Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1005.0569 · Physical Review Letters

Position Measurements Obeying Momentum Conservation

Paul Busch, Leon Loveridge

Published Mar 18, 2011• 29 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a hitherto unknown fundamental limitation to a basic measurement: that of the position of a quantum object when the total momentum of the object and apparatus is conserved. This result extends the famous Wigner-Araki-Yanase theorem, and shows that accurate position measurements are only practically feasible if there is a large momentum uncertainty in the apparatus.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.106.110406

Related papers

Uncertainty beyond the Uncertainty Principle

Charles Day

According to a new extension to an old theory, a particle's position cannot be measured precisely even if its momentum is not measured simultaneously.By Charles Day H eisenberg's uncertainty principle limits the precision with which two observables that do not commute with each other can be simultaneously measured.The Wigner-Araki-Yanase (WAY) theorem goes further.If observables A and B do not commute, and if observable A is conserved, observable B cannot be measured with arbitrary precision even if A is not measured at all.In its original 1960 formulation, the WAY theorem applied only to observables, such as spin, whose possible values are discrete and bounded.Now Yui Kuramochi of Kyushu University and Hiroyasu Tajima of the University of Electro-Communications-both in Japan-have proven that the WAY theorem also encompasses observables, such as position, that are continuous and unbounded [1].Besides resolving the decades-long problem of how to deal with such observables, the extension will likely find practical applications in quantum optics.The difficulty of extending the WAY theorem arose from how an

Physics•Nov 21, 2023•0 citations

QUANTUM MEASUREMENTS CONSTRAINED BY SYMMETRIES

Paul Busch, Leon Loveridge

We revisit the theorem of Wigner, Araki and Yanase (WAY) describing limitations to repeatable quantum measurements that arise from the presence of conservation laws. We will review a strengthening of this theorem by exhibiting and discussing a condition that has hitherto not been identified as a relevant factor. We will also show that an extension of the theorem to continuous variables such as position and momentum can be obtained if the degree of repeatability is suitably quantified.

arXiv:1303.6536•WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 14, 2013•3 citations

A Reexamination of the Wigner and Araki-Yanase Theorem

Shuichi Matsumoto

The limitation on the measurement of an operator imposed by the presence of one conservation law was discussed by Wigner and Araki-Yanase. But we do not know whether their results still hold or not when we consider two conservation laws or more at a time. In this article, a model of a quantum measuring process is discussed from the point of view that all three components of angular momentum should be conserved in the process.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jul 1, 1993•7 citations

Quantum Limits of Measurement and Computing Induced by Conservation Laws and Uncertainty Relations

Masanao Ozawa

A quantitative extension of the Wigner-Araki-Yanase theorem is obtained on the limitation on precise, non-disturbing measurements of observables which do not commute with additive conserved quantities, and applied to obtaining a limitation on the accuracy of quantum computing with computational bases which do not commute with angular momentum.

arXiv:quant-ph/0210046•Oct 8, 2002•1 citation

Conservation Laws, Uncertainty Relations, and Quantum Limits of Measurements

Masanao Ozawa

The uncertainty relation between the noise operator and the conserved quantity leads to a bound on the accuracy of general measurements. The bound extends the assertion by Wigner, Araki, and Yanase that conservation laws limit the accuracy of "repeatable," or "nondisturbing," measurements to general measurements, and improves the one previously obtained by Yanase for spin measurements. The bound represents an obstacle to making a small quantum computer.

arXiv:quant-ph/0112154•Physical Review Letters•Jan 23, 2002•72 citations

Does a conservation law limit position measurements?

Masanao Ozawa

The demonstrations of Wigner and others, that observables which do not commute with additive conserved quantities cannot be measured precisely, are reexamined. A proposed new formulation of the claim is shown to be valid for observables with a continuous spectrum whenever the conserved quantities are bounded. However, a countermodel is constructed, and it suggests that the position can be measured as precisely as the momentum even though the measuring interaction conserves the total linear momentum.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 7, 1991•30 citations
We present a hitherto unknown fundamental limitation to a basic measurement: that of the position of a quantum object when the total momentum of the object and apparatus is conserved. This result extends the famous Wigner-Araki-Yanase theorem, and shows that accurate position measurements are only practically feasible if there is a large momentum uncertainty in the apparatus.
According to a new extension to an old theory, a particle's position cannot be measured precisely even if its momentum is not measured simultaneously.By Charles Day H eisenberg's uncertainty principle limits the precision with which two observables that do not commute with each other can be simultaneously measured.The Wigner-Araki-Yanase (WAY) theorem goes further.If observables A and B do not commute, and if observable A is conserved, observable B cannot be measured with arbitrary precision even if A is not measured at all.In its original 1960 formulation, the WAY theorem applied only to observables, such as spin, whose possible values are discrete and bounded.Now Yui Kuramochi of Kyushu University and Hiroyasu Tajima of the University of Electro-Communications-both in Japan-have proven that the WAY theorem also encompasses observables, such as position, that are continuous and unbounded [1].Besides resolving the decades-long problem of how to deal with such observables, the extension will likely find practical applications in quantum optics.The difficulty of extending the WAY theorem arose from how an
The demonstrations of Wigner and others, that observables which do not commute with additive conserved quantities cannot be measured precisely, are reexamined. A proposed new formulation of the claim is shown to be valid for observables with a continuous spectrum whenever the conserved quantities are bounded. However, a countermodel is constructed, and it suggests that the position can be measured as precisely as the momentum even though the measuring interaction conserves the total linear momentum.