Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1005.0583 · Physical Review B

Projective ribbon permutation statistics: A remnant of non-Abelian braiding in higher dimensions

Michael Hartley Freedman, Matthew B. Hastings, Chetan Nayak, Xiao-Liang Qi, Kevin P. Walker, Zhenghan Wang

Published Mar 23, 2011• 68 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent paper, Teo and Kane [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 046401 (2010)] proposed a three-dimensional (3D) model in which the defects support Majorana fermion zero modes. They argued that exchanging and twisting these defects would implement a set $\mathcal{R}$ of unitary transformations on the zero-mode Hilbert space which is a ``ghostly'' recollection of the action of the braid group on Ising anyons in two dimensions. In this paper, we find the group ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}$, which governs the statistics of these defects by analyzing the topology of the space ${K}_{2n}$ of configurations of $2n$ defects in a slowly spatially varying gapped free-fermion Hamiltonian: ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\ensuremath{\pi}}_{1}({K}_{2n})$. We find that the group ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}=\mathbb{Z}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathcal{T}}_{2n}^{r}$, where the ``ribbon permutation group'' ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}^{r}$ is a mild enhancement of the permutation group ${S}_{2n}$: ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}^{r}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}E\mathbf{(}({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}\ensuremath{\rtimes}{S}_{2n}\mathbf{)}$. Here, $E\mathbf{(}({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}\ensuremath{\rtimes}{S}_{2n}\mathbf{)}$ is the ``even part'' of $({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}\ensuremath{\rtimes}{S}_{2n}$, namely, those elements for which the total parity of the element in $({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}$ added to the parity of the permutation is even. Surprisingly, $\mathcal{R}$ is only a projective representation of ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}$, a possibility proposed by Wilczek [e-print arXiv:hep-th/9806228]. Thus, Teo and Kane's defects realize projective ribbon permutation statistics,'' which we show to be consistent with locality. We extend this phenomenon to other dimensions, codimensions, and symmetry classes. We note that our analysis applies to 3D networks of quantum wires supporting Majorana fermions; thus, these networks are not required to be planar. Because it is an essential input for our calculation, we review the topological classification of gapped free-fermion systems and its relation to Bott periodicity.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.83.115132

Related papers

Non-Abelian braid statistics versus projective permutation statistics

N. Read

Recent papers by Finkelstein, Galiautdinov, and co-workers [J. Math. Phys. 42, 1489 (2001); 42, 3299 (2001)] discuss a suggestion by Wilczek that non-Abelian projective representations of the permutation group can be used as a new type of particle statistics, valid in any dimension. Wilczek’s suggestion was based in part on an analysis by Nayak and Wilczek (NW) of the non-Abelian representation of the braid group in a quantum Hall system. We point out that projective permutation statistics is not possible in a local quantum field theory as it violates locality, and show that the NW braid group representation is not equivalent to a projective representation of the permutation group. The structure of the finite image of the braid group in a 2n/2−1-dimensional representation is obtained.

arXiv:hep-th/0201240•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 17, 2003•20 citations

Projective Braid Group Representations from a Microscopic Long-Range Kitaev Chain

Rowan Brad Quni-Gudzinas

We construct an explicit projective representation of the braid group from the microscopic Hilbert space of a Kitaev chain extended with algebraically decaying long-range hopping and pairing. The construction proceeds in three steps. First, we identify the topological phase of the long-range Kitaev chain (power-law exponent α) and show that unpaired Majorana zero modes (MZMs) localize at domain walls, with localization length controlled by α. Second, we write the braid unitary U_ij = exp((π/4)γ_iγ_j) acting on the zero-mode Majorana operators γ_i and verify, by explicit matrix computation in a fixed-parity sector, that the braid relation σ₁σ₂σ₁ = σ₂σ₁σ₂ holds exactly while the relation σ⁴ = 1 is lifted: U⁴ = −𝟙 rather than +𝟙. This defines a genuine projective (2-cocycle-twisted) representation whose class is the Ising one, with per-exchange projective phase anchored at π/8. Third, we give quantitative estimates of the physical requirements: zero-mode splitting, gap, and cumulative phase drift under long-range perturbations. Our central quantitative result is that the Ising projective class is stable against long-range hopping with exponent α > 2 and open gap: our projection at α = 3 with representative parameters — based on the assumed, undischarged scaling ε ~ λ^s · s^{−α} rather than a derived bound — gives a per-braid drift of ≤ 1.5 × 10⁻¹⁷ rad and a cumulative drift over 10⁶ braids of ≤ 9.2 × 10⁻¹¹ rad. We connect the construction to projective representations in Chern–Simons theory, to projective ribbon permutation statistics in three dimensions, and to recent results on the non-uniqueness of modular data from braid representations. Falsification criteria and open questions are discussed. ## 1. Introduction Topological phases of matter support exotic quantum statistics: when quasiparticles are exchanged adiabatically, the wave function transforms by a unitary matrix, and for non-Abelian anyons these matrices form a representation of the braid group B_N. A Full text and updates: papers.qnfo.org/papers/projective-braid-group-representations-from-a-microscopic-long-range-kitaev-chai/

•Oct 3, 2026•0 citations

Topological Protection and Non-Abelian Braiding of Majorana Zero Modes — E8 Intelligence Research

Andrew Stewart Caldin

FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) realize non-Abelian braid statistics via the Ising anyon model, with topological protection scaling exponentially in wire length. | MATH: Braid group \( B_n \) generators \( \sigma_i \) act on a 2D degenerate ground space (for \( 2n \) MZMs) via \( \gamma_i \to \gamma_j = U^\dagger \gamma_i U \), where \( U = \exp(\frac{\pi}{4}\gamma_i\gamma_j) \). The non-Abelian exchange yields \( \sigma_i^2 = -1 \) (fermion parity flip), and the topological gap \( \Delta_{\rm top} \propto e^{-L/\xi} \) (exponential suppression of splitting with wire length \( L \), coherence length \( \xi \)). Kitaev chain Hamiltonian: \( H = -\mu\sum c_i^\dagger c_i - t\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i + {\rm h.c.}) + \Delta\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i^\dagger + {\rm h.c.}) \), with MZM operators \( \gamma_1 = c_1 + c_1^\dagger \), \( \gamma_2 = -i(c_N - c_N^\dagger) \) at \( \mu=0, t=\Delta \). | CONNECTION: The braid group \( B_n \) is the fundamental group of configuration space of \( n \) Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com

•Aug 29, 2026•0 citations

Twist defects and projective non-Abelian braiding statistics

Maissam Barkeshli, Chao‐Ming Jian, Xiao-Liang Qi

It has recently been realized that a general class of non-Abelian defects can be created in conventional topological states by introducing extrinsic defects, such as lattice dislocations or superconductor-ferromagnet domain walls in conventional quantum Hall states or topological insulators. In this paper, we begin by placing these defects within the broader conceptual scheme of extrinsic twist defects associated with symmetries of the topological state. We explicitly study several classes of examples, including ${Z}_{2}$ and ${Z}_{3}$ twist defects, where the topological state with $N$ twist defects can be mapped to a topological state without twist defects on a genus $g\ensuremath{\propto}N$ surface. To emphasize this connection we refer to the twist defects as genons. We develop methods to compute the projective non-Abelian braiding statistics of the genons, and we find the braiding is given by adiabatic modular transformations, or Dehn twists, of the topological state on the effective genus $g$ surface. We study the relation between this projective braiding statistics and the ordinary non-Abelian braiding statistics obtained when the genons become deconfined, finite-energy excitations. We find that the braiding is generally different, in contrast to the Majorana case, which opens the possibility for fundamentally novel behavior. We find situations where the genons have quantum dimension 2 and can be used for universal topological quantum computing (TQC), while the host topological state is by itself nonuniversal for TQC.

arXiv:1208.4834•Physical Review B•Jan 31, 2013•296 citations

Defects between gapped boundaries in two-dimensional topological phases of matter

Iris Cong, Meng Cheng, Zhenghan Wang

Defects between gapped boundaries provide a possible physical realization of projective non-Abelian braid statistics. A notable example is the projective Majorana/parafermion braid statistics of boundary defects in fractional quantum Hall/topological insulator and superconductor heterostructures. In this paper, we develop general theories to analyze the topological properties and projective braiding of boundary defects of topological phases of matter in two spatial dimensions. We present commuting Hamiltonians to realize defects between gapped boundaries in any $(2+1)D$ untwisted Dijkgraaf-Witten theory, and use these to describe their topological properties such as their quantum dimension. By modeling the algebraic structure of boundary defects through multifusion categories, we establish a bulk-edge correspondence between certain boundary defects and symmetry defects in the bulk. Even though it is not clear how to physically braid the defects, this correspondence elucidates the projective braid statistics for many classes of boundary defects, both amongst themselves and with bulk anyons. Specifically, three such classes of importance to condensed matter physics/topological quantum computation are studied in detail: (1) a boundary defect version of Majorana and parafermion zero modes, (2) a similar version of genons in bilayer theories, and (3) boundary defects in $\mathfrak{D}({S}_{3})$.

arXiv:1703.03564•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 14, 2017•41 citations

Unconventional fusion and braiding of topological defects in a lattice model

Jeffrey C. Y. Teo, Abhishek Roy, Xiao Chen

We examine non-Abelian topological defects in an Abelian lattice model in two dimensions. We first construct an exact solvable lattice model that exhibits coexisting and intertwined topological and classical orders. The anyon types of quasiparticle excitations are permuted by lattice symmetry operations like translations, rotations, and reflections. The global anyon permutation symmetry has a group structure of ${S}_{3}$, the permutation group of three elements. Topological crystalline defects---dislocations and disclinations---change the anyon type of an orbiting quasiparticle. They exhibit multichannel order-dependent fusion rules and projective braiding operations. Their braiding and exchange statistics breaks modular invariance and violates the conventional spin-statistics theorem. We develop a framework to characterize these unconventional properties that originate from the semiclassical nature of defects.

arXiv:1306.1538•Physical Review B•Sep 8, 2014•56 citations
In a recent paper, Teo and Kane [Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 046401 (2010)] proposed a three-dimensional (3D) model in which the defects support Majorana fermion zero modes. They argued that exchanging and twisting these defects would implement a set R\mathcal{R}R of unitary transformations on the zero-mode Hilbert space which is a ghostly'' recollection of the action of the braid group on Ising anyons in two dimensions. In this paper, we find the group ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}$, which governs the statistics of these defects by analyzing the topology of the space ${K}_{2n}$ of configurations of $2n$ defects in a slowly spatially varying gapped free-fermion Hamiltonian: ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\ensuremath{\pi}}_{1}({K}_{2n})$. We find that the group ${\mathcal{T}}_{2n}=\mathbb{Z}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}{\mathcal{T}}_{2n}^{r}$, where the ribbon permutation group'' T2nr{\mathcal{T}}_{2n}^{r}T2nr​ is a mild enhancement of the permutation group S2n{S}_{2n}S2n​: T2nr\ensuremath≡Z2\ifmmode×\else\texttimes\fiE((Z2)2n\ensuremath⋊S2n){\mathcal{T}}_{2n}^{r}\ensuremath{\equiv}{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}E\mathbf{(}({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}\ensuremath{\rtimes}{S}_{2n}\mathbf{)}T2nr​\ensuremath≡Z2​\ifmmode×\else\texttimes\fiE((Z2​)2n\ensuremath⋊S2n​). Here, E((Z2)2n\ensuremath⋊S2n)E\mathbf{(}({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}\ensuremath{\rtimes}{S}_{2n}\mathbf{)}E((Z2​)2n\ensuremath⋊S2n​) is the ``even part'' of (Z2)2n\ensuremath⋊S2n({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}\ensuremath{\rtimes}{S}_{2n}(Z2​)2n\ensuremath⋊S2n​, namely, those elements for which the total parity of the element in (Z2)2n({\mathbb{Z}}_{2}){}^{2n}(Z2​)2n added to the parity of the permutation is even. Surprisingly, R\mathcal{R}R is only a projective representation of T2n{\mathcal{T}}_{2n}T2n​, a possibility proposed by Wilczek [e-print arXiv:hep-th/9806228]. Thus, Teo and Kane's defects realize projective ribbon permutation statistics,'' which we show to be consistent with locality. We extend this phenomenon to other dimensions, codimensions, and symmetry classes. We note that our analysis applies to 3D networks of quantum wires supporting Majorana fermions; thus, these networks are not required to be planar. Because it is an essential input for our calculation, we review the topological classification of gapped free-fermion systems and its relation to Bott periodicity.
Recent papers by Finkelstein, Galiautdinov, and co-workers [J. Math. Phys. 42, 1489 (2001); 42, 3299 (2001)] discuss a suggestion by Wilczek that non-Abelian projective representations of the permutation group can be used as a new type of particle statistics, valid in any dimension. Wilczek’s suggestion was based in part on an analysis by Nayak and Wilczek (NW) of the non-Abelian representation of the braid group in a quantum Hall system. We point out that projective permutation statistics is not possible in a local quantum field theory as it violates locality, and show that the NW braid group representation is not equivalent to a projective representation of the permutation group. The structure of the finite image of the braid group in a 2n/2−1-dimensional representation is obtained.
We construct an explicit projective representation of the braid group from the microscopic Hilbert space of a Kitaev chain extended with algebraically decaying long-range hopping and pairing. The construction proceeds in three steps. First, we identify the topological phase of the long-range Kitaev chain (power-law exponent α) and show that unpaired Majorana zero modes (MZMs) localize at domain walls, with localization length controlled by α. Second, we write the braid unitary U_ij = exp((π/4)γ_iγ_j) acting on the zero-mode Majorana operators γ_i and verify, by explicit matrix computation in a fixed-parity sector, that the braid relation σ₁σ₂σ₁ = σ₂σ₁σ₂ holds exactly while the relation σ⁴ = 1 is lifted: U⁴ = −𝟙 rather than +𝟙. This defines a genuine projective (2-cocycle-twisted) representation whose class is the Ising one, with per-exchange projective phase anchored at π/8. Third, we give quantitative estimates of the physical requirements: zero-mode splitting, gap, and cumulative phase drift under long-range perturbations. Our central quantitative result is that the Ising projective class is stable against long-range hopping with exponent α > 2 and open gap: our projection at α = 3 with representative parameters — based on the assumed, undischarged scaling ε ~ λ^s · s^{−α} rather than a derived bound — gives a per-braid drift of ≤ 1.5 × 10⁻¹⁷ rad and a cumulative drift over 10⁶ braids of ≤ 9.2 × 10⁻¹¹ rad. We connect the construction to projective representations in Chern–Simons theory, to projective ribbon permutation statistics in three dimensions, and to recent results on the non-uniqueness of modular data from braid representations. Falsification criteria and open questions are discussed. ## 1. Introduction Topological phases of matter support exotic quantum statistics: when quasiparticles are exchanged adiabatically, the wave function transforms by a unitary matrix, and for non-Abelian anyons these matrices form a representation of the braid group B_N. A Full text and updates: papers.qnfo.org/papers/projective-braid-group-representations-from-a-microscopic-long-range-kitaev-chai/
FINDING: Majorana zero modes (MZMs) realize non-Abelian braid statistics via the Ising anyon model, with topological protection scaling exponentially in wire length. | MATH: Braid group Bn B_n Bn​ generators σi \sigma_i σi​ act on a 2D degenerate ground space (for 2n 2n 2n MZMs) via γi→γj=U†γiU \gamma_i \to \gamma_j = U^\dagger \gamma_i U γi​→γj​=U†γi​U, where U=exp⁡(π4γiγj) U = \exp(\frac{\pi}{4}\gamma_i\gamma_j) U=exp(4π​γi​γj​). The non-Abelian exchange yields σi2=−1 \sigma_i^2 = -1 σi2​=−1 (fermion parity flip), and the topological gap Δtop∝e−L/ξ \Delta_{\rm top} \propto e^{-L/\xi} Δtop​∝e−L/ξ (exponential suppression of splitting with wire length L L L, coherence length ξ \xi ξ). Kitaev chain Hamiltonian: H=−μ∑ci†ci−t∑(ci+1†ci+h.c.)+Δ∑(ci+1†ci†+h.c.) H = -\mu\sum c_i^\dagger c_i - t\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i + {\rm h.c.}) + \Delta\sum(c_{i+1}^\dagger c_i^\dagger + {\rm h.c.}) H=−μ∑ci†​ci​−t∑(ci+1†​ci​+h.c.)+Δ∑(ci+1†​ci†​+h.c.), with MZM operators γ1=c1+c1† \gamma_1 = c_1 + c_1^\dagger γ1​=c1​+c1†​, γ2=−i(cN−cN†) \gamma_2 = -i(c_N - c_N^\dagger) γ2​=−i(cN​−cN†​) at μ=0,t=Δ \mu=0, t=\Delta μ=0,t=Δ. | CONNECTION: The braid group Bn B_n Bn​ is the fundamental group of configuration space of n n n Author: Andrew Stewart Caldin, Independent Researcher, UK. Part of the E8 Intelligence Research series. Platform: e8intelligence.com
It has recently been realized that a general class of non-Abelian defects can be created in conventional topological states by introducing extrinsic defects, such as lattice dislocations or superconductor-ferromagnet domain walls in conventional quantum Hall states or topological insulators. In this paper, we begin by placing these defects within the broader conceptual scheme of extrinsic twist defects associated with symmetries of the topological state. We explicitly study several classes of examples, including Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ and Z3{Z}_{3}Z3​ twist defects, where the topological state with NNN twist defects can be mapped to a topological state without twist defects on a genus $g\ensuremath{\propto}N$ surface. To emphasize this connection we refer to the twist defects as genons. We develop methods to compute the projective non-Abelian braiding statistics of the genons, and we find the braiding is given by adiabatic modular transformations, or Dehn twists, of the topological state on the effective genus ggg surface. We study the relation between this projective braiding statistics and the ordinary non-Abelian braiding statistics obtained when the genons become deconfined, finite-energy excitations. We find that the braiding is generally different, in contrast to the Majorana case, which opens the possibility for fundamentally novel behavior. We find situations where the genons have quantum dimension 2 and can be used for universal topological quantum computing (TQC), while the host topological state is by itself nonuniversal for TQC.
Defects between gapped boundaries provide a possible physical realization of projective non-Abelian braid statistics. A notable example is the projective Majorana/parafermion braid statistics of boundary defects in fractional quantum Hall/topological insulator and superconductor heterostructures. In this paper, we develop general theories to analyze the topological properties and projective braiding of boundary defects of topological phases of matter in two spatial dimensions. We present commuting Hamiltonians to realize defects between gapped boundaries in any (2+1)D(2+1)D(2+1)D untwisted Dijkgraaf-Witten theory, and use these to describe their topological properties such as their quantum dimension. By modeling the algebraic structure of boundary defects through multifusion categories, we establish a bulk-edge correspondence between certain boundary defects and symmetry defects in the bulk. Even though it is not clear how to physically braid the defects, this correspondence elucidates the projective braid statistics for many classes of boundary defects, both amongst themselves and with bulk anyons. Specifically, three such classes of importance to condensed matter physics/topological quantum computation are studied in detail: (1) a boundary defect version of Majorana and parafermion zero modes, (2) a similar version of genons in bilayer theories, and (3) boundary defects in D(S3)\mathfrak{D}({S}_{3})D(S3​).
We examine non-Abelian topological defects in an Abelian lattice model in two dimensions. We first construct an exact solvable lattice model that exhibits coexisting and intertwined topological and classical orders. The anyon types of quasiparticle excitations are permuted by lattice symmetry operations like translations, rotations, and reflections. The global anyon permutation symmetry has a group structure of S3{S}_{3}S3​, the permutation group of three elements. Topological crystalline defects---dislocations and disclinations---change the anyon type of an orbiting quasiparticle. They exhibit multichannel order-dependent fusion rules and projective braiding operations. Their braiding and exchange statistics breaks modular invariance and violates the conventional spin-statistics theorem. We develop a framework to characterize these unconventional properties that originate from the semiclassical nature of defects.