Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0912.2367

The shadow system in coordinate space: The shadow system in coordinate space: A locally explicable system that violates Bell's inequality

Leffler, Warren

Published Dec 11, 2009• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We explore the consequences of denying the "emptiness of paths not taken," EPNT, a premise of Bernstein, Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger in their paper titled, Bell theorem without inequalities. Carrying out the negation of EPNT leads to the concept of a "shadow stream." Streams are essentially particle implementations of the path amplitudes in Feynman's formulation of quantum mechanics, resulting in a simple and consistent extension of the standard postulates for quantum mechanics. Following up on the negation of EPNT using shadow streams, we analyze the experimental outcomes in a standard two-particle interferometer. The result is a simple counterexample to Bell's theorem in position/momentum space.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0912.2367

Related papers

The shadow interpretation versus quantum paradoxes

Leffler, Warren

This paper explores the consequences of denying the "emptiness of paths not taken," EPNT, premise of Bernstein, Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger (BGHZ) in their paper titled, Bell theorem without inequalities.[ ] Carrying out the negation of EPNT leads to the concept of a "shadow stream." Streams are essentially particle implementations of the paths in Feynman path-integrals, resulting in a simple and consistent extension of the standard axioms for quantum mechanics. The construct provides elegant resolutions of single- and multi-particle interference paradoxes. Moreover, combining the argument of this paper with that of BGHZ shows that there are just two choices for quantum foundations: interpretations closely similar to the present one or those that harbor instantaneous action at a distance.

arXiv:0906.4992•Jun 26, 2009•0 citations

Bell theorem without inequalities for two spinless particles

Herbert Joseph Bernstein, Daniel M. Greenberger, Michael Horne +1 more

We use the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger [in Bell's Theorem, Quantum Theory,and Conceptions of the Universe, edited by M. Kafatos (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1989)] approach to present three demonstrations of the failure of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) [Phys. Rev. 47, 777 (1935)] local realism for the case of two spinless particles in a two-particle interferometer. The original EPR assumptions of locality and reality do not suffice for this. First, we use the EPR assumptions of locality and reality to establish that in a two-particle interferometer, the path taken by each particle is an element of reality. Second, we supplement the EPR premises by the postulate that when the path taken by a particle is an element of reality, all paths not taken are empty. We emphasize that our approach is not applicable to a single-particle interferometer because there the path taken by the particle cannot be established as an element of reality. We point out that there are real conceptual differences between single-particle, two-particle, and multiparticle interferometry.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1993•63 citations

Bell theorem without inequalities: A single-particle formulation

Marek Czachor

It is demonstrated that the following two postulates are inconsistent: (1) the locality postulate, stating that if two physical systems are noninteracting then no real change can take place in one system in consequence of anything that may be done to the other one; and (2) the hidden-variable postulate, stating that a physical quantity has a pre-existing definite value before a measurement. The proof is based on a particular Mach-Zehnder interferometer in which the first beam splitter is an analyzer of circular polarizations. A left-handed beam of light propagates in this interferometer through only one optical path and does not interact with the interferometer's phase shifter. Still, it is shown that, having detected the photon in one of the output ports of the interferometer, an acceptance of the above hidden-variable postulate implies that we know what would have been the result of the measurement had we chosen a phase shift \ensuremath{\alpha}+\ensuremath{\pi} instead of \ensuremath{\alpha}: The photon would be with certainty detected in the other port. It follows that the phase shifter deterministically influences the behavior of photons at the second beam splitter. The proof is formulated for a single-photon state. Another difference with respect to the ordinary proofs of the Bell theorem is the fact that the alternative settings of the phase shifter correspond to measurements of the same observable (in all other proofs one considers simultaneously the values of complementary observables). The proof is formulated without any use of inequalities and no additional assumption such as ``the emptiness of the path not taken'' is made.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1994•14 citations

The Space of all Paths for a Quantum System: Revisiting EPR and Bell's Theorem

Leffler, Warren

In this paper we identify a hidden premise in Bell's theorem: measurability of the underlying space. But our system (the space of all paths, SP) is not measurable, although it replicates the predictions of standard quantum mechanics. Using it we present three counterexamples to Bell's theorem and also show why Bell-like arguments for more than two particles cannot be carried out in this model. Moreover, we show that the result places severe constraints on possible viable interpretations of quantum mechanics: Either an interpretation must in some form represent a quantum system in terms of all paths within the system or, alternatively, the interpretation must harbor "action at a distance".

arXiv:1109.6049•Sep 27, 2011•0 citations

Bell inequalities and hidden variables over all possible paths in a quantum system

Leffler, Warren

Bell's theorem rests on the following fundamental condition for a local system: P(a,b|alpha, beta, lambda)= P(a|alpha, lambda)P(b|beta, lambda). Here a and b are the outcomes respectively for measurements alpha on one side, and beta on the other, of an experiment involving two entangled particles traveling in opposite directions from a source. The parameter lambda (the set of "hidden variables") represents a more complete description of the joint state of the two particles. Because of lambda, the joint probability of detection is now dependent only on lambda and the local measurement setting of alpha; similarly for the other side and the setting beta. From this equation John Bell derived a simple inequality that is violated by the predictions of quantum mechanics, which is generally taken to imply that quantum mechanics is a nonlocal theory. But, by combining Richard Feynman's formulation of quantum mechanics with a model of particle interaction described by David Deutsch, we develop a system (the "space of all paths," SP) that (1) is immediately seen to replicate the predictions of quantum mechanics, (2) has a single outcome for each quantum event (unlike MWI on which it is partly based), and (3) contains the set lambda of hidden variables consisting of all possible paths from the source to the detectors on each side of the two-particle experiment. However, the set lambda is nonmeasurable, and therefore the above equation is meaningless in SP.

arXiv:1207.6352•Jul 26, 2012•0 citations

Bell’s theorem: Critique of proofs with and without inequalities

K. Hess

Most of the standard proofs of the Bell theorem are based on the Kolmogorov axioms of probability theory. We show that these proofs contain mathematical steps that cannot be reconciled with the Kolmogorov axioms. Specifically we demonstrate that these proofs ignore the conclusion of a theorem of Vorob'ev on the consistency of joint distributions. As a consequence Bell's theorem stated in its full generality remains unproven, in particular, for extended parameter spaces that are still objective local and that include instrument parameters that are correlated by both time and instrument settings. Although the Bell theorem correctly rules out certain small classes of hidden variables, for these extended parameter spaces the standard proofs come to a halt. The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) approach is based on similar fallacious arguments. For this case we are able to present an objective local computer experiment that simulates the experimental test of GHZ performed by Pan, Bouwmeester, Daniell, Weinfurter and Zeilinger and that directly contradicts their claim that Einstein-local elements of reality can neither explain the results of quantum mechanical theory nor their experimental results.

arXiv:quant-ph/0410015•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2005•91 citations
We explore the consequences of denying the "emptiness of paths not taken," EPNT, a premise of Bernstein, Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger in their paper titled, Bell theorem without inequalities. Carrying out the negation of EPNT leads to the concept of a "shadow stream." Streams are essentially particle implementations of the path amplitudes in Feynman's formulation of quantum mechanics, resulting in a simple and consistent extension of the standard postulates for quantum mechanics. Following up on the negation of EPNT using shadow streams, we analyze the experimental outcomes in a standard two-particle interferometer. The result is a simple counterexample to Bell's theorem in position/momentum space.
This paper explores the consequences of denying the "emptiness of paths not taken," EPNT, premise of Bernstein, Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger (BGHZ) in their paper titled, Bell theorem without inequalities.[ ] Carrying out the negation of EPNT leads to the concept of a "shadow stream." Streams are essentially particle implementations of the paths in Feynman path-integrals, resulting in a simple and consistent extension of the standard axioms for quantum mechanics. The construct provides elegant resolutions of single- and multi-particle interference paradoxes. Moreover, combining the argument of this paper with that of BGHZ shows that there are just two choices for quantum foundations: interpretations closely similar to the present one or those that harbor instantaneous action at a distance.
We use the Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger [in Bell's Theorem, Quantum Theory,and Conceptions of the Universe, edited by M. Kafatos (Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, 1989)] approach to present three demonstrations of the failure of Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) [Phys. Rev. 47, 777 (1935)] local realism for the case of two spinless particles in a two-particle interferometer. The original EPR assumptions of locality and reality do not suffice for this. First, we use the EPR assumptions of locality and reality to establish that in a two-particle interferometer, the path taken by each particle is an element of reality. Second, we supplement the EPR premises by the postulate that when the path taken by a particle is an element of reality, all paths not taken are empty. We emphasize that our approach is not applicable to a single-particle interferometer because there the path taken by the particle cannot be established as an element of reality. We point out that there are real conceptual differences between single-particle, two-particle, and multiparticle interferometry.
It is demonstrated that the following two postulates are inconsistent: (1) the locality postulate, stating that if two physical systems are noninteracting then no real change can take place in one system in consequence of anything that may be done to the other one; and (2) the hidden-variable postulate, stating that a physical quantity has a pre-existing definite value before a measurement. The proof is based on a particular Mach-Zehnder interferometer in which the first beam splitter is an analyzer of circular polarizations. A left-handed beam of light propagates in this interferometer through only one optical path and does not interact with the interferometer's phase shifter. Still, it is shown that, having detected the photon in one of the output ports of the interferometer, an acceptance of the above hidden-variable postulate implies that we know what would have been the result of the measurement had we chosen a phase shift \ensuremath{\alpha}+\ensuremath{\pi} instead of \ensuremath{\alpha}: The photon would be with certainty detected in the other port. It follows that the phase shifter deterministically influences the behavior of photons at the second beam splitter. The proof is formulated for a single-photon state. Another difference with respect to the ordinary proofs of the Bell theorem is the fact that the alternative settings of the phase shifter correspond to measurements of the same observable (in all other proofs one considers simultaneously the values of complementary observables). The proof is formulated without any use of inequalities and no additional assumption such as ``the emptiness of the path not taken'' is made.
In this paper we identify a hidden premise in Bell's theorem: measurability of the underlying space. But our system (the space of all paths, SP) is not measurable, although it replicates the predictions of standard quantum mechanics. Using it we present three counterexamples to Bell's theorem and also show why Bell-like arguments for more than two particles cannot be carried out in this model. Moreover, we show that the result places severe constraints on possible viable interpretations of quantum mechanics: Either an interpretation must in some form represent a quantum system in terms of all paths within the system or, alternatively, the interpretation must harbor "action at a distance".
Bell's theorem rests on the following fundamental condition for a local system: P(a,b|alpha, beta, lambda)= P(a|alpha, lambda)P(b|beta, lambda). Here a and b are the outcomes respectively for measurements alpha on one side, and beta on the other, of an experiment involving two entangled particles traveling in opposite directions from a source. The parameter lambda (the set of "hidden variables") represents a more complete description of the joint state of the two particles. Because of lambda, the joint probability of detection is now dependent only on lambda and the local measurement setting of alpha; similarly for the other side and the setting beta. From this equation John Bell derived a simple inequality that is violated by the predictions of quantum mechanics, which is generally taken to imply that quantum mechanics is a nonlocal theory. But, by combining Richard Feynman's formulation of quantum mechanics with a model of particle interaction described by David Deutsch, we develop a system (the "space of all paths," SP) that (1) is immediately seen to replicate the predictions of quantum mechanics, (2) has a single outcome for each quantum event (unlike MWI on which it is partly based), and (3) contains the set lambda of hidden variables consisting of all possible paths from the source to the detectors on each side of the two-particle experiment. However, the set lambda is nonmeasurable, and therefore the above equation is meaningless in SP.
Most of the standard proofs of the Bell theorem are based on the Kolmogorov axioms of probability theory. We show that these proofs contain mathematical steps that cannot be reconciled with the Kolmogorov axioms. Specifically we demonstrate that these proofs ignore the conclusion of a theorem of Vorob'ev on the consistency of joint distributions. As a consequence Bell's theorem stated in its full generality remains unproven, in particular, for extended parameter spaces that are still objective local and that include instrument parameters that are correlated by both time and instrument settings. Although the Bell theorem correctly rules out certain small classes of hidden variables, for these extended parameter spaces the standard proofs come to a halt. The Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) approach is based on similar fallacious arguments. For this case we are able to present an objective local computer experiment that simulates the experimental test of GHZ performed by Pan, Bouwmeester, Daniell, Weinfurter and Zeilinger and that directly contradicts their claim that Einstein-local elements of reality can neither explain the results of quantum mechanical theory nor their experimental results.