Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0908.0424 · New Journal of Physics

Inadequacy of von Neumann entropy for characterizing extractable work

Oscar Dahlsten, Renato Renner, Elisabeth Rieper, Vlatko Vedral

Published May 12, 2011• 157 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The lack of knowledge that an observer has about a system limits the amount of work it can extract. This lack of knowledge is normally quantified using the Gibbs/von Neumann entropy. We show that this standard approach is, surprisingly, only correct in very specific circumstances. In general, one should use the recently developed smooth entropy approach. For many common physical situations, including large but internally correlated systems, the resulting values for the extractable work can deviate arbitrarily from those suggested by the standard approach.

DOI
10.1088/1367-2630/13/5/053015

Related papers

Inadequacy of von Neumann entropy for characterising extractable work

Oscar Dahlsten, Renato Renner, Elisabeth Rieper +1 more

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 24, 2011•1 citation

Statistical entropy of quantum systems

Smitarani Mishra, Shaon Sahoo

Statistical formulations of thermodynamic entropy, such as those by Boltzmann and Gibbs, were originally developed for classical systems and are well understood in that context. However, the foundational aspects of quantum statistical mechanics remain an area of active debate and are yet to be fully understood. This work is motivated by the need to develop a comprehensive understanding of the statistical measures of thermodynamic entropy in quantum systems - a topic intimately connected to the phenomenon of quantum thermalization. In particular, we investigate the conditions under which the von Neumann entropy can be regarded as a valid statistical measure of thermodynamic entropy in quantum systems. This paper demonstrates that the equivalence between the von Neumann and thermodynamic entropies is not universal, but instead depends on several subtle and often overlooked assumptions. In this context, we also briefly revisit key criticisms of von Neumann entropy - particularly its time-invariance and subadditivity - and argue that these concerns can be meaningfully addressed in the setting of thermodynamic systems. To substantiate some arguments and to clarify some issues, we provide suitable numerical results from our analysis of a spin-1/2 system.

arXiv:2412.15316•Dec 19, 2024•0 citations

Mixing indistinguishable systems leads to a quantum Gibbs paradox

Benjamin Yadin, Benjamin Morris, Gerardo Adesso

The classical Gibbs paradox concerns the entropy change upon mixing two gases. Whether an observer assigns an entropy increase to the process depends on their ability to distinguish the gases. A resolution is that an "ignorant" observer, who cannot distinguish the gases, has no way of extracting work by mixing them. Moving the thought experiment into the quantum realm, we reveal new and surprising behaviour: the ignorant observer can extract work from mixing different gases, even if the gases cannot be directly distinguished. Moreover, in the macroscopic limit, the quantum case diverges from the classical ideal gas: as much work can be extracted as if the gases were fully distinguishable. We show that the ignorant observer assigns more microstates to the system than found by naive counting in semiclassical statistical mechanics. This demonstrates the importance of accounting for the level of knowledge of an observer, and its implications for genuinely quantum modifications to thermodynamics.

arXiv:2006.12482•Nature Communications•Mar 5, 2021•15 citations

Duality Between Smooth Min- and Max-Entropies

Marco Tomamichel, Roger Colbeck, Renato Renner

In classical and quantum information theory, operational quantities such as the amount of randomness that can be extracted from a given source or the amount of space needed to store given data are normally characterized by one of two entropy measures, called smooth min-entropy and smooth max-entropy, respectively. While both entropies are equal to the von Neumann entropy in certain special cases (e.g., asymptotically, for many independent repetitions of the given data), their values can differ arbitrarily in the general case. In this paper, a recently discovered duality relation between (nonsmooth) min- and max-entropies is extended to the smooth case. More precisely, it is shown that the smooth min-entropy of a systemAconditioned on a systemBequals the negative of the smooth max-entropy ofAconditioned on a purifying systemC. This result immediately implies that certain operational quantities (such as the amount of compression and the amount of randomness that can be extracted from given data) are related. We explain how such relations have applications in cryptographic security proofs.

arXiv:0907.5238•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Aug 19, 2010•252 citations

Concentration of ergotropy in quantum many-body systems

Karen V. Hovhannisyan, Rick P. A. Simon, Janet Anders

Ergotropy$\unicode{x2014}$the maximal amount of unitarily extractable work$\unicode{x2014}$quantifies the "charge level" of a quantum battery. We prove that, in large many-body batteries, it exhibits a concentration of measure phenomenon. Namely, the ergotropy almost coincides with its average for almost all states sampled from the Hilbert$\unicode{x2013}$Schmidt measure. Importantly, the average ergotropy is macroscopic, scaling with the number of particles in the system. This occurs despite the von Neumann entropy also concentrating around a macroscopic average, a surprising coexistence since high entropy is commonly associated with effective thermality and thus passivity. We establish these results by proving that ergotropy, as a function of the state, is Lipschitz continuous with respect to the Bures distance and by applying Lévy's measure concentration lemma. Furthermore, we numerically extend our findings to the Bures measure, which represents the situation with the least amount of prior information about the state. Our continuity and concentration bounds open a new perspective on the noise-robustness of quantum many-body batteries and lay the groundwork for further rigorous studies of their charge stability and work extraction with limited prior knowledge.

arXiv:2412.19801•Dec 27, 2024•7 citations

Exact exponents for smoothing the max-relative entropy and quantum information decoupling in von Neumann algebras

Zhiwen Lin, Hongsen Qiu, Xinyu Zhang

We establish the exact exponent for smoothing the max-relative entropy on arbitrary von Neumann algebras. The proof first develops the required large-deviation and smoothing estimates in the semifinite setting and then passes to general von Neumann algebras through Haagerup-Junge-Xu reduction. We next study catalytic quantum information decoupling when the reference system is described by an arbitrary von Neumann algebra. A key ingredient is an operator layer-cake formula valid on arbitrary von Neumann algebras. This formula leads to a convex-split estimate for normal states with a general von Neumann algebraic reference system. Combining this estimate with the smoothing exponent result, we obtain lower and upper bounds on the catalytic-decoupling reliability function. These bounds coincide below the corresponding critical rate, yielding the exact decoupling reliability function in that regime.

cs.ITCross-listedarXiv:2607.07997•Jul 10, 2026•1 citation
The lack of knowledge that an observer has about a system limits the amount of work it can extract. This lack of knowledge is normally quantified using the Gibbs/von Neumann entropy. We show that this standard approach is, surprisingly, only correct in very specific circumstances. In general, one should use the recently developed smooth entropy approach. For many common physical situations, including large but internally correlated systems, the resulting values for the extractable work can deviate arbitrarily from those suggested by the standard approach.
Statistical formulations of thermodynamic entropy, such as those by Boltzmann and Gibbs, were originally developed for classical systems and are well understood in that context. However, the foundational aspects of quantum statistical mechanics remain an area of active debate and are yet to be fully understood. This work is motivated by the need to develop a comprehensive understanding of the statistical measures of thermodynamic entropy in quantum systems - a topic intimately connected to the phenomenon of quantum thermalization. In particular, we investigate the conditions under which the von Neumann entropy can be regarded as a valid statistical measure of thermodynamic entropy in quantum systems. This paper demonstrates that the equivalence between the von Neumann and thermodynamic entropies is not universal, but instead depends on several subtle and often overlooked assumptions. In this context, we also briefly revisit key criticisms of von Neumann entropy - particularly its time-invariance and subadditivity - and argue that these concerns can be meaningfully addressed in the setting of thermodynamic systems. To substantiate some arguments and to clarify some issues, we provide suitable numerical results from our analysis of a spin-1/2 system.
The classical Gibbs paradox concerns the entropy change upon mixing two gases. Whether an observer assigns an entropy increase to the process depends on their ability to distinguish the gases. A resolution is that an "ignorant" observer, who cannot distinguish the gases, has no way of extracting work by mixing them. Moving the thought experiment into the quantum realm, we reveal new and surprising behaviour: the ignorant observer can extract work from mixing different gases, even if the gases cannot be directly distinguished. Moreover, in the macroscopic limit, the quantum case diverges from the classical ideal gas: as much work can be extracted as if the gases were fully distinguishable. We show that the ignorant observer assigns more microstates to the system than found by naive counting in semiclassical statistical mechanics. This demonstrates the importance of accounting for the level of knowledge of an observer, and its implications for genuinely quantum modifications to thermodynamics.
In classical and quantum information theory, operational quantities such as the amount of randomness that can be extracted from a given source or the amount of space needed to store given data are normally characterized by one of two entropy measures, called smooth min-entropy and smooth max-entropy, respectively. While both entropies are equal to the von Neumann entropy in certain special cases (e.g., asymptotically, for many independent repetitions of the given data), their values can differ arbitrarily in the general case. In this paper, a recently discovered duality relation between (nonsmooth) min- and max-entropies is extended to the smooth case. More precisely, it is shown that the smooth min-entropy of a systemAconditioned on a systemBequals the negative of the smooth max-entropy ofAconditioned on a purifying systemC. This result immediately implies that certain operational quantities (such as the amount of compression and the amount of randomness that can be extracted from given data) are related. We explain how such relations have applications in cryptographic security proofs.
Ergotropy$\unicode{x2014}$the maximal amount of unitarily extractable work$\unicode{x2014}$quantifies the "charge level" of a quantum battery. We prove that, in large many-body batteries, it exhibits a concentration of measure phenomenon. Namely, the ergotropy almost coincides with its average for almost all states sampled from the Hilbert$\unicode{x2013}$Schmidt measure. Importantly, the average ergotropy is macroscopic, scaling with the number of particles in the system. This occurs despite the von Neumann entropy also concentrating around a macroscopic average, a surprising coexistence since high entropy is commonly associated with effective thermality and thus passivity. We establish these results by proving that ergotropy, as a function of the state, is Lipschitz continuous with respect to the Bures distance and by applying Lévy's measure concentration lemma. Furthermore, we numerically extend our findings to the Bures measure, which represents the situation with the least amount of prior information about the state. Our continuity and concentration bounds open a new perspective on the noise-robustness of quantum many-body batteries and lay the groundwork for further rigorous studies of their charge stability and work extraction with limited prior knowledge.
We establish the exact exponent for smoothing the max-relative entropy on arbitrary von Neumann algebras. The proof first develops the required large-deviation and smoothing estimates in the semifinite setting and then passes to general von Neumann algebras through Haagerup-Junge-Xu reduction. We next study catalytic quantum information decoupling when the reference system is described by an arbitrary von Neumann algebra. A key ingredient is an operator layer-cake formula valid on arbitrary von Neumann algebras. This formula leads to a convex-split estimate for normal states with a general von Neumann algebraic reference system. Combining this estimate with the smoothing exponent result, we obtain lower and upper bounds on the catalytic-decoupling reliability function. These bounds coincide below the corresponding critical rate, yielding the exact decoupling reliability function in that regime.