Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0905.3810 · Physical Review A

Weak values, “negative probability,” and the uncertainty principle

D. Sokolovski

Published Oct 25, 2007• 45 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A quantum transition can be seen as a result of interference between various pathways (e.g., Feynman paths), which can be labeled by a variable $f$. An attempt to determine the value of $f$ without destroying the coherence between the pathways produces a weak value of $\overline{f}$. We show $\overline{f}$ to be an average obtained with an amplitude distribution which can, in general, take negative values, which, in accordance with the uncertainty principle, need not contain information about the actual range of $f$ which contributes to the transition. It is also demonstrated that the moments of such alternating distributions have a number of unusual properties which may lead to a misinterpretation of the weak-measurement results. We provide a detailed analysis of weak measurements with and without post-selection. Examples include the double-slit diffraction experiment, weak von Neumann and von Neumann--like measurements, traversal time for an elastic collision, phase time, and local angular momentum.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.76.042125

Related papers

Quantum Measurements, Stochastic Networks, the Uncertainty Principle, and the Not So Strange “Weak Values”

D. Sokolovski

Suppose we make a series of measurements on a chosen quantum system. The outcomes of the measurements form a sequence of random events, which occur in a particular order. The system, together with a meter or meters, can be seen as following the paths of a stochastic network connecting all possible outcomes. The paths are shaped from the virtual paths of the system, and the corresponding probabilities are determined by the measuring devices employed. If the measurements are highly accurate, the virtual paths become “real”, and the mean values of a quantity (a functional) are directly related to the frequencies with which the paths are traveled. If the measurements are highly inaccurate, the mean (weak) values are expressed in terms of the relative probabilities’ amplitudes. For pre- and post-selected systems they are bound to take arbitrary values, depending on the chosen transition. This is a direct consequence of the uncertainty principle, which forbids one from distinguishing between interfering alternatives, while leaving the interference between them intact.

arXiv:1606.01845•Mathematics•Sep 15, 2016•8 citations

Observing the Weak Value through Quantum Interference

森, 琢也

In quantum mechanics, it is well known that counterfactual arguments sometimes lead to paradoxes, which implies that our classical intuition is not always reliable.However, it has been pointed out by several authors that the weak value, which was introduced by Aharonov et al. in 1988, may be useful to comprehend quantum mechanics intuitively.Another extraordinary aspect of the weak value is its amplification, which has been exploited for precision measurement.Nevertheless, the physical meaning of the weak value is still obscure due to its complexity of the value and the very fact of the amplification.In this thesis, by considering various situations of quantum interference, we attempt to provide a possible interpretation of the weak value.We find, on one hand, that the imaginary part of the weak value is relevant to the wave nature.On the other hand, in the double-slit experiment the particle nature can be seen in the real part of the position weak value.This property for the real part does not hold for more general cases such as the multiple (more than two) slit experiment.The position weak value, nevertheless, can be interpreted as the average of the classical trajectories based on a complex probability.We also investigate the possibility of knowing which path the particle takes in the multiple-slit experiment without destroying the interference fringes.We show that, because of the statistical nature of the weak value, obtaining the which-path information and the interference pattern is compatible with complementarity.Our study suggests that the weak value is a reasonable physical quantity.

•Mar 24, 2015•0 citations

Are the Weak Measurements Really Measurements?

D. Sokolovski

Weak measurements can be seen as an attempt at answering the Which way? question without destroying interference between the pathways involved. Unusual mean values obtained in such measurements represent the response of a quantum system to this forbidden question, in which the true composition of virtual pathways is hidden from the observer. Such values indicate a failure of a measurement where the uncertainty principle says it must fail, rather than provide an additional insight into physical reality. Quanta 2013; 2: 50–57.

arXiv:1305.4809•Quanta•May 14, 2013•12 citations

Time averaging of weak values—consequences for time-energy and coordinate-momentum uncertainty

Eli Pollak, Salvador Miret-Artés

Using the quantum transition path time probability distribution we show that time averaging of weak values leads to unexpected results. We prove a weak value time-energy uncertainty principle and time-energy commutation relation. We also find that time averaging allows one to predict in advance the momentum of a particle at a post selected point in space with accuracy greater than the limit of ℏ/2 as dictated by the uncertainty principle. This comes at a cost—it is not possible at the same time to predict when the particle will arrive at the post selected point. A specific example is provided for one dimensional scattering from a square barrier.

arXiv:1805.09600•New Journal of Physics•Jun 29, 2018•9 citations

Uncertainty relations for time-averaged weak values

Eli Pollak, Salvador Miret-Artés

Time averaging of weak values using the quantum transition path time probability distribution enables us to establish a general uncertainty relation for the weak values of two not necessarily Hermitian operators. This new relation is a weak value analog of the Schr\"odinger strong value uncertainty relation. It leads to the conclusion that it is possible to determine with high accuracy the simultaneous mean weak values of noncommuting operators by judicious choice of the pre- and postselected states even when the postselected state is not an eigenfunction of one of the respective operators. When the time fluctuations of the two weak values are proportional to each other there is no uncertainty limitation on their variances and, in principle, their means can be determined with arbitrary precision even though their corresponding operators do not commute. To exemplify these properties we consider specific weak value uncertainty relations for the time-energy, coordinate-momentum, and coordinate--kinetic-energy pairs. In addition we analyze spin operators and the Stern-Gerlach experiment in weak and strong inhomogeneous magnetic fields. This classic case leads to anomalous spin values when the field is weak. The weak value uncertainty relation implies that anomalous spin values are associated with large variances so that their measurement demands increased signal averaging. These examples establish the importance of considering the time dependence of weak values in scattering experiments.

arXiv:1808.06384•Physical Review A•Jan 8, 2019•6 citations

Quantum trajectories based on the weak value

Takuya Mori, Izumi Tsutsui

The notion of the trajectory of an individual particle is strictly inhibited in quantum mechanics because of the uncertainty principle. Nonetheless, the weak value, which has been proposed as a novel and measurable quantity definable to any quantum observable, can offer a possible description of trajectory on account of its statistical nature. In this paper, we explore the physical significance provided by this “weak trajectory” by considering various situations where interference takes place simultaneously with the observation of particles, that is, in prototypical quantum situations for which no classical treatment is available. These include the double slit experiment and Lloyd's mirror, where in the former case it is argued that the real part of the weak trajectory describes an average over the possible classical trajectories involved in the process, and that the imaginary part is related to the variation of interference. It is shown that this average interpretation of the weak trajectory holds universally under the complex probability defined from the given transition process. These features remain essentially unaltered in the case of Lloyd's mirror where interference occurs with a single slit.

arXiv:1412.0916•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Apr 1, 2015•17 citations
A quantum transition can be seen as a result of interference between various pathways (e.g., Feynman paths), which can be labeled by a variable fff. An attempt to determine the value of fff without destroying the coherence between the pathways produces a weak value of f‾\overline{f}f​. We show f‾\overline{f}f​ to be an average obtained with an amplitude distribution which can, in general, take negative values, which, in accordance with the uncertainty principle, need not contain information about the actual range of fff which contributes to the transition. It is also demonstrated that the moments of such alternating distributions have a number of unusual properties which may lead to a misinterpretation of the weak-measurement results. We provide a detailed analysis of weak measurements with and without post-selection. Examples include the double-slit diffraction experiment, weak von Neumann and von Neumann--like measurements, traversal time for an elastic collision, phase time, and local angular momentum.
Suppose we make a series of measurements on a chosen quantum system. The outcomes of the measurements form a sequence of random events, which occur in a particular order. The system, together with a meter or meters, can be seen as following the paths of a stochastic network connecting all possible outcomes. The paths are shaped from the virtual paths of the system, and the corresponding probabilities are determined by the measuring devices employed. If the measurements are highly accurate, the virtual paths become “real”, and the mean values of a quantity (a functional) are directly related to the frequencies with which the paths are traveled. If the measurements are highly inaccurate, the mean (weak) values are expressed in terms of the relative probabilities’ amplitudes. For pre- and post-selected systems they are bound to take arbitrary values, depending on the chosen transition. This is a direct consequence of the uncertainty principle, which forbids one from distinguishing between interfering alternatives, while leaving the interference between them intact.
In quantum mechanics, it is well known that counterfactual arguments sometimes lead to paradoxes, which implies that our classical intuition is not always reliable.However, it has been pointed out by several authors that the weak value, which was introduced by Aharonov et al. in 1988, may be useful to comprehend quantum mechanics intuitively.Another extraordinary aspect of the weak value is its amplification, which has been exploited for precision measurement.Nevertheless, the physical meaning of the weak value is still obscure due to its complexity of the value and the very fact of the amplification.In this thesis, by considering various situations of quantum interference, we attempt to provide a possible interpretation of the weak value.We find, on one hand, that the imaginary part of the weak value is relevant to the wave nature.On the other hand, in the double-slit experiment the particle nature can be seen in the real part of the position weak value.This property for the real part does not hold for more general cases such as the multiple (more than two) slit experiment.The position weak value, nevertheless, can be interpreted as the average of the classical trajectories based on a complex probability.We also investigate the possibility of knowing which path the particle takes in the multiple-slit experiment without destroying the interference fringes.We show that, because of the statistical nature of the weak value, obtaining the which-path information and the interference pattern is compatible with complementarity.Our study suggests that the weak value is a reasonable physical quantity.
Weak measurements can be seen as an attempt at answering the Which way? question without destroying interference between the pathways involved. Unusual mean values obtained in such measurements represent the response of a quantum system to this forbidden question, in which the true composition of virtual pathways is hidden from the observer. Such values indicate a failure of a measurement where the uncertainty principle says it must fail, rather than provide an additional insight into physical reality. Quanta 2013; 2: 50–57.
Using the quantum transition path time probability distribution we show that time averaging of weak values leads to unexpected results. We prove a weak value time-energy uncertainty principle and time-energy commutation relation. We also find that time averaging allows one to predict in advance the momentum of a particle at a post selected point in space with accuracy greater than the limit of ℏ/2 as dictated by the uncertainty principle. This comes at a cost—it is not possible at the same time to predict when the particle will arrive at the post selected point. A specific example is provided for one dimensional scattering from a square barrier.
Time averaging of weak values using the quantum transition path time probability distribution enables us to establish a general uncertainty relation for the weak values of two not necessarily Hermitian operators. This new relation is a weak value analog of the Schr\"odinger strong value uncertainty relation. It leads to the conclusion that it is possible to determine with high accuracy the simultaneous mean weak values of noncommuting operators by judicious choice of the pre- and postselected states even when the postselected state is not an eigenfunction of one of the respective operators. When the time fluctuations of the two weak values are proportional to each other there is no uncertainty limitation on their variances and, in principle, their means can be determined with arbitrary precision even though their corresponding operators do not commute. To exemplify these properties we consider specific weak value uncertainty relations for the time-energy, coordinate-momentum, and coordinate--kinetic-energy pairs. In addition we analyze spin operators and the Stern-Gerlach experiment in weak and strong inhomogeneous magnetic fields. This classic case leads to anomalous spin values when the field is weak. The weak value uncertainty relation implies that anomalous spin values are associated with large variances so that their measurement demands increased signal averaging. These examples establish the importance of considering the time dependence of weak values in scattering experiments.
The notion of the trajectory of an individual particle is strictly inhibited in quantum mechanics because of the uncertainty principle. Nonetheless, the weak value, which has been proposed as a novel and measurable quantity definable to any quantum observable, can offer a possible description of trajectory on account of its statistical nature. In this paper, we explore the physical significance provided by this “weak trajectory” by considering various situations where interference takes place simultaneously with the observation of particles, that is, in prototypical quantum situations for which no classical treatment is available. These include the double slit experiment and Lloyd's mirror, where in the former case it is argued that the real part of the weak trajectory describes an average over the possible classical trajectories involved in the process, and that the imaginary part is related to the variation of interference. It is shown that this average interpretation of the weak trajectory holds universally under the complex probability defined from the given transition process. These features remain essentially unaltered in the case of Lloyd's mirror where interference occurs with a single slit.