelerated one. The acceleration is caused by the quantum potential. From the quantum theoretical point of view, the accelerated electrons should, with a certain probabil-ity, emit photons during its movement from the slits to the screen. According to the Copenhagen interpretation we found that this quantity is strictly zero because the electron moves as a free particle along its path after it leaves the slit and before reach the screen. Then, there is no emission of photons. On the other hand, by using the Bohm-de Broglie (BdB) approach we calculate the emission power, giving a general formula and which results, for a concrete real experiment, in a very tiny but not a vanishing value. We give an idea of the type of spectrum that could be measured. Therefore we have shown that the theoretical predictions of the usual quan-tum mechanics and that of Bohm-de Broglie’s interpretation are different. An experiment could determine the correct prediction.
A recently proposed model of the Dirac electron, which has been shown to describe several observed properties of the particle correctly, is in the present paper shown to be also able to explain quantum interference by classical probabilities. According to this model, the electron is not point-like, but rather an “entity with structure”, formed by a fast periodic motion of a “light-like object”, whose momentum (p) causes the angular momentum responsible for the spin, and whose energy (E = pc) is equal to the energy of the electron, mc2. A qualitative description of the model is given, together with the quantitative formulae that allow to discuss interference. Applied to the experimental situation of the “two-slit” experiment, the formulae yield the same time dependence of the detection probability as the quantum mechanical treatment, and hence the same interference pattern. In contrast to quantum mechanics, the pattern is due to “particle interference” rather than to “wave interference”. No wave-particle paradox arises. The merits of the model are summarized, and its physical content discussed.
This paper discusses up to what point the fundamental two slits electron diffraction experiment can be modelled as a purely classical electromagnetic scattering problem [1]. The trajectories of single point charges (electrons with no spin) are computed as they pass, one by one, between two ungrounded perfectly conducting spheres, all computations being exclusively based on classical electromagnetic theory [2]. The computed particles trajectories clearly exhibit “interference like” behavior like those predicted by quantum theory, namely• Particles trajectories deviations depending on the accelerating voltage, spheres radii, separation (gap) and initial particle coordinates• Trajectories exhibiting velocity/energy discontinuities similar to quantum trajectories• Depending on the overall system dimensions, the energy jumps associated to observed trajectory discontinuity have been found to bear a clear association to the energy jumps in quantum systems as expressed in terms of Pank ́s constant h.
The de Broglie matter‑wave hypothesis treats wave‑like behaviour as an intrinsic property of all microscopic particles. Based on the Charge‑Cluster Topology Hypothesis (CCTH), this paper points out that such postulate conflicts with multiple basic experimental facts: particle beams propagate in straight lines without spontaneous dispersion in disturbance‑free perfect vacuum; low‑velocity coherent particle beams do not produce spontaneous interference when intersecting in vacuum; electrically‑neutral particles and macroscopic neutral grains likewise exhibit no spontaneous wave‑like behaviour, in sharp contrast to light waves which can produce interference without gratings.This work argues that so‑called quantum wave‑like behaviour is not an intrinsic property of particles, but a statistical manifestation arising from deterministic electromagnetic interactions between charge‑packets and target nuclear charge‑clusters. Diffraction and interference patterns are superpositions of deflection landing positions of numerous independent events. Huygens secondary wave‑sources are equivalent mathematical descriptions of scattering centres rather than real expanding physical waves. The inverse proportional relation between equivalent wavelength and momentum originates from inertial impedance of electromagnetic coupling for high‑speed particles.This paper also challenges the ontological assumption that the uncertainty relation is a fundamental axiom of nature. Position‑momentum uncertainty is interpreted not as intrinsic fuzziness of individual particles, but as a statistical consequence of sensitive‑to‑initial‑conditions many‑body charge‑cluster dynamics plus electromagnetic perturbations introduced during detection. The mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics provides excellent phenomenological fitting for microscopic observations, yet does not directly represent underlying physical reality.Unified physical interpretations for relativistic mass‑increase, deep inelastic scattering and high‑energy particle showers are provided, together with several testable predictions. This manuscript presents a candidate‑hypothesis‑level argument. Quantum entanglement is outside the present framework; precise internal topology of nucleonic charge‑packets and quantitative treatment of gravitation remain unfinished. This preprint is derived from the CCTH theoretical series. It provides an alternative ontological interpretation for quantum wave‑like phenomena instead of negating the computational validity of quantum‑mechanical mathematics. Testable predictions are proposed. Quantum entanglement is explicitly marked as an unresolved boundary issue; precise nucleon internal topology and quantitative gravitation treatment remain unfinished.
The de Broglie wavelength λ= h/mv of simple particles (photon, electron, neutron) atoms (helium, neon) and molecules (fullerene, fluorous porphyrin) deduced from the de Broglie (dB) relation and those measured by double slits interferometry are compared.The de Broglie relation is verified in very large domains of velocity v and mass m of the particles, respectively 8 and 13 orders of magnitude.In this paper one analyses the interference spectra of photons and electrons and give the Intensity Relations IR(II-DI) between the interference intensity (II) by two slits and the diffracted intensity (DI) by one slit.The double slits interference in the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation is an interference of particle and pilot waves, internal and external waves each passing by a different slit.The velocities of these waves are discussed.From the universal de Broglie relation and the relation vp = vw between the particle and pilot waves one shows that only in the domain of the maximum of the light spectrum (λm~ 550 µm) the dB relation leads to the Plank-Einstein (PE) relation hν=mc 2 .A measure of the mass of the photon m* = 4 10 -36 Kg is deduced.The de Broglie relation for different wave lengths shows that the PE relation must be modified, the velocity of light is not constant as shown by various experiments: Global Positioning Systems GPS, red shift in astronomy etc.This has been discussed by Marmet in years 2000.The same conclusion was given by Sato in 2010 for electromagnetic waves.The trajectories of electrons observed by Jönsson by double slits interferometry and then calculated by Gondran according to the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation are then analyzed in detail.The correlations observed between the properties of these trajectories at short and long distances from the slits permit to give the general equation of the trajectories.The origin of these properties is discussed in the framework model of De Broglie and Bohm, assuming that at any point the intensity of the two waves (particle and pilot wave) passing by the 2 slits are deceasing functions of the distance to the slits.The changes of direction of the trajectories are explained.