Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1001.2831 · Chinese Physics Letters

Quantum Model of Bertrand Duopoly

Salman Khan, Muhammad Asif Ramzan, M.K.R. Khan

Published Aug 1, 2010• 38 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a quantum model of Bertrand duopoly and study the entanglement behavior on the profit functions of the firms. Using the concept of optimal response of each firm to the price of the opponent, we find only one Nash equilibirum point for the maximally entangled initial state. The presence of quantum entanglement in the initial state gives payoffs higher to the firms than the classical payoffs at the Nash equilibrium. As a result, the dilemma-like situation in the classical game is resolved.

DOI
10.1088/0256-307x/27/8/080302

Related papers

Quantum oligopoly

Chi‐Fai Lo, David Kiang

Based upon a modification of Li et al. 's "minimal" quantization rules ( Phys. Lett. A 306 (2002) 73), we investigate the quantum version of the Cournot and Bertrand oligopoly. In the Cournot oligopoly, the profit of each of the N firms at the Nash equilibrium point rises monotonically with the measure of the quantum entanglement. Only at maximal entanglement, however, does the Nash equilibrium point coincide with the Pareto optimal point. In the Bertrand case, the Bertrand Paradox remains for finite entanglement ( i.e. , the perfectly competitive stage is reached for any N ⩾2), whereas with maximal entanglement each of the N firms will still have a non-zero shared profit. Hence, the Bertrand Paradox is completely resolved. Furthermore, a perfectly competitive market is reached asymptotically for N → ∞ in both the Cournot and Bertrand oligopoly.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Dec 1, 2003•22 citations

Dynamics of a quantum Cournot-Bertrand duopoly model based on bounded rationality and product substitutability

Yu-Chung Chang

The development of quantum information theory based on quantum entangled states is advancing rapidly and has promoted the emergence of quantum game theory. Quantum game theory is quantum information processing applied to classical games, which solves problems that classical games cannot solve. This paper explores the quantum Cournot-Bertrand game model of two firms in a duopoly market with bounded rationality and product substitutability. The first and second firms choose production output and sales price as their decision variables, respectively. We first define the quantum Cournot-Bertrand dynamical system and study the existence and locally stable conditions of equilibrium points. Then we explore bifurcation conditions and bifurcation types. Finally, we do the bifurcation analysis and explore the impacts of the model parameters as the potential market size of products, the two firms' linear marginal cost, the players' speed of strategy adjustment, the product substitution index, and the quantum entanglement degree on the Nash equilibrium stability and bifurcation using numerical analysis and simulation, and provide economic explanations for the results.

Quantum Information Processing•Jul 9, 2025•7 citations

Quantum Cournot model based on general entanglement operator

Katarzyna Bolonek-Lasoń

Abstract The properties of the Cournot model based on the most general entanglement operator containing quadratic expressions which is symmetric with respect to the exchange of players are considered. The degree of entanglement of games dependent on one and two squeezing parameters and their payoff values in Nash equilibrium are compared. The analysis showed that the relationship between the degree of entanglement of the initial state of the game and the payoff values in Nash equilibrium is ambiguous. The phase values included in the entanglement operator have a strong influence on the final outcome of the game. In a quantum duopoly based on the initial state of a game that depends on one squeezing parameter, the maximum possible payoff in Nash equilibrium cannot be reached when the value of the phase parameter is greater than zero, in contrast with a game that depends on two parameters.

arXiv:2406.16049•Quantum Information Processing•Nov 5, 2024•2 citations

Uniqueness of Nash equilibria in a quantum Cournot duopoly game

Yohei Sekiguchi, Kiri Sakahara, Takashi Sato

A quantum Cournot game whose classical form game has multiple Nash equilibria is examined. Although the classical equilibria fail to be Pareto optimal, the quantum equilibrium exhibits the following two properties: (i) if the measurement of entanglement between strategic variables chosen by the competing firms is sufficiently large, the multiplicity of equilibria vanishes, and (ii) the more strongly the strategic variables are entangled, the more closely the unique equilibrium approaches to the optimal one.

arXiv:0910.5275•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 18, 2010•31 citations

Unique Solution to the Quantum Prisoner’s Dilemma Game

Ahmed S. Elgazzar

A quantized version of the prisoner’s dilemma game based on the Marinatto–Weber quantization scheme is introduced. A four-qubit-basis initial entangled quantum state is assumed. Two domains for Nash equilibria are observed in terms of the degree of entanglement of the game. Each Nash equilibrium point is found to be Pareto optimal in its corresponding domain. Therefore, there is a unique solution to the game dilemma in each domain of the entanglement parameter. The maximally entangled limit is studied, and the players’ payoffs are found to equal the average of the payoff matrix independently of their choices. Consequently, any combination of players’ choices is a solution to the dilemma of the game. The nonentangled limits are also studied and found to coincide with the classical mixed-strategy game. Our results are equivalent to those of the noisy schemes of the quantum prisoner’s dilemma game. In our scheme, entanglement can be interpreted as a noise.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Feb 1, 2019•11 citations

Quantum Games with Unawareness with Duopoly Problems in View

Piotr Frąckiewicz, Jakub Bilski

Playing the Cournot duopoly in the quantum domain can lead to the optimal strategy profile in the case of maximally correlated actions of the players. However, that result can be obtained if the fact that the players play the quantum game is common knowledge among the players. Our purpose is to determine reasonable game outcomes when players’ perceptions about what game is actually played are limited. To this end, we consider a collection consisting of the classical and quantum games that specifies how each player views the game and how each player views the other players’ perceptions of the game. We show that a slight change in how the players perceive the game may considerably affect the result of the game and, in the case of maximally correlated strategies, may vary from the inefficient Nash equilibrium outcome in the classical Cournot duopoly to the Pareto optimal outcome. We complete our work by investigating in the same way the Bertrand duopoly model.

Entropy•Nov 10, 2019•7 citations
We present a quantum model of Bertrand duopoly and study the entanglement behavior on the profit functions of the firms. Using the concept of optimal response of each firm to the price of the opponent, we find only one Nash equilibirum point for the maximally entangled initial state. The presence of quantum entanglement in the initial state gives payoffs higher to the firms than the classical payoffs at the Nash equilibrium. As a result, the dilemma-like situation in the classical game is resolved.
Based upon a modification of Li et al. 's "minimal" quantization rules ( Phys. Lett. A 306 (2002) 73), we investigate the quantum version of the Cournot and Bertrand oligopoly. In the Cournot oligopoly, the profit of each of the N firms at the Nash equilibrium point rises monotonically with the measure of the quantum entanglement. Only at maximal entanglement, however, does the Nash equilibrium point coincide with the Pareto optimal point. In the Bertrand case, the Bertrand Paradox remains for finite entanglement ( i.e. , the perfectly competitive stage is reached for any N ⩾2), whereas with maximal entanglement each of the N firms will still have a non-zero shared profit. Hence, the Bertrand Paradox is completely resolved. Furthermore, a perfectly competitive market is reached asymptotically for N → ∞ in both the Cournot and Bertrand oligopoly.
The development of quantum information theory based on quantum entangled states is advancing rapidly and has promoted the emergence of quantum game theory. Quantum game theory is quantum information processing applied to classical games, which solves problems that classical games cannot solve. This paper explores the quantum Cournot-Bertrand game model of two firms in a duopoly market with bounded rationality and product substitutability. The first and second firms choose production output and sales price as their decision variables, respectively. We first define the quantum Cournot-Bertrand dynamical system and study the existence and locally stable conditions of equilibrium points. Then we explore bifurcation conditions and bifurcation types. Finally, we do the bifurcation analysis and explore the impacts of the model parameters as the potential market size of products, the two firms' linear marginal cost, the players' speed of strategy adjustment, the product substitution index, and the quantum entanglement degree on the Nash equilibrium stability and bifurcation using numerical analysis and simulation, and provide economic explanations for the results.
Abstract The properties of the Cournot model based on the most general entanglement operator containing quadratic expressions which is symmetric with respect to the exchange of players are considered. The degree of entanglement of games dependent on one and two squeezing parameters and their payoff values in Nash equilibrium are compared. The analysis showed that the relationship between the degree of entanglement of the initial state of the game and the payoff values in Nash equilibrium is ambiguous. The phase values included in the entanglement operator have a strong influence on the final outcome of the game. In a quantum duopoly based on the initial state of a game that depends on one squeezing parameter, the maximum possible payoff in Nash equilibrium cannot be reached when the value of the phase parameter is greater than zero, in contrast with a game that depends on two parameters.
A quantum Cournot game whose classical form game has multiple Nash equilibria is examined. Although the classical equilibria fail to be Pareto optimal, the quantum equilibrium exhibits the following two properties: (i) if the measurement of entanglement between strategic variables chosen by the competing firms is sufficiently large, the multiplicity of equilibria vanishes, and (ii) the more strongly the strategic variables are entangled, the more closely the unique equilibrium approaches to the optimal one.
A quantized version of the prisoner’s dilemma game based on the Marinatto–Weber quantization scheme is introduced. A four-qubit-basis initial entangled quantum state is assumed. Two domains for Nash equilibria are observed in terms of the degree of entanglement of the game. Each Nash equilibrium point is found to be Pareto optimal in its corresponding domain. Therefore, there is a unique solution to the game dilemma in each domain of the entanglement parameter. The maximally entangled limit is studied, and the players’ payoffs are found to equal the average of the payoff matrix independently of their choices. Consequently, any combination of players’ choices is a solution to the dilemma of the game. The nonentangled limits are also studied and found to coincide with the classical mixed-strategy game. Our results are equivalent to those of the noisy schemes of the quantum prisoner’s dilemma game. In our scheme, entanglement can be interpreted as a noise.
Playing the Cournot duopoly in the quantum domain can lead to the optimal strategy profile in the case of maximally correlated actions of the players. However, that result can be obtained if the fact that the players play the quantum game is common knowledge among the players. Our purpose is to determine reasonable game outcomes when players’ perceptions about what game is actually played are limited. To this end, we consider a collection consisting of the classical and quantum games that specifies how each player views the game and how each player views the other players’ perceptions of the game. We show that a slight change in how the players perceive the game may considerably affect the result of the game and, in the case of maximally correlated strategies, may vary from the inefficient Nash equilibrium outcome in the classical Cournot duopoly to the Pareto optimal outcome. We complete our work by investigating in the same way the Bertrand duopoly model.