In contrast with software-generated randomness (called pseudo-randomness), quantum randomness can be proven incomputable; that is, it is not exactly reproducible by any algorithm. We provide experimental evidence of incomputability---an asymptotic property---of quantum randomness by performing finite tests of randomness inspired by algorithmic information theory.
In contrast with software-generated randomness (called pseudo-randomness), quantum randomness can be proven incomputable; that is, it is not exactly reproducible by any algorithm. We provide experimental evidence of incomputability---an asymptotic property---of quantum randomness by performing finite tests of randomness inspired by algorithmic information theory.
Our aim is to experimentally study the possibility of distinguishing between quantum sources of randomness--recently proved to be theoretically incomputable--and some well-known computable sources of pseudo-randomness. Incomputability is a necessary, but not sufficient "symptom" of "true randomness". We base our experimental approach on algorithmic information theory which provides characterizations of algorithmic random sequences in terms of the degrees of incompressibility of their finite prefixes. Algorithmic random sequences are incomputable, but the converse implication is false. We have performed tests of randomness on pseudo-random strings (finite sequences) of length 232 generated with software (Mathematica, Maple), which are cyclic (so, strongly computable), the bits of π, which is computable, but not cyclic, and strings produced by quantum measurements (with the commercial device Quantis and by the Vienna IQOQI group). Our empirical tests indicate quantitative differences, some statistically significant, between computable and incomputable sources of "randomness".
Abstract The advantages of quantum random number generators (QRNGs) over pseudo-random number generators (PRNGs) are normally attributed to the nature of quantum measurements. This is often seen as implying the superiority of the sequences of bits themselves generated by QRNGs, despite the absence of empirical tests supporting this. Nonetheless, one may expect sequences of bits generated by QRNGs to have properties that pseudo-random sequences do not; indeed, pseudo-random sequences are necessarily computable, a highly nontypical property of sequences. In this paper, we discuss the differences between QRNGs and PRNGs and the challenges involved in certifying the quality of QRNGs theoretically and testing their output experimentally. While QRNGs are often tested with standard suites of statistical tests, such tests are designed for PRNGs and only verify statistical properties of a QRNG, but are insensitive to many supposed advantages of QRNGs. We discuss the ability to test the incomputability and algorithmic complexity of QRNGs. While such properties cannot be directly verified with certainty, we show how one can construct indirect tests that may provide evidence for the incomputability of QRNGs. We use these tests to compare various PRNGs to a QRNG, based on superconducting transmon qutrits and certified by the Kochen–Specker theorem, to see whether such evidence can be found in practice. While our tests fail to observe a strong advantage of the quantum random sequences due to algorithmic properties, the results are nonetheless informative: some of the test results are ambiguous and require further study, while others highlight difficulties that can guide the development of future tests of algorithmic randomness and incomputability.
Random numbers are used to generate cryptographic keys, to run Monte Carlo simulations, and to train and sample machine learning models. Most software obtains them from deterministic pseudo-random number generators, which have good statistical properties but are predictable once their internal state is known. Quantum random number generators take their output from measurements on quantum systems, whose outcomes are not fixed by any prior state of the device. This article introduces the types of random number generators, reviews studies that compare quantum and pseudo-random numbers in numerical experiments, and lists the sources of randomness available in current computing systems. It then describes applications of quantum randomness in security, hashing, software, artificial intelligence, and public randomness. The quality of encryption is treated as depending on three factors: the algorithm, its implementation, and the randomness of keys and other security-relevant values. We give arguments for which applications benefit from quantum randomness, name further areas in which it could be tested, and outline next steps.
A physical system is determined by a finite set of initial conditions and “laws” represented by equations. The system is computable if we can solve the equations in all instances using a “finite body of mathematical knowledge”. In this case, if the laws of the system can be coded into a computer program, then given the initial conditions of the system, one can compute the system's evolution. Are there incomputable physical systems? This question has been theoretically studied in the last 30–40 years. In this paper, we experimentally show for the first time the strong incomputability of a quantum experiment, namely the outputs of a quantum random number generator. Moreover, the experimental results are robust and statistically significant.
Randomness is an essential ingredient for computation.The pitfalls of software-generated pseudo-randomness arewell-known. So, can we do it better?The obvious candidate is quantum randomness.Quantum randomness has been confirmed by theoretical andexperimental research. The first book containing a million ofquantum random digits—generated by using radioactive decayfrom electronic vacuum tubes—was published by the RANDCorporation in 1955.Is it quantum randomness provable better thenpseudo-randomness? If yes, how much better?
In this thesis we study the generation of randomness from quantum mechanical sources: quantum random number generators (QRNGs). Such devices are thought to provide a better quality of randomness than is possible with classical devices, but the issue is in need of more rigorous study. In Chapter 1 we provide the necessary background for the thesis from both computability and probability theory. We then present and extend some recent results providing a more theoretical grounding for the indeterminism in quantum mechanics. In particular, we show that sequences of quantum random bits are incomputable in the strongest sense: no bit can be provably computed in advance. In Chapter 2 we study in detail the use of von Neumann normalisation for QRNGs producing both finite strings and infinite sequences of bits; such normalisation methods are necessary in order to counter for experimental imperfections. We show that, in the case of a constantly biased source, this normalisation gives the desired uniform distribution. The effect of this normalisation on the (in)computability of the generated sequences is studied, and it is shown that algorithmic randomness and Borel normality are preserved, but e-randomness (and thus incomputability) is, in general, not. Experimental bounds for the extent of departure from the uniform distribution in the non-ideal case of a slowly drifting bias are derived. In Chapter 3 we propose a new QRNG which uses entangled photon pairs and is certified to produce incomputable bits by value indefiniteness; this is the first QRNG with explicit certification by a physical principle. The effects of various experimental imperfections are discussed in detail, and care is taken to make the proposed QRNG as robust as is possible to these. A robust method based on XORing the produced bitstrings together is proposed to further improve the quality of the distribution produced by the QRNG. Various improvements and optimisations to this scheme are discussed.