Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1004.3182 · Physical Review A

Testing nonclassicality in multimode fields: A unified derivation of classical inequalities

Adam Miranowicz, Monika Bartkowiak, Xiaoguang Wang, Yu-xi Liu, Franco Nori

Published Jul 21, 2010• 184 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a way to generate operational inequalities to test nonclassicality (or quantumness) of multimode bosonic fields (or multiparty bosonic systems) that unifies the derivation of many known inequalities and allows to propose new ones. The nonclassicality criteria are based on Vogel's criterion corresponding to analyzing the positivity of multimode $P$ functions or, equivalently, the positivity of matrices of expectation values of, e.g., creation and annihilation operators. We analyze not only monomials but also polynomial functions of such moments, which can sometimes enable simpler derivations of physically relevant inequalities. As an example, we derive various classical inequalities which can be violated only by nonclassical fields. In particular, we show how the criteria introduced here easily reduce to the well-known inequalities describing (a) multimode quadrature squeezing and its generalizations, including sum, difference, and principal squeezing; (b) two-mode one-time photon-number correlations, including sub-Poisson photon-number correlations and effects corresponding to violations of the Cauchy-Schwarz and Muirhead inequalities; (c) two-time single-mode photon-number correlations, including photon antibunching and hyperbunching; and (d) two- and three-mode quantum entanglement. Other simple inequalities for testing nonclassicality are also proposed. We have found some general relations between the nonclassicality and entanglement criteria, in particular those resulting from the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. It is shown that some known entanglement inequalities can be derived as nonclassicality inequalities within our formalism, while some other known entanglement inequalities can be seen as sums of more than one inequality derived from the nonclassicality criterion. This approach enables a deeper analysis of the entanglement for a given nonclassicality.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.82.013824

Related papers

Experimentally-friendly methods of generation and detection of quantum correlations

Monika Bartkowiak

One of the most relevant problems in the quantum theory is the question whether the appropriate state of the system can be described within a classical theory. The famous examples of nonclassical states are Schrodinger-cats states or entanglement states. In spite of many practical applications of entanglement as a special kind of nonclassicality (like quantum teleportation [1], dense coding [2], or implementation of super-fast [3] and fast algorithms [4]), we still have difficulties with describing and specifying it. One cannot find such an operational optimal method, which would allow us to maximally use the technological and scientific potential arising from the adaptation properties of quantum correlations. Thus, my thesis is focused on giving a proposal of a theoretical recipe for constructing experimentally achievable procedures for the study of quantum correlations. In my thesis I have focused on quantum correlations described in terms of nonclassicality (quantumness) and specific kind of it,i.e., entanglement. The nonclassicality definition, used by me in the thesis, is based on the Glauber-Sudarshan function (P -function). One can assume, that a state is nonclassical, if its P -function is negative or more singular than Dirac’s delta [5]. As follows, the state is nonclassical, when its P -function cannot be treated as a “real” probabilistic distribution. Based on specific properties of the P -function, Agarwal and Tara [6], as well as, Shchukin, Richter and Vogel [7, 8] proposed nonclassicality and entanglement [9] criteria based on matrices of moments of annihilation and creation operators. The operational procedures for analyzing nonclassicality and an efficient method for measuring such moments developed by Shchukin and Vogel [10] creates basis for my thesis. It can be seen that the nonclassicality criteria based on matrices of moments offer an effective way of deriving specific inequalities, which might be useful in the verification of nonclassicality of particular states generated in experiments. Therefore, criteria constructed based on the above definition of nonclassicality can be used to find practical and effective methods of generating and testing nonclassicality and, therefore, also quantum entanglement of optical fields. The results presented in my thesis can be divided into three main groups: 1. Finding operational and practical criteria to classify states in terms of nonclassicality and entanglement based on fundamental classical inequalities like Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. It was also shown how some known entanglement inequalities can be derived as nonclassicality inequalities or as sums of more than one inequality [Bartkowiak2010a]. 2. Describing properties and behaviour of quantum correlations for different optical fields (e.g. for multiand single-mode systems, for interacting and noninteracting modes). In particular, general occurrence of sudden vanishing of nonclassicality, which can be observed not only for twoor multimode but also for single-mode fields, was proven [Bartkowiak2011]. 3. Finding the methods of generating and testing of quantum correlations, which would be practical and easy to implement with available resources in both linear and nonlinear optics.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Nonclassicality in Two-Mode New Generalized Binomial State

Kathakali Mandal, Anjali Jatwani, Amit Verma

The study of nonclassical properties of two-mode quantum states is particularly useful in quantum information theory because of the possibilities of obtaining entanglement and other two-mode quantum correlations in these states. Here we have investigated the possibilities of the existence of nonclassicality in a two-mode New generalized binomial state (TMNGBS). Specifically two-mode antibunching, Quadrature squeezing, sum \& difference squeezing, and various entanglement criteria e.g Shchukin-Vogel entanglement criterion, the uncertainty relation of SU(1,1) Algebra and EPR entanglement criterion are explored in two mode particular example of quantum state named as New generalized binomial state. Earlier we studied nonclassicality in single-mode NGBS, here we are extending our study toward the two-mode version of a quantum state. Here we provide the general expressions of moments for a two-mode quantum state (Fock basis) and explore the quantification in a particular example NGBS. It is found that antibunching, squeezing, and SV entanglement are possible with different limits of depending parameters but the entanglement criteria (EPR, SU (1,1) algebra and Cauchy - Schwarz inequality based)for NGBS are not possible. This study opens up the possibility of exploring the two-mode nonclassicality in other states too.

arXiv:2406.09751•Jun 14, 2024•2 citations

Classical-Nonclassical Polarity of Gaussian States

Jiru Liu, Wenchao Ge, Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

Gaussian states with nonclassical properties such as squeezing and entanglement serve as crucial resources for quantum information processing. Accurately quantifying these properties within multimode Gaussian states has posed some challenges. To address this, we introduce a unified quantification: the "classical-nonclassical polarity," represented by P. For a single mode, a positive value of P captures the reduced minimum quadrature uncertainty below the vacuum noise, while a negative value represents an enlarged uncertainty due to classical mixtures. For multimode systems, a positive P indicates bipartite quantum entanglement. We show that the sum of the total classical-nonclassical polarity is conserved under arbitrary linear optical transformations for any two-mode and three-mode Gaussian states. For any pure multimode Gaussian state, the total classical-nonclassical polarity equals the sum of the mean photon number from single-mode squeezing and two-mode squeezing. Our results provide a new perspective on the quantitative relation between single-mode nonclassicality and entanglement, which may find applications in a unified resource theory of nonclassical features.

arXiv:2310.12104•Physical Review Letters•Jun 13, 2024•5 citations

Nonclassical moments and their measurement

Evgeny V Shchukin, W. Vogel

Practically applicable criteria for the nonclassicality of quantum states are formulated in terms of different types of moments. For this purpose the moments of the creation and annihilation operators, of two quadratures, and of a quadrature and the photon number operator turn out to be useful. It is shown that all the required moments can be determined by homodyne correlation measurements. An example of a nonclassical effect that is easily characterized by our methods is amplitude-squared squeezing.

arXiv:quant-ph/0506029•Physical Review A•Oct 12, 2005•155 citations

Unifying entanglement and nonclassicality via the Narcowich-Wigner spectrum

Massimo Frigerio, Zacharie Van Herstraeten, Hania Herbi +5 more

Entanglement and nonclassicality are two fundamental features of quantum mechanics which serve as resources in quantum information processing tasks and are tightly connected by two-mode mixing. In this work, we show that the connection between entanglement and nonclassicality extends well beyond the two-mode mixing setting by considering the case of arbitrary multimode Gaussian evolutions. Using the Narcowich-Wigner spectrum as our main technical tool to quantify single-mode phase-space nonclassicality, we derive sufficient conditions for a single-mode state to generate NPT entanglement after a multimode Gaussian unitary evolution, which both tighten and generalize existing criteria. As an application, we obtain simple single-mode protocols for quantitatively testing the entanglement structure of multimode quantum states over arbitrary bipartitions. Our results identify the Narcowich-Wigner spectrum as a powerful tool for investigating fundamental properties of bosonic quantum states.

quant-pharXiv:2611.03544•Nov 3, 2026•0 citations

Nonclassicality and entanglement criteria for bipartite optical fields characterized by quadratic detectors

Jan Peřina, Ievgen I. Arkhipov, Václav Michálek +1 more

Numerous inequalities involving moments of integrated intensities and revealing nonclassicality and entanglement in bipartite optical fields are derived using the majorization theory, nonnegative polynomials, the matrix approach, and the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. Different approaches for deriving these inequalities are compared. Using the experimental photocount histogram generated by a weak noisy twin beam monitored by a photon-number-resolving intensified CCD camera, the performance of the derived inequalities is compared. A basic set of 10 inequalities suitable for monitoring entanglement of a twin beam is suggested. Inequalities involving moments of photocounts (photon numbers) as well as some containing directly the elements of photocount (photon-number) distributions are also discussed as a tool for revealing nonclassicality.

arXiv:1710.03793•Physical Review A•Oct 18, 2017•37 citations
We consider a way to generate operational inequalities to test nonclassicality (or quantumness) of multimode bosonic fields (or multiparty bosonic systems) that unifies the derivation of many known inequalities and allows to propose new ones. The nonclassicality criteria are based on Vogel's criterion corresponding to analyzing the positivity of multimode PPP functions or, equivalently, the positivity of matrices of expectation values of, e.g., creation and annihilation operators. We analyze not only monomials but also polynomial functions of such moments, which can sometimes enable simpler derivations of physically relevant inequalities. As an example, we derive various classical inequalities which can be violated only by nonclassical fields. In particular, we show how the criteria introduced here easily reduce to the well-known inequalities describing (a) multimode quadrature squeezing and its generalizations, including sum, difference, and principal squeezing; (b) two-mode one-time photon-number correlations, including sub-Poisson photon-number correlations and effects corresponding to violations of the Cauchy-Schwarz and Muirhead inequalities; (c) two-time single-mode photon-number correlations, including photon antibunching and hyperbunching; and (d) two- and three-mode quantum entanglement. Other simple inequalities for testing nonclassicality are also proposed. We have found some general relations between the nonclassicality and entanglement criteria, in particular those resulting from the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. It is shown that some known entanglement inequalities can be derived as nonclassicality inequalities within our formalism, while some other known entanglement inequalities can be seen as sums of more than one inequality derived from the nonclassicality criterion. This approach enables a deeper analysis of the entanglement for a given nonclassicality.
One of the most relevant problems in the quantum theory is the question whether the appropriate state of the system can be described within a classical theory. The famous examples of nonclassical states are Schrodinger-cats states or entanglement states. In spite of many practical applications of entanglement as a special kind of nonclassicality (like quantum teleportation [1], dense coding [2], or implementation of super-fast [3] and fast algorithms [4]), we still have difficulties with describing and specifying it. One cannot find such an operational optimal method, which would allow us to maximally use the technological and scientific potential arising from the adaptation properties of quantum correlations. Thus, my thesis is focused on giving a proposal of a theoretical recipe for constructing experimentally achievable procedures for the study of quantum correlations. In my thesis I have focused on quantum correlations described in terms of nonclassicality (quantumness) and specific kind of it,i.e., entanglement. The nonclassicality definition, used by me in the thesis, is based on the Glauber-Sudarshan function (P -function). One can assume, that a state is nonclassical, if its P -function is negative or more singular than Dirac’s delta [5]. As follows, the state is nonclassical, when its P -function cannot be treated as a “real” probabilistic distribution. Based on specific properties of the P -function, Agarwal and Tara [6], as well as, Shchukin, Richter and Vogel [7, 8] proposed nonclassicality and entanglement [9] criteria based on matrices of moments of annihilation and creation operators. The operational procedures for analyzing nonclassicality and an efficient method for measuring such moments developed by Shchukin and Vogel [10] creates basis for my thesis. It can be seen that the nonclassicality criteria based on matrices of moments offer an effective way of deriving specific inequalities, which might be useful in the verification of nonclassicality of particular states generated in experiments. Therefore, criteria constructed based on the above definition of nonclassicality can be used to find practical and effective methods of generating and testing nonclassicality and, therefore, also quantum entanglement of optical fields. The results presented in my thesis can be divided into three main groups: 1. Finding operational and practical criteria to classify states in terms of nonclassicality and entanglement based on fundamental classical inequalities like Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. It was also shown how some known entanglement inequalities can be derived as nonclassicality inequalities or as sums of more than one inequality [Bartkowiak2010a]. 2. Describing properties and behaviour of quantum correlations for different optical fields (e.g. for multiand single-mode systems, for interacting and noninteracting modes). In particular, general occurrence of sudden vanishing of nonclassicality, which can be observed not only for twoor multimode but also for single-mode fields, was proven [Bartkowiak2011]. 3. Finding the methods of generating and testing of quantum correlations, which would be practical and easy to implement with available resources in both linear and nonlinear optics.
The study of nonclassical properties of two-mode quantum states is particularly useful in quantum information theory because of the possibilities of obtaining entanglement and other two-mode quantum correlations in these states. Here we have investigated the possibilities of the existence of nonclassicality in a two-mode New generalized binomial state (TMNGBS). Specifically two-mode antibunching, Quadrature squeezing, sum \& difference squeezing, and various entanglement criteria e.g Shchukin-Vogel entanglement criterion, the uncertainty relation of SU(1,1) Algebra and EPR entanglement criterion are explored in two mode particular example of quantum state named as New generalized binomial state. Earlier we studied nonclassicality in single-mode NGBS, here we are extending our study toward the two-mode version of a quantum state. Here we provide the general expressions of moments for a two-mode quantum state (Fock basis) and explore the quantification in a particular example NGBS. It is found that antibunching, squeezing, and SV entanglement are possible with different limits of depending parameters but the entanglement criteria (EPR, SU (1,1) algebra and Cauchy - Schwarz inequality based)for NGBS are not possible. This study opens up the possibility of exploring the two-mode nonclassicality in other states too.
Gaussian states with nonclassical properties such as squeezing and entanglement serve as crucial resources for quantum information processing. Accurately quantifying these properties within multimode Gaussian states has posed some challenges. To address this, we introduce a unified quantification: the "classical-nonclassical polarity," represented by P. For a single mode, a positive value of P captures the reduced minimum quadrature uncertainty below the vacuum noise, while a negative value represents an enlarged uncertainty due to classical mixtures. For multimode systems, a positive P indicates bipartite quantum entanglement. We show that the sum of the total classical-nonclassical polarity is conserved under arbitrary linear optical transformations for any two-mode and three-mode Gaussian states. For any pure multimode Gaussian state, the total classical-nonclassical polarity equals the sum of the mean photon number from single-mode squeezing and two-mode squeezing. Our results provide a new perspective on the quantitative relation between single-mode nonclassicality and entanglement, which may find applications in a unified resource theory of nonclassical features.
Practically applicable criteria for the nonclassicality of quantum states are formulated in terms of different types of moments. For this purpose the moments of the creation and annihilation operators, of two quadratures, and of a quadrature and the photon number operator turn out to be useful. It is shown that all the required moments can be determined by homodyne correlation measurements. An example of a nonclassical effect that is easily characterized by our methods is amplitude-squared squeezing.
Entanglement and nonclassicality are two fundamental features of quantum mechanics which serve as resources in quantum information processing tasks and are tightly connected by two-mode mixing. In this work, we show that the connection between entanglement and nonclassicality extends well beyond the two-mode mixing setting by considering the case of arbitrary multimode Gaussian evolutions. Using the Narcowich-Wigner spectrum as our main technical tool to quantify single-mode phase-space nonclassicality, we derive sufficient conditions for a single-mode state to generate NPT entanglement after a multimode Gaussian unitary evolution, which both tighten and generalize existing criteria. As an application, we obtain simple single-mode protocols for quantitatively testing the entanglement structure of multimode quantum states over arbitrary bipartitions. Our results identify the Narcowich-Wigner spectrum as a powerful tool for investigating fundamental properties of bosonic quantum states.
Numerous inequalities involving moments of integrated intensities and revealing nonclassicality and entanglement in bipartite optical fields are derived using the majorization theory, nonnegative polynomials, the matrix approach, and the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality. Different approaches for deriving these inequalities are compared. Using the experimental photocount histogram generated by a weak noisy twin beam monitored by a photon-number-resolving intensified CCD camera, the performance of the derived inequalities is compared. A basic set of 10 inequalities suitable for monitoring entanglement of a twin beam is suggested. Inequalities involving moments of photocounts (photon numbers) as well as some containing directly the elements of photocount (photon-number) distributions are also discussed as a tool for revealing nonclassicality.