Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0906.1435 · Physical Review E

Chaos and correspondence in classical and quantum Hamiltonian ratchets: A Heisenberg approach

Jordan Pelc, Jiangbin Gong, Paul W. Brumer

Published Jun 16, 2009• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Previous work [Gong and Brumer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 240602 (2006)] motivates this study as to how asymmetry-driven quantum ratchet effects can persist despite a corresponding fully chaotic classical phase space. A simple perspective of ratchet dynamics, based on the Heisenberg picture, is introduced. We show that ratchet effects are in principle of common origin in classical and quantum mechanics, although full chaos suppresses these effects in the former but not necessarily the latter. The relationship between ratchet effects and coherent dynamical control is noted.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.79.066207

Related papers

Issues in quantum mechanics: Chaotic Hamiltonian ratchets and commutation relations

Jordan Pelc

The first considers asymmetry-driven Hamiltonian ratchet effects in context of quantum chaos. It is shown, in the Liouville framework, that a biased net effective force can emerge in initially symmetric systems subject to a force of zero mean. This arises via an asymmetric system distortion in both classical and quantum mechanics. However, differences in time-periodicity and chaos between the two mechanics lead to differences in the evolution of the effective force in time. The second part obtains the canonical commutation relation of quantum mechanics assuming, in addition to the standard assumptions of the quantum Hilbert space, only that position and momentum are functionally independent. This exposes the fundamental interpretation of the commutation relation as an expression of independence, and thereby establishes its analogy with the classical Poisson bracket. Operator techniques used in these arguments are discussed at length.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Causal Wave Mechanics and the Advent of Complexity. II. Dynamic uncertainty in quantum systems and the correspondence principle

Andrei P. Kirilyuk

The intrinsic multivaluedness of interaction process, revealed in Part I of this series of papers, is interpreted as the origin of the true dynamical (in particular, quantum) chaos. The latter is causally deduced as unceasing series of transitions, dynamically probabilistic by their origin, between the equally real, but incompatible 'realisations' (modes of interaction) of a system. The obtained set of realisations form the causally derived, intrinsically complete "space of events" providing the crucial extension of the notion of probability and the method of its first-principle calculation. The fundamental dynamic uncertainty thus revealed is specified for Hamiltonian quantum systems and applied to quantum chaos description in periodically perturbed systems. The ordinary semiclassical transition in our quantum-mechanical results leads to exact reproduction of the main features of chaotic behaviour of the system known from classical mechanics, which permits one to "re-establish" the correspondence principle for chaotic systems (inevitably lost in any their conventional, single-valued description). The causal dynamical randomness in the extended quantum mechanics is not restricted, however, to semiclassical conditions and generically occurs also in essentially quantum regimes, even though partial "quantum suppression of chaos" does exist and is specified in our description, as well as other particular types of the quantum (truly) chaotic behaviour.

arXiv:quant-ph/9511035•Nov 23, 1995•1 citation

An Introduction to Quantum Chaos

Mason Alexander Porter

Nonlinear dynamics (``chaos theory'') and quantum mechanics are two of the scientific triumphs of the 20th century. The former lies at the heart of the modern interdisciplinary approach to science, whereas the latter has revolutionized physics. Both chaos theory and quantum mechanics have achieved a fairly large level of glamour in the eyes of the general public. The study of quantum chaos encompasses the application of dynamical systems theory in the quantum regime. In the present article, we give a brief review of the origin and fundamentals of both quantum mechanics and nonlinear dynamics. We recount the birth of dynamical systems theory and contrast chaotic motion with integrable motion. We similarly recall the transition from classical to quantum mechanics and discuss the origin of the latter. We then consider the interplay between nonlinear dynamics and quantum mechanics via a classification and explanation of the three types of quantum chaos. We include several recent results in this discussion.

arXiv:nlin/0107039•Jul 17, 2001•4 citations

The influence of quantization on the onset of chaos in Hamiltonian systems: The Kolmogorov entropy interpretation

Ronnie Kosloff, Stuart A. Rice

An extension of the concept of Kolmogorov entropy to quantum mechanical systems is given. Using the Kolmogorov entropy as a common basis for discussion, the onset of chaotic motion in classical mechanical and quantum mechanical systems is compared. It is found that if the spectrum of the system is discrete, the Kolmogorov entropy is zero, and therefore that a bounded quantum mechanical system cannot have chaotic motion like that observed for a corresponding classical mechanical system. This analysis leads to the prediction that if the distributions of states are similar for two bounded systems which in the classical limit have, respectively, quasiperiodic and chaotic motion, wave packets for the two systems decay at similar rates as found by Brumer and Shapiro. The relationship between the defined Kolmogorov entropy, previous interpretations of ’’KAMlike’’ onset of chaos in quantum mechanical systems, and the role played by preparation and observation of a system in influencing the intramolecular dynamics, are discussed.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 15, 1981•89 citations

Chaos and Quantum Tunneling

Akira Shudo

In generic Hamiltonian systems that are neither completely integrable nor fully chaotic, phase space consists of a mixture of regular and chaotic components. In classical dynamics, transitions between different invariant sets in phase space are strictly forbidden, and these sets act as dynamical barriers to one another. In quantum mechanics, in contrast, wave effects allow transitions through such dynamical barriers. This process, known as dynamical tunneling, refers to penetration through dynamical barriers in phase space and was first recognized in the early 1980s. Since then, various aspects of dynamical tunneling have been elucidated, significantly advancing our understanding of such a novel quantum phenomenon. In this article, we provide an overview of several phenomenological perspectives of dynamical tunneling, including chaos-assisted and resonance-assisted tunneling, and also introduce approaches based on classical mechanics extended into the complex domain. In particular, we seek to clarify what is meant by the common claim that "chaos leads to an enhancement of the tunneling probability", which is often made when dynamical tunneling is dressed. We discuss what regime this refers to and, if such an enhancement occurs, what its likely origin is.

nlin.CDCross-listedarXiv:2604.12926•Apr 15, 2026

Coherent control, quantum chaos, and decoherence in molecular dynamics

Jiangbin Gong

Extensive coherent control of quantum chaotic diffusion in periodically kicked dynamics is demonstrated in both a paradigm of quantum chaos and molecular systems in pulsed microwave fields. The origin of the control in deviations from random matrix theory is identified, and the survival of the control in the presence of decoherence effects is studied. Next, a fundamental principle in quantum physics with regard to indistinguishability and interference between multiple pathways to the same final state is applied to the significant field of coherent control. Later, coherent control of diatom-diatom elastic and inelastic scattering of identical molecules is demonstrated by revealing an intriguing role of quantum entanglement in coherent control problems. Finally, quantum classical correspondence in conservative chaotic systems is carefully examined using a distribution function strategy. Further, the role of decoherence in improving the correspondence is computationally studied from several complementary perspectives.

•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations
Previous work [Gong and Brumer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 240602 (2006)] motivates this study as to how asymmetry-driven quantum ratchet effects can persist despite a corresponding fully chaotic classical phase space. A simple perspective of ratchet dynamics, based on the Heisenberg picture, is introduced. We show that ratchet effects are in principle of common origin in classical and quantum mechanics, although full chaos suppresses these effects in the former but not necessarily the latter. The relationship between ratchet effects and coherent dynamical control is noted.
The first considers asymmetry-driven Hamiltonian ratchet effects in context of quantum chaos. It is shown, in the Liouville framework, that a biased net effective force can emerge in initially symmetric systems subject to a force of zero mean. This arises via an asymmetric system distortion in both classical and quantum mechanics. However, differences in time-periodicity and chaos between the two mechanics lead to differences in the evolution of the effective force in time. The second part obtains the canonical commutation relation of quantum mechanics assuming, in addition to the standard assumptions of the quantum Hilbert space, only that position and momentum are functionally independent. This exposes the fundamental interpretation of the commutation relation as an expression of independence, and thereby establishes its analogy with the classical Poisson bracket. Operator techniques used in these arguments are discussed at length.
The intrinsic multivaluedness of interaction process, revealed in Part I of this series of papers, is interpreted as the origin of the true dynamical (in particular, quantum) chaos. The latter is causally deduced as unceasing series of transitions, dynamically probabilistic by their origin, between the equally real, but incompatible 'realisations' (modes of interaction) of a system. The obtained set of realisations form the causally derived, intrinsically complete "space of events" providing the crucial extension of the notion of probability and the method of its first-principle calculation. The fundamental dynamic uncertainty thus revealed is specified for Hamiltonian quantum systems and applied to quantum chaos description in periodically perturbed systems. The ordinary semiclassical transition in our quantum-mechanical results leads to exact reproduction of the main features of chaotic behaviour of the system known from classical mechanics, which permits one to "re-establish" the correspondence principle for chaotic systems (inevitably lost in any their conventional, single-valued description). The causal dynamical randomness in the extended quantum mechanics is not restricted, however, to semiclassical conditions and generically occurs also in essentially quantum regimes, even though partial "quantum suppression of chaos" does exist and is specified in our description, as well as other particular types of the quantum (truly) chaotic behaviour.
Nonlinear dynamics (``chaos theory'') and quantum mechanics are two of the scientific triumphs of the 20th century. The former lies at the heart of the modern interdisciplinary approach to science, whereas the latter has revolutionized physics. Both chaos theory and quantum mechanics have achieved a fairly large level of glamour in the eyes of the general public. The study of quantum chaos encompasses the application of dynamical systems theory in the quantum regime. In the present article, we give a brief review of the origin and fundamentals of both quantum mechanics and nonlinear dynamics. We recount the birth of dynamical systems theory and contrast chaotic motion with integrable motion. We similarly recall the transition from classical to quantum mechanics and discuss the origin of the latter. We then consider the interplay between nonlinear dynamics and quantum mechanics via a classification and explanation of the three types of quantum chaos. We include several recent results in this discussion.
An extension of the concept of Kolmogorov entropy to quantum mechanical systems is given. Using the Kolmogorov entropy as a common basis for discussion, the onset of chaotic motion in classical mechanical and quantum mechanical systems is compared. It is found that if the spectrum of the system is discrete, the Kolmogorov entropy is zero, and therefore that a bounded quantum mechanical system cannot have chaotic motion like that observed for a corresponding classical mechanical system. This analysis leads to the prediction that if the distributions of states are similar for two bounded systems which in the classical limit have, respectively, quasiperiodic and chaotic motion, wave packets for the two systems decay at similar rates as found by Brumer and Shapiro. The relationship between the defined Kolmogorov entropy, previous interpretations of ’’KAMlike’’ onset of chaos in quantum mechanical systems, and the role played by preparation and observation of a system in influencing the intramolecular dynamics, are discussed.
In generic Hamiltonian systems that are neither completely integrable nor fully chaotic, phase space consists of a mixture of regular and chaotic components. In classical dynamics, transitions between different invariant sets in phase space are strictly forbidden, and these sets act as dynamical barriers to one another. In quantum mechanics, in contrast, wave effects allow transitions through such dynamical barriers. This process, known as dynamical tunneling, refers to penetration through dynamical barriers in phase space and was first recognized in the early 1980s. Since then, various aspects of dynamical tunneling have been elucidated, significantly advancing our understanding of such a novel quantum phenomenon. In this article, we provide an overview of several phenomenological perspectives of dynamical tunneling, including chaos-assisted and resonance-assisted tunneling, and also introduce approaches based on classical mechanics extended into the complex domain. In particular, we seek to clarify what is meant by the common claim that "chaos leads to an enhancement of the tunneling probability", which is often made when dynamical tunneling is dressed. We discuss what regime this refers to and, if such an enhancement occurs, what its likely origin is.
Extensive coherent control of quantum chaotic diffusion in periodically kicked dynamics is demonstrated in both a paradigm of quantum chaos and molecular systems in pulsed microwave fields. The origin of the control in deviations from random matrix theory is identified, and the survival of the control in the presence of decoherence effects is studied. Next, a fundamental principle in quantum physics with regard to indistinguishability and interference between multiple pathways to the same final state is applied to the significant field of coherent control. Later, coherent control of diatom-diatom elastic and inelastic scattering of identical molecules is demonstrated by revealing an intriguing role of quantum entanglement in coherent control problems. Finally, quantum classical correspondence in conservative chaotic systems is carefully examined using a distribution function strategy. Further, the role of decoherence in improving the correspondence is computationally studied from several complementary perspectives.