Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0906.1011

The construction of a general inner product in non-Hermitian quantum theory and some explanation for the nonuniqueness of the C operator in PT quantum mechanics

Frieder Kleefeld

Published Jun 4, 2009• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Most recently it has been observed e.g. by Bender and Klevansky (arXiv:0905.4673 [hep-th]) that the C-operator related to a PT-symmetric non-Hermitian Hamilton operator is not unique. Moreover it has been remarked by Shi and Sun (arXiv:0905.1771 [hep-th]) very recently that there seems to exist a well defined inner product in the context of the Hamilton operator of the PT-symmetric non-Hermitian Lee model yielding a different C-operator as compared to the one previously derived by Bender et al.. The puzzling observations of both manuscripts are reconciled and explained in the present manuscript as follows: the actual form of the metric operator (and the induced C-operator) related to some non-Hermitian Hamilton operator constructed along the lines of Shi and Su depends on the chosen normalization of the left and right eigenvectors of the Hamilton operator under consideration and is therefore ambiguous. For a specific PT-symmetric 2x2-matrix Hamilton operator it is shown that - by a suitable choice of the norm of its eigenvectors - the metric operator yielding a positive semi-definite inner product can be made even independent of the parameters of the considered Hamilton operator. This surprising feature makes in turn the obtained metric operator rather unique and attractive. For later convenience the metric operator for the Bosonic and Fermionic (anti)causal harmonic oscillator is derived.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.0906.1011

Related papers

On "non-Hermitian Quantum Mechanics"

M. J. Everitt, Shaaban Khalil, Alexandre M. Zagoskin

A series of recent papers ``Faster than Hermitian Quantum Mechanics'' and related articles made a point of the possibility of a non-Hermitian, but PT-symmetric, operator to play the role of a Hamiltonian. In particular, they show that with an appropriate choice of an inner product, the evolution generated by such an operator will conserve the norm and scalar product. Here we observe that if one chooses such an inner product then the Hamiltonian in question is actually Hermitian, and the whole exercise is to a certain degree redundant.

arXiv:0804.2051•Apr 13, 2008•0 citations

Investigation of PT -symmetric Hamiltonian Systems from an Alternative Point of View

Junqing Li, Qian Li, Yan-Gang Miao

Two non-Hermitian PT-symmetric Hamiltonian systems are reconsidered by means of the algebraic method which was originally proposed for the pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian systems rather than for the PT-symmetric ones. Compared with the way converting a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian to its Hermitian counterpart, this method has the merit that keeps the Hilbert space of the non-Hermitian PT-symmetric Hamiltonian unchanged. In order to give the positive definite inner product for the PT-symmetric systems, a new operator V, instead of C, can be introduced. The operator V has the similar function to the operator C adopted normally in the PT-symmetric quantum mechanics, however, it can be constructed, as an advantage, directly in terms of Hamiltonians. The spectra of the two non-Hermitian PT-symmetric systems are obtained, which coincide with that given in literature, and in particular, the Hilbert spaces associated with positive definite inner products are worked out.

arXiv:1204.6544•Communications in Theoretical Physics•Oct 1, 2012•13 citations

CPT-Frames for Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians

Cao Huai-xin, Zhihua Guo, Zhengli Chen

Based on the PT-symmetric quantum theory, the concepts of PT-frame, PT-symmetric operator and CPT-frame on a Hilbert space K and for an operator on K are proposed. It is proved that the spectrum and point spectrum of a PT-symmetric linear operator are both symmetric with respect to the real axis and the eigenvalues of an unbroken PT-symmetric operator are real. For a linear operator H on C d , it is proved that H has unbroken PT-symmetry if and only if it has d different eigenvalues and the corresponding eigenstates are eigenstates of PT. Given a CPT-frame on K, a new positive inner product on K is induced and called CPT-inner product. Te relationship between the CPT-adjoint and the Dirac adjoint of a densely defined linear operator is derived, and it is proved that an operator which has a bounded CPT-frame is CPT-Hermitian if and only if it is T-symmetric, in that case, it is similar to a Hermitian operator. The existence of an operator C consisting of a CPT-frame is discussed. These concepts and results will serve a mathematical discussion about PT-symmetric quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1212.3944•Communications in Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 2013•11 citations

Calculation of C Operator in PT-Symmetric Quantum Mechanics

Qinghai Wang

If a HamiltonianH has an unbroken PT symmetry, then it also possesses a hidden symmetry represented by the linear operator C. The operator C commutes with both H and PT . The inner product with respect to CPT is associated with a positive norm and the quantum theory built on the associated Hilbert space is unitary. In this paper it is shown how to construct the operator C for the non-Hermitian PT -symmetric Hamiltonian H = 12p + 1 2x 2 + i x using perturbative techniques. It is also shown how to construct the operator C for H = 12p 2 + 12x 2 − x using nonperturbative methods [1].

•Jan 1, 2004•1 citation

A Possible Method for Non-Hermitian and Non-PT-Symmetric Hamiltonian Systems

Junqing Li, Yan-Gang Miao, Xue Zhu Zhao

A possible method to investigate non-Hermitian Hamiltonians is suggested through finding a Hermitian operator η+ and defining the annihilation and creation operators to be η+ -pseudo-Hermitian adjoint to each other. The operator η+ represents the η+ -pseudo-Hermiticity of Hamiltonians. As an example, a non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian with imaginary linear coordinate and linear momentum terms is constructed and analyzed in detail. The operator η+ is found, based on which, a real spectrum and a positive-definite inner product, together with the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution, are obtained for the non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian. Moreover, this Hamiltonian turns out to be coupled when it is extended to the canonical noncommutative space with noncommutative spatial coordinate operators and noncommutative momentum operators as well. Our method is applicable to the coupled Hamiltonian. Then the first and second order noncommutative corrections of energy levels are calculated, and in particular the reality of energy spectra, the positive-definiteness of inner products, and the related properties (the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution) are found not to be altered by the noncommutativity.

arXiv:1107.4972•PLoS ONE•Jun 4, 2014•13 citations

The metric for non-Hermitian Hamiltonians: a case study

Dibwe Pierrot Musumbu

We are studying a possible implementation of an appropriate framework for a proper non-Hermitian quantum theory.We present the case where for a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian with real eigenvalues, we define a new inner product on the Hilbert space with respect to which the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian is Quasi-Hermitian.The Quasi-hermiticity of the Hamiltonian introduces the bi-orthogonality between the left-hand eigenstates and the right-hand eigenstates, in which case the metric becomes a basis transformation.We use the non-Hermitian quadratic Hamiltonian to show that such a metric is not unique but can be uniquely defined by requiring to hermitize all elements of one of the irreducible sets defined on the set of all observables.We compare the constructed metric with specific known examples in the literature in which cases a unique choice is made.Opsomming Ons ondersoek die implementering van n gepaste raamwerk virn nie-Hermitiese kwantumteorie.Ons beskoun nie-Hermitiese Hamilton-operator met reele eiewaardes en definieer in gepaste binneproduk ten opsigte waarvan die operator kwasi-Hermitiese is.Die kwasi-Hermities aard van die Hamilton operator lei dan tot n stel bi-ortogonale toestande.Ons konstrueer n basistransformasie wat die linker en regter eietoestande van hierdie stel koppel.Hierdie transformasie word dan gebruik omn nuwe binneproduk op die Hilbert-ruimte te definieer.Die oorspronklike nie-HermitieseHamilton-operator is danHermitiesmet betrekking tot hierdie nuwe binneproduk.Ons gebruik die nie-Hermitiese kwadratieseHamilton-operator om te toon dat hierdie metriek nie uniek is nie, maar wel uniek bepaal kan word deur verder te vereis dat dit al die elemente van n onherleibare versameling operatoreHermitiseer. Ons vergelyk hierdie konstruksie met die bekende voorbeelde in die literatuur en toon dat die metriek in beide gevalle uniek bepaal kan word.

•Dec 1, 2006•0 citations
Most recently it has been observed e.g. by Bender and Klevansky (arXiv:0905.4673 [hep-th]) that the C-operator related to a PT-symmetric non-Hermitian Hamilton operator is not unique. Moreover it has been remarked by Shi and Sun (arXiv:0905.1771 [hep-th]) very recently that there seems to exist a well defined inner product in the context of the Hamilton operator of the PT-symmetric non-Hermitian Lee model yielding a different C-operator as compared to the one previously derived by Bender et al.. The puzzling observations of both manuscripts are reconciled and explained in the present manuscript as follows: the actual form of the metric operator (and the induced C-operator) related to some non-Hermitian Hamilton operator constructed along the lines of Shi and Su depends on the chosen normalization of the left and right eigenvectors of the Hamilton operator under consideration and is therefore ambiguous. For a specific PT-symmetric 2x2-matrix Hamilton operator it is shown that - by a suitable choice of the norm of its eigenvectors - the metric operator yielding a positive semi-definite inner product can be made even independent of the parameters of the considered Hamilton operator. This surprising feature makes in turn the obtained metric operator rather unique and attractive. For later convenience the metric operator for the Bosonic and Fermionic (anti)causal harmonic oscillator is derived.
A series of recent papers ``Faster than Hermitian Quantum Mechanics'' and related articles made a point of the possibility of a non-Hermitian, but PT-symmetric, operator to play the role of a Hamiltonian. In particular, they show that with an appropriate choice of an inner product, the evolution generated by such an operator will conserve the norm and scalar product. Here we observe that if one chooses such an inner product then the Hamiltonian in question is actually Hermitian, and the whole exercise is to a certain degree redundant.
Two non-Hermitian PT-symmetric Hamiltonian systems are reconsidered by means of the algebraic method which was originally proposed for the pseudo-Hermitian Hamiltonian systems rather than for the PT-symmetric ones. Compared with the way converting a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian to its Hermitian counterpart, this method has the merit that keeps the Hilbert space of the non-Hermitian PT-symmetric Hamiltonian unchanged. In order to give the positive definite inner product for the PT-symmetric systems, a new operator V, instead of C, can be introduced. The operator V has the similar function to the operator C adopted normally in the PT-symmetric quantum mechanics, however, it can be constructed, as an advantage, directly in terms of Hamiltonians. The spectra of the two non-Hermitian PT-symmetric systems are obtained, which coincide with that given in literature, and in particular, the Hilbert spaces associated with positive definite inner products are worked out.
Based on the PT-symmetric quantum theory, the concepts of PT-frame, PT-symmetric operator and CPT-frame on a Hilbert space K and for an operator on K are proposed. It is proved that the spectrum and point spectrum of a PT-symmetric linear operator are both symmetric with respect to the real axis and the eigenvalues of an unbroken PT-symmetric operator are real. For a linear operator H on C d , it is proved that H has unbroken PT-symmetry if and only if it has d different eigenvalues and the corresponding eigenstates are eigenstates of PT. Given a CPT-frame on K, a new positive inner product on K is induced and called CPT-inner product. Te relationship between the CPT-adjoint and the Dirac adjoint of a densely defined linear operator is derived, and it is proved that an operator which has a bounded CPT-frame is CPT-Hermitian if and only if it is T-symmetric, in that case, it is similar to a Hermitian operator. The existence of an operator C consisting of a CPT-frame is discussed. These concepts and results will serve a mathematical discussion about PT-symmetric quantum mechanics.
If a HamiltonianH has an unbroken PT symmetry, then it also possesses a hidden symmetry represented by the linear operator C. The operator C commutes with both H and PT . The inner product with respect to CPT is associated with a positive norm and the quantum theory built on the associated Hilbert space is unitary. In this paper it is shown how to construct the operator C for the non-Hermitian PT -symmetric Hamiltonian H = 12p + 1 2x 2 + i x using perturbative techniques. It is also shown how to construct the operator C for H = 12p 2 + 12x 2 − x using nonperturbative methods [1].
A possible method to investigate non-Hermitian Hamiltonians is suggested through finding a Hermitian operator η+ and defining the annihilation and creation operators to be η+ -pseudo-Hermitian adjoint to each other. The operator η+ represents the η+ -pseudo-Hermiticity of Hamiltonians. As an example, a non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian with imaginary linear coordinate and linear momentum terms is constructed and analyzed in detail. The operator η+ is found, based on which, a real spectrum and a positive-definite inner product, together with the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution, are obtained for the non-Hermitian and non-PT-symmetric Hamiltonian. Moreover, this Hamiltonian turns out to be coupled when it is extended to the canonical noncommutative space with noncommutative spatial coordinate operators and noncommutative momentum operators as well. Our method is applicable to the coupled Hamiltonian. Then the first and second order noncommutative corrections of energy levels are calculated, and in particular the reality of energy spectra, the positive-definiteness of inner products, and the related properties (the probability explanation of wave functions, the orthogonality of eigenstates, and the unitarity of time evolution) are found not to be altered by the noncommutativity.
We are studying a possible implementation of an appropriate framework for a proper non-Hermitian quantum theory.We present the case where for a non-Hermitian Hamiltonian with real eigenvalues, we define a new inner product on the Hilbert space with respect to which the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian is Quasi-Hermitian.The Quasi-hermiticity of the Hamiltonian introduces the bi-orthogonality between the left-hand eigenstates and the right-hand eigenstates, in which case the metric becomes a basis transformation.We use the non-Hermitian quadratic Hamiltonian to show that such a metric is not unique but can be uniquely defined by requiring to hermitize all elements of one of the irreducible sets defined on the set of all observables.We compare the constructed metric with specific known examples in the literature in which cases a unique choice is made.Opsomming Ons ondersoek die implementering van n gepaste raamwerk virn nie-Hermitiese kwantumteorie.Ons beskoun nie-Hermitiese Hamilton-operator met reele eiewaardes en definieer in gepaste binneproduk ten opsigte waarvan die operator kwasi-Hermitiese is.Die kwasi-Hermities aard van die Hamilton operator lei dan tot n stel bi-ortogonale toestande.Ons konstrueer n basistransformasie wat die linker en regter eietoestande van hierdie stel koppel.Hierdie transformasie word dan gebruik omn nuwe binneproduk op die Hilbert-ruimte te definieer.Die oorspronklike nie-HermitieseHamilton-operator is danHermitiesmet betrekking tot hierdie nuwe binneproduk.Ons gebruik die nie-Hermitiese kwadratieseHamilton-operator om te toon dat hierdie metriek nie uniek is nie, maar wel uniek bepaal kan word deur verder te vereis dat dit al die elemente van n onherleibare versameling operatoreHermitiseer. Ons vergelyk hierdie konstruksie met die bekende voorbeelde in die literatuur en toon dat die metriek in beide gevalle uniek bepaal kan word.