Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0912.1565 · Physica Scripta

An analogue of the Heisenberg uncertainty relation in prequantum classical field theory

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Published Feb 1, 2010• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT) is a model which provides a possibility to represent averages of quantum observables, including correlations of observables on subsystems of a composite system, as averages with respect to fluctuations of classical random fields. PCSFT is a classical model of the wave type. For example, "electron" is described by electronic field. In contrast to QM, this field is a real physical field and not a field of probabilities. An important point is that the prequantum field of e.g. electron contains the irreducible contribution of the background field, vacuum fluctuations. In principle, the traditional QM-formalism can be considered as a special regularization procedure: subtraction of averages with respect to vacuum fluctuations. In this paper we derive a classical analog of the Heisenberg-Robertson inequality for dispersions of functionals of classical (prequantum) fields. PCSFT Robertson-like inequality provides a restriction on the product of classical dispersions. However, this restriction is not so rigid as in QM. The quantum dispersion corresponds to the difference between e.g. the electron field dispersion and the dispersion of vacuum fluctuations. Classical Robertson-like inequality contains these differences. Hence, it does not imply such a rigid estimate from below for dispersions as it was done in QM.

DOI
10.1088/0031-8949/81/06/065001

Related papers

PREQUANTUM CLASSICAL STATISTICAL FIELD THEORY: DERIVATION OF GAUSSIANITY OF PROBABILITY DISTRIBUTIONS

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We developed a purely field model of microphenomena – prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). This model reproduces important probabilistic predictions of QM including correlations for entangled systems. The presence of the sufficiently strong background field is a fundamental element of PCSFT. In the absence of such a field (“fluctuations of vacuum”) PCSFT can reproduce correlations only for quantum systems in factorizable states. By taking into account a random background (of the white noise type) we are able to construct the classical field representation in the general case. This has been done under the additional assumption that prequantum random fields are Gaussian. In previous works on PCSFT, Gaussianity of prequantum fields was invented as a purely mathematical assumption – to simplify calculation of correlations. In this paper we present the derivation of Gaussianity by representing the probability distributions of prequantum fields as the limiting distributions of wave-pulse Poissonian processes.

QP-PQ, quantum probability and white noise analysis•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Prequantum classical statistical field theory: background field as a source of everything?

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT) is a new attempt to consider quantum mechanics (QM) as an emergent phenomenon, cf. with De Broglie's "double solution" approach, Bohmian mechanics, stochastic electrodynamics (SED), Nelson's stochastic QM and its generalization by Davidson, 't Hooft's models and their development by Elze. PCSFT is a comeback to a purely wave viewpoint on QM, cf. with early Schrodinger. There is no quantum particles at all, only waves. In particular, photons are simply wave-pulses of the classical electromagnetic field, cf. SED. Moreover, even massive particles are special "prequantum fields": the electron field, the neutron field, and so on. PCSFT claims that (sooner or later) people will be able to measure components of these fields: components of the "photonic field" (the classical electromagnetic field of low intensity), electronic field, neutronic field, and so on. At the moment we are able to produce quantum correlations as correlations of classical Gaussian random fields. In this paper we are interested in mathematical and physical reasons of usage of Gaussian fields. We consider prequantum signals (corresponding to quantum systems) as composed of a huge number of wave-pulses (on very fine prequantum time scale). We speculate that the prequantum background field (the field of "vacuum fluctuations") might play the role of a source of such pulses, i.e., the source of everything.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 8, 2011•7 citations

Can fluctuations of classical random field produce quantum averages?

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

Albert Einstein did not believe in completeness of QM. He dreamed of creation of prequantum classical statistical mechanics such that QM will be reproduced as its approximation. He also dreamed of total exclusion of corpuscules from the future model. Reality of Einstein's dream was pure fields' reality. Recently I made his dream come true in the form of so called prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). In this approach quantum systems are described by classical random fields, e.g., electromagnetic field (instead of photon), electron field or neutron field. In this paper we generalize PCSFT to composite quantum system. It is well known that in QM, unlike classical mechanics, the state of a composite system is described by the tensor product of state spaces for its subsystems. In PCSFT one can still use Cartesian product, but state spaces are spaces of classical fields (not particles). In particular, entanglement is nothing else than correlation of classical random fields, cf. again Einstein. Thus entanglement was finally demystified.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Aug 20, 2009•0 citations

Prequantum Classical Statistical Field Theory (PCSFT)

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

This chapter presents the basics of the mathematical formalism and methodologyof the prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). In theBild-conception framework, PCSFT gives an example of acausal theoretical model (CTM) beyond QM, considered as observationalmodel (OM). Generally CTM-OM correspondence is not as straightforwardas in Bell’s model with hidden variables. In PCSFT hidden variables are randomfields fluctuating at spatial and temporal scales which are essentiallyfiner than those approached by the present measurement technology. Thekey element of the PCSFT-QM correspondence is mapping of the complexcovariance operator of a subquantum random field to the density operator.For compound systems, the situation is more complicated. Here PCSFT providestwo descriptions of compound systems with random fields valued intensor vs. Cartesian product of the Hilbert spaces of subsystems. The lattermodel matches representation of compound systems in classical statisticalmechanics. Both approaches are used for measure-theoretic representationof the correlations violating the Bell inequalities.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 28, 2024•0 citations

Correlations of components of prequantum field corresponding to biparticle quantum system

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

In a series of previous papers we developed a purely wave model of microphenomena, the so-called prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). Important probabilistic predictions of QM including correlations of entangled systems can be reproduced by PCSFT. In this note we show that our model provides even a possibility to go beyond QM. By PCSFT each conventional QM-observable is represented by the corresponding quadratic functional of the prequantum field. Consideration of nonquadratic functionals in the PCSFT framework extends essentially the class of observables on microsystems, comparing with QM. In this note we restrict our studies to simplest functionals of such type, namely, to the linear functionals. In particular, components of the prequantum field are represented as these functionals. We find their correlations. As an example, we find the correlation between polarization vectors of a pair of entangled photons in the Bell state. This is a new prediction that in principle can be experimentally checked, even if actual experiments may require essential improvements of our present instrumentation.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•May 1, 2010•27 citations

Prequantum Classical Statistical Field Theory—PCSFT

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Guillaume Adenier, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov +3 more

In this short note we present (without to go into mathematical details) the main notions of Prequantum Classical Statistical Field Theory (PCSFT): theory of classical fields which fluctuations produce averages approximatively coinciding with averages given by the quantum formalism. Thus the conventional quantum mechanics can be considered as a probabilistic approximation of a more detailed classical field model. Experimental predictions of PCSFT are discussed

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2007•4 citations
Prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT) is a model which provides a possibility to represent averages of quantum observables, including correlations of observables on subsystems of a composite system, as averages with respect to fluctuations of classical random fields. PCSFT is a classical model of the wave type. For example, "electron" is described by electronic field. In contrast to QM, this field is a real physical field and not a field of probabilities. An important point is that the prequantum field of e.g. electron contains the irreducible contribution of the background field, vacuum fluctuations. In principle, the traditional QM-formalism can be considered as a special regularization procedure: subtraction of averages with respect to vacuum fluctuations. In this paper we derive a classical analog of the Heisenberg-Robertson inequality for dispersions of functionals of classical (prequantum) fields. PCSFT Robertson-like inequality provides a restriction on the product of classical dispersions. However, this restriction is not so rigid as in QM. The quantum dispersion corresponds to the difference between e.g. the electron field dispersion and the dispersion of vacuum fluctuations. Classical Robertson-like inequality contains these differences. Hence, it does not imply such a rigid estimate from below for dispersions as it was done in QM.
We developed a purely field model of microphenomena – prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). This model reproduces important probabilistic predictions of QM including correlations for entangled systems. The presence of the sufficiently strong background field is a fundamental element of PCSFT. In the absence of such a field (“fluctuations of vacuum”) PCSFT can reproduce correlations only for quantum systems in factorizable states. By taking into account a random background (of the white noise type) we are able to construct the classical field representation in the general case. This has been done under the additional assumption that prequantum random fields are Gaussian. In previous works on PCSFT, Gaussianity of prequantum fields was invented as a purely mathematical assumption – to simplify calculation of correlations. In this paper we present the derivation of Gaussianity by representing the probability distributions of prequantum fields as the limiting distributions of wave-pulse Poissonian processes.
Prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT) is a new attempt to consider quantum mechanics (QM) as an emergent phenomenon, cf. with De Broglie's "double solution" approach, Bohmian mechanics, stochastic electrodynamics (SED), Nelson's stochastic QM and its generalization by Davidson, 't Hooft's models and their development by Elze. PCSFT is a comeback to a purely wave viewpoint on QM, cf. with early Schrodinger. There is no quantum particles at all, only waves. In particular, photons are simply wave-pulses of the classical electromagnetic field, cf. SED. Moreover, even massive particles are special "prequantum fields": the electron field, the neutron field, and so on. PCSFT claims that (sooner or later) people will be able to measure components of these fields: components of the "photonic field" (the classical electromagnetic field of low intensity), electronic field, neutronic field, and so on. At the moment we are able to produce quantum correlations as correlations of classical Gaussian random fields. In this paper we are interested in mathematical and physical reasons of usage of Gaussian fields. We consider prequantum signals (corresponding to quantum systems) as composed of a huge number of wave-pulses (on very fine prequantum time scale). We speculate that the prequantum background field (the field of "vacuum fluctuations") might play the role of a source of such pulses, i.e., the source of everything.
Albert Einstein did not believe in completeness of QM. He dreamed of creation of prequantum classical statistical mechanics such that QM will be reproduced as its approximation. He also dreamed of total exclusion of corpuscules from the future model. Reality of Einstein's dream was pure fields' reality. Recently I made his dream come true in the form of so called prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). In this approach quantum systems are described by classical random fields, e.g., electromagnetic field (instead of photon), electron field or neutron field. In this paper we generalize PCSFT to composite quantum system. It is well known that in QM, unlike classical mechanics, the state of a composite system is described by the tensor product of state spaces for its subsystems. In PCSFT one can still use Cartesian product, but state spaces are spaces of classical fields (not particles). In particular, entanglement is nothing else than correlation of classical random fields, cf. again Einstein. Thus entanglement was finally demystified.
This chapter presents the basics of the mathematical formalism and methodologyof the prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). In theBild-conception framework, PCSFT gives an example of acausal theoretical model (CTM) beyond QM, considered as observationalmodel (OM). Generally CTM-OM correspondence is not as straightforwardas in Bell’s model with hidden variables. In PCSFT hidden variables are randomfields fluctuating at spatial and temporal scales which are essentiallyfiner than those approached by the present measurement technology. Thekey element of the PCSFT-QM correspondence is mapping of the complexcovariance operator of a subquantum random field to the density operator.For compound systems, the situation is more complicated. Here PCSFT providestwo descriptions of compound systems with random fields valued intensor vs. Cartesian product of the Hilbert spaces of subsystems. The lattermodel matches representation of compound systems in classical statisticalmechanics. Both approaches are used for measure-theoretic representationof the correlations violating the Bell inequalities.
In a series of previous papers we developed a purely wave model of microphenomena, the so-called prequantum classical statistical field theory (PCSFT). Important probabilistic predictions of QM including correlations of entangled systems can be reproduced by PCSFT. In this note we show that our model provides even a possibility to go beyond QM. By PCSFT each conventional QM-observable is represented by the corresponding quadratic functional of the prequantum field. Consideration of nonquadratic functionals in the PCSFT framework extends essentially the class of observables on microsystems, comparing with QM. In this note we restrict our studies to simplest functionals of such type, namely, to the linear functionals. In particular, components of the prequantum field are represented as these functionals. We find their correlations. As an example, we find the correlation between polarization vectors of a pair of entangled photons in the Bell state. This is a new prediction that in principle can be experimentally checked, even if actual experiments may require essential improvements of our present instrumentation.