Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0910.3253 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

An anhomomorphic logic for quantum mechanics

Stanley Gudder

Published Feb 9, 2010• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Although various schemes for anhomomorphic logics for quantum mechanics have been considered in the past we shall mainly concentrate on the quadratic or grade-2 scheme. In this scheme, the grade-2 truth functions are called coevents. We discuss properties of coevents, projections on the space of coevents and the master observable. We show that the set of projections forms an orthomodular poset. We introduce the concept of precluding coevents and show that this is stronger than the previously studied concept of preclusive coevents. Precluding coevents are defined naturally in terms of the master observable. A result that exhibits a duality between preclusive and precluding coevents is given. Some simple examples are presented.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/43/9/095302

Related papers

The emergence of probabilities in anhomomorphic logic

Yousef Ghazi-Tabatabai, Petros Wallden

Anhomomorphic logic is a new interpretation of Quantum Theory (due to R. Sorkin). It is a histories formulation (c.f. consistent histories, quantum measure theory). In this approach, reality is a co-event, which is essentially an assignment of a truth value {True, False} to each question. The way this assignment is done mimics classical physics in as much as possible allowing however for sufficient flexibility to accommodate quantum 'paradoxes', as is shown by the analysis of Kochen-Specker theorem. In this contribution, after briefly reviewing the approach, we will examine how probabilistic predictions can arise. The Cournot principle and the use of approximate preclusions will play a crucial role. Facing similar problems in interpreting probability as in classical probability theory, we will resort to the weak form of Cournot principle, where possible realities will be preclusive co-events and the quantum measure is used to obtain predictions. Examples considered, includes the fair coin and the double slit pattern arguably one of the most important paradigms for quantum theory.

arXiv:0907.0754•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2009•12 citations

An exercise in "anhomomorphic logic"

Rafael D. Sorkin

A classical logic exhibits a threefold inner structure comprising an algebra of propositions , a space of "truth values" V , and a distinguished family of mappings ϕ from propositions to truth values. Classically is a Boolean algebra, V = 2 , and the admissible maps ϕ: 2 are homomorphisms . If one admits a larger set of maps, one obtains an anhomomorphic logic that seems better suited to quantal reality (and the needs of quantum gravity). I explain these ideas and illustrate them with three simple examples.

arXiv:quant-ph/0703276•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2007•55 citations

Quantum reality filters

Stan Gudder

An anhomomorphic logic $\ascript ^*$ is the set of all possible realities for a quantum system. Our main goal is to find the "actual reality" $ϕ_a\in\ascript ^*$ for the system. Reality filters are employed to eliminate unwanted potential realities until only $ϕ_a$ remains. In this paper, we consider three reality filters that are constructed by means of quantum integrals. A quantum measure $μ$ can generate or actualize a $ϕ\in\ascript ^*$ if $μ(A)$ is a quantum integral with respect to $ϕ$ for a density function $f$ over events $A$. In this sense, $μ$ is an "average" of the truth values of $ϕ$ with weights given by $f$. We mainly discuss relations between these filters and their existence and uniqueness properties. For example, we show that a quadratic reality generated by a quantum measure is unique. In this case we obtain the unique actual quadratic reality.

arXiv:1002.4225•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Nov 11, 2010•3 citations

On the structure of quantum logic

Peter D. Finch

In the axiomatic development of the logic of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics it is not difficult to set down certain plausible axioms which ensure that the quantum logic of propositions has the structure of an orthomodular poset. This can be done in a number of ways, for example, as in Gunson [2], Mackey [4], Piron [5], Varadarajan [7] and Zierler [8], and we summarise one of these ways in §2 below.

Journal of Symbolic Logic•Jul 25, 1969•50 citations

Quantum logic and projective spaces

Lada Peksová

A set of statements about the properties of a quantum system is looked at as at a partially ordered set of subspaces of finite or infinite dimensional Hilbert space. The operation of ordering is performed on a set of propositions comparing the truth values of these propositions and on the set of subspaces as the opera- tion of inclusion. Based on the required properties these structures are translated into operations on the lattice. The correspondence with Heisenberg uncertainty principle is shown there. Furthermore, it is shown that the lattices correspond- ing to the subspaces of infinite dimensional Hilbert space are not modular. This property is replaced with weaker property of orthomodularity, when operation of the negation is added. Following the work of G. Birkhoff and J. von Neumann, the structure of quantum logic is looked for in projective spaces, which are in- troduced either arithmetically or axiomatically. The examples of quantum logic, their physical implementation and eventual implementation in projective spaces are analysed. 1

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Introduction to a Quantum Logic

Enrico G. Beltrametti, Gianni Cassinelli, Peter Carruthers

In a sense this chapter is marginal to the content of this volume; the reader can skip it without prejudice to the comprehension of chapters to follow. Quantum logic is a discipline that branched off from the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann and has the orthomodular-poset structures encountered in previous chapters as basic mathematical carriers: that is why we think it worthwhile to devote some pages to the subject. But the main interests quantum logic calls into play are in the territory of logicians and philosophers: that is why we (who are neither logicians nor philosophers) shall confine ourselves to a very simplified introduction to the subject.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 28, 1984•1 citation
Although various schemes for anhomomorphic logics for quantum mechanics have been considered in the past we shall mainly concentrate on the quadratic or grade-2 scheme. In this scheme, the grade-2 truth functions are called coevents. We discuss properties of coevents, projections on the space of coevents and the master observable. We show that the set of projections forms an orthomodular poset. We introduce the concept of precluding coevents and show that this is stronger than the previously studied concept of preclusive coevents. Precluding coevents are defined naturally in terms of the master observable. A result that exhibits a duality between preclusive and precluding coevents is given. Some simple examples are presented.
Anhomomorphic logic is a new interpretation of Quantum Theory (due to R. Sorkin). It is a histories formulation (c.f. consistent histories, quantum measure theory). In this approach, reality is a co-event, which is essentially an assignment of a truth value {True, False} to each question. The way this assignment is done mimics classical physics in as much as possible allowing however for sufficient flexibility to accommodate quantum 'paradoxes', as is shown by the analysis of Kochen-Specker theorem. In this contribution, after briefly reviewing the approach, we will examine how probabilistic predictions can arise. The Cournot principle and the use of approximate preclusions will play a crucial role. Facing similar problems in interpreting probability as in classical probability theory, we will resort to the weak form of Cournot principle, where possible realities will be preclusive co-events and the quantum measure is used to obtain predictions. Examples considered, includes the fair coin and the double slit pattern arguably one of the most important paradigms for quantum theory.
A classical logic exhibits a threefold inner structure comprising an algebra of propositions , a space of "truth values" V , and a distinguished family of mappings ϕ from propositions to truth values. Classically is a Boolean algebra, V = 2 , and the admissible maps ϕ: 2 are homomorphisms . If one admits a larger set of maps, one obtains an anhomomorphic logic that seems better suited to quantal reality (and the needs of quantum gravity). I explain these ideas and illustrate them with three simple examples.
An anhomomorphic logic $\ascript ^*$ is the set of all possible realities for a quantum system. Our main goal is to find the "actual reality" $ϕ_a\in\ascript ^*$ for the system. Reality filters are employed to eliminate unwanted potential realities until only ϕaϕ_aϕa​ remains. In this paper, we consider three reality filters that are constructed by means of quantum integrals. A quantum measure μμμ can generate or actualize a $ϕ\in\ascript ^*$ if μ(A)μ(A)μ(A) is a quantum integral with respect to ϕϕϕ for a density function fff over events AAA. In this sense, μμμ is an "average" of the truth values of ϕϕϕ with weights given by fff. We mainly discuss relations between these filters and their existence and uniqueness properties. For example, we show that a quadratic reality generated by a quantum measure is unique. In this case we obtain the unique actual quadratic reality.
A set of statements about the properties of a quantum system is looked at as at a partially ordered set of subspaces of finite or infinite dimensional Hilbert space. The operation of ordering is performed on a set of propositions comparing the truth values of these propositions and on the set of subspaces as the opera- tion of inclusion. Based on the required properties these structures are translated into operations on the lattice. The correspondence with Heisenberg uncertainty principle is shown there. Furthermore, it is shown that the lattices correspond- ing to the subspaces of infinite dimensional Hilbert space are not modular. This property is replaced with weaker property of orthomodularity, when operation of the negation is added. Following the work of G. Birkhoff and J. von Neumann, the structure of quantum logic is looked for in projective spaces, which are in- troduced either arithmetically or axiomatically. The examples of quantum logic, their physical implementation and eventual implementation in projective spaces are analysed. 1
In a sense this chapter is marginal to the content of this volume; the reader can skip it without prejudice to the comprehension of chapters to follow. Quantum logic is a discipline that branched off from the 1936 paper of Birkhoff and von Neumann and has the orthomodular-poset structures encountered in previous chapters as basic mathematical carriers: that is why we think it worthwhile to devote some pages to the subject. But the main interests quantum logic calls into play are in the territory of logicians and philosophers: that is why we (who are neither logicians nor philosophers) shall confine ourselves to a very simplified introduction to the subject.