Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1002.1726

Narratability and Cluster Decomposition

Simon Judes

Published Feb 8, 2010• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently David Albert presented an argument that relativistic quantum theories are non-narratable. That is, specifying the state on every space-like hypersurface in a given foliation of space-time is not in general sufficient to determine the states on other hypersurfaces, so the history of the universe cannot be told as a narration of states at successive times. We show that the system Albert examined to arrive at this conclusion violates cluster decomposition of the S-matrix, a locality requirement satisfied by relativistic quantum field theories. We formulate the general requirements for a system to display non-narratability, and argue that a large class of systems satisfying them violate the cluster decomposition principle.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1002.1726

Related papers

Cluster Decomposition and Two Senses of Isolability

Porter Williams, John Dougherty, Michael E. Miller

In the framework of quantum field theory, one finds multiple load-bearing locality and causality conditions. One of the most important is the cluster decomposition principle, which requires that scattering experiments conducted at large spatial separation have statistically independent results. The principle grounds a number of features of quantum field theory, especially the structure of scattering theory. However, the statistical independence required by cluster decomposition is in tension with the long-range correlations characteristic of entangled states. In this paper, we argue that cluster decomposition is best stated as a condition on the dynamics of a quantum field theory, not directly as a statistical independence condition. This redefinition avoids the tension with entanglement while better capturing the physical significance of cluster decomposition and the role it plays in the structure of quantum field theory.

Philosophy of Physics•Jan 1, 2024•2 citations

RELATIVISTIC QUANTUM DYNAMICS OF MANY-BODY SYSTEMS

F. Coester, Wayne Nicholas Polyzou

Relativistic quantum dynamics requires a unitary representation of the Poincare group on the Hilbert space of states. The dynamics of many-body systems must satisfy cluster separability requirements. In this paper we formulate an abstract framework of four dimensional Euclidean Green functions that can be used to construct relativistic quantum dynamics of N-particle systems consistent with these requirements. This approach should be useful in bridging the gap between few-body dynamics based on phenomenological mass operators and on quantum field theory.

arXiv:nucl-th/0102050•Sep 1, 2001•5 citations

Relativistic Quantum Becoming

Wayne C. Myrvold

In a recent paper, David Albert has suggested that no quantum theory can yield a description of the world unfolding in Minkowski spacetime. This conclusion is premature; a natural extension of Stein's notion of becoming in Minkowski spacetime to accommodate the demands of quantum nonseparability yields such an account, an account that is in accord with a proposal which was made by Aharonov and Albert but which is dismissed by Albert as a ‘mere trick’. The nature of such an account is clarified by an extension to a relativistic quantum context of David Lewis' picture of objective chances evolving in time. 1Introduction 2Classical relativistic becoming 3Relativistic quantum becoming, without collapse 4Relativistic quantum becoming, with collapse 5Objective chance, conditional probability, and definite properties 6The nature of the wave function 7Conclusion

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Sep 1, 2003•36 citations

QUANTUM FIELD COHERENCE AND RELATIVISTIC SPACE-TIME STRUCTURE: CONCEPTUAL AND FOUNDATIONAL ANALYSIS

Mart Kallas, Liis Vaher

Abstract The conceptual unification of quantum mechanics and relativity remains one of the central challenges of modern theoretical physics. While quantum theory successfully describes microscopic phenomena through probabilistic wave dynamics and field quantization, relativity establishes the geometric structure of space-time and the causal organization of physical events. Despite extensive progress in quantum field theory and relativistic quantum frameworks, foundational tensions persist regarding locality, causality, and coherence. This study presents a conceptual and structural analysis of quantum field coherence within relativistic space-time. Rather than focusing on specific unification proposals, we examine the compatibility conditions between quantum coherence, relativistic causality, and space-time structure. Particular attention is given to field-based interpretations of quantum states, entanglement propagation limits, and covariance requirements. The analysis synthesizes perspectives from relativistic quantum field theory, conceptual foundations of quantum measurement, and geometric interpretations of space-time. We argue that coherence phenomena can be understood as structurally constrained by relativistic causal order, without requiring violation of space-time locality. The aim of this article is to clarify foundational relationships between quantum coherence and relativistic structure through a conceptual framework that integrates field-theoretic and geometric viewpoints.

•Mar 3, 2026•0 citations

Wavefunctions and Minkowski Space-Time: On the Reconciliation of Quantum Theory with Special Relativity

Beck, Christian

The implications of the relativistic space-time structure for a physical description by quantum mechanical wave-functions are investigated. On the basis of a detailed analysis of Bell's concept of local causality, which is violated in quantum theory, we argue that this is a subtle, as well as an important effort. A central requirement appearing in relativistic quantum mechanics, namely local commutativity, is analyzed in detail and possible justifications are given and discussed. The complexity of the implications of wave function reduction in connection with Minkowski space-time are illustrated by a quantum mechanical measurement procedure which was proposed by Aharonov and Albert. This procedure and its relativistic implications are explicitly analyzed and discussed in terms of state evolution. This analysis shows that the usual notion of state evolution fails in relativistic quantum theory. Two possible solutions of this problem are given. In particular, it is shown that also a theory with a distinguished foliation of space-time into space-like leafs - accounting for nonlocality - makes the right predictions for the Aharonov-Albert experiment. We will repeatedly encounter that an analysis of the wave-function alone does not suffice to answer the question of relativistic compatibility of the theory, but that the actual events in space time, which are predicted and described by the theory, are crucial. Relativistic versions of quantum mechanical theories which precisely describe actual processes in space-time are briefly described and discussed in the appendix.

arXiv:2009.00440•Aug 29, 2020•1 citation

Successive observations in relativistic quantum theory

M. D. Srinivas

Relativistic quantum theory is formulated as a theory of successive local observations, consistent with all the fundamental requirements of relativistic invariance. Based on the causal structure of the space–time of special relativity, it is argued that the nonrelativistic notion of a ’’time-ordered sequence of instantaneous observations’’should be replaced in a relativistic theory by the notion of a ’’causally ordered sequence of local observations.’’ The fundamental statistical law of relativistic quantum theory is then formulated such that it provides an unambigous prescription for the statistical correlations between the outcomes of any causally ordered sequence of local observations. It is also shown that the fundamental statistical law of the theory is consistent with the so-called ’’principle of local causes’’ which essentially states that the probability connections between a set of local events do not depend on local observations carried out in space–time regions which lie outside of their causal past. Finally, an equivalent formulation of the theory in terms of a relativistically covariant generalization of the collapse postulate is presented.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 1979•5 citations
Recently David Albert presented an argument that relativistic quantum theories are non-narratable. That is, specifying the state on every space-like hypersurface in a given foliation of space-time is not in general sufficient to determine the states on other hypersurfaces, so the history of the universe cannot be told as a narration of states at successive times. We show that the system Albert examined to arrive at this conclusion violates cluster decomposition of the S-matrix, a locality requirement satisfied by relativistic quantum field theories. We formulate the general requirements for a system to display non-narratability, and argue that a large class of systems satisfying them violate the cluster decomposition principle.
In the framework of quantum field theory, one finds multiple load-bearing locality and causality conditions. One of the most important is the cluster decomposition principle, which requires that scattering experiments conducted at large spatial separation have statistically independent results. The principle grounds a number of features of quantum field theory, especially the structure of scattering theory. However, the statistical independence required by cluster decomposition is in tension with the long-range correlations characteristic of entangled states. In this paper, we argue that cluster decomposition is best stated as a condition on the dynamics of a quantum field theory, not directly as a statistical independence condition. This redefinition avoids the tension with entanglement while better capturing the physical significance of cluster decomposition and the role it plays in the structure of quantum field theory.
Relativistic quantum dynamics requires a unitary representation of the Poincare group on the Hilbert space of states. The dynamics of many-body systems must satisfy cluster separability requirements. In this paper we formulate an abstract framework of four dimensional Euclidean Green functions that can be used to construct relativistic quantum dynamics of N-particle systems consistent with these requirements. This approach should be useful in bridging the gap between few-body dynamics based on phenomenological mass operators and on quantum field theory.
In a recent paper, David Albert has suggested that no quantum theory can yield a description of the world unfolding in Minkowski spacetime. This conclusion is premature; a natural extension of Stein's notion of becoming in Minkowski spacetime to accommodate the demands of quantum nonseparability yields such an account, an account that is in accord with a proposal which was made by Aharonov and Albert but which is dismissed by Albert as a ‘mere trick’. The nature of such an account is clarified by an extension to a relativistic quantum context of David Lewis' picture of objective chances evolving in time. 1Introduction 2Classical relativistic becoming 3Relativistic quantum becoming, without collapse 4Relativistic quantum becoming, with collapse 5Objective chance, conditional probability, and definite properties 6The nature of the wave function 7Conclusion
Abstract The conceptual unification of quantum mechanics and relativity remains one of the central challenges of modern theoretical physics. While quantum theory successfully describes microscopic phenomena through probabilistic wave dynamics and field quantization, relativity establishes the geometric structure of space-time and the causal organization of physical events. Despite extensive progress in quantum field theory and relativistic quantum frameworks, foundational tensions persist regarding locality, causality, and coherence. This study presents a conceptual and structural analysis of quantum field coherence within relativistic space-time. Rather than focusing on specific unification proposals, we examine the compatibility conditions between quantum coherence, relativistic causality, and space-time structure. Particular attention is given to field-based interpretations of quantum states, entanglement propagation limits, and covariance requirements. The analysis synthesizes perspectives from relativistic quantum field theory, conceptual foundations of quantum measurement, and geometric interpretations of space-time. We argue that coherence phenomena can be understood as structurally constrained by relativistic causal order, without requiring violation of space-time locality. The aim of this article is to clarify foundational relationships between quantum coherence and relativistic structure through a conceptual framework that integrates field-theoretic and geometric viewpoints.
The implications of the relativistic space-time structure for a physical description by quantum mechanical wave-functions are investigated. On the basis of a detailed analysis of Bell's concept of local causality, which is violated in quantum theory, we argue that this is a subtle, as well as an important effort. A central requirement appearing in relativistic quantum mechanics, namely local commutativity, is analyzed in detail and possible justifications are given and discussed. The complexity of the implications of wave function reduction in connection with Minkowski space-time are illustrated by a quantum mechanical measurement procedure which was proposed by Aharonov and Albert. This procedure and its relativistic implications are explicitly analyzed and discussed in terms of state evolution. This analysis shows that the usual notion of state evolution fails in relativistic quantum theory. Two possible solutions of this problem are given. In particular, it is shown that also a theory with a distinguished foliation of space-time into space-like leafs - accounting for nonlocality - makes the right predictions for the Aharonov-Albert experiment. We will repeatedly encounter that an analysis of the wave-function alone does not suffice to answer the question of relativistic compatibility of the theory, but that the actual events in space time, which are predicted and described by the theory, are crucial. Relativistic versions of quantum mechanical theories which precisely describe actual processes in space-time are briefly described and discussed in the appendix.
Relativistic quantum theory is formulated as a theory of successive local observations, consistent with all the fundamental requirements of relativistic invariance. Based on the causal structure of the space–time of special relativity, it is argued that the nonrelativistic notion of a ’’time-ordered sequence of instantaneous observations’’should be replaced in a relativistic theory by the notion of a ’’causally ordered sequence of local observations.’’ The fundamental statistical law of relativistic quantum theory is then formulated such that it provides an unambigous prescription for the statistical correlations between the outcomes of any causally ordered sequence of local observations. It is also shown that the fundamental statistical law of the theory is consistent with the so-called ’’principle of local causes’’ which essentially states that the probability connections between a set of local events do not depend on local observations carried out in space–time regions which lie outside of their causal past. Finally, an equivalent formulation of the theory in terms of a relativistically covariant generalization of the collapse postulate is presented.