Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0906.0315 · International Journal of Modern Physics D

SHORTCOMINGS IN THE UNDERSTANDING OF WHY COSMOLOGICAL PERTURBATIONS LOOK CLASSICAL

Daniel Sudarsky

Published Apr 1, 2011• 140 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

There is a persistent state of confusion regarding the account of the quantum origin of the seeds of cosmological structure during inflation. The issue is the transition from the quantum uncertainties in the homogeneous and isotropic initial state, into the late-time "classical" anisotropies and inhomogeneities. There seems to be a widespread belief that decoherence addresses the issue in a satisfactory way. This view is taken, often implicitly, by most researchers working in the field. This can be seen most clearly in those accounts intended on facing the issue directly. For instance, a recent article [C. Kiefer and D. Polarski, arXiv: 0810.0087] argues just that, and presents a detailed explanation of the justifications. The explicit nature of that account will allow us to discuss the issue in detail. There are, of course, various other works that often indirectly address the issue with similar approaches (see Refs. 2–13). This type of arguments do not only implicitly assume that decoherence offers a satisfactory solution to the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, but also that, in particular, such approach is applicable to these quantum aspects of cosmology. We will review here, why do we, together with various other researchers in the field, consider that this assumption is not correct in general. Moreover as previously discussed in Refs. 22–26, we will argue that the cosmological situation is one where the measurement problem of quantum mechanics appears in a particular exacerbated form, and that, it is this, even sharper conundrum, that should be addressed when dealing with the inflationary account of the origin of the seeds of cosmic structure in the early Universe. We briefly discuss the ideas behind what we feel might be a promising approach to deal with this problem.

DOI
10.1142/s0218271811018937

Related papers

The Quantum Origin of the Seeds of Cosmic Structure: The case for a missing link

Daniel Sudarsky, Hugo Aurelio Morales-Técotl, Luis Arturo Ureña-López +2 more

We discuss here a not very well advertised problem afflicting the standard inflationary account of the origin of structure in the universe as the result of the, so called, quantum fluctuations of the inflaton field. We will show that such account is based on the properties of a quantum state that is homogeneous and isotropic, and that there is in the usual proposal no explanation for the emergence of inhomogeneities and anisotropies through a dynamics that preserves those symmetries in the quantum state. We will see that the issue can be seen as connected with the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, an unsatisfactory conceptual aspect of current quantum theory, which becomes intractable in the cosmological context at hand. We will see that one can address the issue adding the assumption that a new, and fundamental process in physics plays an essential role in this situation, (and naturally in other situations as well), and that unlike other cases, the cosmological problem at hand offers a path to investigate under empirical guidance some of the characteristics of this new physics.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2010•5 citations

Quantum to Classical transition in the early Universe: models andobservational signatures

Aoumeur Daddi Hammou

Inflation is the standard scenario for the Early Universe providing a mechanism to explain the generation of primordial density perturbations from which all the structures we see in the universe formed by subsequent gravitational growth (like, e.g., anisotropies of the Cosmic Microwave Background, or the large-scale distribution of galaxies). The inflationary seeds for structure formation are traced back to quantum fluctuations of one or more (scalar) fields. However galaxies or cluster of galaxies do behave as classical objects. This entails the issue of understanding a quantum-to-classical transition in a cosmological framework. From this point of view inflation and cosmological observations can represent an interesting laboratory to explore some issues related to the quantum measurement problem. This issue has been long known, still it has been not explored in full details, and recently there has been a renowned interest in it. The thesis will consist in a first part of review of the most recent studies on the subject. It will then focus on some aspects of the problem, namely how the classical to quantum transition impacts on primordial gravitational waves which are a smoking gun of inflation, and whether and how such a transition can leave specific signatures in cosmological observables that go beyond the usual analyses (such as, e.g., non-Gaussianity of the cosmological perturbations from inflation).

•Oct 1, 2020•0 citations

Eternal inflation and collapse theories

Rosa-Laura Lechuga, Daniel Sudarsky

Abstract The eternal inflation problem continues to be considered one of standard's cosmology most serious shortcomings. This arises when one considers the effects of “quantum fluctuations” on the zero mode of inflaton field during a Hubble time in the inflationary epoch. In the slow-roll regime it is quite clear that such quantum fluctuations could dwarf the classical rolling down of the inflaton, and with overwhelming probability this prevents inflation from ever ending. When one recognizes that quantum fluctuations can not be taken as synonymous of stochastic fluctuations, but rather intrinsic levels of indefiniteness in the quantities in question, one concludes that the eternal inflation problem simply does not exist. However, the same argument would serve to invalidate the account for the generation of the primordial seeds of cosmic structure as has been amply discussed elsewhere [1,2,3]. In order to do address that issue, one must explain the breaking of homogeneity and isotropy of the situation prevailing during the early inflationary epoch (at both the quantum and classical levels of the description). For that one needs to rely on some additional element, beyond those present in the traditional treatments. The so called spontaneous collapse theories offer a viable candidate for that element, namely the stochastic and spontaneous state reduction characteristic of those proposals possesses the basic features to break those symmetries. In fact, a version of the CSL theory adapted to the cosmological context has been shown to offer a satisfactory account for the origin the seeds of cosmic structure with an adequate power spectrum [2], and will serve as the basis of our analysis. However, once such stochastic collapse is introduced into the theoretical framework the eternal inflation problem has the potential reappear. In this manuscript we explore those issues in detail and discuss an avenue that seems to allow for a satisfactory account for the generation of the primordial inhomogeneities and anisotropies while freeing the theory from the eternal inflation problem.

arXiv:2308.01383•Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics•Jan 1, 2024•8 citations

On the Quantum-to-Classical Transition of Primordial Perturbations

Wouter Ryssens

Detailed measurements of the cosmic microwave background indicate the large-scale homogeneity of the universe. On very small scales, we observe however inhomogeneities such as galaxies, stars, planets and ourselves. In the context of hot Big-Bang cosmology, these inhomogeneities are often explained as the remains of quantum fluctuations at very early times, enlarged to observable scales through the process of inflation. In this dissertation, I examine two important questions surrounding this scenario: a) How do inherently quantal fluctuations transition to the observed inhomogeneities, which behave classically? ; and b) If the initial state of the universe was symmetric, how can the currently observed state? This dissertation is organized in three parts. Part one first introduces the slow-roll inflation model and then discusses the behavior of small (scalar) perturbations to this model. The second part investigates various answers provided to the questions above, starting with some general observations on the classical limit of quantum mechanics with special attention given to the inverted harmonic oscillator. The formalisms of `squeezing' and decoherence are discussed and weak points are pointed out. In the final part, I examine in detail the pilot-wave approach to the problem, discussing in detail the classical limit of the theory and how pilot-wave theory addresses both questions above. Numerical results for pilot-wave trajectories are presented, illustrating directly the classical limit.

arXiv:1907.00258•Jun 29, 2019•2 citations

Why do Cosmological Perturbations Look Classical to Us?

Claus Kiefer, David Polarski

According to the inflationary scenario of cosmology, all structure in the Universe can be traced back to primordial fluctuations during an accelerated (inflationary) phase of the very early Universe. A conceptual problem arises due to the fact that the primordial fluctuations are quantum, while the standard scenario of structure formation deals with classical fluctuations. In this essay we present a concise summary of the physics describing the quantum-to-classical transition. We first discuss the observational indistinguishability between classical and quantum correlation functions in the closed system approach (pragmatic view). We then present the open system approach with environment-induced decoherence. We finally discuss the question of the fluctuations' entropy for which, in principle, the concrete mechanism leading to decoherence possesses observational relevance.

arXiv:0810.0087•Advanced Science Letters•Jun 1, 2009•266 citations

The Bohmian Approach to the Problems of Cosmological Quantum Fluctuations

Sheldon Goldstein, Ward Struyve, Roderich Tumulka

There are two kinds of quantum fluctuations relevant to cosmology that we focus on in this article: those that form the seeds for structure formation in the early universe and those giving rise to Boltzmann brains in the late universe. First, structure formation requires slight inhomogeneities in the density of matter in the early universe, which are then amplified by the effect of gravity, leading to clumping of matter into stars and galaxies. According to inflation theory, quantum fluctuations form the seeds of these inhomogeneities. However, these quantum fluctuations are described by a quantum state that is homogeneous and isotropic, and this raises a problem, connected to the foundations of quantum theory, as the unitary evolution alone cannot break the symmetry of the quantum state. Second, Boltzmann brains are random agglomerates of particles that, by extreme coincidence, form functioning brains. Unlikely as these coincidences are, they seem to be predicted to occur in a quantum universe as vacuum fluctuations if the universe continues to exist for an infinite (or just very long) time; in fact, they are predicted to occur over and over, even forming the majority of all brains in the history of the universe. We provide a brief introduction to the Bohmian version of quantum theory and explain why in this version Boltzmann brains, an undesirable kind of fluctuation, do not occur (or at least not often), while inhomogeneous seeds for structure formation, a desirable kind of fluctuation, do.

arXiv:1508.01017•The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Jun 24, 2022•31 citations
There is a persistent state of confusion regarding the account of the quantum origin of the seeds of cosmological structure during inflation. The issue is the transition from the quantum uncertainties in the homogeneous and isotropic initial state, into the late-time "classical" anisotropies and inhomogeneities. There seems to be a widespread belief that decoherence addresses the issue in a satisfactory way. This view is taken, often implicitly, by most researchers working in the field. This can be seen most clearly in those accounts intended on facing the issue directly. For instance, a recent article [C. Kiefer and D. Polarski, arXiv: 0810.0087] argues just that, and presents a detailed explanation of the justifications. The explicit nature of that account will allow us to discuss the issue in detail. There are, of course, various other works that often indirectly address the issue with similar approaches (see Refs. 2–13). This type of arguments do not only implicitly assume that decoherence offers a satisfactory solution to the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, but also that, in particular, such approach is applicable to these quantum aspects of cosmology. We will review here, why do we, together with various other researchers in the field, consider that this assumption is not correct in general. Moreover as previously discussed in Refs. 22–26, we will argue that the cosmological situation is one where the measurement problem of quantum mechanics appears in a particular exacerbated form, and that, it is this, even sharper conundrum, that should be addressed when dealing with the inflationary account of the origin of the seeds of cosmic structure in the early Universe. We briefly discuss the ideas behind what we feel might be a promising approach to deal with this problem.
We discuss here a not very well advertised problem afflicting the standard inflationary account of the origin of structure in the universe as the result of the, so called, quantum fluctuations of the inflaton field. We will show that such account is based on the properties of a quantum state that is homogeneous and isotropic, and that there is in the usual proposal no explanation for the emergence of inhomogeneities and anisotropies through a dynamics that preserves those symmetries in the quantum state. We will see that the issue can be seen as connected with the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, an unsatisfactory conceptual aspect of current quantum theory, which becomes intractable in the cosmological context at hand. We will see that one can address the issue adding the assumption that a new, and fundamental process in physics plays an essential role in this situation, (and naturally in other situations as well), and that unlike other cases, the cosmological problem at hand offers a path to investigate under empirical guidance some of the characteristics of this new physics.
Inflation is the standard scenario for the Early Universe providing a mechanism to explain the generation of primordial density perturbations from which all the structures we see in the universe formed by subsequent gravitational growth (like, e.g., anisotropies of the Cosmic Microwave Background, or the large-scale distribution of galaxies). The inflationary seeds for structure formation are traced back to quantum fluctuations of one or more (scalar) fields. However galaxies or cluster of galaxies do behave as classical objects. This entails the issue of understanding a quantum-to-classical transition in a cosmological framework. From this point of view inflation and cosmological observations can represent an interesting laboratory to explore some issues related to the quantum measurement problem. This issue has been long known, still it has been not explored in full details, and recently there has been a renowned interest in it. The thesis will consist in a first part of review of the most recent studies on the subject. It will then focus on some aspects of the problem, namely how the classical to quantum transition impacts on primordial gravitational waves which are a smoking gun of inflation, and whether and how such a transition can leave specific signatures in cosmological observables that go beyond the usual analyses (such as, e.g., non-Gaussianity of the cosmological perturbations from inflation).
Abstract The eternal inflation problem continues to be considered one of standard's cosmology most serious shortcomings. This arises when one considers the effects of “quantum fluctuations” on the zero mode of inflaton field during a Hubble time in the inflationary epoch. In the slow-roll regime it is quite clear that such quantum fluctuations could dwarf the classical rolling down of the inflaton, and with overwhelming probability this prevents inflation from ever ending. When one recognizes that quantum fluctuations can not be taken as synonymous of stochastic fluctuations, but rather intrinsic levels of indefiniteness in the quantities in question, one concludes that the eternal inflation problem simply does not exist. However, the same argument would serve to invalidate the account for the generation of the primordial seeds of cosmic structure as has been amply discussed elsewhere [1,2,3]. In order to do address that issue, one must explain the breaking of homogeneity and isotropy of the situation prevailing during the early inflationary epoch (at both the quantum and classical levels of the description). For that one needs to rely on some additional element, beyond those present in the traditional treatments. The so called spontaneous collapse theories offer a viable candidate for that element, namely the stochastic and spontaneous state reduction characteristic of those proposals possesses the basic features to break those symmetries. In fact, a version of the CSL theory adapted to the cosmological context has been shown to offer a satisfactory account for the origin the seeds of cosmic structure with an adequate power spectrum [2], and will serve as the basis of our analysis. However, once such stochastic collapse is introduced into the theoretical framework the eternal inflation problem has the potential reappear. In this manuscript we explore those issues in detail and discuss an avenue that seems to allow for a satisfactory account for the generation of the primordial inhomogeneities and anisotropies while freeing the theory from the eternal inflation problem.
Detailed measurements of the cosmic microwave background indicate the large-scale homogeneity of the universe. On very small scales, we observe however inhomogeneities such as galaxies, stars, planets and ourselves. In the context of hot Big-Bang cosmology, these inhomogeneities are often explained as the remains of quantum fluctuations at very early times, enlarged to observable scales through the process of inflation. In this dissertation, I examine two important questions surrounding this scenario: a) How do inherently quantal fluctuations transition to the observed inhomogeneities, which behave classically? ; and b) If the initial state of the universe was symmetric, how can the currently observed state? This dissertation is organized in three parts. Part one first introduces the slow-roll inflation model and then discusses the behavior of small (scalar) perturbations to this model. The second part investigates various answers provided to the questions above, starting with some general observations on the classical limit of quantum mechanics with special attention given to the inverted harmonic oscillator. The formalisms of `squeezing' and decoherence are discussed and weak points are pointed out. In the final part, I examine in detail the pilot-wave approach to the problem, discussing in detail the classical limit of the theory and how pilot-wave theory addresses both questions above. Numerical results for pilot-wave trajectories are presented, illustrating directly the classical limit.
According to the inflationary scenario of cosmology, all structure in the Universe can be traced back to primordial fluctuations during an accelerated (inflationary) phase of the very early Universe. A conceptual problem arises due to the fact that the primordial fluctuations are quantum, while the standard scenario of structure formation deals with classical fluctuations. In this essay we present a concise summary of the physics describing the quantum-to-classical transition. We first discuss the observational indistinguishability between classical and quantum correlation functions in the closed system approach (pragmatic view). We then present the open system approach with environment-induced decoherence. We finally discuss the question of the fluctuations' entropy for which, in principle, the concrete mechanism leading to decoherence possesses observational relevance.
There are two kinds of quantum fluctuations relevant to cosmology that we focus on in this article: those that form the seeds for structure formation in the early universe and those giving rise to Boltzmann brains in the late universe. First, structure formation requires slight inhomogeneities in the density of matter in the early universe, which are then amplified by the effect of gravity, leading to clumping of matter into stars and galaxies. According to inflation theory, quantum fluctuations form the seeds of these inhomogeneities. However, these quantum fluctuations are described by a quantum state that is homogeneous and isotropic, and this raises a problem, connected to the foundations of quantum theory, as the unitary evolution alone cannot break the symmetry of the quantum state. Second, Boltzmann brains are random agglomerates of particles that, by extreme coincidence, form functioning brains. Unlikely as these coincidences are, they seem to be predicted to occur in a quantum universe as vacuum fluctuations if the universe continues to exist for an infinite (or just very long) time; in fact, they are predicted to occur over and over, even forming the majority of all brains in the history of the universe. We provide a brief introduction to the Bohmian version of quantum theory and explain why in this version Boltzmann brains, an undesirable kind of fluctuation, do not occur (or at least not often), while inhomogeneous seeds for structure formation, a desirable kind of fluctuation, do.