Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0906.3169 · Physical Review B

Correlated electron physics in two-level quantum dots: Phase transitions, transport, and experiment

David E. Logan, Christopher J. Wright, Martin R. Galpin

Published Sep 18, 2009• 57 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study correlated two-level quantum dots, coupled in effective one-channel fashion to metallic leads, with electron interactions including on-level and interlevel Coulomb repulsions, as well as the interorbital Hund's rule exchange favoring the spin-1 state in the relevant sector of the free dot. For arbitrary dot occupancy, the underlying phases, quantum phase transitions (QPTs), thermodynamics, single-particle dynamics, and electronic transport properties are considered, and direct comparison is made to conductance experiments on lateral quantum dots. Two distinct phases arise generically, one characterized by a normal Fermi liquid fixed point (FP) and the other by an underscreened (USC) spin-1 FP. Associated QPTs, which occur in general in a mixed valent regime of nonintegral dot charge, are found to consist of continuous lines of Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions, separated by first-order level-crossing transitions at high symmetry points. A ``Friedel-Luttinger sum rule'' is derived and, together with a deduced generalization of Luttinger's theorem to the USC phase (a singular Fermi liquid), is used to obtain a general result for the $T=0$ zero-bias conductance, expressed solely in terms of the dot occupancy and applicable to both phases. Relatedly, dynamical signatures of the QPT show two broad classes of behavior, corresponding to the collapse of either a Kondo resonance, or antiresonance, as the transition is approached from the Fermi liquid phase, the latter behavior being apparent in experimental differential conductance maps. The problem is studied using the numerical renormalization group method, combined with analytical arguments.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.80.125117

Related papers

Theoretical studies of underscreened Kondo physics in quantum dots

Wright, Christopher James, Wright, Christoper

We study correlated two-level quantum impurity models coupled to a metallic conduction band in the hope of gaining insight into the physics of nanoscale quantum dot systems. We focus on the possibility of formation of a spin-1 impurity local moment which, on coupling to the band, generates an underscreened (USC) singular Fermi liquid state. By employing physical arguments and the numerical renormalization group (NRG) technique, we analyse such systems in detail examining in particular both the thermodynamic and dynamic properties, including the differential conductance.The quantum phase transitions occurring between the USC phase and a more ordinary Fermi liquid (FL) phase are analysed in detail. They are generically found to be of Kosterlitz-Thouless type; exceptions occur along lines of high symmetry where first-order transitions are found. A `Friedel-Luttinger sum rule' is derived and, together with a generalization of Luttinger's theorem to the USC phase, is used to obtain general results for the $T=0$ zero-bias conductance --- it is expressed solely in terms of the number of electrons present on the impurity and applicable in both the USC and FL phases. Relatedly, dynamical signatures of the quantum phase transition show two broad classes of behaviour corresponding to the collapse of either a resonance or antiresonance in the single-particle density of states. Evidence of both of these behaviours is seen in experimental devices.We study also the effect of a local magnetic field on both single- and two-level quantum impurities. In the former case we attempt to resolve some points of contention that remain in the literature. Specifically we show that the position of the maximum in the spin resolved density of states (and related peaks in the differential conductance) is not linear in the applied field, showing a more complicated form than a simple `Zeeman splitting'. The analytic result for the low-field asymptote is recovered. For two-level impurities we illustrate the manner in which the USC state is destroyed: due to two cancelling effects an abrupt change in the zero-bias conductance does not occur as one might expect. Comparison with experiment is made in both cases and used to interpret experimental findings in a manner contrary to previous suggestions. We find that experiments are very rarely in the limit of strong impurity-host coupling. Further, features in the differential conductance as a function of bias voltage should not be simply interpreted in terms of isolated quantum dot states. The many-body nature of such systems is crucially important to their observed properties.

•Jan 1, 2011•2 citations

Renormalization group study of capacitively coupled double quantum dots

Martin R. Galpin, David E. Logan, H R Krishnamurthy

The numerical renormalization group is employed to study a double quantum (DQD) dot system consisting of two equivalent single-level dots, each coupled to its own lead and with a mutual capacitive coupling embodied in an interdot interaction U', in addition to the intradot Coulomb interaction U. We focus on the regime with two electrons on the DQD, and the evolution of the system on increasing U'/U. The spin-Kondo effect arising for U'=0 (SU(2) x SU(2)) is found to persist robustly with increasing U'/U, before a rapid but continuous crossover to (a) the SU(4) point U'=U where charge and spin degrees of freedom are entangled and the Kondo scale strongly enhanced; and then (b) a charge-Kondo state, in which a charge-pseudospin is quenched on coupling to the leads/conduction channels. A quantum phase transition of Kosterlitz-Thouless type then occurs from this Fermi liquid, strong coupling (SC) phase, to a broken symmetry, non-Fermi liquid charge ordered (CO) phase at a critical U'_c. Our emphasis in this paper is on the structure, stability and flows between the underlying RG fixed points, on the overall phase diagram in the (U,U')-plane and evolution of the characteristic low-energy Kondo scale inherent to the SC phase; and on static physical properties such as spin- and charge-susceptibilities (staggered and uniform), including universality and scaling behaviour in the strongly correlated regime. Some exact results for associated Wilson ratios are also obtained.

arXiv:cond-mat/0608169•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Jun 30, 2006•36 citations

Two-channel Kondo phases in coupled quantum dots

Andrew K. Mitchell

We investigate systems comprising chains and rings of quantum dots, coupled to two metallic leads. Such systems allow to study the competition between orbital and spin degrees of freedom in a nanodevice, and the effect this subtle interplay has on two-channel Kondo (2CK) physics. We demonstrate that a rich range of strongly correlated electron behaviour results, with non-Fermi liquid 2CK phases and non-trivial phase transitions accessible. We employ physical arguments and the numerical renormalization group (NRG) technique to analyse these systems in detail, examining in particular both thermodynamic and dynamical properties. When leads are coupled to either end of a chain of dots, we show that the resulting behaviour on low temperature/energy scales can be understood in terms of simpler paradigmatic quantum `impurity' models. An effective low-energy single-spin 2CK model is derived for all odd-length chains, while the behaviour of even-length chains is related fundamentally to that of the classic `two-impurity Kondo' model. In particular, for small interdot coupling, we show that an effective coupling mediated though incipient single-channel Kondo states drives all odd chains to the 2CK fixed point (FP) on the lowest temperature/energy scales. A theory is also developed to describe a phase transition in even chains. We derive an effective channel-anisotropic 2CK model, which indicates that the critical FP of such models must be the 2CK FP. This physical picture is confirmed using NRG for various chain systems. We also examine the effect of local frustration on 2CK physics in mirror-symmetric ring systems. The importance of geometry and symmetry is demonstrated clearly in the markedly different physical behaviour that arises in systems where two leads are either connected to the same dot, or to neighbouring dots. In the latter case, we show for all odd-membered rings that two distinct 2CK phases, with different ground state parities, arise on tuning the interdot couplings. A frustration-induced phase transition thus occurs, the 2CK phases being separated by a novel critical point for which an effective low-energy model is derived. Precisely at the transition, parity mixing of the quasidegenerate local trimer states acts to destabilise the 2CK FPs, and the critical FP is shown to consist of a free pseudospin together with effective single-channel spin quenching. While connecting both leads to the same dot again results in two parity-distinct phases, a simple level-crossing transition now results due to the symmetry of the setup. The proposed geometry also allows access to a novel ferromagnetically-coupled two-channel local moment phase. Driven by varying the interdot couplings and occurring at the point of inherent magnetic frustration, such transitions in ring structures provide a striking example of the subtle interplay between internal spin and orbital degrees of freedom in coupled quantum dot systems, and the resulting effect on Kondo physics.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Kondo Physics and Many-Body Effects in Quantum Dots and Molecular Junctions

David A. Ruiz‐Tijerina

In this document we present a study of the thermodynamic and transport properties of two kinds of quantum impurity systems in the Kondo regime.The first system consists of a spin-1 molecule in which mechanical stretching along the transport axis produces a magnetic anisotropy.We find that a generic coupling between a vibrational mode along this axis and the molecular spin induces a correction to the magnetic anisotropy, driving the ground state of the system into a non-Fermi-liquid phase.A transition into a Fermi-liquid ground state can then be induced by means of stretching, going through an underscreened spin-1 Kondo ground state at zero effective anisotropy.In the second system we study the effects of a charge detector, implemented by a quantum point-contact (QPC), on the Kondo state of a nearby spin-1/2 quantum dot (QD).While making the charge detection possible, the Coulomb interaction between the electrons traversing the QPC and those within the QD contribute to decoherence of the Kondo state.By modeling the QPC as two metallic terminals connected to an intermediate localized level, we can explore three transport regimes of the detector: a zero-conductance regime, a finite-conductance regime in mixed valence, and unitary conductance in a Kondo ground state that has been suggested as an explanation to the "0.7 anomaly" in QPCs.Transitions between these different ground states can be achieved by tuning the strength of a capacitive coupling that parameterizes the electrostatic interaction.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Numerical Renormalization Group studies of Correlation effects in Phase Coherent Transport through Quantum Dots

T. Hecht

This thesis contributes to the field of transport through quantum dots. These devices allow for a controlled study of quantum transport and fundamental physical effects, like the Kondo effect. In this thesis we will focus on dots that are well described by generalized Anderson impurity models, where the discrete levels of the quantum dot are tunnel-coupled to fermionic reservoirs. The model parameters, like level energy and width, can be tuned in experiments. Therefore these systems constitute a valuable arena for testing experiment against theory and vice versa. In order to describe these strongly correlated systems, we employ the numerical renormalization group method. This allows us to address both longstanding questions concerning experimental results and new physical phenomena in these fundamental models. This thesis consists of three major projects. The first and most extensive one is concerned with the phase of the transmission amplitude through a quantum dot. Measurements of many-electron quantum dots with small level spacing reveal universal phase behaviour, a result not fully understood for almost 10 years. Recent experiments have seen that, contrarily, for dots with only a few electrons, i.e. large level spacing, the phase depends on the mesoscopic dot parameters. Analyzing a multi-level Anderson model, we show that the generic feature of the two regimes can be reproduced in the regime of overlapping levels or well separated levels, respectively. Thereby the universal character follows from Fano-type antiresonances of the renormalized single-particle levels. Moderate temperature supports the universal character. In the mesoscopic regime, we also investigate the effect of Kondo correlations on the transmission phase. In a second project we analyze a quantum dot coupled to a superconducting reservoir. In contrast to previous belief, the energy resolution of our method is not restricted by the energy scale of the superconducting gap, leading to new insights into the method. The high resolution allows us to resolve sharp peaks in the spectral function that emerge for a certain regime of parameters. A third project deals with a quantum dot coupled to two independent channels, a system known to exhibit non-Fermi liquid behaviour. We investigate the existence of the non-Fermi liquid regime when driving the system out of the Kondo regime by emptying the dot. We find that the extent of the non-Fermi liquid regime strongly depends on the mechanisms that couple impurity and reservoirs but prevent mixing of the latter.

•Jan 1, 2008•2 citations

Quantum Phase Transition in Capacitively Coupled Double Quantum Dots

Martin R. Galpin, David E. Logan, H. R. Krishnamurthy

We investigate two equivalent, capacitively coupled semiconducting quantum dots, each coupled to its own lead, in a regime where there are two electrons on the double dot. With increasing interdot coupling, a rich range of behavior is uncovered: first a crossover from spin- to charge-Kondo physics, via an intermediate SU(4) state with entangled spin and charge degrees of freedom, followed by a quantum phase transition of Kosterlitz-Thouless type to a non-Fermi-liquid "charge-ordered" phase with finite residual entropy and anomalous transport properties. Physical arguments and numerical renormalization group methods are employed to obtain a detailed understanding of the problem.

arXiv:cond-mat/0505413•Physical Review Letters•May 11, 2005•97 citations
We study correlated two-level quantum dots, coupled in effective one-channel fashion to metallic leads, with electron interactions including on-level and interlevel Coulomb repulsions, as well as the interorbital Hund's rule exchange favoring the spin-1 state in the relevant sector of the free dot. For arbitrary dot occupancy, the underlying phases, quantum phase transitions (QPTs), thermodynamics, single-particle dynamics, and electronic transport properties are considered, and direct comparison is made to conductance experiments on lateral quantum dots. Two distinct phases arise generically, one characterized by a normal Fermi liquid fixed point (FP) and the other by an underscreened (USC) spin-1 FP. Associated QPTs, which occur in general in a mixed valent regime of nonintegral dot charge, are found to consist of continuous lines of Kosterlitz-Thouless transitions, separated by first-order level-crossing transitions at high symmetry points. A ``Friedel-Luttinger sum rule'' is derived and, together with a deduced generalization of Luttinger's theorem to the USC phase (a singular Fermi liquid), is used to obtain a general result for the T=0T=0T=0 zero-bias conductance, expressed solely in terms of the dot occupancy and applicable to both phases. Relatedly, dynamical signatures of the QPT show two broad classes of behavior, corresponding to the collapse of either a Kondo resonance, or antiresonance, as the transition is approached from the Fermi liquid phase, the latter behavior being apparent in experimental differential conductance maps. The problem is studied using the numerical renormalization group method, combined with analytical arguments.
We study correlated two-level quantum impurity models coupled to a metallic conduction band in the hope of gaining insight into the physics of nanoscale quantum dot systems. We focus on the possibility of formation of a spin-1 impurity local moment which, on coupling to the band, generates an underscreened (USC) singular Fermi liquid state. By employing physical arguments and the numerical renormalization group (NRG) technique, we analyse such systems in detail examining in particular both the thermodynamic and dynamic properties, including the differential conductance.The quantum phase transitions occurring between the USC phase and a more ordinary Fermi liquid (FL) phase are analysed in detail. They are generically found to be of Kosterlitz-Thouless type; exceptions occur along lines of high symmetry where first-order transitions are found. A `Friedel-Luttinger sum rule' is derived and, together with a generalization of Luttinger's theorem to the USC phase, is used to obtain general results for the T=0T=0T=0 zero-bias conductance --- it is expressed solely in terms of the number of electrons present on the impurity and applicable in both the USC and FL phases. Relatedly, dynamical signatures of the quantum phase transition show two broad classes of behaviour corresponding to the collapse of either a resonance or antiresonance in the single-particle density of states. Evidence of both of these behaviours is seen in experimental devices.We study also the effect of a local magnetic field on both single- and two-level quantum impurities. In the former case we attempt to resolve some points of contention that remain in the literature. Specifically we show that the position of the maximum in the spin resolved density of states (and related peaks in the differential conductance) is not linear in the applied field, showing a more complicated form than a simple `Zeeman splitting'. The analytic result for the low-field asymptote is recovered. For two-level impurities we illustrate the manner in which the USC state is destroyed: due to two cancelling effects an abrupt change in the zero-bias conductance does not occur as one might expect. Comparison with experiment is made in both cases and used to interpret experimental findings in a manner contrary to previous suggestions. We find that experiments are very rarely in the limit of strong impurity-host coupling. Further, features in the differential conductance as a function of bias voltage should not be simply interpreted in terms of isolated quantum dot states. The many-body nature of such systems is crucially important to their observed properties.
The numerical renormalization group is employed to study a double quantum (DQD) dot system consisting of two equivalent single-level dots, each coupled to its own lead and with a mutual capacitive coupling embodied in an interdot interaction U', in addition to the intradot Coulomb interaction U. We focus on the regime with two electrons on the DQD, and the evolution of the system on increasing U'/U. The spin-Kondo effect arising for U'=0 (SU(2) x SU(2)) is found to persist robustly with increasing U'/U, before a rapid but continuous crossover to (a) the SU(4) point U'=U where charge and spin degrees of freedom are entangled and the Kondo scale strongly enhanced; and then (b) a charge-Kondo state, in which a charge-pseudospin is quenched on coupling to the leads/conduction channels. A quantum phase transition of Kosterlitz-Thouless type then occurs from this Fermi liquid, strong coupling (SC) phase, to a broken symmetry, non-Fermi liquid charge ordered (CO) phase at a critical U'_c. Our emphasis in this paper is on the structure, stability and flows between the underlying RG fixed points, on the overall phase diagram in the (U,U')-plane and evolution of the characteristic low-energy Kondo scale inherent to the SC phase; and on static physical properties such as spin- and charge-susceptibilities (staggered and uniform), including universality and scaling behaviour in the strongly correlated regime. Some exact results for associated Wilson ratios are also obtained.
We investigate systems comprising chains and rings of quantum dots, coupled to two metallic leads. Such systems allow to study the competition between orbital and spin degrees of freedom in a nanodevice, and the effect this subtle interplay has on two-channel Kondo (2CK) physics. We demonstrate that a rich range of strongly correlated electron behaviour results, with non-Fermi liquid 2CK phases and non-trivial phase transitions accessible. We employ physical arguments and the numerical renormalization group (NRG) technique to analyse these systems in detail, examining in particular both thermodynamic and dynamical properties. When leads are coupled to either end of a chain of dots, we show that the resulting behaviour on low temperature/energy scales can be understood in terms of simpler paradigmatic quantum `impurity' models. An effective low-energy single-spin 2CK model is derived for all odd-length chains, while the behaviour of even-length chains is related fundamentally to that of the classic `two-impurity Kondo' model. In particular, for small interdot coupling, we show that an effective coupling mediated though incipient single-channel Kondo states drives all odd chains to the 2CK fixed point (FP) on the lowest temperature/energy scales. A theory is also developed to describe a phase transition in even chains. We derive an effective channel-anisotropic 2CK model, which indicates that the critical FP of such models must be the 2CK FP. This physical picture is confirmed using NRG for various chain systems. We also examine the effect of local frustration on 2CK physics in mirror-symmetric ring systems. The importance of geometry and symmetry is demonstrated clearly in the markedly different physical behaviour that arises in systems where two leads are either connected to the same dot, or to neighbouring dots. In the latter case, we show for all odd-membered rings that two distinct 2CK phases, with different ground state parities, arise on tuning the interdot couplings. A frustration-induced phase transition thus occurs, the 2CK phases being separated by a novel critical point for which an effective low-energy model is derived. Precisely at the transition, parity mixing of the quasidegenerate local trimer states acts to destabilise the 2CK FPs, and the critical FP is shown to consist of a free pseudospin together with effective single-channel spin quenching. While connecting both leads to the same dot again results in two parity-distinct phases, a simple level-crossing transition now results due to the symmetry of the setup. The proposed geometry also allows access to a novel ferromagnetically-coupled two-channel local moment phase. Driven by varying the interdot couplings and occurring at the point of inherent magnetic frustration, such transitions in ring structures provide a striking example of the subtle interplay between internal spin and orbital degrees of freedom in coupled quantum dot systems, and the resulting effect on Kondo physics.
In this document we present a study of the thermodynamic and transport properties of two kinds of quantum impurity systems in the Kondo regime.The first system consists of a spin-1 molecule in which mechanical stretching along the transport axis produces a magnetic anisotropy.We find that a generic coupling between a vibrational mode along this axis and the molecular spin induces a correction to the magnetic anisotropy, driving the ground state of the system into a non-Fermi-liquid phase.A transition into a Fermi-liquid ground state can then be induced by means of stretching, going through an underscreened spin-1 Kondo ground state at zero effective anisotropy.In the second system we study the effects of a charge detector, implemented by a quantum point-contact (QPC), on the Kondo state of a nearby spin-1/2 quantum dot (QD).While making the charge detection possible, the Coulomb interaction between the electrons traversing the QPC and those within the QD contribute to decoherence of the Kondo state.By modeling the QPC as two metallic terminals connected to an intermediate localized level, we can explore three transport regimes of the detector: a zero-conductance regime, a finite-conductance regime in mixed valence, and unitary conductance in a Kondo ground state that has been suggested as an explanation to the "0.7 anomaly" in QPCs.Transitions between these different ground states can be achieved by tuning the strength of a capacitive coupling that parameterizes the electrostatic interaction.
This thesis contributes to the field of transport through quantum dots. These devices allow for a controlled study of quantum transport and fundamental physical effects, like the Kondo effect. In this thesis we will focus on dots that are well described by generalized Anderson impurity models, where the discrete levels of the quantum dot are tunnel-coupled to fermionic reservoirs. The model parameters, like level energy and width, can be tuned in experiments. Therefore these systems constitute a valuable arena for testing experiment against theory and vice versa. In order to describe these strongly correlated systems, we employ the numerical renormalization group method. This allows us to address both longstanding questions concerning experimental results and new physical phenomena in these fundamental models. This thesis consists of three major projects. The first and most extensive one is concerned with the phase of the transmission amplitude through a quantum dot. Measurements of many-electron quantum dots with small level spacing reveal universal phase behaviour, a result not fully understood for almost 10 years. Recent experiments have seen that, contrarily, for dots with only a few electrons, i.e. large level spacing, the phase depends on the mesoscopic dot parameters. Analyzing a multi-level Anderson model, we show that the generic feature of the two regimes can be reproduced in the regime of overlapping levels or well separated levels, respectively. Thereby the universal character follows from Fano-type antiresonances of the renormalized single-particle levels. Moderate temperature supports the universal character. In the mesoscopic regime, we also investigate the effect of Kondo correlations on the transmission phase. In a second project we analyze a quantum dot coupled to a superconducting reservoir. In contrast to previous belief, the energy resolution of our method is not restricted by the energy scale of the superconducting gap, leading to new insights into the method. The high resolution allows us to resolve sharp peaks in the spectral function that emerge for a certain regime of parameters. A third project deals with a quantum dot coupled to two independent channels, a system known to exhibit non-Fermi liquid behaviour. We investigate the existence of the non-Fermi liquid regime when driving the system out of the Kondo regime by emptying the dot. We find that the extent of the non-Fermi liquid regime strongly depends on the mechanisms that couple impurity and reservoirs but prevent mixing of the latter.
We investigate two equivalent, capacitively coupled semiconducting quantum dots, each coupled to its own lead, in a regime where there are two electrons on the double dot. With increasing interdot coupling, a rich range of behavior is uncovered: first a crossover from spin- to charge-Kondo physics, via an intermediate SU(4) state with entangled spin and charge degrees of freedom, followed by a quantum phase transition of Kosterlitz-Thouless type to a non-Fermi-liquid "charge-ordered" phase with finite residual entropy and anomalous transport properties. Physical arguments and numerical renormalization group methods are employed to obtain a detailed understanding of the problem.