Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0907.1028 · Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

Hubbard-Uband-structure methods

Robert C. Albers, N. Egede Christensen, A. Svane

Published Aug 5, 2009• 65 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The last decade has seen a large increase in the number of electronic-structure calculations that involve adding a Hubbard term to the local-density approximation band-structure Hamiltonian. The Hubbard term is then determined either at the mean-field level or with sophisticated many-body techniques such as using dynamical mean-field theory. We review the physics underlying these approaches and discuss their strengths and weaknesses in terms of the larger issues of electronic structure that they involve. In particular, we argue that the common assumptions made to justify such calculations are inconsistent with what the calculations actually do. Although many of these calculations are often treated as essentially first-principles calculations, in fact, we argue that they should be viewed from an entirely different point of view, namely, as based on phenomenological many-body corrections to band-structure theory. Alternatively, it may also be considered that they are just based on a Hubbard model that is more complex than the simple one- or few-band models traditionally used in many-body theories of solids.

DOI
10.1088/0953-8984/21/34/343201

Related papers

An ab-initio many-body method for electronic structure calculations of solids. I. Description of the method

I. Schnell, G. Czycholl, Robert C. Albers

We propose a new, alternative method for ab-initio calculations of the electronic structure of solids, which has been specifically adapted to treat many-body effects in a more rigorous way than many existing ab-initio methods. We start from a standard band-structure calculation for an effective one-particle Hamiltonian approximately describing the material of interest. This yields a suitable set of one-particle basis functions, from which well localized Wannier functions can be constructed using a method proposed by Marzari and Vanderbilt. Within this (minimal) basis of localized Wannier functions the matrix elements of the non-interacting (one-particle) Hamiltonian as well as the Coulomb matrix elements can be calculated. The result is a many-body Hamiltonian in second quantization with parameters determined from first principles calculations for the material of interest. The Hamiltonian is in the form of a multi-band Hamiltonian in second quantization (a kind of extended, multi-band Hubbard model) such that all the standard many-body methods can be applied. We explicitly show how this approach can be solved in the simplest many-body approximation, the mean-field Hartree-Fock approximation (HFA), which takes into account exact exchange and corrects for self-interaction effects.

arXiv:cond-mat/0304643•Apr 28, 2003•0 citations

Solving the strong-correlation problem in materials

Eva Pavarini

Abstract This article is a short introduction to the modern computational techniques used to tackle the many-body problem in materials. The aim is to present the basic ideas, using simple examples to illustrate strengths and weaknesses of each method. We will start from density-functional theory (DFT) and the Kohn–Sham construction—the standard computational tools for performing electronic structure calculations. Leaving the realm of rigorous density-functional theory, we will discuss the established practice of adopting the Kohn–Sham Hamiltonian as approximate model. After recalling the triumphs of the Kohn–Sham description, we will stress the fundamental reasons of its failure for strongly-correlated compounds, and discuss the strategies adopted to overcome the problem. The article will then focus on the most effective method so far, the DFT+DMFT technique and its extensions. Achievements, open issues and possible future developments will be reviewed. The key differences between dynamical (DFT+DMFT) and static (DFT+ U ) mean-field methods will be elucidated. In the conclusion, we will assess the apparent dichotomy between first-principles and model-based techniques, emphasizing the common ground that in fact they share.

Rivista Del Nuovo Cimento•Jul 14, 2021•27 citations

Dynamical Mean Field Theory, Model Hamiltonians and First Principles Electronic Structure Calculations

Gabriel Kotliar, Sergey Yu. Savrasov

We review the basic ideas of the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) and some of the insights into the electronic structure of strongly correlated electrons obtained by this method in the context of model Hamiltonians. We then discuss the perspectives for carrying out more realistic DMFT studies of strongly correlated electron systems and we compare it with existent methods, LDA and LDA+U. We stress the existence of new functionals for electronic structure calculations which allow us to treat situations where the single--particle description breaks down such as the vicinity of the Mott transition.

arXiv:cond-mat/0208241•Aug 12, 2002•15 citations

Comparison of mean-field theories of an extended Hubbard model

S. N. Coppersmith, P. B. Littlewood

Models of strongly interacting Fermi systems are sufficiently intractable that simple mean-field approximations (typically Hartree-Fock) are often employed to obtain qualitative insight into their properties, and also to set parameter values by comparing with band-structure calculations. However, if the correlations are accounted for with use of more sophisticated (but still mean-field-like) methods, qualitative changes in charge densities and magnetic properties can result. We compare four ``mean-field'' approximations for an extended Hubbard model and show that they yield quite different results. Implications for the choice of model for high-temperature superconductors are discussed.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 1, 1990•3 citations

First-Principles Approach to the Electronic Structure of Strongly Correlated Systems: Combining the GW Approximation and Dynamical Mean-Field Theory

Silke Biermann, F. Aryasetiawan, Antoine Georges

We propose a dynamical mean-field approach for calculating the electronic structure of strongly correlated materials from first principles. The scheme combines the GW method with dynamical mean-field theory, which enables one to treat strong interaction effects. It avoids the conceptual problems inherent to conventional "LDA+DMFT," such as Hubbard interaction parameters and double-counting terms. We apply a simplified version of the approach to the electronic structure of nickel and find encouraging results.

arXiv:cond-mat/0207419•Physical Review Letters•Feb 27, 2003•398 citations

Magnetism and Superconductivity in the Two-Band Hubbard Model: A Variational Monte Carlo Perspective

Caterina De Franco

Mott insulators and high-temperature superconductivity: models and materialsBand theory was the first successful theoretical description of metals and insulators.Indeed, it was able to predict the metallic or insulating character of a given material by simple inspection of the electronic spectrum.The solution of the Schrödinger equation, in the presence of the periodic potential, generated by the lattice, gives rise to a band structure, namely a set of electronic states specified by E n (q) (where q is the momentum and n is an integer that labels the band) (Ashcroft and Mermin 2011).At zero temperature, the many-body ground state is obtained by populating the lowest-energy levels, in accordance with the Pauli principle.Then, the distinction between metals and insulators is determined by the filling of the electronic bands: whenever the highest occupied band is completely filled and there is a finite gap to the lowest unoccupied one, the system is an insulator; otherwise, in the presence of partially filled electronic bands, the system is a metal.The foundations of the band theory rely on a strong approximation in which electrons behave as independent particles.Here, the Coulomb interaction is replaced by an effective single-particle potential that represents the average (mean-field) interaction felt by each electrons and generated by all the other ones.In the early years of quantum mechanics the band picture was already well established, however, a few transition-metal 1 filling is considered.The breakdown of the band theory becomes clear when the electronelectron interaction is not negligible.Let us consider a single atom with an electron in the 1s orbital with energy at .When adding a second electron, the total energy turns out to be 2 at + U where U is the Coulomb interaction between the two electrons (see Fig. 1.1).These energy levels are fundamentally different from the usual single-electron spectrum.

•Oct 26, 2018•0 citations
The last decade has seen a large increase in the number of electronic-structure calculations that involve adding a Hubbard term to the local-density approximation band-structure Hamiltonian. The Hubbard term is then determined either at the mean-field level or with sophisticated many-body techniques such as using dynamical mean-field theory. We review the physics underlying these approaches and discuss their strengths and weaknesses in terms of the larger issues of electronic structure that they involve. In particular, we argue that the common assumptions made to justify such calculations are inconsistent with what the calculations actually do. Although many of these calculations are often treated as essentially first-principles calculations, in fact, we argue that they should be viewed from an entirely different point of view, namely, as based on phenomenological many-body corrections to band-structure theory. Alternatively, it may also be considered that they are just based on a Hubbard model that is more complex than the simple one- or few-band models traditionally used in many-body theories of solids.
We propose a new, alternative method for ab-initio calculations of the electronic structure of solids, which has been specifically adapted to treat many-body effects in a more rigorous way than many existing ab-initio methods. We start from a standard band-structure calculation for an effective one-particle Hamiltonian approximately describing the material of interest. This yields a suitable set of one-particle basis functions, from which well localized Wannier functions can be constructed using a method proposed by Marzari and Vanderbilt. Within this (minimal) basis of localized Wannier functions the matrix elements of the non-interacting (one-particle) Hamiltonian as well as the Coulomb matrix elements can be calculated. The result is a many-body Hamiltonian in second quantization with parameters determined from first principles calculations for the material of interest. The Hamiltonian is in the form of a multi-band Hamiltonian in second quantization (a kind of extended, multi-band Hubbard model) such that all the standard many-body methods can be applied. We explicitly show how this approach can be solved in the simplest many-body approximation, the mean-field Hartree-Fock approximation (HFA), which takes into account exact exchange and corrects for self-interaction effects.
Abstract This article is a short introduction to the modern computational techniques used to tackle the many-body problem in materials. The aim is to present the basic ideas, using simple examples to illustrate strengths and weaknesses of each method. We will start from density-functional theory (DFT) and the Kohn–Sham construction—the standard computational tools for performing electronic structure calculations. Leaving the realm of rigorous density-functional theory, we will discuss the established practice of adopting the Kohn–Sham Hamiltonian as approximate model. After recalling the triumphs of the Kohn–Sham description, we will stress the fundamental reasons of its failure for strongly-correlated compounds, and discuss the strategies adopted to overcome the problem. The article will then focus on the most effective method so far, the DFT+DMFT technique and its extensions. Achievements, open issues and possible future developments will be reviewed. The key differences between dynamical (DFT+DMFT) and static (DFT+ U ) mean-field methods will be elucidated. In the conclusion, we will assess the apparent dichotomy between first-principles and model-based techniques, emphasizing the common ground that in fact they share.
We review the basic ideas of the dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) and some of the insights into the electronic structure of strongly correlated electrons obtained by this method in the context of model Hamiltonians. We then discuss the perspectives for carrying out more realistic DMFT studies of strongly correlated electron systems and we compare it with existent methods, LDA and LDA+U. We stress the existence of new functionals for electronic structure calculations which allow us to treat situations where the single--particle description breaks down such as the vicinity of the Mott transition.
Models of strongly interacting Fermi systems are sufficiently intractable that simple mean-field approximations (typically Hartree-Fock) are often employed to obtain qualitative insight into their properties, and also to set parameter values by comparing with band-structure calculations. However, if the correlations are accounted for with use of more sophisticated (but still mean-field-like) methods, qualitative changes in charge densities and magnetic properties can result. We compare four ``mean-field'' approximations for an extended Hubbard model and show that they yield quite different results. Implications for the choice of model for high-temperature superconductors are discussed.
We propose a dynamical mean-field approach for calculating the electronic structure of strongly correlated materials from first principles. The scheme combines the GW method with dynamical mean-field theory, which enables one to treat strong interaction effects. It avoids the conceptual problems inherent to conventional "LDA+DMFT," such as Hubbard interaction parameters and double-counting terms. We apply a simplified version of the approach to the electronic structure of nickel and find encouraging results.
Mott insulators and high-temperature superconductivity: models and materialsBand theory was the first successful theoretical description of metals and insulators.Indeed, it was able to predict the metallic or insulating character of a given material by simple inspection of the electronic spectrum.The solution of the Schrödinger equation, in the presence of the periodic potential, generated by the lattice, gives rise to a band structure, namely a set of electronic states specified by E n (q) (where q is the momentum and n is an integer that labels the band) (Ashcroft and Mermin 2011).At zero temperature, the many-body ground state is obtained by populating the lowest-energy levels, in accordance with the Pauli principle.Then, the distinction between metals and insulators is determined by the filling of the electronic bands: whenever the highest occupied band is completely filled and there is a finite gap to the lowest unoccupied one, the system is an insulator; otherwise, in the presence of partially filled electronic bands, the system is a metal.The foundations of the band theory rely on a strong approximation in which electrons behave as independent particles.Here, the Coulomb interaction is replaced by an effective single-particle potential that represents the average (mean-field) interaction felt by each electrons and generated by all the other ones.In the early years of quantum mechanics the band picture was already well established, however, a few transition-metal 1 filling is considered.The breakdown of the band theory becomes clear when the electronelectron interaction is not negligible.Let us consider a single atom with an electron in the 1s orbital with energy at .When adding a second electron, the total energy turns out to be 2 at + U where U is the Coulomb interaction between the two electrons (see Fig. 1.1).These energy levels are fundamentally different from the usual single-electron spectrum.