Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0910.0769 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Constraint-induced mean curvature dependence of Cartesian momentum operators

Q H Liu, C L Tong, M M Lai

Published Mar 23, 2007• 35 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Hermitian Cartesian quantum momentum operator p for an embedded surface M in R 3 is proved to be a constant factor −iℏ times the mean curvature vector field H n added to the usual differential term. With use of this form of momentum operators, the operator-ordering ambiguity exists in the construction of the correct kinetic energy operator and three different operator-orderings lead to the same result.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/40/15/007

Related papers

Gauge Transformation and Constraint Induced Operator Ordering for Charged Rigid Planar Rotator in Uniform Magnetic Field

Lai Mei-Mei, Wang Xin, Yanping Xiao +1 more

When the motion of a particle is constrained, excess terms exist using hermitian form of Cartesian momentum p i ( i = 1,2,3) in usual kinetic energy (1/2μ)∑ p i 2 , and the correct kinetic energy turns out to be (1/2μ)∑1/ f i p i f i p i , where f i are dummy factors in classical mechanics and nontrivial in quantum mechanics. In this paper the explicit form of the dummy functions f i is given for a charged rigid planar rotator in the uniform magnetic field with different gauge chosen. Under different gauges, we have different sets of dummy factors. It means that these factors do not have direct observable effect.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Nov 1, 2006•2 citations

The Cartesian momentum and the kinetic operators on curved surfaces

Quanhui Liu, 湖南大学理论物理研究所,长沙 410082

For describing particles moving on the two dimensional curved surfaces, we can use either the intrinsic local coordinates or the Cartesian coordinates. The representation of the momentum operators differs from each other in these two kinds of coordinates, the former ones depend on the intrinsic geometrical quantities, but the latter case depend on a geometrical invariant, namely the mean curvature. Taking the operator-ordering problem into consideration, the kinetic operator for the former case can be expressed in a possibly unique way, while that for latter case can be expressed in two different ways.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2008•1 citation

A Secondary Operator Ordering Problem for a Charged Rigid Planar Rotator in Uniform Magnetic Field

Yanping Xiao, Meimei Lai, Ji-Xuan Hou +2 more

When the motion of a particle is constrained, an excess term exists using hermitian form of Cartesian momentum p i ( i =1,2,3) in usual kinetic energy (1/2μ) ∑ p i 2 , and the correct kinetic energy turns out to be (1/2μ) ∑ (1/ f i ) p i f i p i , where the f i are dummy factors in classical mechanics and nontrivial in quantum mechanics. In this paper the explicit form of the dummy functions f i is given for a charged rigid planar rotator in the uniform magnetic field.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Jul 1, 2005•8 citations

A Secondary Operator Ordering Problem for a Charged Rigid Planar Rotator in Uniform Magnetic Field

Xiao Xiao, Yanping, Lai +7 more

When the motion of a particle is constrained, an excess term exists using hermitian form of Cartesian momentum pi (i = 1, 2, 3) in usual kinetic energy (1/2μ)∑p2i, and the correct kinetic energy turns out to be (1/2μ) ∑(1/ fi)pifipi, where the fi are dummy factors in classical mechanics and nontrivial in quantum mechanics. In this paper the explicit form of the dummy functions fi is given for a charged rigid planar rotator in the uniform magnetic field.

理论物理通讯:英文版•Jan 1, 2005•2 citations

Generalized Momentum Operators in Quantum Mechanics

Peter D. Robinson, Joseph O. Hirschfelder

The usual form P0 for the quantum-mechanical operator P conjugate to a generalized coordinate q1 is, in atomic units, P0=−ig−12 ∂/∂q1(g12),where g is the Jacobian of the transformation from Cartesian coordinates to the generalized coordinates. However, in some cases, this plusible form for P is not Hermitian with respect to physically acceptable bound-state wavefunctions, as it must be if it is to represent a real observable quantity. In this paper, the general form P=−i(A·grad+12 div A)is justified. Here A = h1q̂1, where h1 is the metric scale factor corresponding to q1, and q̂1 is the unit vector in the direction of increasing q1. This general form reduces to P0 if the usual formula for the divergence is applied. In the cases where P0 is not Hermitian, it transpires that q̂1 is ill-defined at one or both of the end points α and β of the range of q1, and the divergence formula is thus invalid at such points. It is shown that, in order to obtain a Hermitian form for P, certain terms involving delta functions similar to Dirac's must be added to the usual formula for div A. These terms can be regarded as implicit in div A. If q̂1 is ill-defined at the lower limit q1 = α, then the resulting new Hermitian form for P, which we propose as the correct one, is P=−i[g−12 ∂/∂q1(g12)+12 δ+(q1−α)]. If q̂1 is, in addition, ill-defined at the upper limit q1 = β, then the extra term +½i δ_(β − q1) must be added. Corresponding new forms are obtained for the Laplacian operator. In addition, the new formulas for P are applied to hypervirial relations. In the Appendix, Charles Goebel obtains a similar expression for the momentum operators by replacing the metric scale function by θg where θ is a step function, unity inside and zero outside the range of definition of the generalized coordinates. The differentiation of θ then produces the delta functions.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1963•29 citations

Symmetric Surface Momentum and Centripetal Force for a Particle on a Curved Surface

M. S. Shikakhwa

Abstract The Hermitian surface momentum operator for a particle confined to a 2D curved surface spanned by orthogonal coordinates and embedded in 3D space is expressed as a symmetric expression in derivatives with respect to the surface coordinates and so is manifestly along the surface. This is an alternative form to the one reported in the literature and usually named geometric momentum, which has a term proportional to the mean curvature along the direction normal to the surface, and so “apparently” not along the surface. The symmetric form of the momentum is the sum of two symmetric Hermitian operators along the two orthogonal directions defined by the surface coordinates. The centripetal force operator for a particle on the surface of a cylinder and a sphere is calculated by taking the time derivative of the momentum and is seen to be a symmetrization of the well-known classical expressions.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 2018•4 citations
The Hermitian Cartesian quantum momentum operator p for an embedded surface M in R 3 is proved to be a constant factor −iℏ times the mean curvature vector field H n added to the usual differential term. With use of this form of momentum operators, the operator-ordering ambiguity exists in the construction of the correct kinetic energy operator and three different operator-orderings lead to the same result.
When the motion of a particle is constrained, excess terms exist using hermitian form of Cartesian momentum p i ( i = 1,2,3) in usual kinetic energy (1/2μ)∑ p i 2 , and the correct kinetic energy turns out to be (1/2μ)∑1/ f i p i f i p i , where f i are dummy factors in classical mechanics and nontrivial in quantum mechanics. In this paper the explicit form of the dummy functions f i is given for a charged rigid planar rotator in the uniform magnetic field with different gauge chosen. Under different gauges, we have different sets of dummy factors. It means that these factors do not have direct observable effect.
For describing particles moving on the two dimensional curved surfaces, we can use either the intrinsic local coordinates or the Cartesian coordinates. The representation of the momentum operators differs from each other in these two kinds of coordinates, the former ones depend on the intrinsic geometrical quantities, but the latter case depend on a geometrical invariant, namely the mean curvature. Taking the operator-ordering problem into consideration, the kinetic operator for the former case can be expressed in a possibly unique way, while that for latter case can be expressed in two different ways.
The usual form P0 for the quantum-mechanical operator P conjugate to a generalized coordinate q1 is, in atomic units, P0=−ig−12 ∂/∂q1(g12),where g is the Jacobian of the transformation from Cartesian coordinates to the generalized coordinates. However, in some cases, this plusible form for P is not Hermitian with respect to physically acceptable bound-state wavefunctions, as it must be if it is to represent a real observable quantity. In this paper, the general form P=−i(A·grad+12 div A)is justified. Here A = h1q̂1, where h1 is the metric scale factor corresponding to q1, and q̂1 is the unit vector in the direction of increasing q1. This general form reduces to P0 if the usual formula for the divergence is applied. In the cases where P0 is not Hermitian, it transpires that q̂1 is ill-defined at one or both of the end points α and β of the range of q1, and the divergence formula is thus invalid at such points. It is shown that, in order to obtain a Hermitian form for P, certain terms involving delta functions similar to Dirac's must be added to the usual formula for div A. These terms can be regarded as implicit in div A. If q̂1 is ill-defined at the lower limit q1 = α, then the resulting new Hermitian form for P, which we propose as the correct one, is P=−i[g−12 ∂/∂q1(g12)+12 δ+(q1−α)]. If q̂1 is, in addition, ill-defined at the upper limit q1 = β, then the extra term +½i δ_(β − q1) must be added. Corresponding new forms are obtained for the Laplacian operator. In addition, the new formulas for P are applied to hypervirial relations. In the Appendix, Charles Goebel obtains a similar expression for the momentum operators by replacing the metric scale function by θg where θ is a step function, unity inside and zero outside the range of definition of the generalized coordinates. The differentiation of θ then produces the delta functions.
Abstract The Hermitian surface momentum operator for a particle confined to a 2D curved surface spanned by orthogonal coordinates and embedded in 3D space is expressed as a symmetric expression in derivatives with respect to the surface coordinates and so is manifestly along the surface. This is an alternative form to the one reported in the literature and usually named geometric momentum, which has a term proportional to the mean curvature along the direction normal to the surface, and so “apparently” not along the surface. The symmetric form of the momentum is the sum of two symmetric Hermitian operators along the two orthogonal directions defined by the surface coordinates. The centripetal force operator for a particle on the surface of a cylinder and a sphere is calculated by taking the time derivative of the momentum and is seen to be a symmetrization of the well-known classical expressions.