Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1001.2085 · New Journal of Physics

Universal thermodynamics of a strongly interacting Fermi gas: theory versus experiment

Hui Hu, Xia-Ji Liu, P. D. Drummond

Published Jun 30, 2010• 78 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Strongly interacting, dilute Fermi gases exhibit a scale-invariant, universal thermodynamic behavior. This is notoriously difficult to understand theoretically because of the absence of a small interaction parameter. Here, we present a systematic comparison of theoretical predictions from different quantum many-body theories with recent experimental data of Nascimbne et al (2010 Nature 463 1057). Our comparisons have no adjustable parameters, either theoretically or experimentally. All the model approximations seem to fluctuate rather than converge on the experimental data. It turns out that a simple Gaussian pair fluctuation theory gives the best quantitative agreement, except at the critical superfluid transition region. In the normal state, we also calculate the equation of state by using a quantum cluster expansion theory and explore in detail its applicability to low temperatures. Using the accurate experimental result for the thermodynamic function S ( T ), we determine the temperature T of a trapped Fermi gas at unitarity as a function of a non-interacting temperature T i , which can be obtained by an adiabatic sweep to the free gas limit. By analyzing the recent experimental data, we find a characteristic temperature ( T / T F ) 0 =0.19±0.02 or ( T i / T F ) 0 =0.16±0.02 in a harmonic trap, below which there are deviations from normal Fermi-liquid-like behavior that may be attributed to pairing effects. Here, T F is the Fermi temperature for a trapped ideal, non-interacting Fermi gas. Our thorough comparison may shed light on the further theoretical development of strongly interacting fermions.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/12/6/063038

Related papers

Universal contact of strongly interacting fermions at finite temperatures

Hui Hu, Xia-Ji Liu, P. D. Drummond

The recently discovered universal thermodynamic behavior of dilute, strongly interacting Fermi gases also implies a universal structure in the many-body pair-correlation function at short distances, as quantified by the contact . Here, we theoretically calculate the temperature dependence of this universal contact for a Fermi gas in free space and in a harmonic trap. At high temperatures above the Fermi degeneracy temperature, T ≳ T F , we obtain a reliable non-perturbative quantum virial expansion up to third order. At low temperatures, we compare different approximate strong-coupling theories. These make different predictions, which need to be tested either by future experiments or by advanced quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We conjecture that in the universal unitarity limit, the contact or correlation decreases monotonically with increasing temperature, unless the temperature is significantly lower than the critical temperature, T ≪ T c ∼0.2 T F . We also discuss briefly how to measure the universal contact in either homogeneous or harmonically trapped Fermi gases.

arXiv:1011.3845•New Journal of Physics•Mar 16, 2011•81 citations

Comparison between theory and experiment for universal thermodynamics of a homogeneous, strongly correlated Fermi gas

Hui Hu, Xia-Ji Liu, P. D. Drummond

We compare the theoretical predictions for universal thermodynamics of a homogeneous, strongly correlated Fermi gas with the latest experimental measurements reported by the ENS group [S. Nascimb\`ene et al., Nature (London) 463, 1057 (2010)] and the Tokyo group [M. Horikoshi et al., Science 327, 442 (2010)]. The theoretical results are obtained using two diagrammatic theories, together with a virial expansion theory combined with a P\'ade approximation. We find good agreement between theory and experiment. In particular, the virial expansion, using a P\'ade approximation up to third order, describes the experimental results extremely well down to the superfluid transition temperature, ${T}_{c}~0.16{T}_{F}$, where ${T}_{F}$ is the Fermi temperature. The comparison in this work complements our previous comparative study on the universal thermodynamics of a strongly correlated but trapped Fermi gas. The comparison also raises interesting issues about the unitary entropy and the applicability of the P\'ade approximation.

Physical Review A•Jun 10, 2011•12 citations

Universal Thermodynamic Behavior of Strongly Interacting Fermi Gases

Xia-Ji Liu, P. D. Drummond, Hui Hu

Theoretical predictions for the universal thermodynamics of strongly interacting Fermi gases are compared with three recent experimental results for the entropy-energyrelation of ultracold trapped gases of 6Li and 40K atoms. Our calculations are based on an analytic theory that includes pair fluctuations beyond mean-field. Excellent agreement with all experimental measurements is obtained, without any free parameters.

Quantum-Atom Optics Downunder (QAO)•Jan 1, 2007•0 citations

Comparison of strong-coupling theories for a two-dimensional Fermi gas

Brendan C. Mulkerin, Kristian Fenech, Paul Dyke +3 more

Understanding the formation of Cooper pairs and the resulting thermodynamic properties of low-dimensional Fermi gases is an important area of research, which may help build our understanding of other low-dimensional systems, such as high-temperature superconductors. In lower dimensions, quantum fluctuations are expected to play an increasingly important role, and the reliability of strong-coupling theories becomes questionable. Here, we present a comparison of recent thermodynamic measurements and theoretical predictions from different many-body $T$-matrix theories for a two-dimensional strongly interacting Fermi gas in the normal state. We find that the fully self-consistent $T$-matrix theory provides the best description of the experimental data over a wide range of temperatures and interatomic interactions.

arXiv:1509.08225•Physical Review A•Dec 29, 2015•26 citations

Thermodynamics of Ultracold Fermi Gases

Sylvain Nascimbène, Nir Navon, Frédéric Chevy +1 more

We will present recent experimental work on the thermodynamics of strongly interacting Fermi gases. We have developed a general method to probe with high precision the Equation of State (EoS) of locally homogeneous ultracold gases. This allows stringent tests of recent many-body theories. First, we focus on the finite-temperature EoS of the unpolarized unitary gas. Precise thermometry is provided by adding to the Fermi gas of 6Li a trace of bosonic 7Li. We show that the low-temperature properties of the strongly interacting normal phase are well described by Fermi liquid theory and we localize the superfluid transition. Second, we address the zero-temperature EoS of the spin-polarized system in the BEC-BCS crossover. Surprisingly, despite strong interactions, the polarized phase behaves as a mixture of two ideal gases: a Fermi gas of majority atoms and a non-interacting gas of dressed quasi-particles, the Fermi polarons. We also obtain the equation of state of the superfluid state as a function of interaction strength, that we compare to Monte Carlo simulations and to the Lee-Huang-Yang corrections for low-density bosonic and fermionic superfluids.

Latin America Optics and Photonics Conference•Jan 1, 2010•6 citations

Universal thermodynamics of a trapped Fermi gas in the superfluid regime: the role of the Pauli principle

D. K. Watson

Abstract Understanding the universal behavior of strongly-interacting systems of particles has been a major goal in multiple fields of physics from atomic physics to cosmology. Using a recently introduced manybody perturbation formalism for fermions which uses group theoretic and graphical techniques to solve the N -body problem, I study the thermodynamic behavior of the unitary regime for a trapped Fermi gas and investigate the role of the Pauli principle in the emergence of collective behavior, specifically superfluidity at ultralow temperatures. The method, which is called symmetry invariant perturbation theory, has no adjustable parameters and currently offers a solution to the manybody Schrodinger equation through first order in inverse dimensionality exactly. The solution at first order defines collective coordinates in terms of five types of N -body normal modes, identified as symmetric stretch, symmetric bend, single particle angular excitation, single particle radial excitation and phonon. A correspondence is established ‘on paper’ that enforces the Pauli principle through the assignment of specific normal mode quantum numbers. Applied at ultracold temperatures, this normal mode assignment yields occupation only in an extremely low frequency N -body phonon mode. A single particle radial excitation mode at a much higher frequency creates a gap that stabilizes the superfluidity at low temperatures. This radial excitation involves excitation of a single particle out of the synced motion of the phonon mode, rather than the breaking of a fermion pair. Coupled with the corresponding values for the energies at unitarity obtained by this manybody calculation, I obtain good agreement with experimental thermodynamic results. In particular, the lambda transition in the specific heat is clearly seen. Based on these findings, I propose a mechanism for the emergence of superfluidity at ultralow temperatures in this unitary regime that is driven by quantum statistics and the enforcement of the Pauli principle through the selection of normal modes. My results for the calculated thermodynamic quantities suggest that the emergence of some collective behaviors in macroscopic systems is due to the Pauli principle producing manybody pairing and the resulting macroscopic occupation of an N -body phonon mode.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Aug 19, 2019•7 citations
Strongly interacting, dilute Fermi gases exhibit a scale-invariant, universal thermodynamic behavior. This is notoriously difficult to understand theoretically because of the absence of a small interaction parameter. Here, we present a systematic comparison of theoretical predictions from different quantum many-body theories with recent experimental data of Nascimbne et al (2010 Nature 463 1057). Our comparisons have no adjustable parameters, either theoretically or experimentally. All the model approximations seem to fluctuate rather than converge on the experimental data. It turns out that a simple Gaussian pair fluctuation theory gives the best quantitative agreement, except at the critical superfluid transition region. In the normal state, we also calculate the equation of state by using a quantum cluster expansion theory and explore in detail its applicability to low temperatures. Using the accurate experimental result for the thermodynamic function S ( T ), we determine the temperature T of a trapped Fermi gas at unitarity as a function of a non-interacting temperature T i , which can be obtained by an adiabatic sweep to the free gas limit. By analyzing the recent experimental data, we find a characteristic temperature ( T / T F ) 0 =0.19±0.02 or ( T i / T F ) 0 =0.16±0.02 in a harmonic trap, below which there are deviations from normal Fermi-liquid-like behavior that may be attributed to pairing effects. Here, T F is the Fermi temperature for a trapped ideal, non-interacting Fermi gas. Our thorough comparison may shed light on the further theoretical development of strongly interacting fermions.
The recently discovered universal thermodynamic behavior of dilute, strongly interacting Fermi gases also implies a universal structure in the many-body pair-correlation function at short distances, as quantified by the contact . Here, we theoretically calculate the temperature dependence of this universal contact for a Fermi gas in free space and in a harmonic trap. At high temperatures above the Fermi degeneracy temperature, T ≳ T F , we obtain a reliable non-perturbative quantum virial expansion up to third order. At low temperatures, we compare different approximate strong-coupling theories. These make different predictions, which need to be tested either by future experiments or by advanced quantum Monte Carlo simulations. We conjecture that in the universal unitarity limit, the contact or correlation decreases monotonically with increasing temperature, unless the temperature is significantly lower than the critical temperature, T ≪ T c ∼0.2 T F . We also discuss briefly how to measure the universal contact in either homogeneous or harmonically trapped Fermi gases.
We compare the theoretical predictions for universal thermodynamics of a homogeneous, strongly correlated Fermi gas with the latest experimental measurements reported by the ENS group [S. Nascimb\`ene et al., Nature (London) 463, 1057 (2010)] and the Tokyo group [M. Horikoshi et al., Science 327, 442 (2010)]. The theoretical results are obtained using two diagrammatic theories, together with a virial expansion theory combined with a P\'ade approximation. We find good agreement between theory and experiment. In particular, the virial expansion, using a P\'ade approximation up to third order, describes the experimental results extremely well down to the superfluid transition temperature, Tc 0.16TF{T}_{c}~0.16{T}_{F}Tc​ 0.16TF​, where TF{T}_{F}TF​ is the Fermi temperature. The comparison in this work complements our previous comparative study on the universal thermodynamics of a strongly correlated but trapped Fermi gas. The comparison also raises interesting issues about the unitary entropy and the applicability of the P\'ade approximation.
Understanding the formation of Cooper pairs and the resulting thermodynamic properties of low-dimensional Fermi gases is an important area of research, which may help build our understanding of other low-dimensional systems, such as high-temperature superconductors. In lower dimensions, quantum fluctuations are expected to play an increasingly important role, and the reliability of strong-coupling theories becomes questionable. Here, we present a comparison of recent thermodynamic measurements and theoretical predictions from different many-body TTT-matrix theories for a two-dimensional strongly interacting Fermi gas in the normal state. We find that the fully self-consistent TTT-matrix theory provides the best description of the experimental data over a wide range of temperatures and interatomic interactions.
We will present recent experimental work on the thermodynamics of strongly interacting Fermi gases. We have developed a general method to probe with high precision the Equation of State (EoS) of locally homogeneous ultracold gases. This allows stringent tests of recent many-body theories. First, we focus on the finite-temperature EoS of the unpolarized unitary gas. Precise thermometry is provided by adding to the Fermi gas of 6Li a trace of bosonic 7Li. We show that the low-temperature properties of the strongly interacting normal phase are well described by Fermi liquid theory and we localize the superfluid transition. Second, we address the zero-temperature EoS of the spin-polarized system in the BEC-BCS crossover. Surprisingly, despite strong interactions, the polarized phase behaves as a mixture of two ideal gases: a Fermi gas of majority atoms and a non-interacting gas of dressed quasi-particles, the Fermi polarons. We also obtain the equation of state of the superfluid state as a function of interaction strength, that we compare to Monte Carlo simulations and to the Lee-Huang-Yang corrections for low-density bosonic and fermionic superfluids.
Abstract Understanding the universal behavior of strongly-interacting systems of particles has been a major goal in multiple fields of physics from atomic physics to cosmology. Using a recently introduced manybody perturbation formalism for fermions which uses group theoretic and graphical techniques to solve the N -body problem, I study the thermodynamic behavior of the unitary regime for a trapped Fermi gas and investigate the role of the Pauli principle in the emergence of collective behavior, specifically superfluidity at ultralow temperatures. The method, which is called symmetry invariant perturbation theory, has no adjustable parameters and currently offers a solution to the manybody Schrodinger equation through first order in inverse dimensionality exactly. The solution at first order defines collective coordinates in terms of five types of N -body normal modes, identified as symmetric stretch, symmetric bend, single particle angular excitation, single particle radial excitation and phonon. A correspondence is established ‘on paper’ that enforces the Pauli principle through the assignment of specific normal mode quantum numbers. Applied at ultracold temperatures, this normal mode assignment yields occupation only in an extremely low frequency N -body phonon mode. A single particle radial excitation mode at a much higher frequency creates a gap that stabilizes the superfluidity at low temperatures. This radial excitation involves excitation of a single particle out of the synced motion of the phonon mode, rather than the breaking of a fermion pair. Coupled with the corresponding values for the energies at unitarity obtained by this manybody calculation, I obtain good agreement with experimental thermodynamic results. In particular, the lambda transition in the specific heat is clearly seen. Based on these findings, I propose a mechanism for the emergence of superfluidity at ultralow temperatures in this unitary regime that is driven by quantum statistics and the enforcement of the Pauli principle through the selection of normal modes. My results for the calculated thermodynamic quantities suggest that the emergence of some collective behaviors in macroscopic systems is due to the Pauli principle producing manybody pairing and the resulting macroscopic occupation of an N -body phonon mode.