Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:0905.2419 · Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science

The Quantum and Classical Complexity of Translationally Invariant Tiling and Hamiltonian Problems

Daniel Gottesman, Sandy Irani

Published Oct 1, 2009• 76 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study the complexity of a class of problems involving satisfying constraints which remain the same under translations in one or more spatial directions. In this paper, we show hardness of a classical tiling problem on an (N x N) 2-dimensional grid and a quantum problem involving finding the ground state energy of a 1-dimensional quantum system of N particles. In both cases, the only input is N, provided in binary. We show that the classical problem is NEXP-complete and the quantum problem is QMAEXP-complete. Thus, an algorithm for these problems that runs in time polynomial in N (exponential in the input size) would imply EXP = NEXP or BQEXP = QMAEXP, respectively. Although tiling in general is already known to be NEXP-complete, to our knowledge, all previous reductions require that either the set of tiles and their constraints or some varying boundary conditions be given as part of the input. In the problem considered here, these are fixed, constant-sized parameters of the problem. Instead, the problem instance is encoded solely in the size of the system.

DOI
10.1109/focs.2009.22

Related papers

The complexity of translationally invariant low-dimensional spin lattices in 3D

Johannes Bausch, Stephen Piddock

In this theoretical paper, we consider spin systems in three spatial dimensions and consider the computational complexity of estimating the ground state energy, known as the local Hamiltonian problem, for translationally invariant Hamiltonians. We prove that the local Hamiltonian problem for 3D lattices with face-centered cubic unit cells and 4-local translationally invariant interactions between spin-3/2 particles and open boundary conditions is QMAEXP-complete, where QMAEXP is the class of problems which can be verified in exponential time on a quantum computer. We go beyond a mere embedding of past hard 1D history state constructions, for which the local spin dimension is enormous: even state-of-the-art constructions have local dimension 42. We avoid such a large local dimension by combining some different techniques in a novel way. For the verifier circuit which we embed into the ground space of the local Hamiltonian, we utilize a recently developed computational model, called a quantum ring machine, which is especially well suited for translationally invariant history state constructions. This is encoded with a new and particularly simple universal gate set, which consists of a single 2-qubit gate applied only to nearest-neighbour qubits. The Hamiltonian construction involves a classical Wang tiling problem as a binary counter which translates one cube side length into a binary description for the encoded verifier input and a carefully engineered history state construction that implements the ring machine on the cubic lattice faces. These novel techniques allow us to significantly lower the local spin dimension, surpassing the best translationally invariant result to date by two orders of magnitude (in the number of degrees of freedom per coupling). This brings our models on par with the best non-translationally invariant construction.

arXiv:1702.08830•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 1, 2017•15 citations

Quantum-Merlin-Arthur-complete translationally invariant Hamiltonian problem and the complexity of finding ground-state energies in physical systems

Alastair Kay

Here we present a problem related to the local Hamiltonian problem (identifying whether the ground-state energy falls within one of two ranges) which is restricted to being translationally invariant. We prove that for Hamiltonians with a fixed local dimension and $O\mathbf{(}\mathrm{log}(N)\mathbf{)}$-body local terms, or local dimension $N$ and two-body terms, there are instances where finding the ground-state energy is quantum-Merlin-Arthur-complete and simulating the dynamics is BQP-complete (BQP denotes ``bounded error, quantum polynomial time''). We discuss the implications for the computational complexity of finding ground states of these systems and hence for any classical approximation techniques that one could apply including density-matrix renormalization group, matrix product states, and multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz. One important example is a one-dimensional lattice of bosons with nearest-neighbor hopping at constant filling fraction---i.e., a generalization of the Bose-Hubbard model.

arXiv:0704.3142•Physical Review A•Sep 20, 2007•24 citations

Hamiltonian Complexity in the Thermodynamic Limit

Dorit Aharonov, Sandy Irani

Despite immense progress in quantum Hamiltonian complexity in the past decade, little is known about the computational complexity of quantum physics at the thermodynamic limit. In fact, even defining the problem properly is not straight forward. We study the complexity of estimating the ground energy of a fixed, translationally-invariant (TI) Hamiltonian in the thermodynamic limit, to within a given precision; this precision (given by n the number of bits of the approximation) is the sole input to the problem. Understanding the complexity of this problem captures how difficult it is for a physicist to measure or compute another digit in the approximation of a physical quantity in the thermodynamic limit. We show that this problem is contained in FEXP QMA-EXP and is hard for FEXP NEXP . This means that the problem is doubly exponentially hard in the size of the input. As an ingredient in our construction, we study the problem of computing the ground energy of translationally invariant finite 1D chains. A single Hamiltonian term, which is a fixed parameter of the problem, is applied to every pair of particles in a finite chain. In the finite case, the length of the chain is the sole input to the problem and the task is to compute an approximation of the ground energy. No thresholds are provided as in the standard formulation of the local Hamiltonian problem. We show that this problem is contained in FP QMA-EXP and is hard for FP NEXP . Our techniques employ a circular clock structure in which the ground energy is calibrated by the length of the cycle. This requires more precise expressions for the ground energies of the resulting matrices than were required for previous QMA-completeness constructions and even exact analytical bounds for the infinite case which we derive using techniques from spectral graph theory. To our knowledge, this is the first use of the circuit-to-Hamiltonian construction that shows hardness for a function class.

arXiv:2107.06201•Journal of the ACM•Oct 6, 2025•6 citations

The Rotation-Invariant Hamiltonian Problem Is QMA_EXP-Complete

Nelson, Jon, Gottesman, Daniel

In this work we study a variant of the local Hamiltonian problem where we restrict to Hamiltonians that live on a lattice and are invariant under translations and rotations of the lattice. In the one-dimensional case this problem is known to be QMA_EXP-complete. On the other hand, if we fix the lattice length then in the high-dimensional limit the ground state becomes unentangled due to arguments from mean-field theory. We take steps towards understanding this complexity spectrum by studying a problem that is intermediate between these two extremes. Namely, we consider the regime where the lattice dimension is arbitrary but fixed and the lattice length is scaled. We prove that this rotation-invariant Hamiltonian problem is QMA_EXP-complete answering an open question of [Gottesman and Irani, 2013]. This characterizes a broad parameter range in which these rotation-invariant Hamiltonians have high computational complexity.

Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Hamiltonian complexity in the thermodynamic limit

Dorit Aharonov, Sandy Irani

Despite immense progress in quantum Hamiltonian complexity in the past decade, little is known about the computational complexity of quantum physics at the thermodynamic limit. In fact, even defining the problem properly is not straight forward. We study the complexity of estimating the ground energy of a fixed, translationally-invariant (TI) Hamiltonian in the thermodynamic limit, to within a given precision; this precision (given by n the number of bits of the approximation) is the sole input to the problem. Understanding the complexity of this problem captures how difficult it is for a physicist to measure or compute another digit in the approximation of a physical quantity in the thermodynamic limit. We show that this problem is contained in FEXPQMA-EXP and is hard for FEXPNEXP. This means that the problem is doubly exponentially hard in the size of the input.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•Jun 9, 2022•10 citations

On Efficiently Solvable Cases of Quantum k-SAT

Marco Aldi, Niel de Beaudrap, Sevag Gharibian +1 more

Abstract Estimating ground state energies of local Hamiltonian models is a central problem in quantum physics. The question of whether a given local Hamiltonian is frustration-free, meaning the ground state is the simultaneous ground state of all local interaction terms, is known as the Quantum k-SAT (k-QSAT) problem. In analogy to its classical Boolean constraint satisfaction counterpart, the NP-complete problem k-SAT, Quantum k-SAT is $$\hbox {QMA}_1$$ QMA 1 -complete (for $$k\ge 3$$ k ≥ 3 , and where $$\hbox {QMA}_1$$ QMA 1 is a quantum generalization of NP with one-sided error), and thus likely intractable. But whereas k-SAT has been well-studied for special tractable cases, as well as from a “parameterized complexity” perspective, much less is known in similar settings for k-QSAT. Here, we study the open problem of computing satisfying assignments to k-QSAT instances which have a “dimer covering” or “matching”; such systems are known to be frustration-free, but it remains open whether one can efficiently compute a ground state. Our results fall into three directions, all of which relate to the “dimer covering” setting: (1) We give a polynomial-time classical algorithm for k-QSAT when all qubits occur in at most two interaction terms or clauses. (2) We give a “parameterized algorithm” for k-QSAT instances from a certain non-trivial class, which allows us to obtain exponential speedups over brute force methods in some cases. This is achieved by reducing the problem to solving for a single root of a single univariate polynomial. An explicit family of hypergraphs, denoted Crash, for which such a speedup is obtained is introduced. (3) We conduct a structural graph theoretic study of 3-QSAT interaction graphs which have a “dimer covering”. We remark that the results of (2), in particular, introduce a number of new tools to the study of Quantum SAT, including graph theoretic concepts such as transfer filtrations and blow-ups from algebraic geometry.

arXiv:1712.09617•Communications in Mathematical Physics•Dec 24, 2020•7 citations
We study the complexity of a class of problems involving satisfying constraints which remain the same under translations in one or more spatial directions. In this paper, we show hardness of a classical tiling problem on an (N x N) 2-dimensional grid and a quantum problem involving finding the ground state energy of a 1-dimensional quantum system of N particles. In both cases, the only input is N, provided in binary. We show that the classical problem is NEXP-complete and the quantum problem is QMAEXP-complete. Thus, an algorithm for these problems that runs in time polynomial in N (exponential in the input size) would imply EXP = NEXP or BQEXP = QMAEXP, respectively. Although tiling in general is already known to be NEXP-complete, to our knowledge, all previous reductions require that either the set of tiles and their constraints or some varying boundary conditions be given as part of the input. In the problem considered here, these are fixed, constant-sized parameters of the problem. Instead, the problem instance is encoded solely in the size of the system.
In this theoretical paper, we consider spin systems in three spatial dimensions and consider the computational complexity of estimating the ground state energy, known as the local Hamiltonian problem, for translationally invariant Hamiltonians. We prove that the local Hamiltonian problem for 3D lattices with face-centered cubic unit cells and 4-local translationally invariant interactions between spin-3/2 particles and open boundary conditions is QMAEXP-complete, where QMAEXP is the class of problems which can be verified in exponential time on a quantum computer. We go beyond a mere embedding of past hard 1D history state constructions, for which the local spin dimension is enormous: even state-of-the-art constructions have local dimension 42. We avoid such a large local dimension by combining some different techniques in a novel way. For the verifier circuit which we embed into the ground space of the local Hamiltonian, we utilize a recently developed computational model, called a quantum ring machine, which is especially well suited for translationally invariant history state constructions. This is encoded with a new and particularly simple universal gate set, which consists of a single 2-qubit gate applied only to nearest-neighbour qubits. The Hamiltonian construction involves a classical Wang tiling problem as a binary counter which translates one cube side length into a binary description for the encoded verifier input and a carefully engineered history state construction that implements the ring machine on the cubic lattice faces. These novel techniques allow us to significantly lower the local spin dimension, surpassing the best translationally invariant result to date by two orders of magnitude (in the number of degrees of freedom per coupling). This brings our models on par with the best non-translationally invariant construction.
Here we present a problem related to the local Hamiltonian problem (identifying whether the ground-state energy falls within one of two ranges) which is restricted to being translationally invariant. We prove that for Hamiltonians with a fixed local dimension and O(log(N))O\mathbf{(}\mathrm{log}(N)\mathbf{)}O(log(N))-body local terms, or local dimension NNN and two-body terms, there are instances where finding the ground-state energy is quantum-Merlin-Arthur-complete and simulating the dynamics is BQP-complete (BQP denotes ``bounded error, quantum polynomial time''). We discuss the implications for the computational complexity of finding ground states of these systems and hence for any classical approximation techniques that one could apply including density-matrix renormalization group, matrix product states, and multiscale entanglement renormalization ansatz. One important example is a one-dimensional lattice of bosons with nearest-neighbor hopping at constant filling fraction---i.e., a generalization of the Bose-Hubbard model.
Despite immense progress in quantum Hamiltonian complexity in the past decade, little is known about the computational complexity of quantum physics at the thermodynamic limit. In fact, even defining the problem properly is not straight forward. We study the complexity of estimating the ground energy of a fixed, translationally-invariant (TI) Hamiltonian in the thermodynamic limit, to within a given precision; this precision (given by n the number of bits of the approximation) is the sole input to the problem. Understanding the complexity of this problem captures how difficult it is for a physicist to measure or compute another digit in the approximation of a physical quantity in the thermodynamic limit. We show that this problem is contained in FEXP QMA-EXP and is hard for FEXP NEXP . This means that the problem is doubly exponentially hard in the size of the input. As an ingredient in our construction, we study the problem of computing the ground energy of translationally invariant finite 1D chains. A single Hamiltonian term, which is a fixed parameter of the problem, is applied to every pair of particles in a finite chain. In the finite case, the length of the chain is the sole input to the problem and the task is to compute an approximation of the ground energy. No thresholds are provided as in the standard formulation of the local Hamiltonian problem. We show that this problem is contained in FP QMA-EXP and is hard for FP NEXP . Our techniques employ a circular clock structure in which the ground energy is calibrated by the length of the cycle. This requires more precise expressions for the ground energies of the resulting matrices than were required for previous QMA-completeness constructions and even exact analytical bounds for the infinite case which we derive using techniques from spectral graph theory. To our knowledge, this is the first use of the circuit-to-Hamiltonian construction that shows hardness for a function class.
In this work we study a variant of the local Hamiltonian problem where we restrict to Hamiltonians that live on a lattice and are invariant under translations and rotations of the lattice. In the one-dimensional case this problem is known to be QMA_EXP-complete. On the other hand, if we fix the lattice length then in the high-dimensional limit the ground state becomes unentangled due to arguments from mean-field theory. We take steps towards understanding this complexity spectrum by studying a problem that is intermediate between these two extremes. Namely, we consider the regime where the lattice dimension is arbitrary but fixed and the lattice length is scaled. We prove that this rotation-invariant Hamiltonian problem is QMA_EXP-complete answering an open question of [Gottesman and Irani, 2013]. This characterizes a broad parameter range in which these rotation-invariant Hamiltonians have high computational complexity.
Despite immense progress in quantum Hamiltonian complexity in the past decade, little is known about the computational complexity of quantum physics at the thermodynamic limit. In fact, even defining the problem properly is not straight forward. We study the complexity of estimating the ground energy of a fixed, translationally-invariant (TI) Hamiltonian in the thermodynamic limit, to within a given precision; this precision (given by n the number of bits of the approximation) is the sole input to the problem. Understanding the complexity of this problem captures how difficult it is for a physicist to measure or compute another digit in the approximation of a physical quantity in the thermodynamic limit. We show that this problem is contained in FEXPQMA-EXP and is hard for FEXPNEXP. This means that the problem is doubly exponentially hard in the size of the input.
Abstract Estimating ground state energies of local Hamiltonian models is a central problem in quantum physics. The question of whether a given local Hamiltonian is frustration-free, meaning the ground state is the simultaneous ground state of all local interaction terms, is known as the Quantum k-SAT (k-QSAT) problem. In analogy to its classical Boolean constraint satisfaction counterpart, the NP-complete problem k-SAT, Quantum k-SAT is QMA1\hbox {QMA}_1QMA1​ QMA 1 -complete (for k≥3k\ge 3k≥3 k ≥ 3 , and where QMA1\hbox {QMA}_1QMA1​ QMA 1 is a quantum generalization of NP with one-sided error), and thus likely intractable. But whereas k-SAT has been well-studied for special tractable cases, as well as from a “parameterized complexity” perspective, much less is known in similar settings for k-QSAT. Here, we study the open problem of computing satisfying assignments to k-QSAT instances which have a “dimer covering” or “matching”; such systems are known to be frustration-free, but it remains open whether one can efficiently compute a ground state. Our results fall into three directions, all of which relate to the “dimer covering” setting: (1) We give a polynomial-time classical algorithm for k-QSAT when all qubits occur in at most two interaction terms or clauses. (2) We give a “parameterized algorithm” for k-QSAT instances from a certain non-trivial class, which allows us to obtain exponential speedups over brute force methods in some cases. This is achieved by reducing the problem to solving for a single root of a single univariate polynomial. An explicit family of hypergraphs, denoted Crash, for which such a speedup is obtained is introduced. (3) We conduct a structural graph theoretic study of 3-QSAT interaction graphs which have a “dimer covering”. We remark that the results of (2), in particular, introduce a number of new tools to the study of Quantum SAT, including graph theoretic concepts such as transfer filtrations and blow-ups from algebraic geometry.